>middle school tier metalcore >8/10 >possibly the most

>>70307526
boring post mate, you're all about image and not about sound

>>70307526
>how can anyone defend this
why does anyone need to defend it? Dude had an opinion, you don't like it, oh well.

we should have 8 more threads about it just to be sure

Lets reword it using more...musical qualities

>album with a very large variety of styles, rhythms, timbres, and melodies with a metalcore base that's an uniquely triumphant take on something otherwise dark and surreal
>8/10

>anachronistic/outdated jazz rock that's also a regression for the style due to how simplified it is which initially got some decent reviews whose ratings went sky high once its author died a couple days after release
>4/10

>>70307526

is this a meme? because I can't find it on his website.

why doesnt he ever fix his ugly website?

>>70307526
>implying Colors isn't an 8/10 album in its realm and context

Did we listen to the same record?

>>70308034
That's his aesthetic

he's just too deep for you

50 bucks says you didnt actually listen to colors and even when you listened to blackstar you were thinking about how fucking hip you were

Colors is great and all but Scaroof says it's black metal which is just not accurate at all

>>70307788
>>anachronistic/outdated jazz rock that's also a regression for the style due to how simplified it is which initially got some decent reviews whose ratings went sky high once its author died a couple days after release
Blackstar was getting great reception before Bowie died.

t. A person who thinks Bowie's mostly overrated, listened to Blackstar two days before he died and thought it was amazing.

>>70307973
http://www.scaruffi.com/cdreview/new.html