pink floyd was at their best when it was a combination of everyone

>>74110600
Literally plebbest fucking shit opinion I've ever heard. Your description of Meddle is more Ummagumma. Meddle is their best album.

>>74110642
OP is right. You're not.

>>74110642
everyone was working together on meddle probably the best since saucerful of secrets, but there is not clear direction on the album. its not a concept album like dark side or the wall

>>74110687
piper and saucerful is better than anything roger ever pushed onto the group

>>74110701
Doesn't matter when the music on Dark Side and The Wall is literally glorified pop rock

>>74110715
most of saucerful is roger waters ideas, dipshit. and as good as piper and syd are, theyre nowhere near as good as dark side or WYWH era waters so gtfo wit dat shite

File: 51I7BoDxRCL.jpg (53KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 500x500px

>in the middle you have dark side and wish you were here, their best albums.

Dude what?

>>74110642
Ummagumma is each member doing their own thing and resulted in their best album
literally every other album they created was made with a boundary put on it. Ummagumma was them at their most original and avant garde

>>74110715
>piper
Yes.
>and saucerful
No way

>>74110642
This. Meddle and DSOTM are the only albums where Pink Floyd is really a band and not just Syd /Waters and The Pink Floyds. Meddle>DSOTM because of Echoes and One Of These Days obviously

>>74110793
>Meddle and DSOTM are the only albums where Pink Floyd is really a band
They were a band from Sauceurful up to WYWH.

>>74110782
ummagumma has always deep down been my secret favorite album. i cant tell people its my favorite album because its so weird and minimalist

>>74110737
most of the lyrics are waters' retard and they're not even very good lyrics

File: madcap_f.jpg (847KB, 1289x1263px) Image search: [Google]

847KB, 1289x1263px

>>74110600
>when the best Pink Floyd record wasn't even a Pink Floyd record

>>74110771
What happened to that sleeve? Is it the sharter version?