>learning piano >post video of myself playing a Bach invention

File: 1490551929733s.jpg (6KB, 250x221px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 250x221px

>>37511041

Jealousy. Don't listen to them, they are fucking idiots, especially the one who said you could injure yourself (on a fucking piano). But if you're really willing to invest yourself in piano then you probably should get a teacher

>>37511112
>Continuous/repetitive activity doesn't cause harm.

They are right to a degree. You should limit how much you practice each day to avoid straining yourself. But keep up the good work anon.

post it here bro I wanna hear what all the fuss is about

Post the video. Get some fair and accurate criticism from actual musicians. Sounds like those who commented on it are tonedeaf and have zero sense of music. Someone who actually knows how to play the piano can very easily tell if you only have a few weeks of practice.

A good rule of thumb is that the second reaction is always the truthful one. You should search out a teacher to make sure your hand form won't potentially ruin you down the road due to muscle strain or cartilage breakdown. If you're already doing Bach inventions you should be musically advanced enough to eat up the technique stuff and get on the road to making some seriously good music.

They do have a point. It can be damaging to your muscle memory to try to play super advanced pieces, like shredder guitarist wannabes who ruin their technique trying to play fast straight away.

>>37511041
The answer is font think about it -rick

>>37511041
Post your exquisite piece anon, I must cherish it.

I play piano to a good standard (hardest piece I can play is Mendelssohn's rondo capriciosso). Post your vid here for feedback.

Music about what you want, don t guve a shit about them if You play so much keep going, it will never be harmful. On the other hand if one day you hurt your hand you have to let it recover more than necesaary , and when you play again do it slowly. Otherwise you can have permanent domage dont do like me bro

>>37511041
Post us the video my lad.

>>37511041
>4 weeks
How did you learn to play with both hands doing different things? I've tried to learn the piano many times over the course of 10 years and I just can't do it. Am I retarded?

>>37512671
Yes, (not op) but I learne dto play the piano with both hands doing different things on year two of learning... when I was 11

>>37511112
don't have the money for that, I wouldn't want to have to commit to meeting someone every week either. I only play because I'm a NEET with nothing else to do with my time

>>37512612
it wouldn't be a good idea, I posted it under my real name

>>37512671
no idea, I just learn to play small segments of a couple bars at a time hands separate, then when I have them down play slowly hands together, and then I develop hand independence some time in that stage. I know when I have it because the first time I try to play at speed one hand will end up playing quicker than the other and they will desynchronize