Pitchfork review should be in tonight. What's the rating

9.3

how did they rate the other ones?

5.7, putting the final nail in the coffin of the white man's indie rock.

8.8 Screencap this

9.2

>>74888253
Yeess.
Nigga drum drum monkey hoo haa
Only typa shit that'll do ya

9.2. It's not objectively better or worse than Sound of Silver or This is Happening - personal favorites will come down to subjective taste.

>>74888252
LCD Soundsystem: 8.2
Sound of Silver: 9.2
This Is Happening: 9.2

9.2-9.4

7.9 for maximum troll

Post your face when it gets a 9.9

9.0

9.2

I've got some info that suggests it's gonna be an 8.3

9.4 or 9.5

8.2, no bnm, screencap this, legit sources.

my digits confirm the p4k album rating for american dream

>>74888666
666?

>>74888666
HOLY SHIT BOYS ITS GONNA BE A 666

>>74888666
>Double trips
What did he mean by this

File: magnifying glass pepe.png (172KB, 436x361px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 436x361px

>>74888666
double trips

nice

I'm gonna go against the grain and say it's going to be like a 6. Fight me IRL

>>74888666
8.6 CONFIRMED

>>74888715
I'll fight you all the way back to r/indieheads

>>74888217
Does it matter? They could give it a 1/10 and the album will still be lit af

>>74888217
5.7

File: 1392340612279.jpg (23KB, 320x306px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 320x306px

>>74888666
Checked

>>74888217
It's definitely going to get BNM, but it won't deserve it. Kind of redundant to say that at this point, though.

>>74888750
well no of course it doesn't really matter, but does it have to?

>>74888793
You faggots sure act like it matters

>>74888666
6.6 is the correct score

It's going to be a 10. Screenshot this

File: images (1).jpg (17KB, 279x181px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 279x181px

>>74888666
You summoned?

>>74888666
devil magic confirms we get a 10

I feel like they're either gonna give it a REALLY REALLY high score or a REALLY REALLY low one. I'm thinking above 9.0 or below 4.0

8.9
screenshot this.

>>74888850
Below 4 would be absolutely dumb. They sure as hell aren't gonna rate this below Everything Now.

>>74888810
it's just fun to anticipate what one of the biggest indie reviewers is gonna say about this album that a bunch of us dig, idunno

>>74888217

9.5 you wait and see

>>74888666

wew lad

File: 49874373.png (113KB, 402x400px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 402x400px

HOLY SHIT!

>>74888985
fuck you

>>74888985
here's your you

if this shit even sniffs a 9, Dedicated to Bobby Jameson deserves a 9.7+

>>74888985
welp

>>74888985
too high for p4k

NO REVIEW TONIGHT
SCREENSHOT THIS

>>74889051
probably this

>>74888274
Probably this

File: Screenshot 2017-09-01 at 1.02.12 AM.png (166KB, 519x483px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 519x483px

welp

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/lcd-soundsystem-american-dream/

>>74889131

damn...

8.5

LOL

>>74889131
PANNED
A
N
N
E
D

Straight to the recycle bin.

>>74889131
>panned this hard
murphy is finished

>>74889131
So this puts it above S/T but below This Is Happening and SoS

I think that's pretty fair desu

Coondrick about to pull off the 3x aoty record. Noggification of pitchfork.

MELON WILL RATE IT A 5
SCREENCAP THIS

So are they just not giving out 9s this year? Only two so far, and no big releases scheduled for the rest of the year

>>74889131
its over

>>74889131
absolutely NOBODY should be surprised by this, good album, definitely not a masterpiece nor is it AOTY material

DTBJ will beat this pretty easily

>>74889181
there's a gy!be album in sept

>>74889213
and they gave their last album a fat 7.6

File: 1493519382032.jpg (96KB, 1180x765px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 1180x765px

>>74889131
>album gets a good score and labeled as "Best New Music"
>HURR DURR IT DIDN'T GET A 9.2 LCD IS FINISHED
What the fuck is wrong with you morons?

>>74889228
half of it was boring endless drones

>>74889239
>endless drones
>gybe

uhhh

>>74889237
www.hownew.ru

>>74889177

light 8

>>74888725
Off by 1

>>74889212
tf is DTBJ

>>74888730
hey guys moderator for indieheads here ama

>>74889237

are u new here

>>74889237
newfag

>>74889255
>>74889272
>XD it's just /mu/mour lululul

no. an 8.5 is trash for something this hyped.

>>74889271
Will you be my gf?
If so, are you into scat?

>>74889271
why are you guys so white?

>>74888217
8.0

>>74889270
dedicated to bobby jameson

>>74889300

it's a pitchfork rating. shut the fuck up kid

>>74889300
lol 8.5 still means it's a great album

you guys are fucking weird

>>74889271
How do you feel about being almost as bad as r/music?

>>74889237
P A N N E D

>>74888354
then it should be 9.1

File: ryminanutshell.jpg (79KB, 803x349px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 803x349px

which one of your faggots wrote this

it'll be a 7.9 and people'll still act like they panned it

File: 1501573717662.jpg (41KB, 396x382px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 396x382px

>>74889237

8.4

2027

10th Anniversary Edition

10/10 Best New Reissue

I fucking hate Pitchfork

Pitchfork got this wrong, its a 9.1 in comparison to the scores of their other albums

>>74889255
>>74889272
>>74889292
>>74889731
Hook, line, and sinker

The album has the worst opening track & worst closing track in their discography. Sleep is just a boring Dance Yrself. 8.5 is far too generous but what else would you expect.

File: 4L_aB7cS8lR.png (215KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 700x700px

time to guess their ratings /mu/
maybe Christgau while you're at it

it deserves a 4.5 but it's getting a 7.3

>>74890365
>brutally murdered best friend
What is that a reference to? Did he accidentally kill his friend or something?

>>74890417
Its pretty obvious he did it intentionally go read about it, dudes name was Cal or something

>>74890365
Fantano 5/10
Scaruffi 6/10
Christgau B+
Also where did fantano say the wall was the best album of all time

>>74890669
I really like Fantano and like listening to him but I disagree with him strongly 90% of the time. I truly think he has awful taste in music but a really engaging way of talking about it.

Saturation II by Brockhampton is really sloppy with tons of really shitty songs and he rates it an 8 while the new LCD Soundsystem album is a logical next step for the band with some truly excellent pieces of music and I guarantee you he will rate it a 5.

my first time listening to the album and i feel like it's a classic case of "blew the load with the singles". I've always thought lcd soundsystem are really single-oriented in nature, though, so it's fine. P4k score is a point or two higher than I'd rate it, but if it were up to me their old shit would have lower reviews as well

>>74889177
Melon is irrelevant

>>74888217
I will never understand why people care so much about the scores from p4k and Melon.

>>74891364

People like to feel validated one way or the other.

>>74891414
It's a shame. When melon pans this album a lot of people are gonna miss out on a great comeback record.

>>74891486
they never had anything to come back to m8

>>74890051
>hurr durr i was just pretending to be retarded for epic (u)'s
You're not fooling anyone, turbonerd.

I seriously rate it a 9.5.

>>74892595
Agreed. It's their best album.