If Blackstar was called AOTY and given 10/10's by many,

>>74180568
Blackstar wasn't bad.
so no

Fun fact: Bowie actually killed himself. Or technically assisted suicide.

>>74180654
Shitty rumor

>>74180568
no, Blackstar was being critically acclaimed before his death.

Blackstar was good. A magnum opus from an icon. This is a crappy sellout pop album by a memed band whose singer killed himself. So no

>>74180652
>>74180868
>>74180915
wrong
http://www.scaruffi.com/vol3/bowie.html#bls

File: 1494118976441.jpg (47KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 640x960px

both are dissappointing, so whatever

Nah, Blackstar was a fantastic album while One More Light blows.

And I like Linkin Park.

>>74181529
wow one whole bad review. Guess that shows us!

File: 1481496501873.gif (3MB, 286x258px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 286x258px

>>74181529
>This is trivial "music" that any amateur could make, except that most amateurs would be ashamed to release it.
It amazes me some people still take him seriously and get triggered when people call out the dumb shit he's said

>>74181529
wow you're right, this guy just discredited the whole album. now it's utter dogshit. thanks anon!

>>74181529
>not realizing scaruffi is a satire site
come on now

>>74181529
wtf i hate david bowie now

>>74181913
Scruffy is a meme at this point.

>>74181920
Scaruffi has some pretty good opinions sometimes

>>74180568
but blackstar is actually good

>>74182001
Scaruffi is a contrarian faggot who only stumbles ass backwards into "good" opinions because he's too much of a shut in to realize that other people like some of the music he considers good.

I think the title track's worth something in the wake of the suicide but otherwise not really.

>>74180757
It's not a rumor and it's not a shitty rumor

What part of terminal illness do you not understand?

>>74181529
didn't know scaruffi literally makes music good or bad