That's odd, my music thread 404'd. What releases of

>>68412294
Please kys.

>it's a "nobody is allowed to like what i dont like" episode
oh boy here we go
inb4 music is objective

>>68412317
Quite uncalled for.

>>68412326
Oh boy. Tell me: which meme did you fall for ?

why the hell is that music review guy there lol, criticism is not art

put frank ocean on there

im not a particular fan of any of these artists, but dismissing them completely seems pretty autistic

except fantano that man will never do anything of worth

>>68412368
meant to reply to >>68412343

>>68412360
He's a mediocre musician.
>criticism is not art
This is incorrect.
1. The value of art depends on the values of the art critic.
2. Most art is born as imitation, not innovation.
3. The critic, not the artist, is the one who defines innovation, and rates it.
4. The artist is merely a vehicle for the aesthetic/ideology of the critic.
Ergo,
5. The critic is the real artist.

>>68412364
Who would I sub out ?
Nice to see you again, Wajda.

>>68412368
>dismissing them completely seems pretty autistic
Non sequitur.

Mostly a pretty good test. However, Lamar and Daft Punk aren't bad.

File: 200_s.gif (48KB, 370x200px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 370x200px

>>68412408
>the critic is the real artist
o i am laffin

>>68412416
Shut the FUCK up!

>>68412408
nigga you got like two rows worth of blank space, if you had to sub anybody out i say it should be the weeknd because i liked his first three mixtapes

u 2 friendo

>>68412294
you are a poor man's unty but anyways
>grimes-visions
>CC-II
>viper-yall cowards
>st vincent- her over/under
>roger-one of these days
>daft punk-discovery
>kendrick-TPAB
>azu nyan-tenshi ni fureta yo
>yoko- john lennon
>lavren-her qt face
>mizutani-the mizutani pepe
>melon-TPAB review
>danny-his verse on huzzah
>weeknd-his hair
>MIA- that performance with 20 MIAs
>beyonce-7/11

>>68412465
Pussy meet me at the park tomorrow 2 pm

>>68412408
>The critic is the real artist

What comes first the artist or the critic dumbass?

Why is viper there?

>>68412294
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59NYcJD_vVE

Yoko Ono and this fucking cringefest.

>>68412503
"Dogevillage" weighs in.

>>68412408
le scaruffi face

Fantano's ITAOTS review lmaoooooo

>>68412456
Thanks for your well-thought-out and articulate reply.

Viper's videos of him with underage girls

>>68412461
>you got like two rows worth of blank space
I'm still thinking about what to write in that section.
>if you had to sub anybody out i say it should be the weeknd
I agree with this, mostly because he's not discussed as much.

>>68412465
>you are a poor man's unty
I predate Unty.

>>68412490
The critic, because by identifying the "artist", the artist becomes one.

This isn't difficult.

>>68412503
He's a meme and/or for plebeians.

>>68412603
Bitch no one knows you! Your just another John Doe
Put a 9 in your back and call u Rajon Rondo

>>68412631
If anyone is a John Doe, it's you. You are just another anonymous dickhead, one among many. If you left /mu/, nobody would notice or care.

>>68412680
Motherfucker your ass started posting here in june according to the archive. You might as well be an anon.

I guarantee more people here know me than you.

>>68412701
oh look its that obnoxious anon haha

i want to die after reading this thread why is this back up again mods please

File: youre-a-special-rym1dp.jpg (51KB, 600x500px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 600x500px

>>68412626
if the artist wasn't there to begin with the critic wouldnt have anything to indentify. If you dont believe that you're not using common sense

>>68412701
I started posting with a trip in June. I had posted here before then so you can't pull the "muh newfag" trick on me.

Also, how would anyone know you? You're anonymous.

>>68412772
>if the artist wasn't there to begin with the critic wouldnt have anything to indentify.
They're not an artist until someone identifies them as such. Before that, they are just someone with a product.

I'll wait for you to catch up.

>>68412808
are you for real
what about artists who existed before published criticism? did they not count as artists?

>>68412294
You know people complain about plebs on /mu/ but there's never more than one /classical/ thread at a time

File: Azusa_unamused.png (281KB, 844x714px) Image search: [Google]

281KB, 844x714px

>>68412294
Explain yourself

>>68412802
Get the fuck out of my thread with your goofy newfag ass

You've barely been here before june and you have the gall to talk to be. Take a hike.

>>68412808
I hope you're not taking scaruffi's definition by the word, identifying art made by someone does not make you a critic, critic itself means validation and measurement not admiration

File: 1437902482674.jpg (27KB, 358x272px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 358x272px

>>68412802
>I had posted here before then so you can't pull the "muh newfag" trick on me.

>>68412833
This isn't even your thread.

Stop trying to be street, everyone knows you're a 15 year old beta male who takes out his frustration on strangers on a Dutch panty sniffing forum.

File: heterosporous octachord.jpg (44KB, 468x363px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 468x363px

>>68412823
>what about artists who existed before published criticism
What are you babbling about ? "Critic" only became a profession relatively recently.

>>68412824
It's a shame, really.

>>68412831
I couldn't think of any other way to get you back in the game~

>>68412850
crit·ic
[ˈkridik]
NOUN
a person who judges the merits of literary, artistic, or musical works, especially one who does so professionally:
"a film critic"
synonyms: reviewer · commentator · evaluator · analyst · judge

What I said stands.

>>68412896
scaruffi drones are fucking dense, have fun jerking off to TMR and morton feldman

>>68412896
so traditional folk isnt art?
okay

you misspelled plebian

>>68412896
With you coming back bby and the possibility of pharmabro taking over the site I'm truly considering getting back in the game.

Why are you guys even replying to hm haha it's pointless

Sage

>>68412896
How do you manage to be everywhere at once?

>>68412921
it is now that its been criticised

>>68412998
cuz he up yo mommas black ass SUCKA

File: 1474801421572.jpg (55KB, 466x398px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 466x398px

>>68413161
WHATCHU SAYIN MOTHAFUCKA

File: loli taunts you for your cowardice.jpg (157KB, 708x865px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 708x865px

>>68412955

File: [... intensifies].jpg (122KB, 1065x275px) Image search: [Google]

122KB, 1065x275px

>>68412917
>scaruffi drones
What ? See my chart >>68409082

>>68412921
>so traditional folk isnt art?
non sequitur

>>68412947
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/plebeian

>>68412998
It's a talent.

>>68413321
baka you literally got here a day ago and you're already rustling so many jimmies you're worse trip than montie 2bh f a m

File: hey guess what.jpg (59KB, 428x336px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 428x336px

>>68413380
>you literally got here a day ago
This is incorrect.

>>68413380
Are you sure your jimmies are the only things that rustled?

>>68413404
Archives say otherwise

>>68413555
I keep typing Maximizer when I mean Maximus, dammit.

>>68413584
I'll let you figure this one out on your own.

>>68413619
Will you continue to be this active in the future?

>>68413660
It's too early to tell. I'm interesting in kick-starting the patrician renaissance again, however.

We need to get more people in this thread. I feel like this is the beginning of something big.

Needs Kanye.

this is the worst board on 4chan

>>68413805
Philip Glass, Keji Haino, Noah Lennox, Ritsu Tainaka, and James Ferraro, and Frank Ocean have been added.

I have one (or five, if I get two really good recommendations) spot(s) to fill.

>>68413911
it really is

>>68413911
>>68414121
Help make it better and contribute to the chart, then.

>>68414143
twentyonepilots

>>68414100

Jhonn Balance
Kate Bush
Egor Letov
Shinji Sato
Michael Gira
Charles Hayward
Otomo Yoshihide
Dean Blunt
Bjork
Phil Spector
Morton Feldman
Glenn Branca
Arto Lindsay
Sachiko M

>>68414163
>Jhonn Balance
Not widespread enough
>Kate Bush
Patrician
>Shinji Sato
Not widespread enough
>Charles Hayward
Not widespread enough
>Michael Gira
His early output wasn't bad, so I'd feel disingenuous putting him on there.
>Otomo Yoshihide
Patrician
>Dean Blunt
Wasn't he flavor of the month ? His time has passed (I could be wrong about this)
>Bjork
This one is questionable, but I haven't really listened to her at all.
>Phil Spector
I don't see why he'd be on there
>Morton Feldman
I don't see why he'd be on there
>Glenn Branca
I don't see why he'd be on there
>Arto Lindsay
Not widespread enough
>Sachiko M
I don't see why he'd be on there

>>68414220
>Sachiko M
>I don't see why he'd be on there
*she'd

>>68414278
dean blunt should definitely be on there

you should put yamantaka eye on there too

>>68414343
Didn't know Wajda died. I should probably watch some of his films; I hear they are great.

>>68414220

Coil and Fishmans are more famous than Keiji and Mizutani.

Alright, I'm going to bed. See you all tomorrow.