What's the melon review you disagree with the most? Also,

probably Narkopop, that shit was an 8 not a 2

Wolf is pretty good too

>>73572205
TKOL. Still the best pleb filter.

File: garbage.jpg (690KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

690KB, 600x600px

>>73572205

>>73572205
He was right tho

>>73572205
His Age of Adz review where he gave it a six. It's my album of the decade and I think it's at least a nine.

File: asaod.jpg (18KB, 220x220px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 220x220px

>>73572342
Also this

>>73572205
MBDTF
Acid Rap
I don't like shit, I don't go outside
Wolf
Yeezus
Blank Face LP

The melon man doesn't know rap

>>73572205
His brand new review of BODYGUARD is abhorrently wrong. He's lost all credibility in my eyes.

File: ebe389c7b2f9469e914f6d49108fad0c.jpg (43KB, 770x678px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 770x678px

>>73572344
Same, he really fucked it up with that one

>>73572370
>Give Kendrick a 10
>Doesn't know anything about rap
Lmao

>>73572642
Yes, thank you for further proving my point

I cant fucking believe he gave PBVGR a 4

>>73572205
He was pretty spot on with MBDTF, Yeezus and TKOL.

His biggest misses for me are Age of Adz, Morning Phase, Trouble Will Find Me and obviously Narkopop is the most recent one.

>>73572344
Also, the recent Planetarium one. AOTY and he gave it a five.

>>73572344
He could at least give it a 7. I think he feels pressure to not give Sufjan too much credit since people worship him a bit too much. I mean he liked All Delighted People but I cannot fathom how he can praise A Crow Looked At Me (an album that sounds the exact same the entire way through with no sense of progression) and shit on Carrie and Lowell for not going anywhere in the second half.

>>73572854
His hateboner for The National is something I will never quite understand

bodyguard

File: 1.jpg (51KB, 481x481px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 481x481px

music is subjective. he reviews based on how ~he~ feels an album was to ~him~.

why should how an internet man feels about an album matter to you?

>>73572205
>also dont post mbdtf, everyone knows he was right
FTFY

>>73572370
>>73572763
>OF/Chance fag triggered
lol

>>73572298

THIS

literally their best album

>>73573332
Wow, didn't see this coming.

File: AlexG-Rocket-72dpi.jpg (1MB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1000x1000px

>>73572205
this

>>73572205
Lil Boat, but in the other way round

The review I disagreed with the most was The Raven That Refused To Sing. That album was not a strong 4 to a light 5

>>73572763
^^^
imagine being this retarded

Alvvays.

The songwriting on that album should have at the very least qualified it for a formal review instead of that shitty cell phone video he gave it.

his review of the new Slowdive and the review of the last Wonder Years record. Didn't even consider most of the tracks on the wonder years one. its like he didnt even listen.

>>73572205
To Pimp a Butterfly. It was an 8/10 at best.

>>73574319
THIS, easy 9/10

>>73572205
R+7, but I have not heard Narkopop, so that one could be much worse

>>73574691
He kind of automatically writes off a lot of dreampop, folk pop, baroque pop, etc and always says the same thing about it.

"It's dreamy, kind of boring, doesn't really do anything for me."

>>73572205
kero kero bonito
ariel pink - pom pom
dumbo gets mad
blank face

>>73574142
nice, you're either in he autistic 1% or the contrarian 4%

>>73574775
I RESPECTFULLY DISAGREE

The Most Lamentable Tragedy. His review was just embarrassing.

File: foxygenstarpower.jpg (19KB, 320x320px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 320x320px

>>73572205

>Tomorrow's Harvest is a fucking great album.
>An Impression is [spillers] better than Nouns [/oilspill]

>>73572298
>>73572351
these
>>73574878
kkb's review was alright, I'd give it a 7 but whatever (although other 7s have been given to her as well)

File: Untitled.png (542KB, 839x479px) Image search: [Google]

542KB, 839x479px

are his ears even functional?

>>73572205
I can't really say. I stopped listening to his reviews after it was clear by the third video that he has no soul and an academic knowledge of music severely hamstrung by a lack of passion.

He also comes off as an unoriginal, smarmy cunt who paraphrases Jack Rabid and old Magnet reviews.

File: dan-deacon-america.jpg (145KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 800x800px

He gave my favorite album a 5. What a bleb.

John Frusciante, PBX and Enclosure. He gave both a 2/10