NIN discography rated 1) The Downward Spiral 2) Year Zero 3)

>>73337154
The Fragile and Broken should be higher and The Slip should be lower. Otherwise, I agree. Hesitation Marks, in particular, is mad underrated.

>>73337184
My rating changes a lot, The Fragile used to be at the place of Year Zero.

>>73337154
Stop listening to nine inch nails

File: 1.png (2MB, 1262x1564px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1262x1564px

>>73337207
tell me what other stuff to listen to.

>>73337195
The Fragile is #2 for me right now. It rivals TDS at its best moments. The double album curse really gets to it though.

>>73337216
It is definetelly a master piece with some of the best tracks, I just never can properly listen to its entirety due to its lenght and strange flow of the album. Maybe how tracks were organized may something to do with it. There is so much to digest. I think I usually stop listening to it at around Even Deeper. And I don't even dislike that song
I feel like albums like Hesitation Marks or Year Zero are much better listening experiences from beginning to end. One of the reasons why The Slip is so high on my list is due to how amazingly the tracks are put together and how nicely the album floats.

Why do people hate With Teeth? It's comfy depression music.

>>73337662
I really like With_Teeth, most hate it due to the wait it took from The Fragile to With Teeth, I think it is one of his best works, it is super agressive and depressive too with a comfy ending.

1. Pretty Hate Machine
2. DWS
3. Fragile
4. With Teeth

Rest doesn't matter

>>73337274
Yeah The Fragile is pretty hard to get through it all but it's worth it.

File: 1481573161476.png (896KB, 796x800px) Image search: [Google]

896KB, 796x800px

The Fragile > Hesitation Marks > Year Zero > Pretty Hate Machine > Broken > Not The Actual Events > Ghosts I-IV > The Downward Spiral > With_Teeth > The Slip >And All That Could Have Been/Still > Purest Feeling > Strobe Light > Mechanical Animals >Antichrist Superstar

>>73337154
Jesus christ, Pretty Hate Machine at 8? What the fuck are you thinking?

File: Trent reznor 1989 (2).jpg (35KB, 492x246px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 492x246px

>"“The Fragile is weird because when it came out it felt like everyone hated it to me, and now it feels like it’s everyone’s favorite album, at least fan-wise. I think, in hindsight, I should have had The Fragile two single records, much like Radiohead did with Kid A and Amnesiac, recorded at once, broken into two digestible chunks. Hey, it is what it is.”

:3

Downward Spiral
Year Zero
The Fragile
Broken
Pretty Hate Machine
Not The Actual Events
With Teeth
Hesitation Marks
The Slip

Like most of the anons on this thread so far, my rating fluctuates a lot. When The Slip first came out I thought it was better than PHM, for example.

Hesitation Marks still hasn't clicked for me. I don't think any NIN album is under a 5/10, so I don't think it's bad, I just don't think it's to the level the classics are.

>>73337973
This guy knows what's up

Broken > TDS > shit > rest of the discog