ITT: We rate /mu/core >ITAOTS - 8 >TMS - 7 >MBDTF -

>>70087719
some of them are not /mu/core anymore
like hospice

god Ys is such fucking shit
can someone explain the appeal of joanna newsom to me?

didn't we just have this thread?

>>70087768
she's like grimes but doesnt use DAW and is able to play harp

>>70087719
Stop rating music.

File: 1458311344401.jpg (358KB, 2000x1087px) Image search: [Google]

358KB, 2000x1087px

>Giving 10s out this easy

>TMR, anythng below 8
>Popol Vuh - 6

close this tab and never come back to this board

>>70087719
what the fuck are those albums lol

I will only rate the ones i know:
Trout Mask Replica - 3/10
Talking Heads - 7/10
Pet SOunds - 6/10
King Crimson - 9/10
Kid A - 8/10
Swans - 5/10

the rest of those I don't even know

>>70087815
this

>>70087826
>>>/reddit/

The only good albums on there are
Remain in Light
Banana
Spiderland
In the court of the crimson king(not their best album btw)
Hosianna Mantra
Soundtracks
and maybe just maybe HANL if I'm in the right mood

>>70087844
it doesnt' work wtf

>ITAOTS - 10
>TMS - 9
>MBDTF - 9
>TMR - 7
>American Football - 8
>Loveless - 10
>RIL - 9
>TVU - 9
>Spiderland- 10
>Pet Sounds - 9
>Madvillainy - 9
>ITCOTCK - 10
>Kid A - 10
>LYSF - 9
>MPP - 9
>Popol Vuh - 8
>Pink Moon - 9
>Ys - 8
>SFTB - 10
>Illinoise- 10
>Untrue - 9
>GKMC - 9
>Hospice - 8
>SILY - 10
>Deathconsciousness - 6

File: 1482277281108.png (162KB, 494x388px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 494x388px

>>70087815
>TMR above an 8
he fell for the meme album

>>70087881
>not liking NMH
>Reddit Letter Media

lole

>ITAOTS
B-
>TMS
B
>MBDTF
A-
>TMR
C+
>American Football
C
>Loveless
B+
>RiL
A
>TVU
A
>Spiderland
B+
>Pet Sounds
B
>Madvillainy
B+
>ITCOTCK
C+
>Kid A
B
>LYSF
C
>MPP
C+
>Popol Vuh
haven't listened
>Pink Moon
B-
>Ys
B
>SFTB
A+
>Illinois
A-
>Untrue
D+
>GKMC
B+ but also doesn't deserve to be /mu/core
>Hospice
C-
>SILY
C+
>Deathconsciousness
A

>>70087875
Wait, fucked, neither 10 Kid A or ITCOTCK are a 10.

>>70087894
who said anything about NMH

File: 1480090140201.jpg (3MB, 2536x3104px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2536x3104px

>>70087875
>ALL THESE 10s

>>70087881
If you think there's a single 10 on the /mu/ core list you don't deserve and opinion on music
Back to your Fantano threads plebeian.

>>70087923
me

>>70087719
ITAOTS - 7.5
TMS - 7
MBDTF - 6
American Foothball - 7.5
Loveless - 7.5
RIL - 8.5
Bana - 9
Spiderland - 9
Pet Sounds - 7
Madvilliany - 8
KID A - 10
LYSF - 9.5
MPP - 6
Pink Moon - 7
Ys - 5
SFTB - 9.5
Illinoise - 6.5
GKMC - 9
Hospice - 7.5
SILY - 6
HANL - 8

I agree with most of your ratings OP

>>70087901
Just throw in the pole too.

>>70087900
Fuck off Christgau.

File: 1482627667096.gif (2MB, 230x250px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 230x250px

>>70087930
okay..

File: 1455040335600.jpg (42KB, 454x809px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 454x809px

>ITAOTS - 6.5
>TMS - 4
>MBDTF - 5
>TMR - 8
>American Football - 2
>Loveless - 3
>RIL - 7
>TVU - 8
>Spiderland- 5
>Pet Sounds - 5
>Madvillainy - 3
>ITCOTCK - 5
>Kid A - 2
>LYSF - 6
>MPP - 6.5
>Popol Vuh - 7.5
>Pink Moon - 7.5
>Ys - 5
>SFTB - 6.5
>Illinoise- 3
>Untrue - 2
>GKMC - 3
>Hospice - 1
>SILY - 5
>Deathconsciousness - 2

>>70087719
ITAOTS: 7.5
American Football: 8
TVU&N: 8
Pet Sounds: 7
ITCOTCK: 8
Kid A: 8.5
Pink Moon: 9.5
Since I Left You: 7.5

rest I've not heard

>>70087719
I don't rate albums

>>70087966
Man I just think lettered rating is way easier than numbers. For some people, 5/10 is average, and for others it's 7/10. With lettered rating everyone who has gone to school can understand it

>>70088143
Not just that, Talking Heads that much higher than fucking ItCotCK is a dead giveaway that you're actually Robert Christgau.

>>70088038
>he hasn't heard Remain in Light
Do yourself a favor and correct that.

File: ohXi6NE.png (7KB, 112x112px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 112x112px

>>70087924
i didn't say anything about there being a 10, what's your point

>>70088209
how did you post emoji on here

>>70088600
>giving American Football a 3
I think you are being a little ooooverrrr draaamaaaticcc

>>70088600
>Giving The Avalanches a 5.5
End your life

lmaoing at everyone who gives any of these albums more than a 9

>ITAOTS - 5
>TMS - 8
>MBDTF - 9
>TMR - 5
>American Football - 7
>Loveless - 7
>RIL - 7
>TVU - 5
>Spiderland- 7
>Pet Sounds - 7
>Madvillainy - 4
>ITCOTCK - 9
>Kid A - 9
>LYSF - 8
>MPP - 9
>Popol Vuh - /
>Pink Moon - 7
>Ys - 7
>SFTB - 6
>Illinoise- 8
>Untrue - 7
>GKMC - 8
>Hospice - 10
>SILY - 7
>Deathconsciousness - 4

File: text4147-73-70-1.jpg (1MB, 2100x2457px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2100x2457px

IDK = have not listened to it yet

>>70088667
sounds incredibly samey and boring to me
the whole math-rock genre is like this I guess and they don't do anything that stands out
check this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZkLTFKV-fU out if you like math rock I think it's way more interesting than american football and the drumming is great
>>70088689
I find plunderphonics as cringy as electroswing
it isn't half as horrible as AAAAAAAAAA FRANKIE SINATRA at least

>>70088698
>people enjoying critically acclaimed albums
>L
>M
>A
>O

Hasn't /mu/core evolved by now?

Who still cares about Radiohead, Sufjan, Godspeed, The Antlers, Madvillain, American Football, or Have a Nice Life anymore?

Who even makes a big deal bout Ys now?

>>70091355
Is that a 4 for LYSF? Wow. You should be ashamed of yourself of that awful handwriting

>>70091355
>Velvet Underground - 5
>ITCOTKC - 10
what

File: df.png (880KB, 630x737px) Image search: [Google]

880KB, 630x737px

>>70091355
i don't like this, or you probably; what are you doin'?

>>70091688
It got really boring after 1st listen, at least for me.
But I guess I could have rate it a little bit too low
5 should be ok
but then SFTB should be 6
>>70091750
>what
what what?

>>70092290
I dont give a fuck what you rated it I just think that was an awful attempt at drawing a 4. Learn to calligraphy

>>70087826
>>70089108

Jesus how embarrassing

>>70087937
>>70088016
>>70088600
>>70091355

>MPP that low

>>70090972

>People enjoying music

>>70087826
>Those albums
>Swans

File: 1483473316341.png (2MB, 630x737px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 630x737px

objectively correct ratings