Hey /mu/ I'm making a sad music chart It's simply,

i hate this idea but xiu xiu goes in layer 4

File: Sad music chart.png (17KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 872x924px

>>70168843
Done

>>70168824
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy should be Stage 3 or 2.
Pinkerton is 1.

File: Sad music chart.png (18KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 872x924px

>>70168955
Also done

souvlaki stage 3 or 4

>>70168824

>Have a nice Life on 3
>Chelsea Wolfe on 2/3
>Slint on 2
>Americ anFootbal on 1/2
>Burzum on 2
>The Cure on 2
>Jesu on 2/3
>Joy Division on 2/3
>Sunn O))) on 3
>This Will Destroy You on 2

Home, Like NoPlace Is There
Stage 4

>>70168824
both joy division albums at 4 desu

carrie & lowell at 2 or 3, age of adz at 3

File: Sad music chart.png (22KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 872x924px

>>70169057
>>70168997
Here
I persoanlly want to add radiohead...

File: Sad music chart.png (22KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 872x924px

Fuck it, I added it

>>70169168
OK Computer, Kid A both at 3 IMO
In Rainbows, Amnesiac, AMSP at 2
The Bends at 1

>>70169168
Home, Like Noplace is There is Emo Shit. Get it out of stage 4

Death in June definitely deserves layer 4. I mean, I haven't heard much other music that is that nihilistic and beautiful.

>>70169168
>>70169318
You don't have to ask, it's your own chart...

>>70169318
>>70169345
oops nvm

>>70169345
I only add either a specific album, or a band in general.
Man, I remember my first time listening to Radiohead...

>stage 4
dead can dance
current 93
sol invictus


stage 3
red house painters

>>70169318
>radiohead

Kinda triggered. Albums like The Bends deserve to be at 1 or 2, but albums like Amnesiac can easily fit in 4.

File: 2410728.jpg (174KB, 600x597px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 600x597px

>>70169318
make a new section at the bottom for this

>>70169318
Leonard Cohen - Songs about Love And Hate should go around the 2/3 area

Giles Corey goes on the bottom of Stage 4 because after that point you fucking killed yourself.

Also The Glow Pt 2 should go in stage 4 too.

>>70169318
stage 4: every DSBM release.

File: Sad music chart.png (24KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 872x924px

Here you go guys

Ariel Pink's Haunted Graffiti in Stage 4
AnCo in Stage 3

>>70169515

>Stage 1
Cap n Jazz
Sunny Day Real Estate
Saves The Day

>Stage 2
Bjork's Vespertine or Homeogenic
Nothing - Guilty Of Everything
Pretty Hate Machine

>Stage 3
Spirits They've gone Spirits They've Vanished
The Fragile

>Stage 4
Skinny Puppy

>>70169611
the NIN albums are definitely in the right place

>AnCo
>sad
>wat (ok STGSTV and down there, yes)

robert wyatt = tier 3
hospice - tier 2

>>70169515
interpol on 1
arcade fire on 2
coil on 4
oxbow on 4
This heat on 4
SPK on 4
relocate radiohead to 3
ajj on 2
>>70169454 on 4 at least
>joy of division

File: Sad music chart.png (29KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 872x924px

I'm leaving it there.
Thank you guys
Now I have some new stuff to listen to when I'm sad.. I'll check all of it out
It has been fun.
good night

>>70169640
All of AnCo is prettt sad. Avey Tare and Panda are both on antidepressants and have been for years. Down there is an incredibly sad record. Even their upbeat stuff like Painting With comes off as fake and drug fueled "happiness"

ITAOTS could probably be a tier 2

You know this chart makes me want to make a one of albums for the five stages of grief

>>70169702
Good idea. If you're note gonna do it then I will

>>70169669
stage 4-Daddy's Boy Into The Closet Part 1

Simply sad

>>70169727
I mean go right ahead senpai, I'm too lazy to make a template

Patron Saint of Bridge Burner's album "Sorry" should be 3 or 4

Planning for Burial - stage 4
Eels - stage 2/3
Sparklehorse - stage 3


also why is fucking stgstv and anco in general on stage 3?
rec some real sad music and not memeshit

Carissa's Wierd has to go somewhere
Same with Red House Painters

File: grief.png (32KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 1678x748px

the guy's gone to sleep

help me fill this out instead

albums only please

>>70169677
ITAOTS is what 14 yr olds listen to when they break up with their girlfriend of 2 weeks fag

>>70170228
tier 1, then?

>>70170138
Pearl Jam - Vs.
Anger

>>70168824

stage 4 ---> Matt Elliott

jesus christ this is the worst thread ive ever seen on mu

>>70170138
Antlers-Hospice
All levels.

>>70170359
>sad music triggers me

Anon, it's ok it's safe to let go in here

File: grief.png (36KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 1678x748px

>>70170380
pick one

>>70170138
Planning for Burial - Leaving
Depression

>>70170472
Depression I guess.

>>70170138
>Acceptance
California

File: grief.png (46KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 1678x748px

>>70170507
k

>>70170569
bungle?

>>70170587
>Denial
Neutral Milk Hotel - On Avery Island

>Anger
Ministry - Land Of Rape And Honey

>Barganing
Rites of Spring - Self Titled

>Depression
Microphones - the Glow Pt. 2

>Acceptance
Ride - Going Blank Again

>>70170753
>DUDE /mu/CORE LMAO
don't listen to this anon please

>>70170138
Teen Suicide - Waste Yrself/DC Snuff Film

File: grief.png (75KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 1678x748px

>>70170795
hey i'll take what I get. things are running slow

>>70169669
stage 4
public castration is a good idea
disco inferno
he has left us alone...

remove AnCo (keep spirit), AnCo is happy music fool

>>70170911
Pinkerton seems like a bargaining album.

this is one of the worst fuckin' threads so farm where the hell is Number One of Three

>>70170911
Denial
>Corey Feldman-Angelic 2 tha Core

>>70169669
>Glow Pt. 2 in stage 4
>RHP in stage 3
>RHP below The Microphones....
>RHP less depressing/sad than The Microphones.....
>...

File: grief.png (80KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 1678x748px

>>70170906
where?

>>70170985
I just can't. Sorry.

>>70171029
>3
put waste yrself in depression

>>70171029
You have to. It's literally denial-the album. You can't deny it.

Blackstar under Acceptance

>>70169676
interesting POV, I think their music is definitely emotional and can certainly be sad, but is usually on the happier side of things. as much as some of their songs embody nostalgia or heartbreak, I feel like there's always a feeling of optimism and wonder in their music - maybe not exactly happiness, but still positive. I love them, which is weird, since I'm not a very happy person, but I think it's the raw emotion, even if positive, as well as the music itself that attracts me.

even with a sad song like Banshee Beat, it's more "I'm gonna cry" than "I'm gonna kill myself"

anyway, I'd put most of their work at Stage 1, with their heaviest stuff at Stage 2, including STGSTV

>>70171029
The War on Drugs - Lost In The Dream
for acceptance

File: grief.png (95KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 1678x748px

>>70171082
That's a bit literal. I want to focus more on the emotional delivery itself. Plus that album is transcendentally awful.

>>70171116
good one

>>70168824
put xiu xiu in stage 4

>>70171210
nevermind for obvious reasons, I didnt expect that to be literally the first thing

>>70171184
I see then. At least we're on the same page.
Corey out

File: 14532898293810.png (33KB, 872x924px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 872x924px

>>70169669
Fixed the chart

>>70171184
literally any death grips album for anger

Duster needs to be somewhere in there

A Winged Victory for the Sullen = Stage 4

I mean Christ, just look at that name, plus the fact that they have a track titled "Steep Hills of Vicodin Tears" - definitely stage 4.

File: grief.png (99KB, 1678x748px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 1678x748px

k, i'm gonna go to sleep now

>>70171607
AWVFTS is pure bliss what the fuck are you talking about.

Deftones and Team Sleep could fit in stage 2 and 3

>>70170911
Depression: Death in June - But What Ends When the Symbols Shatter?

Bargaining: Metallica - Ride the Lightning

>>70170138

>Bargaining
Antony and the Johnsons - I Am A Bird Now