How would you rank the episodes of this season so far, from

File: PON.gif (282KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

282KB, 500x281px

>>30777139
1. Fame & Misfortune (great)
2. The Perfect Pear (great)
3. Discordant Harmony (great)
4. Parental Glideance (good)
5. Hard To Say Anything (good)
6. A Royal Problem (good)
7. Celestial Advice (good)
8. Forever Filly (good)
9. Rock Solid Friendship (okay)
10. A Flurry of Emotions (okay)
11. All Bottled Up (okay)
12. Not Asking For Trouble (mediocre)
13. Honest Apple (mediocre)
14. Fluttershy Leans In (bad)
15. Triple Threat (bad)

All shit, like all episodes after season 1.

The Perfect Pear
Parental Glideance
A Royal Problem
...
Fluttershy Leans In

I'd have to rewatch the rest to rank them. The middle is kind of muddy.

File: 1417164801735.gif (270KB, 594x594px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 594x594px

>watching the show

1. The Perfect Pear
2. A Royal Problem
3. Parental Glideance
4. Celestial Advice
5. Discordant Harmony
6. All Bottled Up
7. Fame and Misfortune
8. Forever Filly
9. Not Asking For Trouble
10. Honest Apple
11. Triple Threat
12. A Flurry of Emotions
13. Fluttershy Leans In
14. Rock Solid Friendship
15. Hard to Say Anything

>>30777139
Sorting them all would be difficult, but Forever Filly, Fluttershy Leans In, Celestial Advice, aFoE - and, to an extent, also Rock Solid Friendship, Hard To Say Anything, and Not Asking For Trouble - were all quite forgettable to me.

That leaves us with ABU, Glideance, A Royal Problem, Discordant Harmony, Perfect Pear, and Fame and Misfortune. Those were more interesting.

I'm not listing Triple Threat, as I feel it's too fresh in my memory to place in either of the two bins.

I completely forgot about Honest Apple when trying to recall each episode, which I guess would make it the worst in my ranking.

>>30777139
From best to worst. These first five are the cream of the crop, real gems that do the series justice. If someone walked in while I was watching, I would gladly pull my dick out, turn the volume up, and tell them to fuck off. All these episodes are either A or B tier.
> The Perfect Pear
> Hard to Say Anything
> Not Asking for Trouble
> Parental Glideance
> Forever Filly
From this point on episode quality takes a sharp dip in quality, most of these episodes had their moments but also serious underlying flaws, though not serious enough to stop me from enjoying them. If someone walked in while I was watching, I'd quickly flip the channel, then flip back after they left. I'd call these the B to C tier episodes.
>Celestial Advice
>Honest Apple
>Rock Solid Friendship
>Fluttershy Leans In
>Discordant Harmony
>A Royal Problem
From here on out its pure shit. A chuckle here or cameo there doesn't save these episodes from the trash heap. It's abortions like these that make me wanna just watch something else. C to F tier.
>Triple Threat
>All Bottled Up
>A Flurry of Emotions
>Fame and Misfortune

File: masturboop.jpg (81KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 600x600px

>>30777460
>All Bottled Up
>Fame and Misfortune
>not the best
Triggered brony detected
Go back to killing yourself over Glim, retard

As much as I hate to agree with Glimfag, I can't see how Fame and Misfortune is horse shit without taking offense to the premise.

>>30777235
This tbqh, only new episodes I've seen are the trixie ones and the new discord episode which was great.

I've no clue what's going on after season 2.

File: 1462481471858.jpg (60KB, 346x440px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 346x440px

>>30777235

File: die_in_a_fire_glimmercunt.jpg (335KB, 676x485px) Image search: [Google]

335KB, 676x485px

>>30777468
>Liking anything about mary suesparkle 3.0
>Liking writers wasting potentially interesting plots to cry at the fandom over criticism
I bet you think my little pony: adventures in barbieland was great too right?

>>30777504
Did he actually dislike anything in here, though?

Only watched to parental glidance but.

>Best Episode in the Show Tiered
Parental Glidance

>Good Episode Tiered
Forever Filly
Celestial Advice
Rock Solid Friendship

>So Stupid its Good Tiered
All Bottled Up

>Bad Tiered
Flurry of Emotions

>Shit Tiered
Fluttershy Leans In

File: 1502566010933.png (9KB, 872x503px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 872x503px

>>30777208
>episodes featuring glimmer
>great
season 5-7 in their entirety are pure shit.

File: boop.jpg (13KB, 500x279px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 500x279px

>>30777514
>>30777589
S A L T Y

>>30777514
>>Liking writers wasting potentially interesting plots to cry at the fandom over criticism
But anon, it wasn't simply a cry, it helped make for an interesting meta point

>>30777483
Personally I was really looking forward to the episode, the premise sounded really cute and funny which is when the best stuff happens in the show. What we got instead was thirty minutes of meta bullshit, various shadow factions (jim miller) bitching about the fandom, a song that just felt weirdly out of place and forced ("Cause isn't it silly how they're always singing LOL!!!"), plenty of glimshit, and of course as the cherry on top of this shit sundae the moral of the story was, "It's for little girls anyway, SO STOP YELLING AT US!!!" Objectively you're probably right in that there were worse episodes, but for me personally it was the worst so far. Maybe it's just because I had built it up so much in my mind beforehand that it just ended up especially disappointing.

File: ponk.png (221KB, 1112x1124px) Image search: [Google]

221KB, 1112x1124px

>>30777514
>>30777589
>don't judge an episode by its content or message
>judge an episode based on which characters are in it.

Here's a link to fame and misfortune, go watch it then come back and tell us what you learned.
https://mega.nz/#!sSZUnarI!-wu78wJAjIQ0c32DOip8lf03zOkJfd2U3lJKHjJHoRg

File: Glim kek.gif (398KB, 747x508px) Image search: [Google]

398KB, 747x508px

>>30777641
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3KquFZYi6L0

>>30777645
Maybe you should learn to read, glimshit was the least of my problems with that abortion of an episode.

>>30777645
if glimmer never even existed I would not have to suffer through that shit episode.

>A+ Tier (Really really good)
The Perfect Pear
A Royal Problem

>A Tier (Pretty good)
Rock Solid Friendship
Parental Glideance
Fame and Misfortune

>B Tier (Solid episodes)
Discordant Harmony
Celestial Advice
All Bottled Up
Triple Threat

>C Tier (Okay)
Forever Filly
A Flurry of Emotions
Hard to Say Anything
Not Asking for Trouble

>D Tier (Not that great)
Fluttershy Leans In
Honest Apple

Season 7 is pretty good. Nothing has utterly dropped the ball yet like Applejacks Day Off or something like that

File: e14.jpg (85KB, 653x672px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 653x672px

>>30777641
Look you dense motherfucker, the moral of Fame and Misfortune is "Judge a moral tale by the moral it imparts and the tale it tells, not extraneous bullshit that only a turbo autist cares about" and "If you screech autisticly like a retard at someone for making an entirely subjective choice then screech at them for doing the opposite their going to think your an implacable screeching autist".

And how are you proving them wrong? By going on the internet and screeching autsticly. Great Job you doublefaggot.

>>30777220
Cry some more faggot.

>>30777589
You know, maybe more anons would spam that image if you used a more shared opinion
Most of the ones that hate the show now either think that it became shit starting with S2, 3 or 6
For the most part S5 is considered either the last good or not the first bad one

You're literally spamming an unpopular opinion, and that's why everytime I see those graphs I know it's always you, the same anon desperately trying to have it spammed by someone else.

>>30777641
>and of course as the cherry on top of this shit sundae the moral of the story was, "It's for little girls anyway, SO STOP YELLING AT US!!!"
Uh, no it wasn't? It's your interpretation because you got triggered by something you didn't think about for more than 5 seconds and instantly started calling it shit.
The morals were
1) characters are not defined by their respective elements only (works in the narrow context of the show)
2) canon shouldn't necessarily make all of your headcanons come true (works in a broader context of any show)
3) there's no point in trying to pander to specific groups of people because you cannot please everybody anyway (works in a very broad context)

File: 15030478902331314.png (11KB, 872x503px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 872x503px

>>30777589
>implying this isn't the correct graph

File: It's_a_glimmer_episode.png (172KB, 371x351px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 371x351px

>>30777699
>dubs wasted on a glimmercunt white knighting for hasbro's crybaby writers being unable to take the slightest criticism from autistic neckbeards on a taiwanese magnifying glass board

1-Perfect Pear
2-Royal Problem
3-Honest Apple
4-Flurry of Emotion
5-Parental Glideance
6-Discordant Harmony
7-Forever Filly
8-Hard To Say Anything
9-Rock Solid Friendship
10-All Bottled Up
11-Not Asking For Trouble
12-Fluttershy Leans In
13-Triple Threat
15-Celestial Advice

Fame and Misfortune is out of the lis because I have no idea what that was, I seriously don't know if it was good or bad and it's the first time in 7 seasons that I can't rate an episode.

>>30777757
Cry harder, maybe the universe will listen...

>>30777735
>used a more shared opinion
those who don't agree that glimmer is pure shit that has ruined mlp:fim should spend their time committing suicide as opposed to shitposting on /mlp/

File: glimboop.jpg (727KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

727KB, 1920x1080px

This thread PROVES once again that only """people""" with brain damage hate Glimmy

The Perfect Pear (10/10)
A Royal Problem (9/10)
Rock Solid Friendship (8.5/10)
Celestial Advice (7.5/10)
Parental Glideance (7.5/10)
Flurry of Emotions (7/10)
Hard To Say Anything (7/10)
All Bottled Up (7/10)
Forever Filly (7/10)
Triple Threat (7/10)
Discordant Harmony (7/10)
Not Asking for Trouble (6.5/10)
Fluttershy Leans In (5.5/10)
Honest Apple (5/10)
Fame and Misfortune (complete garbage)

I'm pretty happy with all the 7/10s this season. It seems like Joanna and Kristine are actually editing each episode to the point where almost every one has been passable and worth watching. Season 6 felt like every episode was entirely dependent on the writer. Now it feels like if we have a good premise, we can rest easy knowing it'll be at least worth watching once.

File: bakshi.png (73KB, 203x280px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 203x280px

>>30777741
>The readers argue over which pony is best
>They create memes and headcanons like Rarity is a whore and Pinkie is autistic
>They hound the writers relentlessly with unwanted commentary and unfair criticism
>In the end the readers are told they shouldn't care about the mistakes the writers make, it should be about love and tolerance
>The readers are too stupid and unreasonable to get this
>But it doesn't matter because two little fillies got the message
Just recalling that horrible episode made me throw up a little, how anyone can believe this is a quality episode is beyond me.

File: autismo.gif (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

>>30777902
IT HAD PONIES IN IT! I KNOW WHAT THAT IS!!!
10/10 BEST EPISODE EVER!!!!!!!!!!

>>30777902
>>In the end the readers are told they shouldn't care about the mistakes the writers make, it should be about love and tolerance
Um, no. You once again prove that you haven't thought about it for more than 5 seconds. Probably that's why how anyone can have a different opinion is beyond you.

File: Congratulations_You_Have_Autism.png (62KB, 531x604px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 531x604px

>>30777835
>>30777603
>>30777468
> accuses others of brain damage
> has autism

Episodes that are great with very few faults:
1. The Perfect Pear
2. A Royal Problem
3. Celestial Advice
4. Parental Glideance
5. Triple Threat

Episodes that needed more development, focused on weird things, or simply didn't interest me (this is a subjective list)
6. Not Asking For Trouble
7. Flurry of Emotions
8. Rock Solid Friendship
9. All Bottled Up

Episodes that quite frankly did what they wanted to do very poorly/had very little to them/had an idea that was completely bungled in some manner:
10. Forever Filly
11. Fluttershy Leans In
12. Fame and Misfortune
13. Hard to Say Anything
14. Honest Apple
15. Discordant Harmony

>>30777943
>"N-no that's wrong!"
>Literally what happens in the episode
Look if you want to bend over backwards to polish every golden turd hasbro shits out that's your choice, the episode was objectively bad, deal with it.

>>30777943
>>30777975
The episode was going after the behavior of the fans, not the criticisms themselves.

>>30777975
We tried to explain, we broke it down as best we could, but your simple little mind was too small to except a simple premise beyond blind indignant rage.

There is no hope for you, your are fated to wander this world a screeching autist for ever and no amount of friendship lessons can save you.

>>30777139
Every new episode is worse than the last one

>>30778014
>Every new thing is bad.
/Fixed

>>30777975
You're using a form of the "IT'S OBVIOUS" fallacy, trying to erase the need for argument by suggesting your point is common knowledge. In your particular case, by posing your subjective interpretation as if it were an objective fact. But 1) works of fiction cannot be judged objectively save for purely technical stuff 2) nothing is ever obvious in polemics, otherwise there'd be no point in polemics to begin with.

>>30778006
>The episode was a tone argument

So it was invalid, basically?

File: Glimmglimmglimm.jpg (4MB, 2790x3038px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 2790x3038px

every episode with Glimmy is good!

>>30778196
GAS

File: CCCP Glimmy.png (212KB, 1024x1160px) Image search: [Google]

212KB, 1024x1160px

>>30777589
>>30777514
>>30777690
B-But Anons...why do you hate her so much?

>>30778024
Spoiler Alert: There is no point in polemics. It's non-creatives venting their jealousy at creatives, ever since ancient times.

File: 10.png (280KB, 449x596px) Image search: [Google]

280KB, 449x596px

>>30778206

Gas, you say?

File: 1500652002445.png (817KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

817KB, 1280x720px

>>30778254
Who said gas?

File: 9.png (223KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 720x720px

>>30778266

She who smelt it, dealt it.

>>30777139
The perfect pear, it's the worst one I have seen.

File: 1503253688465.png (224KB, 547x598px) Image search: [Google]

224KB, 547x598px

>>30778266
Glimmer is a very gassy pony!

Glimmerfags are a disease

File: 11.png (359KB, 2922x2463px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 2922x2463px

>>30778283

Think she'd be brave enough to give out a dutch oven?

File: 1502632082883.jpg (88KB, 679x701px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 679x701px

>>30778298
Only to the most adamant of her admirers.

You literallt can't discuss the show now without seeing
>glimmernigger
>poochienigger
>glimmerfaggot
>hasdrone
>shill
or
>hasshill
anymore.
It just can't happen.

>>30778668
Ay, you forgot Hi Jim.

>>30778249
>non-creatives venting their jealousy at creatives

b-but i review episodes of MLP on youtube, surely i am one of the creative types, and surely my time spent on tvtropes has educated me enough to pass fair judgment on anything media

>>30778712
So fucking true.

1) The Perfect Pear
2) Forever Filly
3)A Royal Problem
4)Rock Solid Friendship
5)Discordant Harmony
6)I
7)don't
8)fucking
9)care
10)anymore
11)these
12)were
13)good
14)Triple Threat
15)Honest Apple

File: 1501955713516.png (1MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1920x1080px

I rate only good ones because I do not bother thinking about the bad ones.

1) The Perfect Pear
2) Fame and Misfortune
3) Celestial Advice
4) Parental Glideance
5) A Royal Problem
6) All Bottled Up
7) Discordant Harmony

All the shit you can ever eat

>>30777220

>>30777208
fpbp

File: 1516889__safe_screencap_applejack_fluttershy_pinkie+pie_rainbow+dash_rarity_twilight+sparkle_fame+and+misfortune_spoiler-colon-s07e14_alicorn_mane+six_.png (1MB, 1440x803px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1440x803px

>>30777759
>Fame and Misfortune is out of the list because I have no idea what that was, I seriously don't know if it was good or bad and it's the first time in 7 seasons that I can't rate an episode.

Have this analysis >>30755132