"Introducing Hall Of Fame class of 202_ quarterback,

File: eli-manning-white-house.jpg (80KB, 600x350px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 600x350px

>>77524147
>le single-handedly created /sp/ man
>le only reason the notorious system babby Tom Brady is not considered the unanimous GOAT athlete man
>le ruined Brittfar's legacy man
>le 15 year starter even though he plays behind a David Carr tier o-line man
>le redditors don't rate him because he makes a stupid face man

File: 1479183545364.png (1MB, 1334x750px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1334x750px

>>77524147
>Mfw Eli and Brady will be in the same HoF class

File: Eli confused.jpg (66KB, 1024x726px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 1024x726px

>>77524779
>le I think only reddit makes fun of his stupid face
>le I'm a summerfag who calls things reddit in a pathetic attempt to fit in

>>77524147
>he's gonna make it to the hall of fame

>>77524862

>two rings
>15+ year starter

He's not ELITE tier but he's objectively a hall-of-famer. Top 10 QB since 2000.

>>77524862
he will win Peyton invites him and the rest of his family to watch as Peyton gets into the Hall of fame in 2021

>>77524779

>le 15 year starter even though he plays behind a David Carr tier o-line man

Imagine Eli Manning with good blocking.

The Giants would hardly ever lose a game.

>>77524779
He didnt single hand made /sp/ he help but it was definitely brady.

If it was ANY other non pats team without a near perfect record it wouldnt gotten as hype

>>77524779
This
Based Hungarian and Eli

File: 1442634992827.jpg (176KB, 700x758px) Image search: [Google]

176KB, 700x758px

>>77524147

He has literally NEVER been a top 5 QB in any year he has played. He has NEVER led a season in any meaningful QB statistic. He is also somewhere in the 60's in all time passer rating, which doesn't sound awful until you realize the NFL in this day and age is built to inflate passer rating numbers. Russel Wilson is the number 2 QB in terms of passer rating of ALL TIME. TONY ROMO is #4.

Eli should never sniff the fucking hall of fame, but I expect he'll get in first ballot because the NFL hall is a joke anyway.

>>77525718
It was more or less equal. The NFL playoffs during the time was essentially 19-0 shitposting and criticism about how teams get into playoffs (the entire Giants run)

Eli has 2 rings as a starting QB in the capital of the Western World. He's a lock for the hall of fame.

"Leave the Patriots to me"

>goes on to methodically dismantle the Belichik system and expose muh rings man on national television

>>77525922

>then goes on to fail to win a playoff game for five years
>the system they dismantled goes on to win two more Superbowls

of course this post was from a fucking leaf

>>77525922
Giants front 4 was more important than Eli, IMO.

Why Eli shouldn't make the hall:
>83.7 quarterback rating
>3:2 TD:INT ratio, approximately

This QB rating puts him below luminaries Joe Flacco (1 owl), Mark Brunell, Sam Bradford, Marc Bulger, Daunte Culpepper, Jeff Garcia, Donovan McNabb, and Chad Pennington.

TD:INT ratio puts him below: Joe Flacco (1 owl), Michael Vick, Chad Pennington, Ryan Tannehill, Mark Brunell, Sam Bradford, Alex Smith, Jeff Garcia, and Donovan McNabb.

Yeah, he's not that much better than those guys statistically. 2 SB Wins and 2 SB MVPs are cool, sure, but QBs always get overinflated in those categories. Inconsistent play otherwise...bad news.

>>77529212

Mark Brunell doesn't get the love he deserves desu. QB for the based as fuck Jimmy Smith and Keenan McCardell Jaguars WR duo.