[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

what do you guys think about Alsace-Lorraine as either rightful

This is a red board which means that it's strictly for adults (Not Safe For Work content only). If you see any illegal content, please report it.

Thread replies: 201
Thread images: 49

what do you guys think about Alsace-Lorraine as either rightful german land or french?
>>
Why not make it independent and send all the immigrants there?
>>
>>133096858
it is too pure to spoil with shit skins
>>
We're french, no matter what you grossgermanium memers think
>>
>>133096783
French. France's natural border in the Rhine, since the time of the Gauls.
>>
>>133096935
They're already here, it's one of the most enriched place
>>
>>133096984
They'll just come back.

god I wish most countries fucked up migrants like Russia
>>
>>133096783
North Germany = Danish clay
West Germany = Dutch clay
East Germany = Polish clay
South west Germany = French clay
South east Germany = Austrian clay

The German problem is no more.
>>
>>133097073
What about Bavaria?
>>
>>133097073
i cant take you seriously when you use the word "clay" instead of land.
>>
French. Destroy Jewmoney.
>>
Slesvig and Holstein belongs to Denmark you fucking faggot OP.
>>
File: 06304541.jpg (82KB, 331x475px) Image search: [Google]
06304541.jpg
82KB, 331x475px
>>133097210
>>
>>133096935
We have already lots of turks and we've been latety flooded by french.
I feel like it's almost forbidden to be an alsacian in Elsass.
Also we are germans.
>>
>>133097279
shouldn't
>>
File: 1481483126483.gif (2MB, 352x200px) Image search: [Google]
1481483126483.gif
2MB, 352x200px
>>133096783
German
>>133097073
London to Pakis ? british problem Solved ?
>>
File: german-women-raped-berlin-1945.jpg (31KB, 324x196px) Image search: [Google]
german-women-raped-berlin-1945.jpg
31KB, 324x196px
>>133097080
You want to talk about the quality of Russian people gene pool you Slavic subhuman ?
>>
>>133097476
Thanks Vladimir.
>>
Deutschland Uber Alles!
>>
>>133096783
doest it matter? both are gonna ruin it anyway
>>
>>133096783
They're closer to Germany, but let's be honest, maybe you should have united your country earlier.
>>
>>133096783
Clearly a rightful German land. They fucked the French good in the Franco-Prussian war so they deserve that land.
>>
File: Evil-agent-smith.jpg (29KB, 640x400px) Image search: [Google]
Evil-agent-smith.jpg
29KB, 640x400px
me looking at this thread
>>
>>133096783
>german
>french
O.P., both states are currently illegitimate as they're attempting wipe out their populations by massive non-white immigration combined with "assimilation." This means the area is completely up for grabs.
>>
>>133097073

your mom = my clay
>>
>>133096783
Not sure - neither countries deserve it. Give it to the Czech Republic or something.
>>
Rightful SWISS clay.
/thread
>>
>>133096858
It´s one of two landscapes in France, which arent infected by arabs.


But poles and czech people...
>>
>>133097179
Goes to Austria
>>133097476
Asiatic filth
>>133097522
There is no British problem in Europe now Brexit has happened, you can live without us
>>
>>133096783
Only Alsace should be German as it historically has been
Most natives to Lorraine are either Frenchisized Swabians or French settlers.
>>
File: Leonardo-Dicaprio-Cheers.jpg (25KB, 600x400px) Image search: [Google]
Leonardo-Dicaprio-Cheers.jpg
25KB, 600x400px
>>133097755
>>
>>133097755
Germany is a fake country, not even 150 years old, stop larking and return your clay to the true owners
>>
>>133097073
>be english
>descendant of German tribes who conquered modern-day England
>hates Germany, the land of his ancestors
Why are """redpilled""" English nationalists so rootless?
>>
File: rightful France.gif (119KB, 520x441px) Image search: [Google]
rightful France.gif
119KB, 520x441px
>>133096783
Alsace-Lorraine is just a small part of the geographical claim Nature gave to France
>>
File: ++++++.jpg (19KB, 359x391px) Image search: [Google]
++++++.jpg
19KB, 359x391px
Why give a beautiful peace of land to Germans?
I would rather not imagine Gdansk or any other place under Germans. Just look at Frankfurt or Berlin.
>>
>>133096783

Some parts are so fucking mixed I don't know what to think anymore.

They do French wines with German names. Some tows are 90% German but people speak a mixture of German and french. Food is a complete mixture of both.
>>
>>133096783
It's serbian
>>
File: map.png (2MB, 1568x988px) Image search: [Google]
map.png
2MB, 1568x988px
>>133097962
France is a fake country
There is no clear race or tribe of France because you're a mix of Franks, Gaulls, Iberians, Latins, Norwegians et.c
Either way, the former Burgundian and HRE provinces are all rightful Germanic clay.
>>
>>133097896
tl;dr
>I'm swiss btw
>>
>>133097925
Fuck off England has nothing to do with Germany, Germany isnt even 150 years old meanwhile England is over 1000 years old
>>
File: 1492989788452.png (1MB, 1641x1541px) Image search: [Google]
1492989788452.png
1MB, 1641x1541px
>>133097811
>It´s one of two landscapes in France, which arent infected by arabs.
It's actually one of the most infected region.
>>
>>133096783
Alsace is and was actually German, Lorraine was just a spoil of war with a minor German presence, but a good industrial area.
>>
>>133098127
>France is a fake country
Oldest country of Europe, and you ? Sweden YES !
>There is no clear race or tribe of France because you're a mix of Franks, Gaulls, Iberians, Latins, Norwegians et.c
That's technically true, but that's also true of Italy, the UK, Spain and even Germany to some extent (Bavarian and Austrian people are not racially Nordic).
>Either way, the former Burgundian and HRE provinces are all rightful Germanic clay.
Burgundia has always been a French clay with French people ruling and being ruled. It's still the name of a French region actually.
>>
My great grandfather was from Alsace-Lorraine and fought for Germany. 100 years ago the vast majority of the people there either spoke German or both languages, so if you just go by that, I'd consider it German, but I assume most people these days really just identify as French. I think what matters is the sense of belonging, if they want to be French, so be it.
>>
>>133098012
Russia is the least European nation in Europe, highest Muslim percentage huge amount of Asian genes litera shitskin, most blacks who have white gf in this country is with Slavic girls, over 30% of polish girls in England have black bfs says a lot About your so called kinsfolk
>>
>>133098259
>Fuck off England has nothing to do with Germany
No, not anymore because unionism has cut all ties and barely even teach English children about where the Angle-Saxons came from.

>Germany isnt even 150 years old
No it is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_of_Germany
This was the forebearer to the HRE, a German nation.
>>
>>133098384
>Oldest country of Europe
san marino was founded in 301AD
good try though
>>
>>133096783
Only 15% of Alsatians want their independence for 85% who want to stay French.
>>
Gay lefty Bavarian here.

There is no such thing as 'rightful clay'. We are One World.
>>
>>133098384
>That's technically true, but that's also true of Italy, the UK, Spain
True, Spain should wipe it's moorish leftover population out and breed forward the purest of the Iberian Celtic race.
I feel the same way about Italy
The UK should be disbanded and England should return to it's Germanic roots and enter a Pan-Germanic federation in my opinion.
And yeah, it is true about Germany
Lots of Germans are leftover Celts after the Germanic conquest, I think they should be outbred by pure Germanics.
>>
Alsace is a cultural exception and anyone telling you otherwise doesn't really lives there. Also we're closer to Germans but kind of improved version. 's gilt !
>>
>>133098686
>I think they should be outbred

Sex is not a competition. Sex is intimacy and emotion.
>>
>>133096783
Germany should cease to exist!!!!!!!!
>>
File: 1426069682951.jpg (22KB, 453x453px) Image search: [Google]
1426069682951.jpg
22KB, 453x453px
>>133098895
got me good
>>
File: 1469297176807.jpg (136KB, 917x960px) Image search: [Google]
1469297176807.jpg
136KB, 917x960px
>>133096783
it is rightfully Burgundian land you dumbfucks
>>
pic related should've been its own country, instead of switzerland.
>>
File: 1473350252752.png (602KB, 532x1763px) Image search: [Google]
1473350252752.png
602KB, 532x1763px
>>133098895
this
>>
>>133098486
Altogether around 1 million Anglo Saxons, Vikings, Normans and other Germanic tribes moved to England, Britain as a whole had 2 million people at that time so only 50% was Germanic, if we only count England its around 60% Germanic as Y DNA shows, but that still means 40% of English have non Germanic Y DNA and other 40% would be native. Considering majority of Welsh Scots and Irish have non Germanic y DNA the majority of Britain is non Germanic.
>>133098686
>pan-Germanic Union
It would just end up with Germany trying to dominate and rule over the rest like usual.
>>
>>133099133
BURGUNDIAN!? HAH, IT WAS NEVER BURGUNDIAN, IT WAS SWABIAN, GET TAE FUCK
>>
>>133098686
>The UK should be disbanded and England should return to it's Germanic roots and enter a Pan-Germanic federation in my opinion.

"no"

I'd much rather be an Englishmen with a British identity than with a Germanic one.
>>
>>133098686
>The UK should be disbanded and England should return to it's Germanic roots and enter a Pan-Germanic federation in my opinion.
England was Celtic before being Germanic.
The Britons were celtic, then came the Anglp-saxons, then the Norwegians, then the Normans (French people). England surely isn't purer than France.
>>
>>133098543
Conquered by the Goths and the Byzantines
>>
File: 1305506420001.jpg (269KB, 677x782px) Image search: [Google]
1305506420001.jpg
269KB, 677x782px
>>133099185
>he doesn't know about the treaty of verdun
>>
File: Alamannien_ca_1000.png (308KB, 1500x1322px) Image search: [Google]
Alamannien_ca_1000.png
308KB, 1500x1322px
>>133099133
>>133099185
see. Alsace was never Burgundian.

>>133099260
the Angles were the best thing to happen to the British Isles.
The Jutes and Saxons are a bunch of southern fannies, but I have respect for the Angles.
>>
>>133099260
>England surely isn't purer than France.
It is farther away from the non-white races, if that counts, Anon.
>>
File: Flag_of_Lorraine.svg.png (10KB, 251x151px) Image search: [Google]
Flag_of_Lorraine.svg.png
10KB, 251x151px
>>133096783
Lotharingia
>>
File: sampleMap.png (22KB, 750x690px) Image search: [Google]
sampleMap.png
22KB, 750x690px
>>133099352
This is the treaty of Verdun. Tip, use your fucking eyes, it was NEVER part of Burgundy. Get the fuck over it, it's SWABIAN clay.
>>
>>133099362
wrong
>>
Nothing. I don't gaf about cuckland ("Europe") they made their own bed so, let them lie
>>
File: Bourgogne-duche-XVe.gif (27KB, 379x571px) Image search: [Google]
Bourgogne-duche-XVe.gif
27KB, 379x571px
>>133099362
Half of Alsace has been Burgundian.
>>
>>133099519
wrong >>133099537
both strasbourg and Alsace were in burgund
back to your
>holy
>roman
>empire
>>
>>133096783
Its French, Bavaria should also be allowed to be a separate nation
>>
File: qgaule11.jpg (212KB, 620x514px) Image search: [Google]
qgaule11.jpg
212KB, 620x514px
The three nations of France
>>
>>133099670
>Treaty of Mersen.
>>
>>133099177
English people are like 25% germanic at most, the rest being celtic.
>>
>>133099914
last time i tried to imply france was anything other than france, i had some french cunt shouting "FUCK REGIONALISTS" with his garlic breath in my face.
>>
>>133099925
>treat of go fuck yourself verdun predates it
>>
File: france-islam-2.gif (20KB, 240x232px) Image search: [Google]
france-islam-2.gif
20KB, 240x232px
>>133099914
The current nation of France
>>
>>133099914
Give back Rosselló you filthy gavatxs.
>>
File: Barbarossa.jpg (173KB, 362x600px) Image search: [Google]
Barbarossa.jpg
173KB, 362x600px
>>133100023
>Treaty of predating doesn't make it more legitimate you dipshite.
What's your issue with it being part of Swabia anyway?
>>
>>133099914
Also I count 4 regions there nigger.
>>
>>133100240
>what's your issue with it being part of a barbarian nation
the
>holy
>roman
>empire
gee idk anon
>>
File: 4.jpg (73KB, 570x380px) Image search: [Google]
4.jpg
73KB, 570x380px
>>133098783
>'s gilt !
>>
>>133100210
The Roussillon along with the rest of Catalonie is the rightful clay of France. Also, give back the rest of Navarre spanipoor.
>>
>>133096783
I actually live there, in Metz, there are a lot of german coming/living here, and their influence is there with no doubts, we actually still have special laws because of our german past, I'd say the French just because that's what I am but both have their points
>>
File: 1499686427721.gif (116KB, 520x441px) Image search: [Google]
1499686427721.gif
116KB, 520x441px
>>133097962
hey frenchman, want to make a deal?
>>
>>133100303
Get the fuck out of Austria you dirty shitskin.
>>
>>133098783
's gilt
>>
>>133100404
Catalogne*
>>133100272
The green one is what Rome took from the yellow one.
>>
Yes, my family heritage came from there :(
>>
>>133100474
>proud austrian
>family tree goes back to the 600s
>always south of the danube
>barbarian shitskin
lmao no
>>
>>133099362
yes, alsace is alamanni
>>
>>133096783
>what do you guys think about Alsace-Lorraine as either rightful german land or french?

some of my ancestors came from Alsace-Lorraine and they were french.
>>
>>133100457
You're fucking delusional.
There is no historical precedent for Poland extending that far West.
Historically you're a nation of good goys, colluding with the Jews, so you deserved the fucking double penetration you got in the war.
>>
GERMAN. Don't forget Louis XIV. stole it from HRE!
>>
>>133100604
>some of my ancestors came from Alsace-Lorraine and they were french.
Hàsebock, that's what you are
>>
>>133100457
Seems legit to me. You should also add half of Belarus and the Western part of Ukraine.
>>
File: vélètes.png (141KB, 550x664px) Image search: [Google]
vélètes.png
141KB, 550x664px
>>133100605
No, technically he is right.
>>
File: perfect europe.png (171KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
perfect europe.png
171KB, 2124x2124px
This is the ideal Europe you cannot refute this
>>
>>133098259
T.10 years old
>>
>>133101014
That's a moronic map.
-South Belgium has always been French.
-You put the Lorraine part of Alsace-Lorraine (Metz) into Germany, it has always been French.
-Aoste in Italy has always been French.
-Slovenia was never populated by Germans.
-You grouped Latvia and Estonia, when Latvia is culturally close to Lithuania and Estonia of the same language and culture as Finland.
-Island is of the same language and culture as Norway.
-Macedonia is of the same language, race and culture as Bulgaria.

That map is bullshit
>>
>>133098385
Cuck
>>
>>133096783
It belongs to us!
>>
>>133096783
Obvioulsy German

>>133097701
This, the frenchy faggots own too much land compared to the medieval borders.
>>
>>133101008
I didn't ask for your fucking opinion you cunt.
Your map doesn't show the westward border the Polak posted either so you're still wrong.
>>
File: de-elslot.gif (5KB, 324x216px) Image search: [Google]
de-elslot.gif
5KB, 324x216px
>>133101375
>You put the Lorraine part of Alsace-Lorraine (Metz) into Germany, it has always been French.
not always
>>
Fools, you think that clay belongs to anyone but the rightful owners.
>>
File: ppppppppppppppgutss.png (36KB, 918x521px) Image search: [Google]
ppppppppppppppgutss.png
36KB, 918x521px
>>133096783
It's rightful German and thus Dutch clay, along with the rest of Germany and the U.K. and Spain.

Ever heard of William of Orange? Yeah dats rite. He was the rightful heir to the German Imperial throne and his descendant Billy was heir to the British crown (ask those Irish fuckers).

You're all a bunch of imposters!!!!!
>>
>>133101502
>>133102041
Unironically this
>>
File: uuuuuukk.png (482KB, 1547x1092px) Image search: [Google]
uuuuuukk.png
482KB, 1547x1092px
>>133101965
And you are rightful Dutch clay ask billy
>>
>>133101014

Wow, GTFO of Skåne you imbecile.
>>
>>133101014
>Brugge in France
WOW YOU ARE A RETARD
>>
>>133101014
>I am a retard with no knowledge of Europe and based this on some weird mix of fantasy LARPing and "what's closest to each other?": the map.
>>
>>133096783
It's rightful HRE clay and therefore rightful Austrian clay, as is half of Europe.
1806 worst day of my life, gib clay.
>>
>>133101014
>Ideal
>Germany existing
>>
>>133096783
My grandmother was from there. Should stay French. The food is simply too good for it to be German.
>>
>>133101014
>Sweden and norway not part of germanic union
Neck yourself
>>
File: fixed map of Europe.png (171KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
fixed map of Europe.png
171KB, 2124x2124px
>>133101014
I fixed your map
>>
>>133102510
Francis dissolved the Empire himself, you get nothing.
>>
>>133102510
We are all German, bro.
Anschluss, when?
>>
>>133097812
>Austria
are you kidding me? Austria is literally German. Even until 1915, they were considered German. So you want to destroy Germany, but keep a German state alive? Are you this stupid?
>>
File: image.png (216KB, 770x1023px) Image search: [Google]
image.png
216KB, 770x1023px
Alsace was given to Swabia during later times, but originally it was Lotharingian. It doesn't really belong to the Germans or the French, but the language and architecture is closer to the Germans of course.
>>
File: aaaaaaaaaaaaaad.png (85KB, 543x624px) Image search: [Google]
aaaaaaaaaaaaaad.png
85KB, 543x624px
>>133102510
But rightful Habsburg clay is rightful Dutch clay just as most of eastern france, the U.K., Ireland, Spain, Southern Italy, NY, Belgium, Sri Lanka and Indonesia. Go ask William of Orange.
>>
>>133102712
Only if we do reverse Anschluss, I don't wanna have to deal with Merkel.
>>
All memes aside, the objectively correct historical decision would be to have taken it but returned Metz/the French speaking areas to cool their napoleon syndrome/being quite as butthurt about getting it back.

Today though? Sadly I know people from there and not a single one of them even knows a real Alsatian. The area is 95% French speaking and with all the Algerians living there, they might as well keep it.
>>
File: La Marseillaise.jpg (120KB, 746x711px) Image search: [Google]
La Marseillaise.jpg
120KB, 746x711px
Fuck the Prussians. They were the ones who came in shooting and killing. Alsaciens are Alsaciens. Just because we spoke German didn't mean we wanted to be ruled by Asiatic Prussian barbarians, and we like Aryan blood as much as the Frank or the Anglo (pic related).

Remove Kraut.

t. descendant of Alsacien refugees
>>
>>133102782
Fine by me, anything to get that old hag out of our system.
>>
>>133102789
The real Alsatians GTFO when you krauts took over.

Not the first time you've ruined Europe. Won't be the last.
>>
>>133096783
We are all rightful Muslim clay soon
>>
>>133102733
>>133096783
To respond to this thread:
Rightful is complicated. It was mainly German speaking and culturally German until the 1918s (Goethe wrote an essay on German architecture in Straßburg and learned there as well.)
Yet, until the rise of nation states, ethnicity and rulership didn't have to clash. You could be Breton and be under French rule and Polish and under Prussian rule.
The idea of an ethnic homogenous state only came to existence in the mid-19th century. And while Germany had it from 1871 to 1918, it refused to properly implement it into the Reich (don't ask me why), hell they even shipped all soldiers from that region to the Eastern front because they saw them as potential traitor. This, out of quite a few other factores made Alsace-Lorraine be pro-French.
After WWI it was ethnically purged, so ethnically it now belongs to the French. Talking about cultural history, it is German/French. Go there, and you'll see a huge amount of German last names when it comes to history.
Nowadays, it is French clay and will remain it, unless there is a Franco-German war, won by the Germans (which is not going to happen). It is still very international. Most French people there speak German at a very good level.
>>
>>133102861
>Fuck the Prussians. They were the ones who came in shooting and killing
That's not what my grandfather lived. When the town was burnt and shelled, it was by the allies even when no soldier was in town.
Germans in fact dindu nuffin.
>>133103068
Bullshit
>>
>>133102706
>Implying an Emperor can dissolve an Empire
His power is given to him by God and therefore only God can divide Empires.
I haven't seen any burning bushes telling us to dissolve the Empire.

Indivisibiliter ac Inseparabiliter
>>
>owned by Germany from 1871 to 1914
>owned by France from 1600s to now
Tough call
>>
>>133103290
>Owned by
I'll repeat myself but you do know, that ethnic population and rulership didn't have to be the same until the nation-state idea took over right?

It was more problematic to be a protestant in France than to be a catholic German until the mid 19th century. There is a reason, you see a lot of protestant French people moving to protestant German lands under Friedrich der Große and not catholic Germans.
>>
>>133103290
>He doesn't realize France is rightful German clay since they betrayed the rightful Emperor Ludwig the German in 840 and stole the western German lands
>>
File: 1499690947572.png (172KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
1499690947572.png
172KB, 2124x2124px
>>133102675
Some small tweaks
>>
>>133103199
I'm talking about 1871. German-speaking Alsaciens basically got ethnically cleansed after the Franco-Prussian war.

Aryan genocide when?
>>
File: 1438632147916.png (369KB, 1056x4224px) Image search: [Google]
1438632147916.png
369KB, 1056x4224px
>>133097073
But how do we solve the problem with the eternal anglo?
>>
>>133102675
thx for the correct Armenia, bruv
>>
File: Lenguas_de_Oil.png (59KB, 300x262px) Image search: [Google]
Lenguas_de_Oil.png
59KB, 300x262px
>>133100404
France is a meme country admit it, only pic related should be France, the rest is stolen land. Most european countries are memes too so don't get mad.

>>133100536
You have to go back Pierre/Hans.
>>
>>133104317
Well, racially speaking yes. Through history though, French identity was rarely questioned, French Southerners always felt French. And as they are white and hadn't been bred by Arabs (contrary to Spaniards), I have no problem with that.
>>
>>133096960
>>133096969
based
>>
>>133103796
That last part of the pic is rather inaccurate:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2zm2wLKGD4
>>
>>133097755
Literally divide Germany between Austria and Holland on the weißwurstäquator
>>
File: happy Europe.png (165KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
happy Europe.png
165KB, 2124x2124px
>>133105566
I've a better solution to the German problem
>>
>>133100404
>>133104317
Catalonia-Valencia is rightful Occitan clay.
>>
>>133105685
What do you need so much land for? To put more of your beloved sandniggers in?
>>
>>133104885
>French Southerners always felt French.
Well when it's been centuries of erasing their culture and language and imposing your own no wonder they now feel french. On top of that add the millions of northeners migrating south plus all the millions of shitskins imported thanks to parisian politicians which diluted further their occitan identity.
>>
>>133098828
Intimacy and emotion won't be remembered 100 years from now, only the competition (evolution).
>>
File: wewuzarthur.jpg (110KB, 888x456px) Image search: [Google]
wewuzarthur.jpg
110KB, 888x456px
>>133098259
>Germany isnt even 150 years

The battle of Teutoburg forest predates the myth of King Arthur by 500 years. Fuck off you norwegian rape children. We won when the Roman Empire was at it's peak. You had to create the myth of a non-existent king that is basically an affirmation of your slave mentality to the Roman Empire.
>>
well in bulgarian it's called Elsas-Lotharingia so I guess that's settles whose clay we think it is.
>>
>>133103501
I, as descendant of several Huguenots from the annexed Southern Netherlands and France, can confirm this.
>>
>>133106770
Teutoburg forest was Germanic TRIBES, the German country isn't even 150 years old, Germany as a country is a huge mistake
>>
>>133097925
Angles are Saxons were from Denmark. They're germanic not german.
>>
>>133102041
Dutch are fine but not Germans, William of orange was top man, Germany must be controlled like Hanover
>>
>>133102733
Austria is 800+ years older than Germany, Austrians are ethnically different from Germany, germany as a nation is a problem, not Austria
>>
File: 1474244407305.jpg (7KB, 250x198px) Image search: [Google]
1474244407305.jpg
7KB, 250x198px
>>133100210
dis
>>
>>133107049
>Germany as a country is a huge mistake

The only mistake Germany did was to not include every german speaking country during it's creation. Fuck the Kleindeutsche Lösung. As a matter of fact. It should have included northern Italy just for good old times sake.
>>
>>133103796
There is no problem
>>
Hey guys. Op here. Swapped devices and I'm just laughing at the shitstorm I made
>>
>>133097179
That's Austria
>>
>>133096783
Rightfully french. They were the only former german territory were the people actually voted for leaving germany without being forced to. Unlike Schlesien, Tirol or our overseas colonies, I might add.
>>
>>133103290
>owned by germany fro 814 to 1600
>>
>>133097203
Says the guy with the kekistan flag
>>
>>133107394
>Austria is 800+ years older than Germany
Are you implying the Habsburg empire was longer living than the Honhenzollern governed Germany? That is correct. Still Habsburg and Hohenzollern were still long lived dynasties and the Habsburgs were the emperors of the holy roman empire for the longest time, because they were the most powerful German land. The rip only started with the Norddeutsche Bund after Austria officially left the German Bund, because Prussia was acting up.

Again, Austrians in the state we know today (and historically in the Sudetenland etc.) felt German for the longest time.
>>
>>133107489
No, Germany as a unified country shouldn't exist at all
>>
>>133107777
THE POWER OF QUAD 7's AND YOU FUCKING WASTE IT ON THAT?!?!
>>
>>133107139
Better said from the coastal area expanding from northern Netherlands to southern Denmark. English closest language is frisian.
>>
>>133096783
It is Lotharingian
>>
>>133102776
Jacobites > Silly Billies
>>
>>133107783
Austria existsed as an actual unified country for much longer than Germany, and just because they felt German and spoke it doesn't mean they are, Austrians are alpine celts with Germanified culture
>>
>>133108058
>and just because they felt German and spoke it doesn't mean they are, Austrians are alpine celts with Germanified culture
So you're saying, that although the Austrians felt German and a unification of all Germans included Autria up until 1945 included Austria, that is negated by you saying they were alpine celts?
Remember, that the battle of 955 was a combined effort of Bavarians, northern Germans and Austrians combined.
>>
File: 1499690947572.png (171KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
1499690947572.png
171KB, 2124x2124px
>>133102675
>>
>>133108259
What, it doesn't matter what people feel like, lots of Asian immigrants feel British but it doesn't mean they are. Germany supporting pan germanism is not different from tsarist Russia supporting pan slavism, it's about expanding borders and power, not racial or ethnic brotherhood. Austrians are an alpine race and closer genetically to Hungarians and Czechs than Germans (outside of bavaria) even Austrian skull shapes are different to Germanic skull shapes
>>
>>133098259
>germany isn't 150 years old

its not even 20 years old lad.
>>
File: 1499514303586.jpg (46KB, 566x562px) Image search: [Google]
1499514303586.jpg
46KB, 566x562px
>>133102861
France declared war on Prussia, not vice versa.
>>
>>133097073
I unironically agree with this. We need to get rid of the (((eternal Kraut))) if we are ever to prosper as a continent
>>
>>133096783
"Alsace"
"Lorraine"

Very German-sounding place names :^)

Un région français. Vachement, carrément et bien sûr. Pas de lebensraum içi, altern.
>>
>>133109394
Does Brittany belong to Britain? It doesn't sound very French..
>>
>>133096783
Even when it was German territory, the people was overwhelmingly in favor of France. Even the "German" (Alsacien isn't really German) speaking ones.
That should be enough for them to remain French, especially now that their local language is dying.
>>
>>133096783
Why are people so buttblasted when Germans reclaim land that had German people living in it taken after the Treaty? It's not like any other nation had land stolen from them that they took back. The Germans only got the rough end of the straw because crimes against humanity were just invented.
>>
>>133108797
>Germany supporting pan germanism is not different from tsarist Russia supporting pan slavism, it's about expanding borders and power, not racial or ethnic brotherhood.
Except, that Austria post WWI and prior to the Napoleonic wars was in favour of joining Germany, there was no "German" politics behind it, this is actually what hindered a Greater-German solution.
> Austrians are an alpine race and closer genetically to Hungarians and Czechs than Germans (outside of bavaria) even Austrian skull shapes are different to Germanic skull shapes
Tbh I need some scientific proofs for this
>>
>>133107861
It's a sign from the frog god. It's telling you to go fuck yourself with your autistic flag.
>>
>>133109394
I am sure, that Strassburg and Metz don't sound very French either. Funniest thing is, French baguette didn't even alter the name "Metz".
>>
It belongs to the glorious German Empire. It's German land and should be returned along with Prussia
>>
>>133109901
Yes, Brittany belongs to Britons
>>
>>133110548
Metz comes from French. It's an alteration of medieval latin "mettis."
The people of the region of Metz have always been French.
>>
>>133110910
Used to be Celtic beforehand.
>>
File: Paris-Warsaw-Copenhagen Axis.png (165KB, 1140x900px) Image search: [Google]
Paris-Warsaw-Copenhagen Axis.png
165KB, 1140x900px
if only
>>
>>133105685
>Austria actually has to worry about a navy again
>>
>>133107834
Says the island monkey whose "United" Kingdom is at risk of breaking apart. It's alright. In two years time you can reach the EU by foot again simply by going over the border towards the EU member state Scottland.
>>
>>133109901
We're named after Brittany, m8. We kinda belong to them.

Nous sommes à france, mec.

>>133110548
Strasbourg is a pan-European globalised zone being an epicentre of the EU. It can't have a French name :^)
>>
>>133097831
Both should be German, Metz, Toul Verdun were three Metropolias taken by Henri II in 1552. After the 30 Year's War, whole Lothringen was annexed by French.
>>
>>133109394
http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=alsace
>from Proto-Germanic *alja "other" (from PIE root *al- (1) "beyond") + Old High German -sazzo "inhabitant," literally "one who sits."

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=lorraine
>from Medieval Latin Lotharingia (German Lothringen), literally "Lothar's Realm."

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=Lothar
>literally "famous warrior," from Old High German lut (see loud) + heri "host, army" (see harry (v.))


the frogs merely corrupted the names with their fagspeak.
>>
>>133110499
Ok in the past Austrians wanted to be German, that doesn't change the fact they are genetically different from Germans, I'm sorry I don't have sauce right now as I'm phoneposting at work, if the thread is still up when I get home I'll share sauces
>>
>>133096783
It's Turkish clay now, like the rest of Western Germany I guess...
>>
File: Good map.png (133KB, 2124x2124px) Image search: [Google]
Good map.png
133KB, 2124x2124px
>>133101014
>>
>>133097755
owned4life
>>
>>133100039
56%
>>
File: .png (469KB, 583x599px) Image search: [Google]
.png
469KB, 583x599px
>>133112435
>that doesn't change the fact they are genetically different from Germans
While you are away, let me show you some sources, that show the actual opposite of your proposal
>>
File: europe-haplogroups.png (401KB, 554x573px) Image search: [Google]
europe-haplogroups.png
401KB, 554x573px
>>133114532
Almost the same haplogroups too!
Thread posts: 201
Thread images: 49


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.