Regardless of pure love between their kids, how did the parents'

>>30405574
It's for kids. Stop over-analyzing things.

File: 105477__safe_artist-colon-misteraibo_clothes_disney_esmeralda_frollo_ponified_scarf_seduction_teasing_the+hunchback+of+notre+dame_zebra.png (1MB, 5277x2968px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 5277x2968px

>>30405580
>It's for kids

Doesn't mean they can't IMPLY it...

File: 1465074680560.png (463KB, 596x600px) Image search: [Google]

463KB, 596x600px

>>30405580
>Stop over-analyzing things.

>>30405574
>Regardless of pure love between their kids, how did the parents' rivalry not give way to pure lust?
In real life when two people hate each other their hate often manifest as brain tumors.

>>30405636
proofs?

>>30405636
I had two uncles that hated each other and they both happened to develop brain tumors. I put two and two together.

File: I've got you covered.jpg (36KB, 385x350px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 385x350px

>>30405574
Some people just don't like each other and aren't interested in each other in a sexual manner at all.

>>30405700
Not at first, sure, but surely lust would kick in sooner or later, looking at her every night and all that...

>>30405781
t. permavirgin basement dweller

>flashbacks show Granny Smith and Grand Pear at various stages of their lives
>no sign of any Grandpapple or Grandmare Pear
>how did the parents' rivalry not give way to pure lust?

Who says it didn't?

>>30405574
>>30405863
>Grand Pear and Granny Smith both lost their mates when Pear Butter and Bright Mac were very young.
>The widow and widower found themselves attracted to one another, but the business rivalry between the Pear and the Apple farming clans meant they could never admit it to each other.
>Over the years, unrequited love turned to anger, and anger turned to outright hatred.
>Grand Pear's fury at his daughter when he found out she was going out with Bright Mac was a proxy for the grudge he held against Bright Mac's mother.

>>30405781
Anon stop.

File: burro.png (336KB, 1082x1024px) Image search: [Google]

336KB, 1082x1024px

>>30405825
Whaaat?

Basement dwelling virgins on 4chan's pony board?

Are you lost, champ?

File: backgroundponynumber17.png (22KB, 990x252px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 990x252px

>>30405897
>Unrequited love turned to anger, and finally to outright hatred.
>unrequited love turned to anger, and anger turned to outright hatred

Either you're the same person, or you just copied a Derpibooru comment and half-assed covering your tracks.

And if the former, why not link to the Derpibooru comment yourself?

>>30406026
Same person--that's my Derpibooru comment. It was easier to copypasta rather than fiddle with links.

>>30406026
because i got b8'd on derpibooru

>>30406053
Fair enough, though taking a screenshot of your comment after you post it and cropping it only takes a few seconds and can avoid making us think we're talking to someone who copies ideas

>>30406059
b8'd?

>>30406059
>b8'd
Aww, did little baby get butthurt bad? or are you just retarded to not know what ampersand is?

>>30405574
How else do you think Applebloom was made?

>>30405574

It did. Grandpear and Granny fucked, but then they broke up and that caused the feud. They didn't want Bright Mac and Pear Butter to get married because it would be too weird for them to be their parents-in-law.

File: 1465139612557.jpg (963KB, 3000x2000px) Image search: [Google]

963KB, 3000x2000px

Its more likely that two people will just plainly hate eachother with no sexual content between them, especially so if its something like business rivals
But obviously speaking this thread. and /mlp/ in general, is full of hedonistic shipfags who have to make everything fuck everything else, and any genuine answer is going to be shot-down by pornographic autismos. Thats just a fact

Either way, this episode delivered to me way more feels than I thought possible
>The last thing Grand Pear ever said to his daughter was him disowning her
>he probably never reconciled with her before her death
God damn feels

>>30406106
the same as your vagisand

>>30406321
>he probably never reconciled with her before her death
I'm kinda guessing that the reason Apple parents weren't in Sweet Apple Acres that much was because they were often visiting Vanhoover to reconcile with Grand Pear.

>>30406367
But then why would he have come back to Ponyville?
He came back because the feud had gotten in the way of his family, if the feud had been reconciled by that time, then he'd have no point to leave because the sole reason he moved was to end the feud and see his family
Besides Anon, people arent so willing to forgive while the other is still alive. Death and regret is one of the few things that does make a person learn to forgive

File: 669981__safe_artist-colon-hikariviny_ahuizotl_daring+do_oc_oc-colon-yaocihuatl_baby_darizotl_foal_hybrid_interspecies+offspring_offspring_parent-colon-.png (279KB, 722x601px) Image search: [Google]

279KB, 722x601px

>>30405574
In actual life, when two people hate eachother, then usually they just hate eachother. Only dislestia shippers think otherwise because they are virgins who never seen an actual feud except in fictional storis.

>>30405661
And it never occurred to you that maybe they were just alternate universe versions of the same person brought together by a spacetime anomaly?

It's like you don't even deduction.

>>30406367

Bullshit. He talks about how he got letters from her every week, but he never opened them.

The letters stopped, and he figured it was because she was still angry and gave up on him ever responding.

After a few years with no more letters, he finally opens them and reads them, which is what prompts his decision to come back because he wants to know his grandkids.

It's pretty obvious he never saw her again and never reconciled. The implication is subtle, but not at all in doubt.

>>30406398
My point is that they couldn't reconcile with him even with countless visitings and eventually died in front of him or during the travel by an accident or some kind of tragedy.
Grand Pear just couldn't go and tell the fact to Apples if it was former, and couldn't go ask what happened if latter.
Until maybe he got terminal cancer or something and realize he's got no time left for him and had to go to Ponyville and make Perfect Pear happen.

Just my headcanon.

>>30407021
>He talks about how he got letters from her every week

How many minutes into the episode?

>>30405580
Stop over-analyzing things? Where do you think we are?

>>30406321
>>30407021
MLP:FiM: Because three orphans who never knew their parents just wasn't sad enough.

File: 1.png (387KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

387KB, 1024x576px

>>30405574
What bothers me more is how those kids apparently fell in love while still being infants.

>>30407220
Well, it's retarded and you should feel retarded.

>>30405580
So what are you here for? The fetish generals?

>>30409790
No, he's here for the fetish colonels, the fetish majors, the fetish captains, and the fetish lieutenants.

>>30409810
Eat a dick, Carlos!

>>30409826
Do I get to eat pussy for dessert?

>>30405580
Thread should have ended here

>>30410599
Except that this point was refuted in the third post.

>>30409710
Or became friends as infants and anticipated falling in love from having heard that happens.

Neither of them claimed to fall in love with the other until the song.

>>30407220
>Until maybe he got terminal cancer

I think the episode was sad enough as it is, Anon.

>>30411864
I'm just trying to reason myself why Apple parents weren't with their children when they were Apples to the core and lived in Ponyville, and also that asshole suddenly thought visiting his grandchildren after abandoning his daughter for couple decades just because Apples is a okay.
Besides the episode itself was kinda dumb rather than sad if you saw if without bias. I was pretty underwhelmed with Perfect Pear especially for a show that had Tanks For The Memories.

>>30412203
>Tanks For The Memories.

Where Rainbow Dash's characterization flies out the window by having her be absolutely clingy and break down crying loudly?

>>30413892
Where they wrote sensitive subject like departure of someone important in a TVY rating show.
And I think Dash's character was well written as an element of loyalty. Her action might be controversial, but doing anything she can do so she don't have to say goodbye to her important person is something a true loyalty can only do.

>>30414676
The tortoise wasn't stated to have a problem with hibernating. It seemed more like Rainbow Dash was just refusing to let him hibernate out of sheer clinginess.

Which is kind of cute, but also out of character.

>>30415185
>The tortoise wasn't stated to have a problem with hibernating.
Of course. If he had a problem that would be a whole different story that won't fit in TVY show.
The hibernation was a metaphor for inevitable separation you just can't control, and RD's denial is not about hibernation itself, it's about being separated from someone you love.

I guess we just have to agree to disagree on out of character or not part.

NAHHH

>>30407021
This is literally headcanon.

File: sdfsdffdssdf.png (624KB, 1143x1024px) Image search: [Google]

624KB, 1143x1024px

>>30405574
like this?

>>30407021
>>30417178
Yep, I just rewatched it. He pulled all of that from his ass.

>>30417871
> it's a kanashiipanda post