>Greatest Singer ever Paul McCartney >Greatest Songwriter

>Greatest Singer ever Richard Manuel
>Greatest Songwriter ever Robbie Robertson
>Greatest Drummer ever Levon Helm
>Greatest Guitarist ever Robbie Robertson

Fuck off.

>>72871130
>Greatest Singer ever Paul McCartney
>Greatest Songwriter ever Paul McCartney
>Greatest Drummer ever Paul McCartney
>Greatest Guitarist ever Paul McCartney

>>72872275
This.

>>72871130
>Greatest Drummer ever Ringo Starr

what? i mean he's good, he wrote some memorable beats
but he's not the best

File: 05.jpg (21KB, 351x300px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 351x300px

>>72872275
Kek

It's true too

>>72871151
>Robbie Robertson
everyone else in the band died poor because he took all the money
he is anything but great
I hope he suffers greatly

>>72872318
Imma guess
Keith Moon fan?

>>72872348

https://youtu.be/4KP9PNSUME4

>>72871130
I'll maybe give you McCartney and Lennon but Harrison and Ringo were far from it. They were best as a collective anyway.

>>72871130
They have literally one passably good song named she's so heavy, and you've probably never heard of it.

Cornell yourself.

>>72871130
Ringo wasn't even the best drummer in the Beatles

Also daily reminder everything before Rubber Soul was shit

>>72872464
>>Also daily reminder everything before Rubber Soul was shit

Unbelievably incorrect. Please listen again to these masterpieces (not even counting singles):

>No Reply
>If I Fell
>I'll Be Back
>I Saw Her Standing There
>I've Just Seen a Face
>You've Got to Hide Your Love Away
>All My Loving

>>72871151
did you take this shitpost seriously?

>>72872539
Sounds like songs a faggot would listen to while masturbating to pics of his Brazilian boyfriend.

>>72872539
I'll concede You've got to hide your love away is a very well-written song but on average those previous albums were bland and uninspired copycat pop garbage

>>72872595
>bland and uninspired copycat pop garbage
You can say you don't like them, but this is objectively incorrect. Their early sound was as a whole incredibly forward thinking, that's why they were so fucking popular. They combined a bunch of fucking influences to create a pop sound that had more energy and character than basically anything that came before it.

You can say it was in service of some ultimately pretty saccharine or populist kind of goals, but by no means was it bland, uninspired, or copycat. People copied them, not the other way around.

>>72872275
>>72872305
>>72872325
paul fags are fucking cancer

>>72872464
>Ringo wasn't even the best drummer in the Beatles
stop spouting this shitty meme phrase
Paul never said that and it's not true at all

>>72872318
Ringo wrote none of beatles beats

>>72872715
This fag is correct. Ticket to Ride would be considered innovative even today as it's sound is extremely mimicked.