>The Beach Boys >Over 29 albums >Two (debatable) 10/10

File: 1488062835110.jpg (68KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 960x540px

So you are saying Summer in Paradise isn't 10/10

>>71320683
Pet sounds ain't 10/10, it would have been if Brian wilson had gave it to the beatles to sing it

>>71320747
>What's Sgt Pepper???

Beach Boys are monstrously overrated on this board

And this is coming from a huge fan who even loves all their goofy bullshit like Little Saint Nick and Be True to Your School

File: IMG_20170301_072855_01.png (21KB, 582x109px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 582x109px

>>71320683
>>71320747
>>71320752

if you think listening to the same 7/10 album 6 times over makes them all equally good you're a retard.
Especially when the songs are just 1 minute loops and all revolve around the exact same generic shit.

>>71320902
Sho are you?

>>71320902
shit bait t b h

But none of those made a 10/10 album ever what are you smoking ??

>>71321184
Fuck off faggot

>>71321184
>tripfag
>knows nothing
Checks out

>>71321184
You were banned for making a list on RYM just shut up.

>>71320683
But the only debatable 10/10s by The Beatles is Revolver and Sgt.Pepper's

>>71321608
a b b e y r o a d

>>71320683
>Beach Boys 10/10

Pet Sounds
Smile Smiley
Smile Sessions
Friends
Sunflower
Surf's Up

>>71321735
>implying

>>71321795
Lmao no

>>71321795
>two versions of the smile sessions
Yeah, the greatest Beatles albums are
>Let It Be
>Let It Be... Naked
>Get Back (Glyn Johns 1st mix)
>Get Back (Glyn Johns 2nd mix)
>The January 1969 sessions
>The rooftop concert
>Anthology 3 disk 2
All 10/10

>Beatles

like 5 9/10 albums

>Beach Boys

2 11/10 albums

>>71321865
not the same sessions my fella

Smile Smiley was recorded after Smile

>>71321608
Please Please Me
A Hard Day's Night
Beatles For Sale
Help!
Rubber Soul
Revolver
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Magical Mystery Tour
The White Album
Abbey Road
Let It Be

The only album they made that wasn't 10/10 is Yellow Submarine. But the 1998 Yellow Submarine Songtrack is 10/10

>>71321894
I forgot With The Beatles, but it's 10/10

>>71321882
Smiley Smile is another version of Smile, dude

>>71321909
>Smile Smiley is another version of Smile, dude
there's songs wrriten for Smile Smiley not for Smile, lad

File: 1487366780237.png (325KB, 656x602px) Image search: [Google]

325KB, 656x602px

>>71321795
>>71321882
>>71321928
>Smile Smiley

>>71321795
>Smile Smiley
>Friends
>Sunflower
>Surfs Up

Above decent album, stop pretending they are otherwise

>>71321880
this

>>71321608
>is

>>71321995
>not liking Smile Smiley
it's their best album desu

>>71320683
>implying Pet Sounds is higher than an 8/10
>implying Beatles have one (1) album that's higher than a 6/10
absolute peasantry

>>71322118
t. I DON'T LIKE POP kid

go listen to your Dream Theather

>>71322118
>Dream Theater
absolute peasantry

>>71322118
Every Beatles album but Yellow Submarine is 10/10

>>71322189
>8/10 for Pet Sounds = not liking pop
okay...

The chord change in Penny Lane is better than anything than the beach boys did that's a helluva a feat

The Beatles have some great albums but not even a single 10/10. They all have throwaways.

>>71322260
EVERY.
SINGLE.
ALBUM.

>>71322260
>a 10/10 is an album that doesn't have throwaways
i'm sure you're talking about 'greatest hits' compilations

>>71321894
im a huge beatle fan but let it be beatles for sale and mmt are definitely not tens

>>71322331
I'm talking about albums like Lark's Tongue in Aspic, Animals, and Foxtrot that literally have no throwaways.

>>71322208
every thought you have but the suicidal ones is wrong

>>71322425
>Foxtrot
>literally have no throwaways
okay, enough /mu/ for the day

>>71322425
Animals is nothing but throwaways

None of those artists has done anything worth more than a 4/10.

>>71322425
>Foxtrot
i like all of the tracks on it but none of them are great. always pick quality over quantity, kid.

>>71322491
Shitty bait

>>71322502
>"Anything I disagree with is bait!"

>>71322460
Name one. They're all stellar tracks.
Saying that an album can have throwaway tracks and still be 10/10 is retarded. How can an album be perfect when not all its tracks are perfect?

>>71322542
name one stellar track off Foxtrot

>>71322542
>Horizons

>>71322593
Literally all of them.
>>71322597
It's a beautiful little instrumental that leads perfectly into Supper's Ready.

>>71322515
At least you are trying, which is cute

>>71322515
Grow up and welcome to the chan.

File: 658.jpg (18KB, 260x384px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 260x384px

>>71322637
>welcome to the chan

>>71322617
>It's a beautiful little instrumental that leads perfectly into Supper's Ready.
still a filler

>>71322208
>Please Please Me
>With the Beatles
>Beatles for Sale
>Help!
>Let It Be
>10/10
No.

File: 1464460943202.jpg (18KB, 570x587px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 570x587px

>>71322689
>instrumental tracks are all filler

>>71322617
>Literally all of them.
yeah, i've gathered that from your previous post. now defend your opinion and make sure it's not a short non-argumentative blurb too.

>>71322816
They're all instrumentally and lyrically unique, and they're all solid tracks start to finish.
>>71322689
>it's short and doesn't have lyrics so it's filler

>>71322872
>They're all instrumentally and lyrically unique, and they're all solid tracks start to finish.
why?

>>71322940
What do you mean, why? Listen to them and hear it yourself.

>>71322949
what's the point of arguing if you're not going to say anything substantial?

>>71323031
Because I can tell that you're gonna continue naysaying everything I say.

beatles have a bunch of good albums

beach boys have three godlike albums

>>71323078
why do you say that? incapable to argue or aware that Foxtrot isn't perfect?

>>71322251
Bruh it's just some modulation that's all. The Beach Boys modulated ALL OVER pet sounds

>>71320683
I seriously wasn't even aware there was a competition between The Beatles and The Beach Boys until I came onto this board.

In the UK it's kind of without question that The Beatles are the best band, and their main rivals were The Rolling Stones and The Who. Not some American wannabes.

File: Pepe Jim Morrison.png (163KB, 804x804px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 804x804px

>>71320683

>it's a "people don't understand how bell curves work" thread

Pet Sounds > everything Beatles ever did

>>71323218
>Beatles arent important because it's just modulation
>Beach Boys are import because of modulation
Well make up your mind

>>71325493
anything the Beatles ever did > anything the Beach Boys ever did other than Pet Sounds

The Beach Boys Today! is basically a 10/10 if you remove Bull Sessions and put on Brian's Guess I'm Dumb backing track.

Hell play Today and Summer Days back two back and you have an incredible double album

BBoys were more of a singles band, their good stuff came out earlier when singles were more dominant

No band has a greater amount of 8/10 albums than the Beach Boys:

All Summer Long
Today
Summer Days
Smiley Smile
Wild Honey
Friends
Sunflower
Surf's Up
Love You

>>71324316
Dude. Brian Wilson is seen as a god in the UK. I've met people who worship him

>>71326615
Even though The Beatles had better albums, I honestly find the variation between stuff like Today, Friends and Love You miles more interesting than a lot of The Beatles stuff.

You won't meet too many bigger Beatle fans than me. That being said, Pet Sounds is better than any Beatle album, and often I feel the best album ever.

>>71326659
Seriously? Like people know who he is, but most people I talk to know God Only Knows from Love Actually, not from Pet Sounds