[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Fimfiction Thread - Now with 81.5% less supremacy

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 506
Thread images: 85

File: central ohio horse arsonist.png (2MB, 850x1102px) Image search: [Google]
central ohio horse arsonist.png
2MB, 850x1102px
ITT: The Chase is not a meme, shitty canon OCs, professional mango readers, stories that nobody reads and nobody remembers get removed, more of Celestia's Relaxing Vacation because we needed a reminder of that, Fimfiction semantics, romance and how to gut it apart, some more romance, actually writing romance, Feminists bait Voiceguy into a trap, PTSD, The Chase is not a meme is a meme, Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, real literature and that's where it all goes tumbling down.

Tired of writers who delete their stories in a fit of self-righteous rage? Don't want to deal with fanfiction drama to find something worth reading? Well, we've compiled the best of the worst in order to bring you our absolute average!

>FiMFiction Starter Kit (recommended fics):
Winners:
http://i.imgur.com/vuTA7EN.png
List of nominees by category:
http://mlp-fanfics.herokuapp.com/

>How do I write fanfiction?
Ezn’s guide - https://eznguide.neocities.org/
Politics and the English Language - https://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit/
Vhatug's tips for anatomically correct clop - https://pastebin.com/g4VpEg4f
Setting a story in motion - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ufO8LbwTdu0 [Embed] [Embed] [Embed] [Embed]

>Can you pre-read my story?
Post it on Google Docs with inline comments enabled and give us a link. Someone might possibly take a look at it eventually.

>Reviews and riffs:
https://pastebin.com/u/notkickass222urmom

>Voiceguy's readings:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCt68MpmvEketmqOdHncHI2w

Old Thread
>>29433893
>>
81.5% why? The last thread survived until the end
>>
>>29505143
Because you allowed me to create it. Don't be so slow next time, or it will be 81,5%.
>>
>>29503396
>I'm an e/lit/e now
Only if the book's some obscure philosophical work. I'll forever be mad /lit/'s not just /co/ for novels that has general threads devoted to their favorite novel series.
>>
File: kafkaesque.jpg (42KB, 500x333px) Image search: [Google]
kafkaesque.jpg
42KB, 500x333px
>>29505286
Why would you be reading obscure philosophical shit, anyway? I set myself down the path of a nihilist before I even found out about Nietzche, I don't need some old fat faggot telling me what to believe in in some crusty old fat faggot book from a hundred years ago. And half of them are by jews, so.
>>
>>29505163
So you'll use the wrong number and incorrect punctuation?
Ok you passed the test! You truly are an illiterate fanfiction writer
>>
>>29505761
Great to know I'll fit in.
>>
>>29504995
bump
>>
>>29505286
Not him but does Codreanu count?
>>
>>29505286
As far as philosophy goes, I'm happy to stick with the uncontroversial stuff. I'm a down to earth /sci/fag, so I don't actually like reading the meaningless pretentious bullshit that some of /lit/ masturbates over.

I'm reading Thinking, Fast and Slow and Feynman's Lectures on Physics. Judge me.
>>
File: spooks.jpg (38KB, 533x533px) Image search: [Google]
spooks.jpg
38KB, 533x533px
>>29505294
>not reading obscure philosophical shit
>>
I'm throwing around titles for a tentative one-shot.

So, completely devoid of context, what would your reaction be upon glancing at a story titled "Stationery Palaver"?
>>
>>29506877
"The what what?"
>>
>>29506877
"I have no idea what this even is, so the description better be good"
>>
>>29506877
u wot m8
>>
>>29506877
After looking up "palaver", I would realise that the title isn't in fact a typo for "stationary", probably get annoyed that the title tripped me up like that then click through and read the description.

Then I would decide based on that and the cover art. Knowing only the title right now, I can probably say that it sounds more interesting than not.

Ooooooor I would just be too disinterested to look anything up and would scroll to the next story.
>>
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/106538/tea-time-with-the-crusaders
Shilling my old fic because it was a joy to reread and I hope it makes someone happy.
>>
How long do you make your chapters?
Because mine tend to vary. A lot. Anywhere from sub 1k to 15k, and it feels... improper. But I feel as if I am doing it the logical way.

A chapter is to a story what a paragraph is to a page. It is a logical grouping of a thematic whole, it's merely a higher standing. And just like with paragraphs, a chapter can describe anything from the fairly mundane day of a character to the highly detailed fight scene spanning several action-packed hours.
>>
>>29507890
Paragraphs generally don't vary too much though, depending on your style. Writing long walls of text is almost never good.

That said, you're more or less right. Here, for example, are the Lord of the Rings chapter lengths: http://lotrproject.com/statistics/books/chapters
The shorter chapters are around 5k words, the longer around 10-12k, with the single shortest 3.3k and single longest 16k. (Disregard the first 4 in the Fellowship as they're not part of the story per se, and disregard the Silmarillion since it was never properly finished and is more of an anthology compiled by Christopher Tolkien.)
>>
>29 unread chapters
I wish I could keep up with my tracked stories
>>
>>29509136
Oh my sweet summer child.
>>
>>29506880
>>29506896
>>29506899
>>29506900
The story would be about Twilight subscribing to a book-of-the-month club, but some of the novels would fall below her expectations, which in turn prompt her to start writing letters to the editorial with unwanted and unnecessarily long critiques of the stories. This starts taking its toll on her as stress and anger pile up until her friends get her to calm down and stop taking works of fiction so seriously.

It may or may not be inspired in true events.

Also, the title is inspired by an album by the band Camel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BvaqOAes_o
>>
File: Capture.png (3KB, 161x61px) Image search: [Google]
Capture.png
3KB, 161x61px
>>29509136
I'm still at the point where I could catch up with my unread chapters, but if I don't start clearing them soon, it's gonna be a problem.
>>
File: 1483207711285.png (3KB, 113x54px) Image search: [Google]
1483207711285.png
3KB, 113x54px
>>29509136
hm
>>
File: IMG_20170218_115859.jpg (143KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20170218_115859.jpg
143KB, 1920x1080px
Ah Christ this is actually happening.
>>
>>29509967
Hello Daniel Bosse
>>
>>29509985
Sup?
>>
>>29509992
Nothing much.
>>
>>29509967
>browsing fimfiction on a ps4
Why?
>>
>>29510037
Well why not?
>>
>>29510115
>Windows 10
>PS4
Jesus christ it just keeps getting worse
>>
>>29509967
Now, the chances of getting the right D. Bosse is pretty low, but I just want you to know that somewhere out there, in California, one Daniel W Bosse is getting four small, completely blank pizzas delivered to his home.
>>
>>29506717
https://jasoncollins.org/2016/06/29/re-reading-kahnemans-thinking-fast-and-slow/
>All the above points are minor in themselves. But together the shaky science, overconfidence and lazy storytelling add up to something substantial.

https://archive.is/SkPDV
>In 1971, Kahneman and Tversky had cautioned that scientists’ intuitions about randomness—their unwarranted belief that any small sample of the population could stand in for the whole—could lead to “unfortunate consequences in the course of scientific inquiry.” It was as if the field forgot, or simply overlooked, what they’d demonstrated with such clarity and humor—that even virtuosic scientists, even Danny Kahneman and Amos Tversky types, might be prone to this mistake.
>>
>>29506877
"Literally just characters standing in one place and talking? 2mundane4me.". I wouldn't look long enough to notice the pun, but if it did it wouldn't change the verdict.
>>
>>29510539

hownew.ru

https://www.zeemaps.com/map?group=1947200
>>
>>29510632
>"heil avenue"
>>
>>29510539
wrong.
>>
I wish we had more pony cock vore stories.
>>
>>29509136
Sounds like you need to prioritize. When a story I'm tracking updates and I don't read it immediately, I either download the update for offline reading and untrack the story, or just demote it to Read It Later (or at least Read It Sooner).
>>
>>29509222
To be fair, if this is a commercial publisher we're talking about she might have a viable career available as a professional editor. At least until (being Twilight) she finds something else to suddenly obsess over to the exclusion of all responsibilities.
>>
File: 1466364995825.png (139KB, 595x331px) Image search: [Google]
1466364995825.png
139KB, 595x331px
>>29510656
I dunno
>>
File: RatChieftain.png (126KB, 762x311px) Image search: [Google]
RatChieftain.png
126KB, 762x311px
What did he mean by this?
>>
So, how do you guys feel knowing that hybrids are now canon?
Are there any fics that used hippogriffs at all outside of special snowflake self-inserts?
>>
>>29510883
I don't see how griffons (mix between a lion and eagle) are supposed to breed with horses. Like most stuff past mid S5, I'm not going to include them.
>>
>>29510632
The amusing thing for me here is that despite being a Yurofag, I've unknowingly been within a few miles radius of four Americans here, and that's all within the last four or five years.

>>29510871
>Writer and Drawfag for AiE
Absolutely disgusting.

>>29510883
>So, how do you guys feel knowing that hybrids are now canon?
I feel like I'm going to ignore them.

>Are there any fics that used hippogriffs at all outside of special snowflake self-inserts?
I honestly can't think of anything. Doesn't seem like they've been used a lot in fics.
>>
>>29510915
I don't see how lions and eagles are supposed to breed
>>
>>29510871
>rape
>>
>>29510915
Well, griffons are a mix of lion and eagle. hippogrifs are just horse and eagle.
>>
>>29510931
Griffons are just that in mythology. It's like asking how a bird breeds with a horse to make a pegasi.

>>29510969
Then what is the difference between a Hippogriff and a pegasi?
>>
>>29510595
That's interesting, I'm happy to note that some of the points in this blog post also made me tick when reading the book, and although it seems to have taken some dents from the replication crisis, it looks like it holds up pretty well in the end for a >psychology book.
>>
>>29510978
>It's like asking how a bird breeds with a horse to make a pegasi.
Yeah, how do they?
Hippogryphs are just that in mythology too
>>
>>29510978
>Hippogriff and a pegasi
Pegasi are just winged horses.

Hippogrifs are just like griffons, just that instead of being front part eagle and rear part lion, they're eagle in the front, horse in the back, and fuckable all around.
>>
>>29510984
>Yeah, how do they?

>One is that they sprang from the blood issuing from Medusa's neck as Perseus was beheading her,[8] similar to the manner in which Athena was born from the head of Zeus. In another version, when Perseus beheaded Medusa, they were born of the Earth, fed by the Gorgon's blood. A variation of this story holds that they were formed from the mingling of Medusa's blood, pain and sea foam, implying that Poseidon had involvement in their making. The last version bears resemblance to Hesiod's account of the birth of Aphrodite from the foam created when Uranus's severed genitals were cast into the sea by Cronus.
>>
>>29511029
The front doesn't actually look like an eagle, though. So the designers probably didn't give a fuck and just gave a horse front claws.
>>
>>29511029
Just looks like some special snowflake version of pegasi to me. I thought the whole deal of them being "hybrids" was that they were bred with griffon.
>>
File: 1456352220540.png (136KB, 469x447px) Image search: [Google]
1456352220540.png
136KB, 469x447px
>>29511046
Interestingly, stratuses are a family of cloud characterized by being big, flat and just boring in general.

Maybe the designers did give a fuck after all.
>>
>>29510756
So write some. Or if you're lazy, commission them from headless_rainbow, Vraddock, Septia or someone else who takes "anything goes" commissions.
>>
>>29510883
>My Little Pony The Movie
>Guardians of Harmony
Damn it, they can't even keep their own brands straight?
>>
>>29511140
>>29510756
Or Kaidan.
>>
>>29509502
Rainbow Dash--We meet her parents! Windy Whistles and Bow Hot Hoof!
Applejack--Bright Mac and Pear Butter!!! Applejack's Parents!!!!

Headcanons being destroyed left and right
>>
>>29511281
There isn't much regard for topic in these threads, is there?
>>
>>29511742
>There isn't much regard for topic in these threads, is there?
We can talk about literally anything, since there's the built-in excuse of "I'll use it for a fanfic".

Besides, thinking of all the fan names for AJ and Dash's parents that got obliterated seems pretty on-topic for me.
>>
>>29511786
>fan names
>>29511709
>>
>>29511889
You misunderstand me.
I'm saying that it's fun to see all the fan names that people have given to their parents be finally rendered non-canon by the reveal of the official names.
>>
>>29504995
>Fimfiction semantics
...Which part of the thread was that again?
>>
>>29512131
I think it was about that discussion about the difference between a published and an unpublished, but accesible story.
>>
>>29513102
>Fallout: Equestria
Why, of course they'd have shit tastes.
>>
File: Untitled.png (84KB, 1062x583px) Image search: [Google]
Untitled.png
84KB, 1062x583px
Oh Jesus fucking Christ this is actually fucking happening help me
>>
>>29513135
>Those recommendations

OK, it's not that those are bad. That's subjective and all that jazz.

It's that most of them are old as dirt. Of all the things they could recommend, why did they pick mostly ancient shit?
>>
>>29513135
Blame our general
>>
>>29510883
>>29511281
were at a turning point here lads. for quite possibly the first time ever in any fandom anywhere, soon autistic headcanon may very well be less retarded than official material

>>29513135
danny boy, you know youve got to be completely honest with them. admit that you only read terribad shit for the lulz and only one shots unless youre getting paid
>>
>>29506877
Sounds similar to Carabas' Moonlight Palaver
>>
>>29513135
>Illya Leonov
>>
>>29514608
His/her voice sounds edited
>>
>>29513135
I'll do my best to tune in and keep track of every time you sperg a little bit. Or a whole lot.
>>
>>29514834
Don't worry, Dan's sperging will likely be tuned out by a metric fuckton of saliva, landwhale blubber, pitch shift and awkward hissing.
>>
>>29514863
Y'know, it'd be great if he opened doing that inhaling voice he does.
>>
>>29514876
this would be a perfect time for him to get back into doing that hypno thing.

doing a guest spot on a podcast about purified autism while doing a rarity voice? fucking hilarious
>>
>>29514915
>mention something offhand about cocaine and PCP in the middle without ever mentioning it again
>DAAAAAAAHLING
>>
>>29514373
Yeah, I think any story with the name Palaver in it is going to evoke Carabas' fic in the reader's mind, because Palaver is a really obscure word and that's the only fic most people know of that's used it. It's like how titling any fic with the name Pirene is going to make people think of Ether Echoes' fic.
>>
>>29513801
>the first time ever in any fandom anywhere
...Do I need to go digging for insane '30s and '40s comic scans?
>>
>>29515042
Yes. Yes you do.
>>
>>29514834
I don't think it's a live podcast. It's gonna be through skype, so everything will most likely just be recorded, edited, and then uploaded.
>>29514863
Supposedly, it's just gonna be me, Illya, and Kitsune talking about how we got into narrating MLP. (Or 'podfic' as they call it.)
>>29514876
Holy fuck that'd be hilarious. I'll do my best to see if I could insert that somewhere.
>>29514951
Kek
>>
>>29509222
It's like the story of my life, if you replace "long critiques" with "unhinged rants" and then remove the "friends" part and the "stopping" part and replace them with a continuous, never ending downward spiral.
>>
>>29515123
I hear ya, pal.
I'm actually writing these as therapy in hopes to stop taking little horsie stories so seriously.

>>29514373
>>29515026
That's a good point, but I don't think I care all that much.

I mean, it's not as if a lot of people will end up reading what I write, anyway, so I might as well go for a title that I think is fitting.
>>
>>29515252
Am I the weird one out when I never took any of these silly fanfics seriously?
I used to take the show seriously, but then I quickly stopped giving a shit after the first annual wingsday.
>>
File: What did he mean by this.jpg (146KB, 400x808px) Image search: [Google]
What did he mean by this.jpg
146KB, 400x808px
>>29515273
>Am I the weird one out when I never took any of these silly fanfics seriously?
You're in the ~180th thread of an ongoing series of threads in a japanese image board dedicated to writing fanficion about a show about little horses.

If you don't think this is srs biznoose, then get out of my face.
>>
>>29511281
I guess Windy Whistles and Bright Mac (assuming Mac is short for McIntosh) are okay, but what the fuck is up with Bow Hot Hoof and Pear Butter. What self respecting Apple wouldn't have an apple themed name? If you go to the wiki entry for Apple Family there are like twenty Apple family matters and all of their names either have the word Apple or are a reference to Apple related products, then they just decide to give up? Er...wait...Romeo and Juliet plot. An Apple falls in love with a Pear. Never mind, it's cool.

Bow Hot Hoof is still a stupid name though. Is there some clever pun or something I missing with that name?
>>
File: Steve_Urkel.jpg (33KB, 250x374px) Image search: [Google]
Steve_Urkel.jpg
33KB, 250x374px
>>29515322
>family matters
>>
>>29515322
>Romeo and Juliet plot.
Is that how they died?
>>
>>29515322
Is ajs hatred of pears an autistic canon thing, or an autistic fandom thing?
>>
File: theridewillneverend.png (26KB, 295x118px) Image search: [Google]
theridewillneverend.png
26KB, 295x118px
>>29505294
>anyway?
So you can be pretentious and make references to it in your fanfic before sperging out when people don't make the connection and assume it's just a spelling error.

>>29506495
>Romanian
>inter-war period
Yes, he does.

>>29506877
I'd google "palaver," then wonder why the author didn't use the much funnier sounding "rigamarole" instead. Then I'd realize it's a story about a boring and pointless conversation happening on paper and probably skip it unless the synopsis really got me interested.

>>29507890
Depends on the fic. Generally, I do everything I can to avoid a five digit word count, because as a reader, I'm far less inclined to read a chapter that's >10k long.

>what a paragraph is to a page
A chapter is two things in a fanfic: the standard literary mechanism of breaking up a longer work so as to make it easier to read (and stop reading), and a way to serialize a story so it can be published in pieces.

If you have a 30k long chapter, you're kind of defeating the whole point of a chapter, much as if you had a thousand word long paragraph.

>>29509136
>only 29
Anon, pls.

>>29509222
What's the hook, though? Is it a comedy where Twilight's really anal with her criticisms (i.e. a 500 word long rant about the oxford comma and how it's correct/wrong)? Because I can't really see how a straight story about Twilight ranting about stories would be terribly entertaining.

>>29510883
>merch is canon
skyla.jpg

Lack of any VA announcement aside, I think that's pretty cool. It'll hopefully jumpstart some griffon/hippogriff worldbuilding fics that have cooled since the Griffon Klingon Empire was debunked.

>>29510915
Technically wouldn't the anthropomorphic eagle or perhaps parrot be the one hybridizing with the pone? If it was griffon/pone it would be 50% horse, 25% eagle 25% lion. That looks straight 50-50 horse/eagle.
>>
>>29515512
>That looks straight 50-50 horse/eagle.
not really. looks more like bulk biceps got himself wing extensions and some hoof claws. needs more mouthsword or donggun
>>
Dunkin' Ponuts
>>
File: 10_rare_books_and_a_dead_body.jpg (417KB, 1111x1272px) Image search: [Google]
10_rare_books_and_a_dead_body.jpg
417KB, 1111x1272px
>>
>>29516247
Apparently it also has a beak, though it's so subtle and not-beak coloured it looks like a muzzle.
>>
File: how2triforce.png (209KB, 990x759px) Image search: [Google]
how2triforce.png
209KB, 990x759px
We all write[sic], but does anyone here roleplay?

And does anyone here do erotic roleplay?
>>
>>29517884
Ew.
You know that's illegal on the fourchins, don't you?
>>
>>29517889
And?
Is this site the only website in all of existence you visit?
>>
>>29517901
Yes.
>>
>>29517904
Oh.
Close your eyes and plug up your ears, then.
>>
>>29517908
Or, you could go back to wherever you crawled out of.
>>
>>29517916
I crawled out of here.
>>
>>29517919
Well, keep on crawling.
>>
>>29517919
Then you should know about >>>/mlp/rules/4
>>
>>29517927
I'm crawling around in circles.
>>
>>29517943
You're crawling in my skin.
>>
File: fluttershutter wants a hug.jpg (182KB, 604x800px) Image search: [Google]
fluttershutter wants a hug.jpg
182KB, 604x800px
>>29518149
lewd
>>
Oh god it's happening

My current mood

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TR3v_eT8aCA
>>
File: What did I get myself into.gif (3MB, 180x101px) Image search: [Google]
What did I get myself into.gif
3MB, 180x101px
>>29518207
Onwards to victory, voiceguy.
>>
>>29518207
And it's over.

I may or may not have sperged a little bit.

Also, Jesus Christ Illya actually sounds like that. He's over 60 damn years old.
>>
>>29518696
Are you gonna post the video once it's uploaded?
>>
>>29518700
...SHIT

Ah, it's all good, you'll see it on that Auralphonic podcast.
>>
>>29518721
An unedited version would have been fun too
>>
>>29518735
I had the thought of recording it, but I don't think they'd have appreciated that.

I can't be a prick 100% of the time.
>>
>>29518836
>I can't be a prick 100% of the time.
Sure you can. You just need more practice
>>
>>29518721
So, when is that coming up?
>>
>>29519478
We'll have to wait about as long as it takes for these ladies to edit out everything Voicefag said and block him online.
>>
>>29519516
>We'll have to wait about as long as it takes for these ladies to edit out everything Voicefag said


>"And with us today is Voiceguy! How are you?"
>--ello, I'm--fine--
>"Good to know, thanks for coming. That was Voiceguy, everyone."
>>
>>29519478
I'm not sure. Kitsune Heart is the one editing it, so It'll probably be up around the time she finishes it. Doubt it'll be today.

>>29519538
Heh. Honestly though, it was a lot of fun. We talked about how we got started, funny stories, and personal recommendations. Kitsune rec'd Fallout Equestria, Doctor Whooves Adventures, Illya rec'd It's a Dangerous Business, Twilight Sparkle gets a free Salad, and I rec'd Siren Song, and Conversion Bureau The Other Side of the Spectrum.

I might have also mentioned Celestia's Relaxing Vacation.
>>
>>29519589
Did you tell Kitsune to choke on cock?
>>
>>29520202
Why do you guys want me to be assholes to anyone and everyone? That ain't healthy.
>>
>>29519589
Sounds good. I didn't want you to sperg completely, I actually want the end product to be listenable.
>>
read any interesting fic lately?
>>
>>29521971
Just the river thing, which continues to be cute as fuck.

Also https://www.fimfiction.net/story/361744/secret-of-flying, in which someone other than the main character gets to save the day for once.
>>
File: 8i934959345934.png (770KB, 1001x1000px) Image search: [Google]
8i934959345934.png
770KB, 1001x1000px
>>29504995
Recommend me some good anonymous in equestria fics.

Protip: You can't
>>
>>29522020
We know.
>>
>>29520431
Hey voiceguy, can you read my brand spankin new fic next time you do a reading for me.
>>
>>29520431
That reminds me. Did you by any chance gave Bleedin' any free publicity?
>>
>>29522080
Now that would just be cruel.
>>
>>29522020
Exchange was pretty good. That's the only one that comes to mind, really. The good HiEs tend not to use Anon.
>>
>>29522080
>>29522084
No bully the bleedin
>>
File: u88488458435.jpg (790KB, 1980x1530px) Image search: [Google]
u88488458435.jpg
790KB, 1980x1530px
>>29522020
http://pastebin.com/h0V7jE9e

Not on Fimfic but this was the first Luna fic I ever read and is still one of the best by far.
>>
>>29520431
>implying
Kitsune sounds like a fat fucking fuck up and I'll bet $20 that "she" is just a trap who thought "HURR IF I PRETEND TO BE A GIRL, IT'LL BE OK FOR ME TO RAVE ABOUT OBJECTIVELY SHIT THINGS." Just be a cock to people who need an ego check.
>>
>>29522020
Too heterosexual for yo/u/?
What's with the sudden surge of "kill all males" mentality on FiMFiction? For fucks sake, users are approving of people sperging out over ships involving a penis, and blog series that ADMIT to being emotionally-based and consist of "nitpicking about romance until it degenerates into autistic screeching over male positivity." Justify this. Oh that's right you can't.
>>
>>29522084
>>29522114
Nah, its okay, I just gotta accept that no one likes my fics, even the one I just made is failing. i just meed to find a way to quit. I was never meant to succeed, I think ill start drinking or something, gotta quit somehow.
>>
File: 672347273472374.png (169KB, 1074x1180px) Image search: [Google]
672347273472374.png
169KB, 1074x1180px
>>29522258
I just asked a question don't sperg out on me
>>
>>29522501
He can't help it, his autism is too strong.
>>
>>29522501
There were no questions you walking, talking victim complex.

>>29522509
It's more autistic to write gigantic blog posts that are thinly veiled anti-male rants, but aight.
>>
>>29522017
>the river thing
The what, now?

>https://www.fimfiction.net/story/361744/secret-of-flying
>Human turned pony turned alicorn
>176,457 words in series to date
I may pass.

>>29522258
What?
>>
>>29522601
>The what, now?
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/363036/drifting-down-the-lazy-river

Georg's latest georg.
Oc romance about seaponies with Luna and Celestia thrown in there.
Seems to be steadily updating daily.
>>
>>29522205
She is a woman, she was nothing but nice to me and Illya, and she's married to her husband.

Believe me, I'm on your side when it comes to ego's, but she is, honest to god, like you or me, someone who cares about horse words.
>>
>that time I got yelled at on my homepage by a super popular author because I wasn't aware they could see the description of the library I put their story into

it was so fucking weird
>>
>>29522601
>What?
Oh no you don't, cocksucker. You don't get to pretend to be retarded.
>>
What went wrong?

http://www.fimfiction.net/story/364920/jutterance
>>
>>29522644
Please tell us more.
>>
>>29522644
Post it.
>>
>>29522631
>FOEggot
>cares about horse words
At best, "she" would be like a retarded kid who ruins a priceless painting by swatting a fly on it.

Also, when even Kkat lies about being a girl, despite his giant mutton chops...
Well, like attracts like, you know?
>>
File: Come, tell us how you feel.gif (2MB, 395x350px) Image search: [Google]
Come, tell us how you feel.gif
2MB, 395x350px
>>29522683
Are you feeling alright, pal?
>>
File: 9234923949234234.jpg (36KB, 707x490px) Image search: [Google]
9234923949234234.jpg
36KB, 707x490px
>>29522578
>gigantic blog posts

Get your autism checked
A single sentence isn't a blog post.
>>29522020
>>
>>29522666
>>29522669
It was a 2000+ upvoted story with barely any downvotes and I usually at least try anything with that good of a ratio, I should have avoided it due what it was clearly about, that's my fault.

I realized I wasn't enjoying it because every character talked super monotone and the plot was really generic and I skimmed the rest of the pages and threw it into my "already read-stories I didn't like enough to favorite" library.

I noticed I had notifications about 3 days later because I never get any notifications, and I was being told off over it.

I wiped my page and locked my shit down out of fear I was about to get fans sicked on me.
>>
File: Adios, you damned fool.png (412KB, 718x981px) Image search: [Google]
Adios, you damned fool.png
412KB, 718x981px
>>29522703
>Kkat trying to derail via an epik doxx xdddd
Are you okay? Someone should get you help.

With that said, dry your eyes of your tears and direct your attention to this image.
>>
>>29522729
You know I wasn't referring to that post after the non-spoilered part. Quit trying to backpedal.
>>
What the fuck is this shit.

Is this an ebin derail or is someone gonna tell me what went wrong with my story, because I'm gonna fucking lose it.
>>
>>29522796
Post link.
>>
File: Here Hooker.jpg (4KB, 300x57px) Image search: [Google]
Here Hooker.jpg
4KB, 300x57px
>>29522763
That persecution complex isn't healthy, Anon.
>>
>>29522796
Hold the fuck up. Are you actually Kkat, here to do damage control, or do I just need to break out the "fuck off bleedin" folder?
>>
>>29522804
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/364920/jutterance
>>29522822
>Fuck off bleedin folder

Why
>>
File: 1405738298078.png (751KB, 565x510px) Image search: [Google]
1405738298078.png
751KB, 565x510px
>>29522813
>call out your victim complex
>"n-no u have a complex"
Get smoked, fagbait.
>>
>>29522838
Dude, you're the one calling boogeyman.
>>
>>29522832
That opening description of the world and the character hurt me physically, not gonna lie. It feels like stuff that you could have saved for later or at least described better, this is super rushed, sort of "HERE IS EVERYTHING SO I DONT HAVE TO MENTION IT EVER AGAIN YOU SHOULD KNOW THIS NOW"

You also write with some weirdass flair like you're a grizzled british man doing a documentary on how to correctly cut trees down.

What the hell is a sentence like " Yet, we do nothing, but eat, sleep, and defecate into our everlasting toilets."
>>
>>29522832
Goddammit! I was really hoping that Kkat was here to shitpost in retaliation to me posting that pic. Anyway fuck off Bleedin.

>>29522847
You murdered five teenage boys and ate their kidneys. See, I can blatantly lie too!
>>
>>29522832
holy shit you're making me laugh as I read more

" Luminescence felt a bit aggregated at his father brought up old thoughts that she used to have. "
>>
>>29515322

It's very likely that they misheard "Bow Hot Hoof" and that the real name is something completely different.

Windy Whistles is an almost Wind Whistler, a G1 name they couldn't get back, and it sounds like there's a family line of Apple stallions named after an original McIntosh. Big Mac just happens to be the most recent of the line.
>>
>>29522854
>everlasting toilets
I have several questions
>>
>>29522874
GUYS
WHAT COLOR IS BIG MAC'S BUTT PICTURE
WHAT COLOR IS A PEAR
>>
>>29522891
They're pale yellow/gross green colored
>>
>>29522731
>I was being told off over it
Man, what a baby.
What story was it?
>>
>>29522601
>The what, now?
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/363036/drifting-down-the-lazy-river
Sequel to this equally-comfy fic:
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/284135/the-one-who-got-away

>>Human turned pony turned alicorn
>>176,457 words in series to date
>I may pass.
The first book is actually pretty good. It does a nice job portraying an HiE-turned-pony learning to live in Equestria, and there's a nice gradual buildup on the romance. It's mainly book 2 and onward where the MC slowly turns into the immortal alicorn warmage savior of the entire changeling race twice and starts soloing every season premiere and finale and fucking EqG for good measure with no regard for the M6.
Link: https://www.fimfiction.net/story/279271/new-beginnings
>>
>>29515361

Fandom thing.
>>
>>29522895
"I'll always be here for you", it was a bad idea to read something of that genre in the first place but the fucking ratio.
>>
>>29522832
At least there's no gore tag.

What will the overall story be about?
>>
File: download.jpg (4KB, 275x183px) Image search: [Google]
download.jpg
4KB, 275x183px
>>29522854
>>29522866
>>29522884
Goddamnit, there have been worse stories that have better ratings.

But, I guess I really am that terrible.

Is there anything redeeming at all, at least let me have that.
>>
>>29522613

Georg writes a buffer in advance, so most stories get steady releases a chapter at a time.
>>
>>29522891
FUCK
>>
File: pears.png (890KB, 923x781px) Image search: [Google]
pears.png
890KB, 923x781px
>>29522932
>>
>>29522893
>>29522932
DEEPEST LORE
DEEPEST LORE
DEEPEST LORE
DEEPEST LORE
DEEPEST LORE
>>
>>29522919
I dont want to spoil, but I guess it dont matter.

Twilight Sparkle is still alive after a long time. She finds the protagonist and helps her out and tries to use her to finally destroy the black tower, so pony kind can rebuild.
>>
>>29522891

Oh, that gonna be gud.
>>
File: storee.png (320KB, 668x882px) Image search: [Google]
storee.png
320KB, 668x882px
>>29522918
'k so, I know you mean this story...
>>
>>29515322
Somebody in that thread had a suggestion that it was misheard, and is something more like Beau Hothoof, which is not good, but a shitload better.

Plus, don't forget that the Oranges are related to the Apple Family too. I'd been low key assuming that one of AJ's parents was an Apple (Granny's child), and the other was an orange.

>>29515361
Fandom.

>>29515512
>Technically wouldn't the anthropomorphic eagle or perhaps parrot be the one hybridizing with the pone? If it was griffon/pone it would be 50% horse, 25% eagle 25% lion. That looks straight 50-50 horse/eagle.

But that's exactly what it's like in the original poem though. A male griffin mounts a mare, siring a hippogrif, which, despite the sire's lion characteristics, looks like a mix of horse and bird.

I suppose you could think of it as the way a Liger doesn't get a mane, except more extreme.

One thing to remember is that stories of griffins are old enough the origins are lost to forgotten oral history. But some myths have it that griffins aren't lion/eagle hybrids, but rather the parents of both eagles and lions: lesser predators that are kings of only the sky or the land, rather than both.

>>29504995
So is this a man that rides a horse around to light fires, or is it a man who burns down horses?
Oh shit, is it a horse that burns down things?
>>
File: but wait, there's more.png (173KB, 664x599px) Image search: [Google]
but wait, there's more.png
173KB, 664x599px
>>29522962
...but then I found this, too.
>>
>>29522975
Yikes.

Yeah though, the first one.
>>
>>29522891
BRIGHT GREEN
YELLOW
>>
File: but wait, there's more.png (61KB, 668x184px) Image search: [Google]
but wait, there's more.png
61KB, 668x184px
>>29522993
Looks like our best pal Shink left his two cents.
>>
Voiceguy, what's your stance on fics that include singing? Not just "go click this link for background music", but actual in-character singing?

I'd like to request a reading for a fic, but it includes 3-4 key moments that involve heartsongs.
>>
>>29523308
>voiceguy singing
[autistic screeching intensifies]
>>
>>29523318
I don't actually care if the songs are sung, or if they have background music (which would make them hard to post on YT); I'd just like to know if it'd make a reading request unsatisfiable.
>>
>>29522993
Link to his comment?
>>
>>29523308
>What's your stance on fics that include singing?

Depends on the song. Like when I did Come Little Children, I'll take thee away, I just took the song from the youtube video, and played it.

For originals? [External Screaming]
>>
>>29523645
>Depends on the song. Like when I did Come Little Children, I'll take thee away, I just took the song from the youtube video, and played it.
>For originals? [External Screaming]

They're well-known songs, but with replacement lyrics (with varying degrees of originality).

https://www.fimfiction.net/story/187968/cutie-mark-adventurers
>>
File: ani-edgeworth-zoom.gif (15KB, 227x176px) Image search: [Google]
ani-edgeworth-zoom.gif
15KB, 227x176px
>>29522644
>>29522731
>>29522918
>>29522993
ANON, TELL ME YOUR USERNAME
NOW
>>
>>29523680
>https://www.fimfiction.net/story/187968/cutie-mark-adventurers

Specifically, Sweetie Belle is a bard, and uses song-based casting a few times.
>>
>>29523645
I'll give it a look!

So, the podcast audio is finished. Despite you naysayers, everything that I said is in it. Granted, this is just a section of the podcast itself, and the people who actually run Auralphonic may change a few things, Which is why I'm uploading this audio in case they do. but this is everything.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=949wU6EbShw&feature=youtu.be
>>
>>29524170
>I'll give it a look!

Thanks!

It's definitely cheesy at times, but it never descends below cheesy into cringe, and when it's good it's extraordinary.
>>
>>29521971
Read Blink (http://www.fimfiction.net/story/341279/blink). Felt really edgy, in the sense that the grimdark was more there for its own sake rather than to enhance the story and, in fact, caused a far number of inconsistencies (massive energy requirements, infinite teleportation loop, etc.)

>>29522258
>tfw you only follow two people, one of whom has been dead for 30 weeks and the other's a SoarinDash shipper

>>29522832
Are. There are only a small amount "number" would be better than "amount". There are a few who dream.

Spelling errors in the synopsis is almost guaranteed to be one of the biggest turn-offs for potential readers. Always make sure to read through it carefully before clicking that publish button.

>>29522924
Even though the synopsis could be much improved, the root idea of an Equestria thousands of years in the future that's gone Western Roman Empire circa 500 and is a shadow of it's former self, with it's inhabitants dreaming of better days long since gone and perhaps desperately trying to recapture those days is a really interesting idea. One I'd definitely read.

Not too sure about the Sauron tower thing, though. It'd be better if Equestria's decay and collapse just happened naturely rather than some evil force--that would make the protag's journey much harder and more fulfilling, rather than just pointing at a villain to defeat and make everything better. You could even throw in a "fix your own shit and don't rely on immortal alicorns to do it" moral at the end
>>
IF ITS A INTERESTING IDEA, THEN HOW COME NO ONE READ IT

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>29524332
>Read Blink (http://www.fimfiction.net/story/341279/blink). Felt really edgy, in the sense that the grimdark was more there for its own sake rather than to enhance the story and, in fact, caused a far number of inconsistencies (massive energy requirements, infinite teleportation loop, etc.)

While that Blink went for much more direct horror, I preferred the psychological horror of the other story named "Blink": https://www.fimfiction.net/story/269332/1/blink/blink
>>
Note for Voiceguy: The Chase, chapter 3, has a pile of noise at 6:09: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDO16HWJh-E#t=6m09s
>>
>>29524691
I put that there. it's some bit of silence I amplified.
>>
>>29524709
>it's some bit of silence I amplified.

Huh. Why?
>>
>>29524715
Because I don't like The Chase, and I make every effort to have recordings be somewhat entertaining.

Which reminds me. The Chase chapter four for the Thursday stream
>>
Red Eye did nothing wrong. He didn't know about the Gardens of Equestria and was trying to rebuild the bombed-out nation in the only way he could, with slavery.
He was a vital instrument in bringing about the New Canterlot Republic.
>>
>>29524170
>one patron on patreon donating 1 dollar
kek
>pinged for copywrite for tiny tim
did you report yourself? because I cant imagine any of your 3 listeners would
>>
>>29524857
It wasn't a user report. Youtube has an automated system that's able to identify copyrighted content, and either mute that section of the video, or monetize it without your say-so.
>>
Will anyone just write me a fic. I am literally just begging for free shit yes, and it is very retarded what I want.
>>
>>29525166
explain ur request so we can all laugh at how retarded it is
>>
>>29522650
fite me irl male scum

>>29524332
>http://www.fimfiction.net/story/341279/blink
Looked at the description. Is it a copy of Stephen King's "The Jaunt"?
>>
>>29522854
That line is fucking funny.
>>
>>29524170
>I [post] the video in the comment section of the story and they've always been appreciative
Sidestepping the whole issue, I see.
>>
>>29525191
Its just an idea or a /ss/ with Spike and any of the Mane 6. The catch is that Spike is human, which is why I cant find any stories on the matter.
>>
>>29525571
>The catch is that Spike is human
Ew

The only thing that comes to mind is Zen and the Art of Suasion.

http://www.fimfiction.net/story/307701/zen-and-the-art-of-suasion

It's really well-written, and the character interactions feel believeable. I'd love it if I didn't find myself wishing they were ponies every chapter.
>>
>>29525571
Sounds against Fimfiction rules.
>>
>>29522650
...I just realized you called me a cocksucker while insinuating that I'm part of a movement that wants to kill all males. That's some headless_rainbow shit you're accusing me of.
>>
>>29525647
I'm 80% sure he's just shitposting. Best to ignore him and continue with our schedulede bumping and ocassional fic trashtalking.
>>
>>29524369
The account BleedingEquine was registered on 6th Oct, 2012. How many stories were posted between then and your posting this one? Of those, how many stories' descriptions did you read? Of those, how many involved an idea that had the potential to be interesting? Of those, for how many did you go on to read the story and provide detailed feedback within five hours of the story's posting?

Also, please link to the post or posts you reply to.

(Yes, I realize I'm doing a poor job ignoring shitposting.)
>>
>>29515512
>What's the hook, though?
Twilight would start just trying to give her opinion as well as some constructive criticism, but the longer it goes, the more vitriolic her letters start getting and it starts affecting her in her everyday life, and her friends realise this and try to slowly stop taking pieces of fiction so seriously. Cue: happy ending.

I wann do this because I feel my grasp on the characterisation of the M6 is getting a bit sloppy, so I just want to make a full character piece to keep sharp
>>
So, how do you think the ranks in the Royal Guard work?

We know Shining Armor is the 'Captain', but how would the hierarchy work amongst them?
>>
>>29526012
I like the premise. If the critique is done in a humorous way and it's overall just a light SoL piece, I'd read it.
>>
>>29525571
why would spike be human?
>>
>>29526457
Because I really like the picture.
https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2016/7/25/1208912__explicit_artist-colon-cold-dash-blooded-dash-twilight_spike_twilight+sparkle_balls_blushing_embarrassed_erection_femboy_humanized_male_nudity_.png
Its very spery and creepy, but I just want ONE fucking fic from a fandom that's literally catered to every single other fetish I have.
>>
>>29521971
Mostly been reading clop, vore and gore recently.

https://www.fimfiction.net/story/362596/a-night-only-one-will-remember

Luna, to satisfy her "needs", transforms a bat into a stallion and proceeds to torture and kill him, convinced that she's doing nothing wrong, that he ought to enjoy the "mix of fear and pleasure" and that she's very kind and considerate because she feels bad about it and "humanely" doesn't torture him as much as she potentially could. Celestia is mildly annoyed, but grateful that at least Luna didn't kill an actual pony this time.

If I were better read I'd probably recognize the cliché, but as it is I don't think I've ever seen a killer quite so self-satisfiedly convinced of their own kindness because of token expressions of sympathy toward the same creature they're torturing and killing for pleasure. It's an interesting concept, and quality rage fuel. (Probably doubly so if you have sympathy for clearly-sapient animals.)

The author begs for feedback in the author's notes, but on getting some dismissively says he "doesn't care". Yet he's also planning a sequel. [shrug]
>>
>>29522854
>everlasting toilets

That made me laugh more than it should have.
>>
>>29527148
You could try asking in the comments there. It'd be a long shot, but at least you'll get a notification if anyone does reply.

Or you could hire one of the various writers taking commissions.
>>
File: 1461903640711.gif (325KB, 370x330px) Image search: [Google]
1461903640711.gif
325KB, 370x330px
I'm writing a short story comprised entirely of reports and letters.

The underlying story is that back in the first episode, when Twilight is about to contact Celestia regarding the whole Nightmare Moon debacle, Spike mentions that she doesn't actually know anything about what Nightmare Moon is capable of doing. Spike's remark about not having much knowledge about Nightmare Moon prompted Twilight to delay her letter to Princess Celestia until she had a well-rounded plan to deal with her. Seeing how this is a pre-friendship Twilight, this meant she tried to face the problem by herself, which in turn led her to dabble with dark magic. However, dark magic requires a cost, and in this case that means part of Twilight herself got banned to the moon as Nightmare Moon was re-sealed there.

The story itself would be comprised of short, after-the-fact reports.

The first chapter would be one of the guards interviewing Spike, another would deal with the results of Twilight's medical check up by the head doctors of Canterlot, other would be the testimony of maids who were nearby when Twilight blasted NMM and herself to the moon. Another would be the findings of the archmages of the court after they examine what's left of Twilight's study.

I'm wondering how exactly to end the story. The entire purpose is to slowly give clues in every chapter so once you read everything, you realise exactly what happened. But storywise, I don't know how to give it a good ending that still fits within the epistolary format of the story.
>>
>>29527418
>I'm wondering how exactly to end the story. The entire purpose is to slowly give clues in every chapter so once you read everything, you realise exactly what happened. But storywise, I don't know how to give it a good ending that still fits within the epistolary format of the story.

So, I take it you want the fact that Twilight Sparkle banished a part of herself to the moon to be a twist.

In that case, I'd recommend something along the lines of mentioning a new addition to the mare in the moon, like color or something, in one of the last few reports.

Or you could just dump it into a condolence letter sent to Twi's parents.
>>
>>29527434
I thought about including a newspaper clipping later on that reported an addition to the visage of the mare in the moon. Maybe additional spots, or a shade of sorts. I think that could be a good way of explaining it to the people who didn't catch all the hints in the earlier chapters, though I'm not really a fan of speelling things out for the reader.

>Or you could just dump it into a condolence letter sent to Twi's parents.

I like that.

The way I'm working this is that just part of Twilight's mind/soul/whatever got trapped in the moon alongside Luna, so her body is still in Earth, though she's in a coma.

Maybe I could devote a small chapter to just condolence letters by teachers at the Academy, or Moondancer and her other "friends" from back then.
>>
>>29527481
>I'm not really a fan of speelling
hue
>>
>>29527488
Man, that bit alone is funnier than any comedy fic I've ever written.
>>
>>29524170
That as pretty okay.
7/10, nice ambience for laying in a bubble bath and playing with my penis.

Though I have to wonder why they asked you to come on the podcast. I mean, you're cute and all, but you're kind of a "literally who" in the field of MLP fanfic narration. Still, nice show.
>>
>>29527434
>>29527488
Anyway, here's the first chapter, the interview with Spike. I'm going to make the medical report now.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fo2MlkEqa9ynEoWAy97ija5BoiogxBLAVG7pZtD1rLs/edit?usp=sharing
>>
>>29527813
I asked that same question.

There are apparently a bunch of MLP narrators, I was one of the few who had an easy to remember name.

So I guess it was just blind luck.
>>
>>29527825
OK, so first thing's first: Most official and fictional transcripts that I've seen normally have someone's initials before their dialogue.
Example:

AN: Surely, you can't be serious?
LN: I am serious. And don't call me Shirley.

I'm pretty sure this is done to keep track of who's speaking, because otherwise you end up with a long series of quotation marks that can get confusing if you aren't paying close attention.
>>
>>29527856
Something tells me you wouldn't have been invited if you had kept the "voicefag" moniker.

>>29527859
See, I was originally going to do that, but isn't "script style" narrative banned from FiMFiction?

I know that's supposed to deter people from writing Nightmare Star's Revenge levels of cringe, but I just wanted to play it safe here.
>>
>>29527884
See, I was originally going to do that, but isn't "script style" narrative banned from FiMFiction?

Good point. Maybe you should ask a site mod about that.
>>
>>29527481
>Maybe I could devote a small chapter to just condolence letters by teachers at the Academy, or Moondancer and her other "friends" from back then.

Letter from Celestia expressing sympathies and her own regrets that she hadn't pushed Twilight to make more friends to support her?
>>
File: ok.jpg (31KB, 531x488px) Image search: [Google]
ok.jpg
31KB, 531x488px
>>29527898
>how do i greentext
>>
>>29527884
I don't think so. Stuff like The Vinyl Scratch Tapes is up there.

Which reminds me, I read a lot of VinylTavia in the early years of the fandom, and now I have no idea why I did that. I mean, I realise that it probably was because it's popular romance and that the ship was gigantic back then, but I just can't remember any particular things I liked about the characters.
I guess tastes just change. It's around half a decade ago, after all.
>>
>>29528031
I'm well aware of how I fucked up.
>>
Anyone else wish there were a way to view all comments by a Fimfiction user, even yourself?
>>
>>29528277
I'm sure the mods can do something like that, just like they can find out all the fics you've upvoted/favourited.
>>
>>29528304
Probably; but I'm not really interested in >doing it for free, even if they were inclined to let me.
>>
>>29527418
>I'm writing a short story comprised entirely of reports and letters.

That's a hard format to work with.

You might also include narrative chapters told from the point of view of a character other than Twilight or Spike. You don't have to make it the "results" of Twilight's medical check-up, or the "testimony" of maids, or the "findings" of the archmages; give the chapter from their point of view, third-person limited. The reader can put together the full picture, while the viewpoint characters only have part of it. Develop the characters a bit.

Let the doctors be baffled by the workup, because they don't have the whole picture. Show the archmages examining the study, and let it slowly dawn on some of them how far Twilight was ahead of them in some ways, while simultaneously doing something far more dangerous than they'd ever consider doing themselves. (Twilight is brilliant and powerful, but doesn't always know what she doesn't know.)

>>29527418
>I'm wondering how exactly to end the story. The entire purpose is to slowly give clues in every chapter so once you read everything, you realise exactly what happened. But storywise, I don't know how to give it a good ending that still fits within the epistolary format of the story.

Don't leave it hanging. Spell out what happened at the end. People who figure it out early will still enjoy it just as much, and will appreciate the confirmation. People who don't figure it out will get the wham-moment, and go retroactively re-evaluate what they read (or even just re-read it).

You could have somepony like Shining Armor, Cadance, Twilight's parents, or Spike go to Celestia and ask for details, because they know something's not quite right.
>>
>>29527856
>There are apparently a bunch of MLP narrators

Really? I've found very few, and even less if you care about quality. Who else is out there that produces decent-quality narration?
>>
>>29528531
Whoever did the audiobook version of University Days that's on EqD is pretty good. I really enjoyed listening to it again.

I'm not sure who else is good though; the Project: Sunflower narrator on EqD has a thick enough accent that it's hard for me to understand without focusing on it.
>>
>>29528508
>Don't leave it hanging. Spell out what happened at the end. People who figure it out early will still enjoy it just as much, and will appreciate the confirmation. People who don't figure it out will get the wham-moment, and go retroactively re-evaluate what they read (or even just re-read it).

This. There is very little point to leave things hanging. I mean sure, if you expect your readers to be able to connect some conspicuously placed dots, you don't _have_ to spell out every little neat detail about your story or setting. But leaving the main plot twist only vaguely hinted at serves no purpose whatsoever, except to annoy and alienate those readers who didn't make the connection.

One exception is if you want to leave the actual interpretation open to the reader. Generally speaking I dislike these types of stories as they tend to be the /r/im14andthisis2deep4me kind, but assuming the story is good, it can work. If, however, you have a clear "correct" interpretation in your mind, a particular premise you were working towards, then fucking give the readers this premise! /rant
>>
File: 1463164060198.jpg (133KB, 800x612px) Image search: [Google]
1463164060198.jpg
133KB, 800x612px
Esteemed Anons, I have not been diligent in my fanfiction duties lately.
I've read very little fanfiction at all for a long period now, and a significant amount of the fanfiction I have read isn't even pone.

Therefore, I seek to remedy this. Do I:
>Write a story
>Start reading The Blooming Moon Chronicles
Time allowing, with no promise made to finish either project.

I leave my fate in your hands.
>>
File: checkem.jpg (50KB, 334x377px) Image search: [Google]
checkem.jpg
50KB, 334x377px
>>29528700
Write a story.
>>
>>29528700
Write a story.

Or, as a third option: get a recommendation for a better story to read.
>>
File: 1301207269853.jpg (22KB, 314x304px) Image search: [Google]
1301207269853.jpg
22KB, 314x304px
>>29528700
Write a story, Anon.
>>
>>29528700
Write the next Blooming Moon Chronicles.
Problem solved, see you in 5 million words.
>>
File: Thanks, Mr. Meeester.png (20KB, 655x90px) Image search: [Google]
Thanks, Mr. Meeester.png
20KB, 655x90px
>>29527898

Well, Meeester said it's ok as long as it isn't mostly script-like dialogue, so I guess I'm safe.

>>29528508
>>29528620

>That's a hard format to work with.
Which is part of why I want to make a story like this.

My stories often end up with an overwrought narrative, full of needlessly long rambling and overtly detailed descriptions that could work just as effectively or even more so were they to be trimmed down, much like a garden that has been left unattended for too long and now has grown wild and randomly until the point it obscures the house behind it.

That is why I want to make a short story that has the least amount of traditional narration in it (I estimate the final wordcount will be around 5~6k words) while still managing to deliver an engaging plot.

>You might also include narrative chapters told from the point of view of a character
Something I was thinking about including were small excerpts at the end of each report where the character who made the report shares their thought with colleagues or the recipient of the reports.

For example, the doctor who did the checkup on Twilight'sbody, would complete her report and then send a short memo to the head doctor asking just what happened to her because all her symptoms indicate something eveil and whatnot. And then the one of the archmages would send a letter to one of his elders as they try to ascertain whether or not it was really dark magic that led to the accident.

I still want the core of the story to be a somewhat experimental epistolary story.

>Don't leave it hanging. Spell out what happened at the end.
>There is very little point to leave things hanging.
Yeah, it's probably for the best. I'll keep the reveal contained to the very last chapter though. I'll still get my autism kicks from making the preceding chapters be all mysterious.
>>
File: 1481813410964.jpg (88KB, 636x960px) Image search: [Google]
1481813410964.jpg
88KB, 636x960px
Guess I'm going to write a story. Thanks, BMC would be a nightmare.
Time to go into my idea archive and see if there's anything salvageable in there.

>>29528757
Suicide is not presently an option, so I'll stay clear of that insanity.
>>
>>29528508
>>29528620
How do you feel about http://www.fimfiction.net/story/54410/a-description-of-a-fountain-in-canterlots-gardens? The commenters sure seem to like it.
>>
>>29528919
>http://www.fimfiction.net/story/54410/a-description-of-a-fountain-in-canterlots-gardens
>From the Author's note: This made me started wondering what it would be like if I wrote like people drew; this is the result. I didn't start with the notion of telling my headcanon of Equestria's post-Hearth's Warming political history by describing a fountain in Canterlot, I swear.

Is that what this was about? I thought it was some weird Chekhovian sketch of a fountain with a subtle joke at the end.
>>
>>29528919
>It's beeen four years since I read that story
fugg
>>29528947
I thought it was about Celestia getting a gift after her sister got banned to the moon.
>>
>>29528919
I read another story this guy wrote.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/41443/twilight-discovers-literary-analysis

Metafiction makes my brain hurt.
>>
Sodomy
>>
File: lewd.jpg (23KB, 315x320px) Image search: [Google]
lewd.jpg
23KB, 315x320px
>>29529756
But Anon, that's lewd.
Any good sodomy fics?
>>
>>29529787
Celestias relaxing vacation
>>
>>29529787
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/124728/role-reversal
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/322191/2/24-hour-clopshots-season-6/episode-2---a-is-for (other chapters unrelated)
>>
>>29528871
>Time to go into my idea archive and see if there's anything salvageable in there.

Idea for a random prompt:

Randomly choose one of the Mane Six or Luna or Celestia, and then randomly choose a character other than those who has had at least one speaking part in the show. Write a believable romance between those two characters; come up with a way for them to make sense together.

I've seen believable stories with ships that in any other story would seem like a crack ship. Anything is possible. And it makes for an interesting random prompt.
>>
File: why.png (154KB, 634x443px) Image search: [Google]
why.png
154KB, 634x443px
>Already has four tags
>Description says it's also is a Slice of Life and a Romance
Why do that? Isn't mistagging against the rules?
>>
Halp.

I'm looking for a story, that I can't remember, where human in equestria, surprizes everyone by loving chrysalis for who she is or something like that.
>>
>>29530706
>human in equestria
Yeah, I'm sure you need help.
>>
>>29530706
>loving chrysalis for who she
gonna need more than that.
bugbitch luvin' cancer isnt as small a genre as youd think
>>
>>29530730
It was either denying the help of the ponies in favor of Lings, or that she thought she captured a loving critter, who just openly had a crush on the bug queen.

I can't remember.

Either or is good.
>>
>>29530706
>I'm looking for a story, that I can't remember, where human in equestria, surprizes everyone by loving chrysalis for who she is or something like that.

There are several of those; it's a pretty common trope at this point for Chrysalis to offer Anon a choice of forms, and Anon to tell Chrysalis that he wants her true form. I've seen it both in fimfiction and greentext stories.

What else do you remember about the story?

There's a greentext story involving a magic-immune Anon getting all the alicorns pregnant. There's a fimfiction story involving a human who turns into the Alicorn of Sex. There are a couple more fimfiction stories and at least one other greentext, whose details I don't remember.
>>
>>29530738
>Either or is good
well thats debatable

was this one where pones were shunned completely and cheeselegs were embraced, or was everyone waifued?

Any extra details would help because theres no shortage of human fucks __________ in horseland stories
>>
>>29513801
this has already happened, or did you miss to where and back again. be fucking honest. if any fanfic tried to do exactly what the finale did you'd all think it was the most base crack tier bullshit ever.
>>
>>29522258
>durr u dont like my otp donut anon steel self insert/my waifu so that means you're an sjw who wants to kill all men
holy fucking balls please end your miserable existence. no one should have to put up with this kind of stupidity.
>>
>>29530730
>not liking bugmom
the only cancer is (you)
>>
>>29525307
No, when Twilight (or anyone) teleports, she teleports into a giant glass sphere, a copy of her is created out of thin air with all the memories, etc. and teleports out and she's stuck there to eventually die of exposure/thirst/hunger and join the massive pile of corpses of herself and her friends (who'd occasionally teleport with her) she's standing on. There's no explanation for why the spell would do something so massively inefficient other than the author shrugging in the comments and going "maybe someone evil made the spell."

>>29527418
>comprised entirely of reports and letters
Hey, so am I. My framing device is a dying government server full of errors. It starts with boring government transcripts, letters and such but as you sift through it all, things shift to dealing with a zombie apocalypse that started in Manehattan and it ends with the revelation that the princesses are dead, Equestria's been in eternal night for months, and the -100 degree temperatures are what's causing the servers to die.

>part of Twilight herself
How does that work, exactly? Because You could probably leverage that for the ending. Celestia's letter to Twi's parents, or a doctor's speech about Twilight's current vegetable status to a symposium.

It does depend on the kind of ending you want, though.

>>29527825
Pretty cool, overall. I've always been a sucker for fictional reports and the like. You might want to add some bullshit at the top like an ID number, name of report, name of agency, maybe even a stamp/seal or two if you can be bothered to fuck around in Photoshop/Illustrator, etc. to make it feel more like a report. You also might want to add some cues in the transcript, like >"Spike: [sob] I didn’t know, alright! How could I have known she’d do something like that?”
>>
>>29530744
Anon and Chrysalis met in a bar after Twilight tried to experiment on him.
>>
>>29531266
>Hey, so am I. My framing device is a dying government server full of errors. It starts with boring government transcripts, letters and such but as you sift through it all, things shift to dealing with a zombie apocalypse that started in Manehattan and it ends with the revelation that the princesses are dead, Equestria's been in eternal night for months, and the -100 degree temperatures are what's causing the servers to die.

Twist later on, or is this just an "everything sucks and everyone's dead" crapsack world? Or do you not want to say?
>>
>>29531317
>Anon and Chrysalis met in a bar after Twilight tried to experiment on him.

Hmmm. It's been a long time since I've read it, but are you thinking of https://www.fimfiction.net/story/134427/never-judge-a-bug-by-her-cover-chrysaliss-royal-break-up-chronicle ?

The original story was pretty good. Skip the "sequel" entirely; it takes the story in a completely different (and awful) direction.
>>
>>29531317
I always get a chuckle out of how people treat her.
Twaifufags act like she can do no wrong, normal people treat her like a ponified mengele. And very little middle ground
>>
>>29531928
>Twaifufags act like she can do no wrong, normal people treat her like a ponified mengele. And very little middle ground

I don't care for the stories that suggest Twilight would experiment without consent. But even though I like Twilight as best pony, I can easily imagine her getting a little too invasive with questions, or momentarily being thoughtless with an experiment. (She's brilliant, but she doesn't always think things all the way through and apply common sense in addition to intelligence.)
>>
>>29528919

I remember liking it, but feeling it was just slightly on the side of being too obscure in trying to convey what happened without actually saying what happened.
>>
>>29530744
>There's a fimfiction story involving a human who turns into the Alicorn of Sex.

But there already is an Alicorn of Sex...
>>
>>29532198
Is there a version of that picture with a cohesive stream of semen flowing out of her backside?
Because there should be.
>>
>>29532198
>But there already is an Alicorn of Sex...

The story actually brought that up explicitly, and had some clear dividing lines between their two domains.
>>
>>29531266
>My framing device is a dying government server full of errors.
Hey, I remember you talking about that one. How is it going? Did you figure out how to use computer code the way you wanted?

>How does that work, exactly?
This will be revealed by the archmages' report once they finish scanning Twilight's living quarters. What happened was that she tried to seal back Nightmare Moon on her own, but thought that searching for the elements would be a waste of precious time, so she stumbled upon a dark magic ritual used for sealing--picture Sombra's banishment--and decided it was her best shot.

Now, Sombra was sealed by two alicorns, while Twilight is just a unicorn, so the price to pay is greater for her. In the process of sealing Nightmare back, part of her soul/mind/consciousness was stripped from her and was sealed too, leaving her as an empty husk.

I think the best way to deliver the reveal is with the report of the archmages and their findings of dark magic.

My outline so far is:

-Transcript of an interview with Spike
-Medical check up of Twilight's body
-Actual incident report from the local police
-Written testimony of one of the maids who was close to the blast zone
-Letter from Shining Armor to Cadence informing her of what happened, with him breaking down midway through
-Newspaper report about the odd appearance of the moon in the nights following the Summer Sun Celebration
-Report of the court archmages after they ascertain there was black magic involved in the accident
-Series of condolence letters by Twilight's acquaintances sent to her parents, and a letter of apology from Princess Celestia where she explains other details about what happened.

Interspersed at some point would be notes from the ponies doing the reports to their superiors, like the nurse asking just what's wrong with her, to include a bit of character moments, but they'd be minimal.

Sounds good? Does anyone have any suggestion as to what could be added/removed?
>>
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/233710/my-little-orgy-debauchery-is-magic

that title. that ratio.

How?
>>
>>29533214
>how
It's a straight and/or lesbian clopfic
>>
>>29533214
Well, it doesn't seem to have any odd fetish. If the writing is at least passable, then I don't see why it's so weird that it has a somewhat decent rating.

I've seen worse clpopfics with better rating.
>>
>>29528919
Ranting anon here. It was a decent little read.

Now, I am not much of a fan of long descriptions and not much else, so if this story was much longer than it is, I'd probably have ended up bored. As it stands, it was pretty alright to say the least - I did enjoy reading it.

Now as for what I'm guessing is the main reason you asked: I had a guess as to what the point would be about halfway though, but after that there was very little to actually confirm it. According to the author's comments I was right, but had I not looked, I wouldn't have known, and would have been left with a feeling of mild dissatisfaction stemming from my guess being only tentative, and no way to confirm or deny its validity.

It's still, however, clearly meant to be a piece that evokes thought, rather than tells a particular story, so I probably would've enjoyed it either way, because ultimately the story isn't the important part here.

Also,
>The commenters sure seem to like it
That's not a measure of quality by any means. Unless the story lures in wrong readers by describing itself as something it's not (this includes stories that are really, really shitty, but you couldn't tell that from the description alone), or touches on topics that some people will go out of their way to yell at (e.g. foalcon, torture porn, etc.), most stories will generally have predominantly positive feedback.
>>
>>29530744
>magic-immune Anon getting all the alicorns pregnant
>a human who turns into the Alicorn of Sex
I'm gonna need some links anon
>>
>>29533405
anon (or at least a human) knocking everyone up probably isnt too uncommon, but I'm so used to faggots turning into the alicorns of edge that The Prince of Fucking might actually be entertaining in a cringe inducing sort of way
>>
>>29531266
Oh, right. Forgot to mention. I know it isn't exactly the same story, but maybe you could check this out and gather some ideas for your story.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6miahiNDtiE

It's a similar core concept. A computer is slowly dying and is sending distress signals, though the circumstances are vastly different.
>>
>>29530343
I actually found some ideas and concepts I want to use, but this prompt sounds fun. So I'll roll for random characters and write some ideas about it before chucking it into said idea archive.

I'm going to go roll a d8 for main character (sorted alphabetically).
Rolling for the random speaking character is going to be harder, but I think I've found a way. The MLP Wikia, being the glorious autismden that it is, has a fuckton of ponies listed by when they first appeared in the show, down to the second. So I'll just roll for season, episode, minute and second, and then find the speaking character that was first introduced closest to that random point in the series.
I cannot possibly see any issues with this.
>>
>>29532683
>>29527825

I finished the second chapter.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/19uw_8F-I6w68APRXZQVYpbgKMHjxpHeavEd4HO8MbVY/edit?usp=sharing

A medical report of Twilight's state.
>>
File: 2017-02-21_22-37-18.png (2KB, 346x28px) Image search: [Google]
2017-02-21_22-37-18.png
2KB, 346x28px
>>29534293
So that's main character 7 in alphabetical order, which is Rarity.

And her romantic partner will the the pony with a speaking role who was introduced closest to episode 112 (Scare Master), at 15 minutes and 28 seconds into the episode. I'm excluding children and elders.
Just 27 seconds earlier, we are first shown "S05E21 Unnamed Earth Stallion #1", who doesn't have a speaking role. He's only shown for like three seconds. So the search continues.
However, aside from the highlight in his mane and tail, the Unnamed Stallion looks exactly like Noteworthy. So I'd say that kind of counts.

There weren't any new Crystal Ponies introduced that entire season, so they're out. It seems there were actually no new characters introduced this episode at all, or in the following episode. However, the Wikia lists two new introductions in episode 20 (Hearthbreakers), and the latest introduced would be Marble Pie.
HOWEVER, this is just flat out wrong, as Marble Pie was in Pinkie's S1 flashback. The hunt continues.
But she does kind of count since I'm excluding foals and this was her first adult appearance.

I've ended up with "Steel Bolts", one of the McColts from that whole episode. Some literally who, never even been mentioned in a FimFiction story.

So I guess it's either Rarity x Steel Bolts, Rarity x Marble Pie, or Rarity x Noteworthy.
>>
>>29534599
While I'd go for the last two in a heartbeat, I'd be interested int he way the first one could work.

If you can come up with a decent explanation foro Steel Bolts and Rares to have a romance, go ahead.

If not, I'd love me some Rare Marble.
>>
>>29534624
Random anon here to point out that the point was to get an unexpected and challenging ship. Steel Bolts seems like a perfect candidate.
>>
>>29534666
Can't argue with that, Satan.
>>
>>29534624
Yeah, I'm also seeing the most promise in going with Marble Pie.
The rock/mining parallels are pretty obvious and somewhat fitting, so that would be something to incorporate. Marble, the rock, is also kind of a luxury product in a way. So there's some thematic stuff.
Characterwise I'll have to go reread Marble's lines, but she was pretty shy and quiet, right? Better make sure not to write her as a stand-in for Fluttershy then, but find some new angle to her. Maybe contrast her with how Rarity's a pretty social and vocal character, and make a lot of it be about communication. Maybe their interest in each other isn't spawned from conversation, but admiration or fascination with the other's work. I dunno, I'm just throwing stuff out here. And busy 10 hour workdays restrain my already meagre creativity.

It also means Pinkie pretty much has to be involved in the story on some level, which gives me even more to work with. I do believe that episode about getting Maud a gift mentions that Pinkie does this gift swap things with all her sisters, so that might be something to incorporate. Though that treads dangerously close to retreading the ideas of an episode, which isn't something I want to do.

There's definitely something in here that you could work with, easily.

>>29534666
But Satan is also right.
Rarity wasn't there during the episode, so she would be meeting him after the feud is over. Maybe he's left the clan home, and is pursuing work as a carpenter or something?
>>
>>29534712
What are you talking about? I explicitly said I was just a random anon!
>>
>>29534765
Nothing says you can't write both

>Maybe he's left the clan home, and is pursuing work as a carpenter or something?

You just made me think of a parody of The Glass Blower but where the stallion who falls for Rarity is a carpenter.
>>
>>29534765
Steel Bolts also doesn't seem to be very aware of the world outside of his family's feud.

He no longer feels like he needs to stay at home and fight, seeing as the feud is over. In addition, Twilight and Fluttershy's visit has made him curious about the outside world, of which he knows fairly little. He's barely ever been more than a day's travel away from his home, and his education is lacking in a lot of areas. He's got a good talent for carpentry or some other kind of physical labour, but all he's ever used it for is building and rebuilding stuff related to his family's home.

No matter the reason and backgrounds, he ends up leaving home to go somewhere else in Equestria, and encounters Rarity. Maybe it's in Ponyville, maybe it's somewhere else. She's familiar with the story of the feud, but has never met him. But when she hears that he hasn't been having a easy time getting work, her generosity kicks in and she hires him to do some token carpentry or something.

And as per standard romance plot, they grow closer while he's working for her. Despite being very different and all that jazz, they eventually find a bonding tone over something that's more important than their differences. Maybe they find something intriguing in the other in regards to work ethic, siblings/family, or generosity/giving. Or maybe they just hatefuck.

Not exactly inspired or interesting, but I guess it's somewhat functional.

>>29534787
Laziness, Anon. I'm very lazy.
>>
>>29534842
>Not exactly inspired or interesting, but I guess it's somewhat functional.
Many relationships are based on that very same principle.
Godspeed, Anon.
>>
>>29531346
Not the other anon but that story wasn't quite bad, although I stopped reading before the now uncanonical chapters
>>
>>29534865
>Many relationships are based on that very same principle.
That could also be an element to it.

Something like Rarity coming to terms with her feelings for Steel Bolts, when she's spent most of her adult life fantasising about princes, artists and authors. Does she suppress her budding feelings to stay a hopeful romantic, waiting to the "right one", or does she allow herself to fall in love with someone who's actually real and will be there for her, even if he's not exactly what she's been dreaming of?
It would tilt the fic into being more-Rarity centric, but I guess it's a decent place to start when figuring out that plot mandated internal struggle. I don't real a lot of romance these days, in case it's not readily apparent.

Is it defeatist to settle for something that's real and functional, or are Rarity's grand romantic ambitions juvenile?

I dunno, I'm probably not ever going to finish this. But I'll keep some notes, just in case I really feel like being the first guy to publish a fucking Steel Bolts fic.
>>
>>29531212
>Undertale pic
Like clockwork.
>>
File: Steel_Bolts_ID_S5E23.png (562KB, 774x815px) Image search: [Google]
Steel_Bolts_ID_S5E23.png
562KB, 774x815px
Give him a nice haircut and he could be a stud.

>>29535396
>Is it defeatist to settle for something that's real and functional, or are Rarity's grand romantic ambitions juvenile?
Well, there you go, spend a good chunk of the story with Rarity dealing with those feelings, maybe asking the rest of the Mane6 for help and advice.

Have you read "I Love to See You Smile"?

https://www.fimfiction.net/story/27108

It's a mostly Rarity centric fic that does a remarkable job of work out through the developing feelings she has for Pinkie, and that's the same concept you could apply here.
>>
File: Alright, then.png (14KB, 293x199px) Image search: [Google]
Alright, then.png
14KB, 293x199px
Is this the new peaches fad?
>>
File: schlock20010406.jpg (136KB, 780x234px) Image search: [Google]
schlock20010406.jpg
136KB, 780x234px
>>29531266
No, when Twilight (or anyone) teleports, she teleports into a giant glass sphere, a copy of her is created out of thin air with all the memories, etc. and teleports out and she's stuck there to eventually die of exposure/thirst/hunger and join the massive pile of corpses of herself and her friends (who'd occasionally teleport with her) she's standing on.
Read the story. (I mean I did; stupid homonyms.) So it's closer to a ponified version of Schlock Mercenary's wormgates, then.

(There's probably a better example of the idea from classic sci-fi, but I'm regrettably ignorant of it.)

There are other issues the story raises, but I guess there's no point naming them here; you've basically summed it up.
>>
>>29531266
>>29536418
Isn't that Hugh Jackman's trick in The Prestige?

The teleporting machine Tesla built him worked as a fax machine, keeping the original, but made a copy of the teleported subject somewhere else, and then Hugh has to kill the original so only one remains because he only cares about his magic show instead of the infinite possibilities presented by having a cloning machine.
>>
>>29536418
Forgot to >; sorry.

>>29536192
My knee jerk reaction is "I sure hope not"; but it's good if it gets people writing, I guess.
>>
>>29536476
Only if some outside party were secretly following him around abducting all the originals so that the copies never found out they existed. Otherwise it'd either be that or Think Like a Dinosaur (curiously apparently published the same year).
>>
>>29536544
...Come to think of it, Think Like a Dinosaur did have the originals killed in secret without the copies knowing, didn't it? So it's a lot like that, just from the victim's perspective and with the killer(s) hidden.
>>
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/360348/the-skyla-pseudonym
>Celestia Code, book 4
>starring rebellious teenage Flurry Heart
HYPE
>>
>>29536642
>The [adjectiveised noun] [noun]
See? I told you people this scheme worked!
>>
>>29536642

>not calling it The Pskyla Pseudonym

>or the Skyla Seudonym

Missed opportunity tbqh
>>
>>29531334
It's supposed to be sort of a twist. There's going to be a weather "chapter" (with a "local on the 8's" style gif) that reveals what the current weather conditions are.

>>29532683
>How is it going?
Much, much slower than I'd like. I've only got three logs done and there's probably at least a hundred more to go. Plus most of the visual effects.

The coding's still an issue, although I've leaned a little.

>sounds good?
You might want to start with the police report, since they'll probably have no idea what happened, much like the reader, and that could help with the suspense/mystery that'll hook people in.
>>
>>29536870
>The Pskyla Pseudonym
bonus points if you work in a palaver and/or piriene
>>
>>29536642
>not The Skyla Sobriquet
>>
deder dan ded
>>
>>29522017
>>29522613
>http://www.fimfiction.net/story/363036/drifting-down-the-lazy-river
Completed now, I see.
>>
File: You're not saying anything new.png (8KB, 445x80px) Image search: [Google]
You're not saying anything new.png
8KB, 445x80px
>>29537917
>>
>>29537428
>I've only got three logs done and there's probably at least a hundred more to go.
Damn, that sounds like it'll be a trip.
I hope you get to wrap it up within the year.
>>
>>29538492
>I hope you get to wrap it up within the year
sheeeeeeet. those three logs probably took a year
>>
Nyxyanne is a better mouthsworder than your waifu
>>
>>29539319
something something poop
>>
>7 posts in 14 hours
Dead.

Post the last sentence or paragraph you wrote about pone:
>>
>>29540687
The explosion took us by surprise. The castle was in the way, and we couldn’t get a clear view of the Twilight’s tower. Even some of the pegasus guards were knocked from the air.

I don't think I'm doing a good job of showing Shining Armor being shell-shocked. Any advice?
>>
>Aie
>Pinkie names him "Scruffy"
/ourguy/?

>https://www.fimfiction.net/story/360888/10/stranger-in-the-forest/chapter-9---welcome-to-ponyville
>>
>>29540804
>Aie
>/ourguy/
Definitely not this thread's guy.
>>
>>29540804
>a story in which a human shows up in the everfree forest and meets the mane 6
Wow, it's fucking nothing.
>>
>>29540778
You're just describing physical stuff, I have no idea how Shining feels.

How does he? Don't tell us, tell us how he reacts.

Ex:

Our commander, as a drunkman, was falling all over the rubble, gasping for air and trying to straighten himself. I heard the moans of some of my comrades: the unicorn, I assume, as I had hoped the pegasi section had time to fly away before the shock. As I searched around for my glasses, I saw multiple white blurs fly in the distance, flocking towards the castle and, I assumed, other ruins.
>>
>>29540866
Well, the thing is, this is a letter written by Shining Armor to Cadence after Twilight got in an accident.
He's trying to stay collected but starts breaking down as the letter goes on until he scratches the last lines and just writes a plead for Cadence to hurry back.
>>
>>29540901
I don't think he'd break down for a letter. It's more plausible for actual narration, but for letters, it's usually:

A: You're not in a hurry, you can re-read and correct it before sending

B: You are in a hurry, you write it squiggly all around

So I guess it would either be completely collected and formal or completely broken and hasty.
>>
>>29540866
>You're just describing physical stuff
I'm pretty sure that's the point. He wants Shining Armour to seem emotionally blunted, like he's writing his report in an automaton-like state without having the capacity to fully understand the substance behind his words. So the terrible and emotional is presented as mundane.

That isn't to say Anon nailed this, but I'm sure that this is what he's trying to do. I'm also pretty sure that it's the guy who wants to write a story made from letters, reports and scripts.

Your suggestion is just kind of missing the point he's trying to do, and doesn't really sell me on shell shock. You're just kind of saying "this was terrible", which isn't the same as trying to convey that SS present state is terrible.

Again, not saying that the original Anon's sentence was the way to do it, you're just missing the point.
>>
File: Can't Stump the Trump.png (122KB, 961x300px) Image search: [Google]
Can't Stump the Trump.png
122KB, 961x300px
Good to know there's still some semblance of hope for FiMFiction
>>
>>29540687
Does a comment about other comments on a fic about pone count?

>On the topic of the utility of the matter-duplicating portion of the spell, I'm slightly surprised no one has name-dropped Robin Hanson. (Or Thomas Malthus, for that matter.)
>>
>>29540922
As physical, I meant it only described the non-living material around him and not the living Shining Armor. I'll agree my version isn't any better on the actual emotion side of the main character.
>>
>>29540915
I want to go for a mix of both.

Shining starts the letter as collected as he can, going full "Captain" mode for it, because he's writing the letter just after he got Twilight out of the rubble and had her sent to the hospital. After that he goes to inform Cadence, but as he writes the full realisation of "Oh, crap. I don't know if my little sister is going to live" hits him and he just breaks down, and the letter ends with him begging Cadence to come to Canterlot.

>>29540922
>I'm also pretty sure that it's the guy who wants to write a story made from letters, reports and scripts.
Yeah, that's me. I'm going to try to find a better balance, I'm making a rough draft first.
>>
File: Sunnyceruleanskies_zps54a0324a.jpg (82KB, 943x816px) Image search: [Google]
Sunnyceruleanskies_zps54a0324a.jpg
82KB, 943x816px
>>29504995
>stories that nobody reads and nobody remembers get removed

Speaking of removed stories, does anyone have the original, unblanked version of https://www.fimfiction.net/story/184219/4/sunny-cerulean-skies/new-blue-skies? It's not on Fimfetch or in Fimfarchive.
>>
>>29540986
Nope.
Try wayback machine.
>>
>>29541015
Doesn't save Mature stories.
>>
>>29540939
I think that while it might be heavy handed, if you want to write what's essentially the written version of a thousand yard stare, focusing on the non-material might be the way to go. Describing characters and their actions is inherently emotional on some level, because we naturally assume someone's rough mental and emotional state from any mention.

If I write "The captain was injured", you infer that he's feeling bad.
But if I just write stuff like "The wall crumbled and a cart toppled over", and reduce all the effect of the incident to material damage, that's kind of dehumanising (deponynising?). It's mechanical. And that might be the desired effect. It's at the very least worth trying.

But of course, I'll freely admit that I'm talking out of my ass here, so it may just be wrong.

>>29540976
Maybe you should try to make that divide (pre and post breakdown) kind of overstated and blatant in the first rough draft, and then read it afterwards and try to find a more tasteful balance. Play up the contrast between mechanical and emotional.
Better to start with the concept strongly represented and then file it down rather than worry about balance first and then try to enforce the concept in the editing.

But the above line about my talkative ass applies to this as well. I have no clue what I'm talking about.
>>
>>29540976
You mentioned a "server" earlier. Is the letter analog or digital? If analog, could there be crossed-out portions and the indication that it's a draft that was originally meant to be rewritten before sending? If digital, could the corruption have left the file's edit history visible? Or, if the technology is advanced enough, could it be an unedited draft produced with dictation software?
>>
>>29541051
"Twilight-blows-up-and-everyone-writes-reports-about-it-Anon" is separate from "The-world-is-shit-and-here's-the-weather-as-presented-by-a-shitty-government-server-Anon". I think.
>>
>>29541051
Oh, no. That's TSG, he's writing about a dying computer in a post-apocalyptic Equestria.

Mine's more straightforward, just a bunch of letters and reports that together show the aftermath of an accident.
>>
File: 1461720457817.png (29KB, 815x376px) Image search: [Google]
1461720457817.png
29KB, 815x376px
>>29540976
If that happened, I'd probably just scrap the paper and rewrite a shorter and more urgent telegraph style note. That's just me though, who isn't really the best guy with empathy.
>>
File: he's baaaaaaack.png (4KB, 795x36px) Image search: [Google]
he's baaaaaaack.png
4KB, 795x36px
>>
File: file.png (227KB, 904x614px) Image search: [Google]
file.png
227KB, 904x614px
>Special thanks to Emperor Hirohito
>>
File: file.png (40KB, 926x196px) Image search: [Google]
file.png
40KB, 926x196px
>>29541261
> It was a peaceful day in equestria. But the Princess's had a special task for the mane six. Celestia had some 'arrangements with an old friend of hers when she was younger. The mane six were in her castle. All of them were there and Twilight is a princess at this time. The princess said they need to know a lesson on leadership and bravery that is something that they haven't encountered. The princess's made a portal which they go into the other universe and explore it. The special thing is that the portal stops time when the mane six go through the portal so the time in Equestria stops and everything is solid. When they get back everything is back to normal.
> "I'm glad that you ponies made it here.", Celestia said to the mane six.
> "So we have to go through that princess?", Twilight said.
> "Yes and you must go for this lesson. My friend doesn't have all day, he's waiting where you ponies will arrive."
> "Okay we'll go now come every pony."
> "But first let me do this."
> The princess had a red light on her horn and aimed it at the ponies and cancelled something of them.
> "You ponies cannot use the elements of harmony or use magic in this other world due to that they might be used for power."
> "O.K. princess were leaving now." The mane six had entered the portal and then time in Equestria had stopped and everything froze.
>>
>>29541239
Nice. His weeb convention was just last weekend, so I thought there might be more of a delay before he started writing again.
>>
Am I perceiving correctly that there's no way to cancel a vote on a Fimfiction story, only to switch between upvoting and downvoting it?
>>
>>29541781
Yup. There's apparently a good reason for that, but hell if I know what it is.
>>
>>29541781
yes
>>
>>29541810
Same reason why authors can block users from commenting and censor comments.
>>
File: IT IS A GOOD PAIN.jpg (27KB, 320x266px) Image search: [Google]
IT IS A GOOD PAIN.jpg
27KB, 320x266px
>7dsj, book 4, chapter 22

Hey guys, remember how Ponk is madly in love with Sunset? Well don't worry, because this chapter will remind you!
>"By the way, you are a hot kisser."
And remind you...
>“Aww, Pinkie, but we slept together!” Sunset joked.
>“Sunny, please don’t do that,” Pinkie replied. “You don’t know how much I really want to.”
And remind you some more!
>Rarity couldn’t help herself. “Why, Twilight, dear, you should know by now that I wouldn’t stand in the way of young love.”
>“I know that, but….” The plum-haired girl paused. “Wait. Pinkie? And Sunset?”
And of course Sunset and Pinkie are rooming together while the 8M8 are on vacation at some absurdly fancy resort (courtesy of Discord, who in this fic is Fluttershy's ___dad___). What could possibly go wrong?


SUDDENLY, the avatar of bitchiness, Tequila Sunrise, shows up out of nowhere with her two cronies and tries to pick a fight with the 8M8. Why, exactly, does this millionaire teenage pop star give a single fuck about eight random nobodies? I'M GLAD YOU ASKED!

Turns out Tequila has been holding a grudge against Fluttershy, of all people, for 4 or 5 years now! You see, Tequila grew up dreaming of the day she would lose her virginity to the world-famous rock star Discord. Finally, at the age of 13, she got a backstage pass to one of his shows, but she was shocked to discover that he barely paid any attention to her! Using her mystical brain powers, she inferred that he must have a daughter, which has "ruined" him. (Instead of figuring that, you know, maybe he's just not into 13 year olds?)

Anyway, this crazy bitch absolutely despises Fluttershy. So she and her cronies say a bunch of horrible things to the 8M8, the 8M8 say a bunch of horrible things back, and in the end they decide to resolve this bitter feud by way of a singing contest.


Tune in for the thrilling conclusion, next week on 7DSJ!
>>
File: 1450413091113.jpg (193KB, 500x541px) Image search: [Google]
1450413091113.jpg
193KB, 500x541px
>>29542143
On one hand, this hurts to read as a Pinkiefag.
On the other, everything else about this is insane.
>>
File: 1487005405220.gif (4MB, 548x456px) Image search: [Google]
1487005405220.gif
4MB, 548x456px
I just completed an 82,000 word fic. Basically, a few years back some dimensional rift thing opened up and dumped a few million ponies into the western US. Lacking any other way to feed them, they had to be exploited as a source of labor, which turned into a slave system (this was written for SPG).

In this fic, Starlight Glimmer is the newest addition to a massive pony-powered farm. Through her magical prowess and ties to the farm's top ponies, Applejack, Big Mac, and the CMC, she quickly ends up with a position of power that she neither wants nor can refuse.

So yeah, read my novel.
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/361497/a-glimmer-of-hope

http://pastebin.com/TnWCRgzK
>>
>>29542173
>On one hand, this hurts to read as a Pinkiefag.
The Pinkie/Sunset shipping is so fucked. It's like Celestia/Mike from AAG. It hurts my brain, I just want it to stop.
>>
>>29542197
>Basically, a few years back some dimensional rift thing opened up and dumped a few million ponies into the western US. Lacking any other way to feed them, they had to be exploited as a source of labor, which turned into a slave system (this was written for SPG).
Huh, that sounds somewhat interes--

>the literal description: "This fic takes place in a reality where a massive dimensional rift cast a large number of ponies into the continental United States. With nowhere to put them and no way to feed them, the ponies were sold into contracts of indentured servitude for an indefinite period of time, which is also applied at birth. In essence, slavery."
>one single chapter of 84,753 words
>second person
Nope.
>>
>>29542218
Ehh, wrote it as green first and just put it on FimFic for more dank viewz

It's decently written I think, but I couldn't give less of a shit if and how many people read it. The PB already has over 4000 hits so I'm satisfied.
>>
>>29542234
just finished reading it on /spg/. It's probably one of my favorite stories from that general. Keep up the good work mr. goyim, looking forward to the dash fic.
>>
>>29542197
>>29542218
>>29542234
>>29542272
Holy fuck format and rewrite this. It could be legit good if you put a few days' work into it to make it presentable. Give it chapters, because nobody's going to read this in one go and it's a pain in the dick to go back to where you left off. Get rid of second person/present tense. It's always the worst option. Make the main character a character instead of "you".

Then people will read it.
>>
>>29542418
>Make the main character a character instead of "you".
The main character is Starlight Glimmer. But for some inexplicable reason she's referred to in the second person.
>>
File: confused hitler.gif (996KB, 500x400px) Image search: [Google]
confused hitler.gif
996KB, 500x400px
>>29542197
This, pal. >>29542418
Seriously, your story hook seems intriguing, but no-fucking-body is going to read an 84k word chapter. Even if you can't be bothered to change the 2nd person format, at least chop it up in individual chapters.
>>
>>29542418
>It could be legit good
Have we read the same vague description?

A large towns population turns up and the instant solution that everyone comes up with is 'lol quadrupedal niggers'?

PoE is one of my favorite horse related things, but that shits retarded, yo
>>
>>29542702
sorry, read 82k words as ponies for some reason.

Still a 'few million' puckered ponuts popping up is still fewer than the number of invading mexicans weve got, and we're not enslaving them either
>>
File: Screenshot_2017-02-23-00-44-19.png (395KB, 1440x2560px) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_2017-02-23-00-44-19.png
395KB, 1440x2560px
>>29542802
Are you sure? I don't have any links handy, but one reads things.
>>
>>29542143
Conclusion? I don't think that's right - Chink can't possibly end this shitshow with only one more chapter. What happened to the wizard war?!
>>
>>29542850
Gotta leave something for the surprise book 5, Anon.
>>
>>29542847
eh. a relative few senoritas being turned into whores doesnt really equate to enslaving an entire species
>>
Is voicefag doing the stream again?
>>
>>29542197
>Lacking any other way to feed them
The US exports 50 million tons of corn a year. I'm pretty sure we could handle a few million more mouths--especially when we already add 2 million more mouths a year.

>sold into contracts of indentured servitude for an indefinite period of time
>Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
Unless this is an AU where the Civil War never happened, this would result in a cataclysmic legal clusterfuck--say nothing of the massive backlash Congress would face when CNN livestreams footage of cute, sapient ponies being whipped to death.
>>
>>29542197
Can they use magic of any kind, including ground affinity and flying? If yes, that makes all the story unrealistic.

Unicorn would be really invaluable for research purposes and understanding their magic, and could majorly fuck up our understanding of physics. Even if magic doesn't exist (Which isn't the case, seeing your synopsis), you've got sentient beings, which, I hope, most of the US isn't very keen on enslaving.

Not to mention that three earth ponies can plant an apple orchard several square hectares large by themselves. Now multiply this by millions of ponies.

Even if they couldn't cultivate land, they're millions, not hundreds. You know what happens when millions are unsatisfied? Yes, now multiply that with an unicorn powerful enough to challenge an alicorn princess who could move around 22 tons of milk and a constellation bear.
>>
>>29540687
In its own way, slowing like this only served to deepen the erotic sensations, as it gave her better opportunity to luxuriate in the skilful caresses and quivering squeezes of Chrysalis's pussy.
>>
>>29544138
For a second, I thought you were referring to the low activity in the thread.
>>
>>29540915
Yeah, but this is a story, not an actual letter, so you have a certain amount of dramatic license in how you present it.

I like the idea of the letter starting in a straightforward here's-the-facts manner, and then starting to have a few false starts or emotional word choices struck out, becoming more frequent until that breakdown at the end. I think it could be a great, devastating bit for the reader.
>>
File: Chrysalis1340654747046.png (536KB, 645x611px) Image search: [Google]
Chrysalis1340654747046.png
536KB, 645x611px
>>29544143
Fimfiction Thread -- now with 81.5% more futa hatefucking of Chrysalis.
>>
>>29542850
The conclusion to the ridiculous singing contest, at least. This chapter was "August 14, AM", so "August 14, PM" should finish it up.
>>
>>29544310
Woah, woah, woah
It's no longer June?
>>
>>29544323
Yeah, man. And the story covers more than seven days, too.
>>
File: 534472_v1.gif (2MB, 350x264px) Image search: [Google]
534472_v1.gif
2MB, 350x264px
>>29544338
I don't know what to believe.
>>
>>29543615
And yet we use animals for unpaid labor all the time. You're assuming CNN will take their side.
>>
>>29541026
Also, doesn't have any saved older copies of the Fimfetch version.
>>
File: 257949.jpg (56KB, 250x400px) Image search: [Google]
257949.jpg
56KB, 250x400px
>>29504995
>>29524332
Speaking of removed stories, comments on Blink mention another one:
https://fimfetch.net/story/257949/faster-than-starlight
No chapters on Fimfetch, just a description. Nothing in Fimfarchive (including older archives) or Wayback (including for Fimfetch).
>>
>>29544864
>I'm currently planning to take this down and change it, possibly turning it into a new story with teeth and more sensemakings. It is not up to my current self-imposed standards and I think a lot of mistakes were made in the execution. I'll post updates on my blog.

>In the meantime, this story page will remain up for 24 hours so ponies have a chance to see and respond to comments.

>Published Apr 6th, 2015
Hmmm...
>>
Holy shit, this really is a new fad.
>>
>>29544864
>>29544880
http://www.fimfiction.net/user/Trick+Question#comment/1886433
> I rushed it to print, and it was a mistake. Then somepony took the idea and ran with it before I could redo it. :facehoof:

Minor correction. It wasn't actually comments on Blink that mentioned it; it was a comment on another story linked from Blink.
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/341279/blink#comment/7788846
http://www.fimfiction.net/story/273539/dying-to-get-there#comment/6165245

Found the story, though.
http://www.fimfiction.net/blog/413773/hello-fimfiction
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1h8edP_4gqZMfI7VHX8fZTQTcjLD0JiEtYWeAFpqz2l0/edit?usp=sharing
>>
>>29545169
>fan sequel of a fan sequel of a fan sequel
goddamn but I hate horsefuckers
>>
>>29545219
>thread about fan fiction of zombie seasons of a fourth-generation reboot of a series of commercials for plastic toys
Sometimes I don't understand anons.
>>
>>29545275
you dont think that reading a fanfiction of a fanfiction of a fanfiction of a fanfiction of a toy advertisement aimed at little girls is a little odd, anon?
>>
>>29545289
are you >implying something
>>
I finished another chapter of my report project. This is the letter Shining Armor writes Cadence after he sends Twilight to the hospital.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ruzxdORSA12b08ER-1JD7jiSlsLbdFW911fjpYUa_-Y/edit?usp=sharing

I'm actually managing a good writing pace with this thing.

>>29527825 Interview with Spike
>>29534388 ER report on Twilight

Now I'm moving on to the police report about the accident.
>>
>>29546109
Some thing for police reports, iirc they're more similar to forms to fill with a note section in the end for easier understanding. Might want to take that in account.
>>
>>29546307
This is the first sample I found:

http://www.wikihow.com/Sample/Police-Report

I'm going to keep looking for a form that actually looks like what you mention.

Also, I've been thinking about ripping off that Apple Bloom story and include a chapter with images/pdf files of the reports and letters for maximum pretentiousness.
>>
File: 1463347613566.png (329KB, 490x719px) Image search: [Google]
1463347613566.png
329KB, 490x719px
>>29546395
Oh, I was thinking more of an on-scene situation report.

Final report won't be in a form for sure, that looks good. Here's an actual police report.
>>
>>29546411
Cool.
I might as well do both, and include additional info in the final report.
Thanks, Anon!
>>
Is there a full name for the guard? I've seen them referred as "Royal Guard" or even "Royal Canterlot Guard", though that last one sounds odd.
>>
File: file.png (16KB, 537x99px) Image search: [Google]
file.png
16KB, 537x99px
>>29546832
It's exclusively called the Royal Guard in the show. The closest thing you get to a deviation from that is Dash calling them "the Princess's royal guards", which is the same thing.

That said, they're more or less the same thing as the E.U.P. Guard, or at least associated with them according to AKR. So you can go read the transcript from that episode where Dash is retarded, which talks a bit about E.U.P. history. The E.U.P. contains the Protective Pony Platoons, it seems.

I miss AKR, she seemed to care more about worldbuilding and "lore" than most other writers.
>>
>>29546832
I don't think they're really the entirety of the EUP, unless the latter is a symbolic military unit for parading in the capital. I wouldn't rely on some guards that do a worse job at stopping changelings than Twilight's normal everyday friends.
>>
>>29547410
Meant for >>29546983

I'd say the EUP refers to the Equestrian army in general, while the Canterlot Guard are just a symbolic parade unit like the RCMP's mounties or those guys wearing the big black hats near Buckingham palace. Yes, they're properly trained and to some extent equipped, but they're a purely decorative unit, and not made to actually see combat.
>>
>>29547531

The duders in the big black hats are drawn from the Foot Guard. They're not decorative; they're some of the hardest motherfuckers in the British Army.
>>
>>29547531
I don't really care how it works, to be perfectly honest.

The show doesn't really specify it, and as long as that's the case, all that matters is that you include it in the story in a way that's consistent and appropriate. I was just supplying Anon with what available naming information we have, and then he'll have to use that as he likes.

Generally, I feel like I've become increasingly disinterested in trying to explain or justify the fiction inherent to the series. A lot of things about Equestria doesn't make any sort of sense, and that's fine, as long as those inconsistencies are appropriately resolved in accordance to the fic's intended scope.
That isn't to say that people shouldn't do it, or that it's in any way wrong, I just don't find myself as drawn to it as I used to be.
>>
>>29547576
Do you expect them to fight off some VDV troops if they land?

Yes, they're probably drawn from the best or at least the guys who got the best uniform and drill, but they're not destined for actual frontline combat, and will probably get roflstomped by any competent attack.
>>
>>29547602
I guess. It's fine if the actual organization has no effect on plot.
>>
>>29547612

It's a rotational posting the Guards provide. Considering the Guard regiments are the oldest and most prestigious in the British Army, and saw service in both Iraq 1 and 2, yeah they're likely VDV equivalent.
>>
>>29547883
>It's a rotational posting the Guards provide

Oh, didn't know that.

Still, seeing how they faired in ACW compared to the Mane 6 without the elements, I wouldn't really trust the RG to actually fight off an invader.
>>
>>29547996
Did you misread his post? Or do you believe the Equestrian Royal Guard fought in Iraq?
>>
>>29547996

No, they're prolly closer to the Papal Swiss Guard. Pretty, and well trained enough to deal with a terrorist attack or the like, but lacking in the numbers and heavy equipment to fight off a major military attack.
>>
>>29548009

Are you discounting the service provided by horse cavalry in SOF ops in Afghanistan/Iraq?

How dare you discount our stallions in uniform, Anon.
>>
>>29548009
Real patriots remember the contributions of our Equestrian allies in the War on Terror.
Those brave stallions and mares who have given their lives to make the world a friendlier place.
Educate yourself, Anon, and show some respect for the armed forces.
>>
File: 1032445.gif (1MB, 883x694px) Image search: [Google]
1032445.gif
1MB, 883x694px
>>29547410
>>29547531
>>29547996
>>
>>29548009
>Not counting the valiant efforts of our Equestrian allies.

The fuck's wrong with you, anon?
>>
>>29548009
>Discounting the Royal Guards' contributions to the war effort, and the sacrifices so many of them made, even up to suffering repeated and vicious booping.

Why do you hate Equestria?
>>
File: guards_by_groovebird-d8510pv.jpg (39KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]
guards_by_groovebird-d8510pv.jpg
39KB, 1024x768px
>>29548031
>>29548049
>>29548079
>>29548088
I see there's an echo in here.
>>
>>29544116
It's not a terribly easy topic to create a plausible backstory for. But having millions of hungry, unskilled (in modern labor) and confused sapient beings from an entirely different species showing up all at once would be too much for the government to handle. Most would need food aid and other social support, probably enough that the country would either face extreme economic hardship or the social safety net would just fall through, letting them starve. At the time, a temporary system of privatizing labor and care would seem like a highly viable way to deal with the problem, but the idea is that over time the system stayed in place and devolved, affording ponies fewert legal protections and increasingly treating them as slaves.

If you think the USA would be too ideologically opposed, it wouldn't. For one, ponies aren't citizens or even humans, making the "human rights" concept already ambiguous. Second, assuming the labor system was a sudden and massive economic boon, they'd be likely to cast aside many remaining inhibitions in the face of its perceived success. At the point where this story starts, the system is so entrenched that only the more radically left politicians oppose it outright and any emancipation groups are small and without public support. Prejudices have also developed, which will be explored in the next fic I'm writing with a different pony and the same backstory.

As for the raw power of unicorns, many types of magic inhibitors have been developed since the early days and are readily available. Starlight's is a major plot point in this story. As for research, there is a colossal amount of it being done of course, and that is alluded to multiple times in the story. But Glim Glam has her own reasona for not wanting to stand out that dog at her and are explained relatively close to the end of the story, and otherwise only the most unusual or powerful unicorns are worth a researcher's time.
>>
>>29546395
>pretentiousness
Pretense?
>>
>>29548009
>Not fighting in the Saddle Arabian wars to preserve the Equestria backed monarchy against filthy democrat rebels
>>
>>29548015
This is really what I meant. Thank you.

Still doesn't change the fact that a student, farmer, candy maker, designer, wannabe pilot and animal caretaker managed to fend off more changelings than the entire Canterlot guards.
>>
> For one, ponies aren't citizens or even humans, making the "human rights" concept already ambiguous

You should see how avidly the left is defending illegal Mexicans and Arabs south of Canada's border. It might make sense to you, but I definitely don't think the US would be so keen on enslaving these ponies if they don't have any problem with keeping refugees.

Hell, they've already got millions of illegal immigrants without social safety. What you're describing in your first paragraph is basically the whole refugee and illegal immigrant problem which displaced millions in a single year, and we've yet to see any major government turn them all to slavery.

I won't bother you more with it. Best of luck with your story and intended audience, but I'm not going to read it.
>>
>>29548727

That could be because the Guard was heavily infiltrated, and pegged for elimination, while the Mane 6 managed to escape.

Or maybe the changelings triggered their Iraq War PTSD.
>>
>>29548684
That doesn't have enough s's.
But yeah, I'm dumb.
>>
>>29548767
Meant for >>29548627
>>
>>29548768
>That could be because the Guard was heavily infiltrated, and pegged for elimination
I want to read a fic where changelings infiltrate the guard and peg all the war vets with their chitinous cocks.
>>
>>29548768
Not all of it was infiltrated though. With Luna being free and at least some part of the Royal Guard being sane as shown by the prisoners, you would expect much more resistance in the town.

We also don't have any evidence of residents being infiltrated. Again, if six layponies can fend off what appears to be hundreds of changelings, what can a city of at least 50 000 do?
>>
>>29548794

Run around in a panic because oh God bugs are attacking?

The prisoners show that the Guard was incapacitated. If all the officers and noncoms were replaced, the foot soldiers could be knocked out no problem. It would really depend on how you wanted to use the Guard to decide if they were knocked out in a sneak attack or just bad.
>>
>>29548844
I know want a fic where the Royal Guard is shat on by all other reserve groups near Canterlot for doing worse than 6 civilians and having the top members of Equestria's army considering if they really want to keep SS in service.
>>
>>29546109
I finished the preliminary Guard report on the incident. Not that I think anyone is reading these:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1IBMizNhQYoGE_S-mhHEfy7t8zkP5USAHf9peCJ97wyI/edit?usp=sharing

Still, I appreciate your feedback and general advice, guys. It seriously means a lot. And I'm at least happy that my autistic endeavor is stirring up some discussion.

Anyway, I'll move on to the next report, either a written testimony of one of the maids who was close to the magic blast, or a shorter interview with Moondancer regarding Twilight's topic of research that led to her trying to lock up NMM on her own.

God, I wish I was this productive with my other stories...
>>
>>29548872
>Not that I think anyone is reading these

Mate, I'm reading each chapter you post.
>>
>>29548872
Not sure if "underage" is relevant, seems redundant because of the age.

Purely technical, but you could add some letters in the number cases and build some autistic system. Ex: CNT0170956M(I,LTR) for:

Canterlot incident happened in year (2)017, 0956th magic related (M), injuries (I) were sustained, life threatening ones (LTR).

Also, from habit air cadets, so don't put too much trust into this, I'd write abbreviated grades (Ex: Sgt for sergeant, F.Sgt for Flight Sergeant, etc.) in forms instead of full grades.

Also the military and aviation uses 24h time, not 12-12, for ease of understanding. I heard that Americans don't really use 24h often, so maybe that's why you wrote it down like that. I'd be something like 21:36 or just 2136 hour
>>
>>29548963
Aw, thank you.

>>29548965
Ah, stupid me, I meant to say unemployed, since I don't think being Twilight's assistant counts as an official job title. However, I kind of wonder if that is an aceptable term to use. If not, do I just say Spike's name and age?

>I'd write abbreviated grades
Huh, I was going to say the sample I'm blatantly lifting the format from used the full title, but apparently it uses both.

>Reporting Officer: Deputy Jones
>Prepared By: CPL Stevens

I'm assuming the latter one stands for 'corporal'. So I'll change to the abbreviation. What's the abbreviated grade for 'Private'? 'PVT'?

>Also the military and aviation uses 24h time
Ah, right. I'm using a police report for reference, but the Royal Guard works as a military group. Thanks for the catch.
>>
>>29549031
Yup. Abbreviations are really intuitive.
>>
File: ponywords on the go.png (69KB, 864x462px) Image search: [Google]
ponywords on the go.png
69KB, 864x462px
Shhh
Don't tell knighty I showed you this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJHq03vxnAc
>>
>>29549075
Don't worry, Knighty doesn't come here anymore.
>>
>>29548965
>year (2)017

Not 1000?
>>
>>29549075
Does Youtube not let uploaders see referrer data?
>>
>>29549529
Do you guys really take Luna's Banishment as the starting point for the calendar?
>>
Would it be TOO autistic to have a jokey oneshot fic about there being like a billion different sets of Elements of different things? Like, does it go from "heh" to "what are you doing" at this point? To give you an idea of what I'm doing, the first I came up with was The Elements of Health(Dentistry, Cleanliness, Medicine, Exercise, Hydration, and Washing Your Hands (yes, hands, because people need to wash their fucking hands before they cook and if I see one more asshole not wash his hands before cooking a burger I'm gonna eat I will blow a gasket)).
>>
>>29549668
Strictly speaking, it's apparently based on the Summer Sun Celebration, which apparently was started some time not long after Luna's banishment. I don't know why; I just watch the show.
>>
Did anyone here like My Little Alicorn/Bringing up Blueblood?
>>
>>29549679
Little bit. It's probably also been done. (I want to say maybe somewhere in the first 130 chapters of MLP Time Loops, but I'm not sure.)
>>
>>29549785
Loops had an entire snippet with the characters having a drinking contest over who had the stupidest Variant Element. They also have a few Variant Loops centered around bringing different Elements together, and they actually play the Element of Conversion thing somewhat seriously, using it to explore Sunset's conflicted psyche.
>>
>>29549774

Yes.
>>
Sorry there wasn't a stream today.

I was focusing on some of the other stories I needed to do.

There'll be one tomorrow though, at the same time of 11:30

Here's a strawpoll

https://strawpoll.com/cddsdz7
>>
>>29550185
>anything by Pen Stroke
>>
>>29550043
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/98568/94/mlp-time-loops/mlp-loops-90 - 90.9, I guess (or at least it's part of it).

Also: wow, someone else who actually read all that.
>>
>>29550197
It's in the first page of my Read Later, so it goes in the poll.
>>
>>29550185
>11:30
What timezone? I may not make it.
>>
>>29550257
Pacific

He's in CA after all.
>>
>>29544511
>we use animals
Yeah, non-talking, non-sapient, non-giant brained in proportion to their bodies animals.

>>29545169
Is anyone else going to jump on the Blink bandwagon and write a sequel? There's still openings for "Anon accidentally teleports into the fishbowl of death," "a comedic deconstruction," and "something involving sex."

>>29546832
They've only ever just been called the Royal Guard. Most headcanon them as being Celestia's Praetorian guard, while Luna gets the batponies.

>>29548627
>ponies aren't citizens or even humans
Neither was Hobby Lobby, yet SCOTUS still ruled in its favor. I'm 100% positive that, if presented a habeas corpus petition from a sapient creature, SCOTUS would have no issues granting it.

And if this is some bizzarro world where they didn't, you'd see a Dread Scott reaction. Probably enough to prompt an immediate constitutional amendment since there'd be no real opposition.

Seriously, who would want to back such a thing? Forced labor means you fuck up the economy and jobs (what company is going to want to pay someone when they can just get a literal slave?), have a huge PR crisis (just imagine the constant news stories), and *still* have all the food and humanitarian issues, only now you add slavery into it. Slavery's on par with pedophilia in the modern world.

The only way I can see this idea working is if everyone was oblivious--ten million dumb horses just popped into existence. How do we make sure they don't eat all the grass in the midwest? The story is then about the ponies attempting contact before we start getting out the saddles and shotguns.

As it is, it feels like you had the end premise (Starlight in slavery) and then had to throw out a ton of idiot balls and stupidity in order to cram the premise into the setting, without really thinking about the effects or logical course that things would take.
>>
>Waning Moon has been on hiatus for 3 years
Fuck
>>
>>29549774
I've only read the first one and didn't find it particularly pleasant. Maybe that's my taste and aversion to interpersonal conflict more than anything else, but if Celestia was as insensitive and incompetent as she's made out to be, she couldn't have led Equestria through a millennium of peace (which is actually lampshades, but still). Plus it feels like the Luna/Celestia dynamic is spinning its wheels for most of the story when they blow up at each other three quarters of the way through the story. And how about when Twilight is suspicious about Pinkie, and to a mare her friends blow her off on account of the Pinkie Sense incident?

But yeah, taste.
>>
>>29550540
>Dread Scott
>>
>>29549529
Just as example

>Using Luna's banishment year as calendar reference

Hey, I'm not the only one!
>>
>>29548794
How much of the town did we see, though? Could be the Royal quarter was overrun, but the lower city had barricades up and the guard was busy organizing a counterattack...
>>
>>29549785
>>29550043
Fuck.
>>
File: thumb.gif (3MB, 250x200px) Image search: [Google]
thumb.gif
3MB, 250x200px
>>29550540
>Yeah, non-talking, non-sapient, non-giant brained in proportion to their bodies animals.
None of those criteria appear in the amendment you cited.

>Forced labor means you fuck up the economy and jobs (what company is going to want to pay someone when they can just get a literal slave?)
Mass immigration and use of immigrants for forced labor fucks up the economy and jobs, yet it still happens.

>have a huge PR crisis (just imagine the constant news stories)
Again assuming the media will take a stand against the corporations who fund and/or own them.

>and *still* have all the food and humanitarian issues
But now you're monetizing the ponies to help offset them.

People generally find it credible that the Holocaust happened; and that was done to people's neighbors and family, not a bunch of creepy, unnaturally-faux-"cute"-looking aliens who popped out of nowhere.

I'll grant that I haven't read the story, and that I'm discussing scenarios somewhat different than what apparently happens in it. And that "a few million" does seem a bit much, and probably not necessary for the story.

>>29551169
>if Celestia was as insensitive and incompetent as she's made out to be, she couldn't have led Equestria through a millennium of peace
One could say the same about canon or (in particular) IDW Celestia. But I'll grant that I haven't read the story and that she may be even worse there.
>>
2 hours and 30 minutes

I didn't my mic could pick up sounds of swallowing liquid.
>>
>>29551839
But we sure did.
Shouldn't have sucked someone off in the middle of a recording.
>>
>>29551801
>Again assuming the media will take a stand against the corporations who fund and/or own them.

They'll stand against and for anyone if it's going to grant them the views.
>>
>>29551871
I'll refrain from pursuing the subject further.
>>
>>29551953
Good choice
>>
>>29551169
>a millennium of peace

>>29551801 again. Strictly speaking, we don't know it was a millennium of peace. The comics place wars with changelings and shadow creatures during that time, and the griffon war may also have happened then. But your point still stands.
>>
I was going to question people actually discussing the kunta glimmer story until I realized we we're in the excessive shitposting part of the thread.

carry on
>>
10 minutes

Get your hats ready.

twitch tv voiceguystreamswhatever
>>
>>29552364

You could sell it, if you added a "humans are assholes" religious or ethnonationalist bent (both the Nazis and Soviets, for instance, used forced labor), but it still stretches disbelief. Not even the most nightmarish SJW vision of Trump’s America could get away with enslaving sentients.
>>
>>29552531
Done

No one showed up. I feel like the weird kid who hosts a birthday party and no one comes to it.

I should stick to Thursday.
>>
>>29552716
There was that guy who left when you called his name
You're not the weirdest kid out there
>>
Writing habits you can't stand in a story?
It irks me when a writer writes characters in what I can only describe as 'stunted teenager' speak.
Like, a character will be speaking, more or less, how you'd expect them to, but then the author will have them break out into some over-reactive 'OMG XD' level of shouting or speaking (like they're Let's Playing video games) in an attempt at humor.
>>
>>29554308
Some writers think of a unique way of saying a common phrase (like going to sleep, waking up, etc.) and then overuse it.
Rarity saying darling almost all the time when addressing someone.
>>
>>29554374
I have darlinged, and I am filled with regrets.

Anyway, how worried should I be about my invaluable Fimfic password after the Cloudflare breach?

Cloud Flare should be the name of a pegasus stallion in a clop fic. Does he fuck ponies, or is he some kind of cloudophile who can only get it up for cirrus?
>>
>>29554308
Dry exposition.
When the writer hits the brakes on the flow of the story just so he can insert some vapid exposition that isn't even interestingly told.
>>
>>29554615
He gives "cumulus clouds" a whole new meaning.
>>
So, what's the pony equivalent of anthropology?
Equinology?
>>
>>29554374
I always write her saying it with a different degree of irony each time, like it's some bizarre sitcom in-joke and you can't hear the canned laughter.
>>
>>29555754
>"Hello, Twilight."
>"Hi, Rarity! How are you?"
>"I'm quite alright, DARLING."
>Cue thirty seconds of laughter and clapping.
>>
>>29555762
>"Well, I've got something I need you to do, Rarity."
>"Why, what could you possibly need of me?"
>"It is of a... confidential nature."
>Rarity puts a hoof on Twilight's shoulder, looking into her eyes with tantamount trust, "Darling."
>Audience collectively goes "OOOOOOOH"
>>
>>29555741
>mixing latin and greek roots
reee

It's "hippology", don't be a pleb
>>
>>29555780
I frequently find myself forced into using both ancient greek and latin for names when coming up for fictional names in more original writing
>>
>>29554374
>Rarity saying darling almost all the time when addressing someone.

Saw a YouTube video of that once: a compilation of every time Rarity said "Darling" in the series, ending in an overdubbed Samuel L Jackson saying "say darling one more time".
>>
>>29555796
How many were there?

Each time I read Rarity saying "Darling," I picture the previous gens. She really did it say every single fucking sentence back then, and it sounded ridiculous each and every time.
>>
>>29550043
>Loops had an entire snippet with the characters having a drinking contest over who had the stupidest Variant Element. They also have a few Variant Loops centered around bringing different Elements together,

My favorites are Applebloom's Element of Sufficiently Advanced Technology, and Gilda's Element of Brutal Honesty.

But by far my favorite loops of all time are Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo's ascensions in loops 43.1 and 43.2. https://www.fimfiction.net/story/98568/45/mlp-time-loops/loops-43
>>
>>29555801

I don't remember; a few dozen, I think. It was either in one of the Pony Shenanigans, or in a one-off video similar to Ponies the Anthology but whose name I can't remember (it had a lot of video game references).
>>
>>29555801
I've counted them. I've counted all the darlings.
>>28644551
>>28240085 for a full list up till S5
>>
>>29554308
Sounds similar to how I hate overly defensive or "sassy" narrators. The description of https://www.fimfiction.net/story/322183/rebellious-alicorn-teenager-shenanigans is one example. Rage Reviews reviewed a short story whose closing line was something like "And that's my story. I mean, what were you expecting?". The Pony POV series also has a bad case of this from what little I've read.

Meaningless descriptions and inconsequential actions apparently serving only as padding.

Eye dialect and trying to write out accents. The Pony POV Series has a bad case of this too; especially with the very first chapter (at least by publication) being from Applejack's perspective.

Dialogue tags being capitalized, presumably because of autocorrect that the author couldn't be bothered to fix; e.g. ""Darling?" Asked Rarity.".

Fandom memes, like "20% cooler", outside of trollfics. (Yes, I hate it when canon does this too.)

Gratuitous fanon, like the mane six being called "the Elements of Harmony" (or "the mane six" for that matter).

While it's fine to have a scene gradually come into focus rather than have everything spelled out from the start, excessive and gratuitous coyness irks me sometimes. I remember the opening of https://www.fimfiction.net/story/210737/lazy-river suffering from that, though looking again it's not as bad as I remember. (Estee also abuses italics for emphasis a lot.)

Identifying dialogue by exaggerating stereotypical character traits instead of just saying who's talking.
>>
>>29555801
...There was a precious gen Rarity?
>>
>>29555801
>>29555962
*previous; sorry.
>>
And if you don't have an extension or can't operate the archives, have it reposted.
Per season - 5 in S1, 6 S2, only one in S3, 11 in S4, 20 in S5 and 25 in S6
S1 - 5 instances. S1E1, Ticket Master, Boast Busters, Dragonshy, Party of One
S2 - 6 instances - Sweet and Elite, Hearth's Warming Eve (2 times, once as Platinum), the episode with Iron Will (twice again), and the one where Spike has an identity crisis
S3 - Once, in MMC
S4 - 11 instances - Princess Sparkle opener, three times, Power Ponies, Bats!, Breezies, Maud Pie (twice), the Sweetie throws another bitchfit and Luna has to calm her down before she ruins Rarity's career one, Trade Ya, Inspiration Manifestation
S5 - 20 instances - Cutie Map, the one after that (twice), Rarity Investigates, Made in Manehattan eight fucking times, Pinkie has a secret episode, Halloween episode (3 times), the inside jokes with Discord one (4 times)

and also 11 times in all the >eqg
>>
>>29554308
>>29555952
Some more that come to mind:
Words like "squee", "glomp", "adorkable" and anything else whose definition comes from The TV Tropes Wiki. ("Plot" and "ponut" are borderline; I can tolerate them in clop, at least.)

Narration directly telling the reader that something is "cute", rather than trying to actually describe its cuteness.

Ponies describing other, adult ponies as "cute" (or "adorable", et cetera).

(Also: checking >>29555555.)
>>
>>29555966
To be fair, P.P.O.V. probably inflates season 6's count a bit. But it still looks like a pretty clear trend, even if I can personally tolerate it.
>>
>>29556016
Applejack's impressions of Rarity are not counted in, that would up S6 by four more to 29. This is all Rarity herself, though AJ wasn't that far from the truth.
>>
>>29555962
Just watch Minty's Christmas and you'll see.
It might have been Rainbow Dash or something, I can't quite remember. But there were a lot of darlings.
>>
>>29556074
Rainbow "dresses in style" Dash was the darling one, unless my mind is playing tricks on me.
>>
File: bc_rarity.jpg (101KB, 600x460px) Image search: [Google]
bc_rarity.jpg
101KB, 600x460px
>>29555962
>>
>>29556076
Yeah, she is, but she's basically the same.
Just major reverse raridash bait, really.
>>
kinda interesting what changed and what didnt
>>
File: Just one of those days.png (93KB, 386x515px) Image search: [Google]
Just one of those days.png
93KB, 386x515px
>>29555962
Yeah, they called her Rainbow Dash.
>pic
Captcha, please...
>>
>>29556102
Applejack is exactly the fucking same.
>>
>>29556213

>Applejack lives on a farm with three family members
>has three apples for a cutie mark
>had five apples in 1983
>in 1983, her parents weren't dead

DEEPEST LORE
>>
>>29556285
>she lost her parents and two apples from her ass
they really are apples
>>
>>29556339
>>29556285

The real question is, Will her cutie mark go back up to five apples if her parents actually do come back in S7?
>>
>>29556387
No.
>>
>>29556434
You just killed the thread, you horrible person. Now you get to make a new one
>>
>>29556454
I refuse, for I am busy drawing and not writing.
And besides, I have made this one already.
>>
>>29556468
Yeah and you fucked this one up badly enough.
Ok then whos got next?
>>
>>29556478
I'll do it. Should be up by page 5 or so.
>>
>>29549679
>>29549785
>>29550043
I also remember seeing a joke about "the Elements of a Good Cheer"; though I don't recall where.
>>
Here comes the bread
>>29556586
Thread posts: 506
Thread images: 85


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.