ITT: We post our RYM 5 stars, 5 star criteria and the number

4968

N/A

Dialoghi del presente
Faust
Scriabin Recital

647

tds - nin
ITCOTCK - kc
bat out of hell - meatloaf
exit - fire orchestra

i really like walls of sound (booh exempt)

bump desu

41 out of about 3800 ratings
Its just a gut feeling more than anything combined with amount of times played sort of, its not entirely rational

I really would need to revise a lot of my ratings, I really have 4's and 4,5s that need to be re-evaluated. Usually if I like an album a lot it's a straight 4 but I have no real criteria for 4,5 (except if I downgrade from 5)

>>69068188
I also gave that Isis album 5 stars

I have 30 5 star albums out of 2100

Don't have any specific criteria really

File: file.png (145KB, 1156x543px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 1156x543px

507

has to be essentially flawless

File: 5.0s.png (167KB, 1204x973px) Image search: [Google]

167KB, 1204x973px

pic related

criteria is heroin & meth test

i have 1,603 ratings

File: hIUquuD.png (783KB, 700x525px) Image search: [Google]

783KB, 700x525px

>>69070201
>>69070195
>>69070184
>>69068696
>>69068409
>>69068188
fuck you

>>69071114
Bitch

File: 20161115_075223.png (179KB, 1388x569px) Image search: [Google]

179KB, 1388x569px

Out of 1127

>>69071194
Slut