Do you consider this a part of In Rainbows when you're considering

No, because it's fucking awful.

no, because is not on the album.

>>72280317
and because it's fucking awful

>>72280310
>>72280326
Why don't you just consider it an awful part of the album though? If half the songs on the album of any other artist was awful, would you still just dismiss it as "not part of the album"?

Down Is The New Up should've been on the main album desu

>>72280299
Never listened to it, how much am i missing out on

>>72280505
Bangers + Mash is pretty dope

Up on The Ladder really should have been on the main album

Last Flowers should really have been on the main album.

All tracks are good aside from mk2 (mk1 is at least interesting because of the whole gimmick with Videotape)

>>72280370
Because the original release didn't include both albums

>>72280370
> would you still just dismiss it as "not part of the album"?
yes, i'd never count something that amounts to a bonus disc.

even compilations like Analphabetapolothology, I really only care about the first 12 tracks, even if the rest is p good too

>>72280370
do you count the b-sides of any other album a apart of the album
it's literally just a more convenient way of releasing the b sides

>>72280299
I consider it more of an EP. Definitely not part of the album itself. It clearly wasn't intended to be. Unless of course the band stated at some point that they intended it to be. I don't think that's the case though.