Do Muslims ban music because they haven't been able to compete

pls
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5VYEwmbaiIU

(((Nomadic))) tribes fucked up Middle Eastern culture and history. This is coming from a dude born in the fertile crescent: Fuck Islam in its totality.

Don't let it do the same to your people.

>>131386983
Pop music is cancer.

>>131386983
They ban everything because Muslims aren't capable of looking after themselves, they need to be told what to do and they aren't allowed free will because they're just too bloody stupid.

>>131387117

She has a lot of ancient European admixture.

>>131387117
It's nice, but it isn't genius.
You simply can't. Being proud to be in a Muslim country and of arab birth is retarded.

File: 1302516291433.gif (302KB, 294x266px) Image search: [Google]

302KB, 294x266px

>>131386983
gooby pls; pretty much no nation in Europe can compete with Germanic classical composers except the Italians why do you expect the muzzies (who use different musical styles altogether) to do it when your own nation and the rest of Europe failed spectacularly.

File: indasdsdex.jpg (7KB, 230x219px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 230x219px

>>131387928

I think we have found the Muslims weakness.

>>131386983
Probably some stone age anti commercialism.
>don't let the jingle Jew shake your faith

>>131386983
You'll find some answers here, OP:

Why Muslim Culture Lags Behind
http://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/95065/why-muslim-cultures-lag-behind-anti-jihadist

Why the Arabic World Turned Away from Science
http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/why-the-arabic-world-turned-away-from-science

>>131387928

Every Western European country IS Germanic though, so...

>>131388136
I really don't get this argument, you can't compete with Germanics or Italians in the European music genre (excluding multicultural pop) but you expect people who are geographically quite far away to somehow succeed where you have failed over generations (literally this continues to this day).

It's like me saying that Europeans cannot compete in kai singing, something they do not practice at all.

File: 1498386885921.png (29KB, 354x286px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 354x286px

>>131388756
>Muslims right now

>>131387161
>>131387827
>>131388756
Nice Reddit spacing you insufferable assholes. How the fuck am I supposed to read your posts?

>>131388697
I meant core German/Prussian lands; German borders shift too frequently to easily define what constitutes Germany.
>>131389403
>Paragraphs
>Reddit Spacing
wut?
>>131389166
This trolling is so mild it's actually refreshing.

>>131388756
Not true at all. Say what you will but the UK has kickass music.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRtnWVvDX6k

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGrxHO-B2TY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBKBI7DOLHA

>>131386983
mussies will never come close to this
https://youtu.be/RR7eUSFsn28?t=4m19s

>>131386983
>he still hasn't listened to any dank ISIS nasheeds

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EN82zVVQvM&list=PLEtL5xkoPHjIA5FlvK0p7HacqTdPmvkXt

>>131389702
That music is a different genre sir; OP was referring to classical compositions (symphony, concerto etc) which is more or less just dominated by Germans and Italians and has been for centuries.

File: 152863.jpg (40KB, 657x527px)

40KB, 657x527px

>>131386983
Yes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1MT2p41nbc

File: 1325775560584.jpg (44KB, 400x280px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 400x280px

>>131386983
they ban music because it's a form of creative expression -- and explicit prohibition of Islamic mind-rot

>emotionless drones follow orders better

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sx4NojXZAA

>>131386983
They ban fun in general. Thats why they are always pissed

Strict orthodox Sunni Islam forbids not only music but also most form of art and drawing; drawling images of people and animals could lead to idolatry.

Poetry, architecture and calligraphy are really the only art forms that strict Islam approves of.

File: 1498475124904.png (163KB, 282x325px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 282x325px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8gPyLXw7f-Y

>>131386983
>He unironically considers Mozart's christcuck music European
This is real european music:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZqOp-StLoiw

>>131387928
>Germanic classical composers.

Nigger its like you finished elementary third grade.
You fucking germans are shit when it comes to anything other than engineering and construction.
You fucking make Europe ashamed.

>>131387117
Except in true Sharia countries you'd get burned to death for making music like that.

I had a Muslim roommate who was into Katy Perry, but that shit is forbidden as fuck according to Muslims who are more Muslim than he was.

>>131386983
Saleem sawarim is terror kino

File: 321234.jpg (84KB, 800x390px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 800x390px

>>131390987
https://youtu.be/ka9ngXtRTXk

this is better
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qx8hrhBZJ98

>>131389672

I hear ya.

>>131390871
Im not German my Slavic friend but Germans and Italians do more or less dominate the genre, i don't know why.

Have a listen
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qvglWAHDak

Out of curiosity what is your traditional music like, I'm only acquainted with Rus/Ukrainian music is it similar?

File: 2148521.jpg (29KB, 640x480px)

29KB, 640x480px

>>131391316
so, beautiful.

>>131389403
What is this "Reddit spacing" I keep hearing about? Every thread, there's some nigger complaining about it.

>>131391642
I just assumed with the state of American education they didn't know what paragraphs were.

>>131391316

https://twitter.com/Valmet_M76/status/879141526340849665

>>131391825
Is that what it's about? Leaving spaces between paragraphs?

>>131386983
Music with more than one instrument is "devils music". Anything more than literal throat singing, or a guitar strumming, or some other lone instrument is haram.

It's not hard to fall behind when core components of your ideology forbade certain practices, creativity, abstract thought, etc. And even more is that at the end of the day, they will never dispute it; they will always accept de facto "culture" of theirs; because "Allah wills it".

>>131391316
https://twitter.com/Valmet_M76/status/879141526340849665

>>131388756
Britain has some truly great composers- Handel, Elgar, Britten, Purcell. But the exact nationality is unimportant, because music of this caliber has always been a shared European passion. All European countries have beautiful opera houses where music and ballet are appreciated and cultivated. European high culture, whether music or painting or sculpture or dance or literature, always has been and always will be the greatest on earth.

>>131387117
That's literally just an Arab doing Western music.

File: reddit.gif (2MB, 237x240px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 237x240px

>>131391642
>>131391825
>>131391945
If you have written actual multi-sentence paragraphs and there is a need to organize the text, you will get little complaint.
When the poster makes simplistic arguments that boil down to one sentence, and then forces a line break,
we call them out for reddit spacing. If that doesn't clear it up, just go back.

>>131392734
>just go back
Ironic sentiment, considering it takes a reddit user to associate line breaks with reddit in the first place.

>>131391945
I don't think it's just spacing; one of the posts he flagged has no spaces at all, i think the concept of paragraphs just infuriates him for reasons unbeknownst to us mere mortals.
>>131392078
England has fairly decent composers, but they don't rate well against other nationalities; i don't really care much about nationality was just looking askance to OP.

As for the preeminence of a particular culture, i suppose it has a great deal to do with taste and familiarity; i definitely can't understand the appeal of Picasso but i can understand why people like Caravaggio.
>>131392734
I don't use reddit; why is that even an issue though are you browsing on a Mobile?

File: aphex-twin-richard-d-james-album.jpg (54KB, 450x321px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 450x321px

>>131393013

keks to self

>>131387928
>who is Elgar
>who is Vaughan-Williams
Germans are god-tier though

>>131393209
you avin a laff?
>>131394447
They don't really rate that well though, pretty sure most people would rank composers by nationality as follows German,Italian/Russian,French which means that very rarely would an English composer break anyone's top ten.

islam is a military doctrine. muslims are soldiers in a constant state of war. music is a distraction, the only music allowed is for specific purposes. it makes sense when you think about it.

>>131395813
>They don't really rate that well though, pretty sure most people would rank composers by nationality as follows German,Italian/Russian,French which means that very rarely would an English composer break anyone's top ten.

This is a deflection though, the point stands niguh.

>>131395813

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNMEftNVn4k&t

Skip to 28:40 and listen for a minute or two. This puny moment in electronic music is better than any music created by the Muslim world.

File: 1473780334890.jpg (12KB, 236x236px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 236x236px

>>131393209
You earned this

File: 1495381905717.jpg (51KB, 315x315px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 315x315px

>>131397644

>>131386983
the reason why music is banned is because it is a distraction in remembrance to Allah, muslims are supposed to do their best to be always in remembrance to Allah, that's why muslims pray at least 5 times a day

File: 1410925112963.png (197KB, 499x499px) Image search: [Google]

197KB, 499x499px

>>131391316
>>131391121
>>131397069

What about this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woJcJ8zTnBQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTbon8xe-ds

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSK67qNtxXM

File: when.png (374KB, 1920x883px) Image search: [Google]

374KB, 1920x883px

>>131387117
lol A STINKY ARAB SHIT DID A SONG GUYS SO ITS RLY GOOD CAUSE IM A STINKY ARAB TOO LIKE IT OR ILL BLOW U UP

so much culture man wow

>>131396285
What point? not sure if you lost track of the original argument but has England produced a single composer who could compete against Mozart or Beethoven; hell even Vivaldi or Tchaikovsky.

>>131395973
Depends on which school you abide by, since Islam is non clerical it became quite diverse some schools see music as forbidden while others actually use it as part of religious meditation e.g.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SdFjzEGTd3s

>>131397069
Your age is showing m8y

>>131398458
is there problem infidel?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-2nByd2cr4

Because Western music is degenerate. Mudders are extremely pious, so they'd obviously prefer music revolving around god, like:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m_tjxz4yS_U

>>131398718

Did you listen though? Even that small snippet from a random dnb album is better than any Muslim music.

>>131398276
>the reason why music is banned is because it is a distraction in remembrance to Allah

LMAO SURRRE

I guess that's why you ban goat fucking also because it is a distraction from Allah?

We know the truth Abdul.

>>131386983
Muslims ban music because they're dumbasses that need super blunt instruction. There's no subtlety with Muslims. You can't make a distinction between Kendrick Lamar and Mozart so you ban all of music. Besides Muslims are niggers that can't appreciate the fine arts.

>>131398718

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0YyBp8ZyeE

>>131398439

dank

>>131400416
But there might be something to the idea in the OP too. I've actually thought about that myself. It's kind of like when you cover up women because all the men that can't have them will be angry when they see them, including myself. You ban all music because similarly niggers get angry when they hear classical music because A) their race never made anything like it, B) they can't appreciate it, makes them feel inadequate.

>>131400137
I did but it becomes a moot point when you bring contemporary music into it due to the makeup of modern societies,like what would be 'Muslim music' at this point? Zayn, Akon and Ice Cube?

Aside from that personally didn't like that song too much, feels too old and too slow.

>>131400607
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYweg6GbNGs

>>131386983
Compete? Hah It's been surpassed already!

https://youtu.be/hQS0PgsIOFE

File: av-669718-1446470754.gif (18KB, 210x195px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 210x195px

>>131401955

>Hasn't even heard about The Tuss

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGZXJgOa3JM

>>131386983
why is reverb allowed but they ban instruments

>>131402779
Fair to say you are in your late 30s?

File: 1401421293103.jpg (31KB, 526x300px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 526x300px

What would Muslim metal sound like?

>>131403094
24

>>131403390

Like a nail bomb or something?

>>131403602
what's with the retro beats mate?

>>131404703

It's a fair point. Well Aphex Twin is held in some of the highest regards in reference to electronic music and he is English, The Tuss is one of his pseudonyms.

Now, in terms of retro beats. I do also listen to some more modern music, but I still love a lot of earlier stuff. I mean you can't really get much earlier classical.

>>131405534

earlier than classical**

>>131405534
Ah ok i get ya, didn't know Tuss was Aphex Twin so i thought it was just some obscure electronic band.

>>131405988

Ha yeah, not to get all hipster or anything. A lot of the Tuss stuff is just a joke but it has some moments of brilliance.

>>131386983
Who cares what a bunch of sand niggers think?

don't try to understand how their mind works
no one ever did

>>131406579

I do agree with you, and a couple of decades ago people here barely even knew what a Muslim was, but now we are forced to butt heads with them.

File: 70029-004-74AD88C3.jpg (52KB, 261x300px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 261x300px

>>131387928
You forgot Russia https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbxgYlcNxE8

>>131407135

Mark Citadel is that you?

File: 67501-004-45D6163D.jpg (13KB, 277x450px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 277x450px

>>131407135
and don't forget who invented film music

https://youtu.be/vKZPgGbUuX0

>>131407135
I mentioned Russia further down
>>131395813

i believe the music ban is because musical expression uplifts and inspires the everyman. no musical expression dumbs down a population. that's why limited musical expression (in our hyper-censored pop music era) is retarding our society so much. islam is just worse.

i also believe that women are not allowed to "display their beauty" because seeing beautiful women to defend gives men more will to fight against tyrants

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jlu1XyPexn8

>>131402779

Don't be a cunt and just post Syro, same shit.

>>131409239

Fair desu, I really like that Tuss album though.

>>131389166
You got that right.

>>131392734
But the offending post had 2 sentences before a break.

>>131403390
https://youtu.be/3_qvwF_MMvs
I dunno if they're muslim but here you get some MENA metal.