name a melody you like that doesnt conform to tonal doctrines.

what to heck is tonal doctrine

The sound of your mums pussy squeaking as my black lubed up dick plunges it

>>68399624
Death Grips

>>68399651
everything based on overtone relations

Aphex twins

prokofiev - 5 melodies for violin and piano
p much all of them

Epistrophy by Monk. It's mostly chromatically shifting 7 chords.

>>68399671
Sooo.... any music made in a system that has overtones? So basically anything?

File: wtf.png (11KB, 211x246px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 211x246px

>>68399723
nigga pls

>>68399694
>>68399711
thx, will check out

>>68399746
> niggas pls
That's not a response moron. Answer my question. The approximation of the overtone series precludes the invention of equal temperament systems like the 12 tone one we use now, so you're pretty hard pressed to define any music at all that fits your rules, that is if you define sound collage, random shouting and pure noise as melodic (which it's not).

>>68399809
a key or scale isnt 12 tones nigga.
its usually a subset within an octave based on some plausible assumptions inferred from overtone relations.
a tonal melody happens within the same scale.

>Name a melody that is not melodic

You fucking what ?!

>>68399624
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFhJRTdmviA

Anything on Yowie's Cryptooology

How much is "not conforming"?

A lot of metal is not conforming. First of all you've got a lot of chromatic chugging in death metal. But even take a more melodic riff like freezing moon by mayhem:

It starts with an arpeggiated Em triad, then the chords are Bb5, A5, G5, F5. It sounds generally kinda phrygian/locrian minor-y but you can't place all those notes in one tonal center and the melody doesn't obey standard key change rules.

>>68400840
I always thought the whole song has an arabesque pattern to it