Who would be the perfect band if you could pick anyone from any

>>71369562
can someone please explain to me how this hack ended up being concidered one of the GOAT?

>>71369580
he perfected glam/hard rock riffs imo i cant think of one day riff or solo from him

>>71369616
bad*

>>71369580
He is a very solid rocknroll guitar player and has an image that attracts image-obsessed teenagers who still haven't matured enough to listen to music for the music rather than the image that it projects.

>>71369562
I mean, Mr. Big is already perfect.

To answer the fucking question:

Vocals: Bjork and T-Rez
Synths 1: Cevin Key
Synths 2: BoC
Guitar: Kevin Shields
Percussion: Neil Peart
Samples: Brian Eno

This would be very nice.

>>71369562
Vocals: Geoff Tate
Lead Guitar: Tony Iommi
Rythm Guitar: Stone Gossard
Bass: Joey DeMaio
Drums: Mike Portnoy
Keyboards: Roddy Bottum

>>71370222
would be /wank/core

>>71369580
He has a good ear for melody and his phrasing works well in the context of their songs

Zach Hill - Drums
Ron Jarzombek - Lead Guitar
Colin Marston - Bass Guitar
Greg Puciato - Vocals

File: yachty.gif (446KB, 320x180px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 320x180px

Vocals: Josey Scott
Guitar: Benji Madden
Bass: John Cooper
Drums: Meg White

It would be the 80's King Crimson formation unchanged.

Lead Vocals: Bernard Sumner
Drums: Lars Ulrich
PR: Morrissey

>>71370516
kek

david bowie
mick taylor
johnny marr
tony thompson
tina weymouth

Vocals and rhythm guitar: Kurt Cobain
Drums: Keith moon
Bass: Lemmy
Lead guitar: Rhandy Roads

guitar: Robert Fripp
guitar: John Mclaughlin
bass: Trevor Dunn
drums: Bill Bruford
keys: Herbie Hancock

they'd make some sick jazz fusion

File: 12325151.jpg (14KB, 186x217px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 186x217px

>>71369562
Bill Kelliher-riffs
Marty Friedman-Leads
Layne stayley-vocals
danney carey-drums
troy sanders-bass

call me crazy

Literally just King Crimson - Red's lineup but Greg Lake instead of John Wetton.
And I guess Belew can come along for the ride, too.

The perfect band already existed.
>Pete Townshend
>Roger Daltrey
>John Entwistle
>Keith Moon

Close to the Edge's lineup but with Greg Lake to replace Jon Anderson.
Jesus fuck, Anderson's carcinogenic vocals and godawful lyrics singlehandedly ruined Close to the Edge for me.

>inb4 "hurr durr prog lyrics are always shit"
Only babbies whose first prog song was Roundabout say this.

>>71369562
Vocals: Jeff Buckley
Guitar: David Gilmour
Drums: the two drummers from King Gizzard
Bass: unsure, don't mind too much

I can never decide favourites of anything, but who else would you put in a band with Zach Hill and Flea?

>>71372833
it's
drums - Keith Moon
bass - Jaco Pastorius (playing jazzy bassline like JPJ did in Zeppelin)
rhythm guitar and backing vocals - Buddy Holly (sharing vocal duties)
lead guitar - Jimi Hendrix
lead vocals - Jim Morrison

and for RIP rockin' in peace lineup would be
drums - John Bonham
bass - Cliff Burton
guitar - Randy Rhoads
vocals - Bon Scott

Vocals: Anthony Kiedis
Lead guitar: Yngwie Malmsteen
Rhythm guitar: Kurt Cobain
Bass: Sid Vicious
Drums: Lars Ulrich

Percussion bass: Flea
Lead bass: John Entwistle
Bass bass: Karl Alvarez
Vocal bass: Kelly-Dawn Kelso

Drum drums: Phil Rudd
Lead Drums: Travis Barker
Rhythm drums: Zach Hill
vocal drums: Ringo Starr

>>71374981
Lake - Lead Vocals
Fripp - Guitar
Belew - Guitar and vocals
Wetton - Bass and vocals
Levin - Chapman Stick
Bruford - Drums
Cross - Violin

10/10 line up

>>71375011
Then why did they make such shit music? And don't try to say they did m8, I've heard boris the fucking spider.

>>71375754
If you heard Boris and didn't enjoy it, there's no helping you. You have been consumed by the EDGY. I'm sorry, anon. Godspeed.

>>71369580

He created some of the most memorable guitar riffs and solos in rock music history. It's not all about muh tecknikul skillz

>>71375754
You have no soul.

>>71369562
John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison, and Keith Moon

File: 1487856142668.jpg (74KB, 596x628px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 596x628px

>>71375888

>>71369580
He's not a hack, he's genuinely good and has written some great Rock music. He's just not original and has an extremely generic tone and playing style to go with it.

But when it comes to standard Hard/Blues- Rock and wanky pentatonic soloing he's one of the best in the business.

>>71377190
Throw in Eric Clapton and there's a halfway decent band.

>>71377352
>he's not a hack
>he's just not original yet very successful

What did he mean by this?

I'd certainly give that a listen.

>>71373037
I feel like Fripp and Herb wouldn't get along or play well together. If it worked, I'm sure it would be glorious, but I don't see it working.

>>71375463
Ugh. I bit.

I really want to hear Phronesis play with the Avishai Cohen Trio (as it was during Gently Disturbed, anyway), but I can't really imagine a band with two drummers, two bassists, and two pianists working. If they could pull it off though (without taking the tame route that Jasper took with Fellow Creatures), it'd be fucking glorious!

Vox: DEAD

Guitars: Snorre

Bass, rhythm guitars: Joakim Karlsson (CRAFT)

Drums: Uruz (Urgehal)

Les Claypool

Trey Anastasio

Stewart Copeland

>>71369562
Jason Noble - Samples/tapes/guitar/vocals
Jeff Mueller - Guitar/vocals
Brian McMahan - Guitar/lyrics/vocals
Tara Jane O'Neil - Bass guitar/vocals/lyrics
Kevin Coultas - Drums/guitar

Or

Jason Noble - Samples/tapes/bass guitar
Jeff Mueller - Guitar/vocals
David Pajo - Guitar
Brian McMahan - vocals/lyrics
Tara Jane O'Neil -Samples/bells/whistles/harmonica/violin/lyrics
Britt Walford - Drums
Kevin Coultas - Samples/tapes/guitar

>>71369562
Vocals/Guitar: Marc Bolan
Bass: Bootsy Collins
Drums: Keith Moon

Guitar - Jimmy Page
Bass - John Paul Jones
Vocals - Robert Plant
Drums - Meg White

>>71369580
slash is actually fucking incredible

>>71379292
this

>>71379292
Bernard "Pretty" Purdie instead of Meg

>lead vocals
Daryl Hall
>backing vocals
Elvis Costello
>guitar
Stevie Ray Vaughn
>bass
Tony Levin
>drums
Phil Collins
>synth
Roland Orzabal

Freddy Mercury on vocals
Frank Zappa on lead guitar
Jimi Hendrix on rhythm guitar
Les Claypool on bass
John Bonham on drums

>Dan Barrett
>John Cale
>Michael Rother
>Colin Stetson
>Jamie Stewart

>>71369580
He does not wash his hair and somehow that appeals to a lot of people.

File: 1470377741802.gif (1MB, 350x350px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 350x350px

Phill Collins on drums
Steve Vai on lead guitar
Prince on rhythm guitar
Paul Chambers on bass
GG Allin on vocals

Rhythm guitar- will swan
Lead guitar-omar rod lop
Bass- thundercat
Drums- John theodore
Vocals- guy from fugazi
Samples/synths- opn

File: 1488120454800.gif (2MB, 300x369px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 300x369px

Vocals - Bruce Dickinson
Lead guitar - Yngwie Malmsteen
Rhythm guitar - Dave Mustaine
Bass - Cliff Burton
Drums - Mickey Dee

>>71369562
Vocals: Robert Plant
Guitar: David Gilmour & Alexi Laiho
Bass: Steve Harris
Drums: Mario Duplantier
Keys: literally anyone with 10 fingers.

Ultimate math-post-kraut band coming throgh

Guitar : Victor Villarreal
Drums : Britt Walford
Bass : Vern Rumsey
Samples / electronics : Geologist
Vocals : Damo Suzuki

real talk:

Bryan Ferry
Kevin Shields
Johnny Thunders
Clyde Stubblefield
the Disclosure guys

>>71381669
>>71370222
why shields?
His guitar takes up like 90% of the sound, everything would just get buried, he only really works in MBV because the other members make room for him

>>71369562
Drums: John Bonham
Bass: Robert Deleo
Rhythm Guitar: Greg Ginn
Lead Guitar: Stevie Ray Vaughan
Lead Vocals: Layne Staley

>>71378350
hey it's oysterhead

File: 1473701942211.jpg (83KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 640x480px

Cedric Bixler-Zavala
Jonny Greenwood
Thurston Moore
Panda Bear
Tina Weymouth
Eric Copeland

I wonder how this would sound

File: 364DD2E7-71C2-4041-818D-09FABD59994A-6590-000002F016891C86_tmp.jpg (77KB, 582x847px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 582x847px

>>71369562
Rhythmic Guitar and Vocals: John Lennon
Bass and Vocals: Paul McCartney
Lead Guitar: George Harrison
Drums: Pete Best

>>71375736
>Cross
He'd get kicked out again for not playing loud enough in concerts, poor guy.

Jokes aside, that is literally a perfect lineup.

>>71377352
his use your illusions tone is pretty interesting in my opinion

>>71377352
>great rock and roll, uh, music