This seems about right. McCarthy was always the best editor and

Meghan did nothing wrong.

>>29418389
>Glimmer was Meghan's idea
>"Fucking Haber and Glimmer!!"
Also, Larson was the best story editor.

>>29418389
Women always do it best.

File: 1485963168459.jpg (275KB, 793x800px) Image search: [Google]

275KB, 793x800px

>>29418407
Meghan and Larson made Glimmer a perfect and great villain.

Haber turned her into Shimmer 2.0 and made anyone incompetent and weak to force her into the spotlight.

File: 1459555538496.png (49KB, 283x264px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 283x264px

>McCarthy
>the woman who caused the downturn in writing quality
>best script editor
I don't get it

>>29418411
This.

>>29418411
Oh yeah absolutely, but I find it funny that Josh "I didn't even know what to do with Glimmer" Haber is being blamed for her being shit when it was Meghan's idea to reform her in the first place and if she didn't get promoted before season 6, Glimmer might've been in the show even more.

>>29418412
She didn't work on S6. She made like 50% of S5 and mostly worked on MLP Movie after Tirek battle season. She will show her true talent in that movie and if she ever return to story editing S7.

>>29418422
She didn't just leave because of the movie, she's got a higher position in Hasbro now so she'll probably never come back to MLP full time.

File: 1485576353819.jpg (108KB, 900x680px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 900x680px

>>29418419
Haber was the story editor for S6 and he was credited for BOTH STORY (IDEA OF THE PREMISE) and teleplay of "Cutie- remark". If Meghan was responsible for her reformation she would be credited too. The only thing she did was signing approval when she was already busy doing the movie and her only fault was not finding time to properly focus on Season 5.

File: rdshock.gif (2MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 480x270px

>>29418427
>she'll probably never come back to MLP full time

>>29418411
Doesn't help the fact that stupid SJW retards like Ted Anderson thought that it was a good writing and tried to incorporate Starlight as the focus in the comics, too. Making anyone even more stupid to the point of Celestia considering that mind controlling entire Equestria is some sort of a good thing.

>>29418427
Yeah, she's now as much an MLP writer as Hazanuki and Littlest Pet Shop related people. She need to oversee all of this shit.

I think Mike VOgel is now unofficial story developer for the FiM series along with whoever take the editor seat in S7.

>>29418444
Vogel is not working for S7, he's focus on the movie with his girlfriend McCarthy.

>>29418478
Vogel is a homosexual and he work on both S7 and the movie. He will just not write any episodes but still approve the scripts.

>>29418494
He is NOT a story editor for S7! And Vogel and McCarthy are going to hell!

File: 2017-01-29 15_19_00-mktoon on Twitter_ _@StevenGtheBro won't Fluttershy get upset_ ;-P_.jpg (99KB, 629x707px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 629x707px

>>29418478
Pretty sure he will at least be credited as story premise giver for Fluttercord episode.

>>29418507
Fluttercord is NOT canon! Discord will be a bad guy again and be in love with Queen Chrysalis in S7!

File: not accurate.jpg (149KB, 756x651px) Image search: [Google]

149KB, 756x651px

>>29418389
Daily reminder that less than 1/10th of EqD's visitoers bother to vote, and it's always the most autistic ones.

"Voice of the Fandom" my black ass.

File: Aryanne DOUBLE NIGGER.png (2MB, 1000x1456px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1000x1456px

>>29418590

are you a nigger

File: 1484951406466.jpg (52KB, 499x616px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 499x616px

>>29418590
>nigger being a nigger and going full damage control
pls go

>>29418411
>Shimmer 2.0
Sunset LEARNED from HER mistakes
Glimmer has yet to do that

>>29419589
not canon

>>29419589
>learned
more like got lobotomized

Rob Renzetti is still my favorite. He worked on the best seasons of the show, and every other show he's worked on has generally been very good.

>>29418590

You voted Hillary, didn't you?

>>29418389
>Meghan with the two weakest seasons as best editor
>Larson who even admitted that he did fuck all as a story editor because most of it was done as second
>Renzetti who worked on the best seasons, who even Larson admires, as third
I know the EqD babbies are fucking stupid but this rustles my jimjams

>>29422554
Do people visiting EqD even knew Rob Renzetti was the story editor for first two seasons?

>>29422554
Season 4 was the best though
Seasons 1-2 were pure trash

>>29422226
Renzetti did shit. Basedo n quality of S1 and S2 all writers basically did what they wanted with no story editing in place. S1 and S2 was only good because Larson. Amy Rogers and McCarthy were most productive in those seasons. Rob had not even write a single episode.

File: tumblr_ocl41rW0hw1s4andvo1_500.gif (58KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 500x281px

>>29422554
Season 1 and 2 were random. It all depneded on writers. Polsky and Merriweather were trash while Larson and Meghan were great. Rob Renzetti did absolutely nothing to create any sort of story arc or consistency. It make it look like you're just a nostalgic faustfag.

>>29423274
>faustfag
RIP thread

File: .png (65KB, 794x405px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 794x405px

>>29423274
The only season with a story arc was season 4 with the keys, really. And that was just connecting a couple random episodes together with a talisman at the end, they were standard "pony X learns a lesson Y" episodes just like any other.
S1 and S2 actually worked differently thanks to Rob and Lauren. Only starting from S3 were writers writing their own shit, and if you notice, suddenly Meghan's episodes take a nosedive. Sombra two-parter, Power Ponies, Three's a Crowd, Flutter Brutter, fucking 28 Pranks Later.
I also don't see how you can say S1 and S2 were random because the quality of episodes depended on the writers, or whatever your argument is there. Because now you instead get a bunch of new writers so the quality is all over the place, and inconsistent quality even in episodes from one writer like Levinger, Sonneborn or Confalone.

>>29423264
S1 and S2 were actually more strict on the writers. They were told what to write, they couldn't just write their own ideas (or not always, at least).

>>29424204
>S1 and S2 were actually more strict on the writers. They were told what to write, they couldn't just write their own ideas (or not always, at least).
And that's why S01 and 02 were the most constant regarding the setting and lore, Anon.

Once faust and Renzetti were gone Equestria quickly lost it's "Pony world from the past" charm and became more and more like a cheap copy of human world, using modern elements like phones, modern buildings, cars, pony cops, electronic music players, modern music, etc.

>>29422349
>on 4chan
>not acting like a tumblrina or redditard
>>>voted for Shillary
one of these things doesn't fit with the overall picture

File: 1483390764216.png (61KB, 261x212px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 261x212px

>>29425251
You mean the fucking arcade video games becoming canon in Season 2 episode?
Fucking faustfags stop tryiing to make Rob and Faust some sort of gods. McCarthy and Larson were carrying entire show all by themselves while Faust was trying to insert autistic shit like adoption episodes.

http://www.strawpoll.me/12291268
http://www.strawpoll.me/12291268
http://www.strawpoll.me/12291268

http://www.strawpoll.me/12291298
http://www.strawpoll.me/12291298
http://www.strawpoll.me/12291298

>>29425322
You mean how faust kept complaing about no matter how hard she tried to oppose to Hasbro pushing that crap she couldn't avoid them all?

Like for example, that fucking train from S01 and the light switches, which she fucking loathed but the following staff welcomed them with open arms.

>>29418389
How long until the current version of Equestria is dumped for the next generation so we can rewrite the world of pony to be better and make sense?

>>29418410
Shut up fucking femipig

bump for the best story editor