How is "noise" considered a genre? Its literally the

Now cry.

literally just answered your own question

>>68710699
>the thing that is the opposite of music is also music

>>68710713
>implying genres ARE the music
kys pls

>>68710690
how are you defining music here

>>68710744
Google define music

>>68710759
which one of those definitions are you using

>>68710777
The first one

>>68710777
>>68710782
The second refers to sheet music...

>>68710782
well noise certainly fits some parts of that definition, if not all. why didn't you make this thread about something like field recordings where you would have a much stronger argument?

>>68710812
More people consider noise a genre than field recordings

And how is noise instrumental or vocal?

>>68710690
White and black are considered colors

>>68710831
how is it not instrumental? an instrument is not necessarily a piece of wood with strings on it

>>68710845
Was about to argue definition of music instrument but it's self referential
Fucking tautology

>>68710831
instrumental, I would say. How do you make noise.

le

>>68710690
Because noise music can be structured. Noise isn't a focused genre it's more of an umbrella term for a large number of styles of abrasive or atonal music.

>>68710690
Because what is and isn't considered "musical" is just a human application of meaning to a objective occurrence or lack of an occurrence of sound. Even if you don't like noise music or find it interesting, to not consider it music is really to be struggling with some pretty basic concepts.

And you know what, it's also really limiting. You're a boring person for trying to put limits on something like music. Just stick to what you like if it really bothers you that much. The day you come into contact with noise music anywhere in your day to day life in mainstream society maybe you'll have earned the right to have a bit of a whinge, but when you are literally seeking out fringe art to complain about it you know you're a dull cunt.

All music is noise, dummy

>>68710690
its the opposite of edm. its about the structure of the many different layers of tones and frequencies

>replying to the thread as if it's a legitimate and sincere inquiry