Since when are comeback albums this good? Why is 2017 such

I loved Narkopop, Slowdive s/t was hit or miss, mostly miss and I'm not listening to a Brand New album.

File: metal gear solid 6 leaked footage.webm (2MB, 720x1280px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 720x1280px

>>75178077
>I'm not listening to a Brand New album.
your (huge) loss, it's better than their other albums by a mile

>>75178090
It's better than Daisy and YFW but not TDAGARIM and Deja.

Wasn't too impressed w/ narko. Nothing tops Zauberberg for me.

File: Screenshot_20170824-053112.png (106KB, 720x1280px) Image search: [Google]

106KB, 720x1280px

https://open.spotify.com/user/androol_/playlist/1ObWSj7I4uhy9Nilw0WtLY

First album in 15 years

>>75178320
Zauberberg is definitely my favorite as well. But I felt like Narkopop is the most similar to Zauberberg, which I really liked.

>>75178331
go home sp*tify shill

File: Screenshot_20170910-225146.png (110KB, 720x1280px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 720x1280px

>>75178364
How would you propose I post revised track orders?

>>75178049
Slowdive s/t was the only one of those I enjoyed but desu I'm just not that into Brand New or Gas generally.
There have been some incredibly mediocre reunion releases/attempted comebacks this year though:
>Ride - Weather Diaries
>Depeche Mode - Spirit
>Wire - Silver/Lead
>LCD Soundsystem - American Dream
>The Jesus & Mary Chain - Damage & Joy
>Spoon - Hot Thoughts
>The Magnetic Fields - 50 Song Memoir
>GY!BE - Luciferian Towers
>Lupe Fiasco - DROGAS Light

also predicting that the new albums from U2, Eminem, Beck, Björk, and Judas Priest will get a lukewarm reception at best

on a positive note though, Nine Inch Nails has been on a roll with these EPs. and I'm looking forward to the new St. Vincent album, the singles are great

>>75178412
Judas Priest just put out an awesome album in 2014

The cutoff was set at 8 years

>>75178427
they haven't been relevant or doing anything notable since Painkiller

>>75178441
Their 2014 album was very notable and relevant. New guitarist as I recall and he worked out really well.

Lots of others listed there also don't qualify. Brand New set the cutoff at 8 years. Otherwise this would be just an ordinary 2017 thread.

>>75178237
Deja is overrated as fuck mall-emo garbagio. Daisy better than each record on that list.

>>75178412
>There have been some incredibly mediocre reunion releases/attempted comebacks this year though:
>>Wire - Silver/Lead
>>GY!BE - Luciferian Towers
>>Lupe Fiasco - DROGAS Light
How are these comebacks? Lupe and GYBE had albums in 2015, Wire had one in 2016

>>75178510
maybe not GY!BE, Allelujah came out a lot more recently than I thought, but it's been a minute since Lupe or Wire released anything very well-received.
I liked Silver/Lead more than I expected to though, they might still have a great late-career album left in them. probably their best album since Bruce Gilbert left

>>75178467
that's true, taking Brand New as the standard for a comeback/reunion most of those examples are pushing it

>>75178602
wait that's not right, best album with Matthew Simms. Red Barked Tree was great

>>75178412
Wait Ride had a fucking comeback too? Holy shit.

Last year had some great comeback albums too. ATCQ had a wonderful final album.

>>75179127
>ATCQ had a wonderful final album.
overrated

>>75178049
Gas 8/10
Slowdive Haven't listened yet. excited.
Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.

>>75179515
>Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.
It's fucking great

>>75179515
>Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.
imagine having taste this bad

>>75178412
>American Dream
>Bad

and the GY!BE album is not even out

American football wasnt good