Do you suppose Twilight attempts to replicate the various machines

>>29018922
no because its not canon

>>29018926
Beat me to it

File: 8127757622bab610018328c5efd66578.png (35KB, 527x208px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 527x208px

>>29018926
>>29018927
Actually it's canon but it doesn't impact the events of the show. The EQG movies are essentially one long series of Big-Lipped Alligator Moments.

File: ayy lmao.jpg (49KB, 451x600px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 451x600px

>>29018945
>MFW he believes those lies

File: 2352362362362374.png (189KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

189KB, 1024x1024px

>>29018922
>Twilight eats bacon as a hooman

>Develops carnivorous urges as a pony

UH OH

>>29018975
>doesnt know horses are omnivores

File: 533843__safe_screencap_animated_pegasus_hub logo_flash sentry_hubble_crystal pony_the hub_door.gif (1MB, 432x242px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 432x242px

>>29018966
If it's all a lie then how do explain pony Flash Sentry appearing in Three's A Crowd and elsewhere when his debut was in EQG1?

>>29018922
My headcanon is that a human scientist ending up in Equestria in the past is what led to pones having inconsistent technology. That or Discord just brought a bunch of random stuff from other dimensions during his regin.

>>29018980
http://horses.about.com/od/feedingyourhorse/a/What-Not-To-Feed-A-Horse.htm

>Meat

>DeadlyEquines, The Shocking True Story of Meat-Eating & Murderous Horsesby CuChullaine O'Reilly, the Founder of the Long Riders' Guild explores the fact that horses can and do eat meat (and can appear to behave in quite a violent manner to get it). However, that they can and do eat meat does not mean that they should. A horse may be trained to eat meat, or it may be driven to it by need. This doesn’t mean that a regular diet of meat in the long-term is a good thing. Your horse may like an occasional bite of yourhamburgeror tuna sandwich and can eat it without harm. However, since we don’t know the long-term effects on most horses, a diet high in meat would be inadvisable (along with expensive). Horses have the teeth anddigestive systemof a highly specialized herbivore. Few of us are going to take our horses on Antarctic expeditions and our horses will likely be healthiest eating the diet their digestive system evolved to digest.

File: EQG.png (767KB, 1162x782px) Image search: [Google]

767KB, 1162x782px

>>29018989
That scene only reinforces it not being canon, since no one there even looks at him at any time

But pic related, end of discussion

>>29019013
>we don't know the effects
>don't do it
kek.

File: Your Tears.gif (298KB, 308x373px) Image search: [Google]

298KB, 308x373px

>>29019028
flash sentry appeared the first time in the movie, then again subsequent times in the show after. they even used the same VA.
also trixie's love for peanut butter crackers came from the movie.

deny harder.

>>29019028
They are probably keeping it a secret from the general population at the suggestion of Princess Celestia in much the same way the government tries to keep the existence of aliens a secret.

>>29019043
That doesn't prove it is canon.

>>29019049
Friendship Games had gaping wide holes opening up into Equestria.

>>29019049
>grasping at straws this hard
There's nothing wrong with your waifu not being canon, just get over it

>>29019056
deny.
harder.

>>29019064
Oh i think EQG is canon.

>>29019028
i can sense eqgfags squirming whenever they see this

>>29019088
Twilight has a bad memory.

>>29019088
>show up at dusk
>go straight inside the castle
>spend entire time there in the alternate world
>leave

>>29018926
damn that's gotta be the fastest thread derailment i've ever seen

>>29019116
Seems like this how all EqG related threads end up.

>>29019063
>There's nothing wrong with your waifu not being canon, just get over it
This. EqG is written in a way that's it's only canon if you want it to. Same with the books. Like it or hate it on its own merits.

But we can all agree that that there isn't even a discussion with the comics.

File: 1472291218891.jpg (26KB, 500x333px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 500x333px

Why do EqGfags even care if their shit is canon or not? It has zero impact on the show and never will.

>>29019141
>EqGfags, FiMfags and Bookfags all standing in a circle arguing about show lore and whats canon
>Comicfag speaks up
>Group collectively laughs them away

>>29019056
Which happened after the events of that episode since the events of Friendship Games coincides with the events of the Cutie Remark.

File: this is the story of magical ember the tricks that she does are ever so clever.png (309KB, 994x820px) Image search: [Google]

309KB, 994x820px

>>29019146
the better question is why do anti-EqGfags care if it has no impact on the show?

>>29019161
I liked the first two, and I really wish I could like the rest. There is SOME potential in the concept that I realize will never be utilised.

File: 1453377018247.png (787KB, 654x539px) Image search: [Google]

787KB, 654x539px

>>29019152
>Comicfags
I think that these are the Bigfoot of the fandom; people will insist they exist, but evidence is always given through third hand accounts and blatant trolling.

>>29019161
I've seen several decent reasons put up here, but the main argument seems to be that the series is objectively bad. Now, that's not exactly unique among FiM's spinoffs - just look at the comics - but making things canon gives them a certain weight, even if they have no influence on the main series.

Thanks for the image, I really need more 'consider the followings'.

>>29019161
It's a highschool musical thing with characters that are not even ponies, think about it for a second.
I enjoy the movies for what they are, based on the show but separate, with the characters we love in scenarios that are only possible with them being teenage human girls

>>29019188
Mega Man did the same thing with the Battle Network series and everyone loves that.

>>29019183
>I think that these are the Bigfoot of the fandom
They used to be real at the very brief period where the comics were good at the beginning. Now the most praise I ever see people give the comics is that they're an okay passtime while you wait for actual episode. The only "fans" of the comics now seem to be idw themselves.

>>29019203
>Everyone loves Battle Network
Say that on /v/ and see what happens. The only one that people can agree is good is 3.

>>29019203
Battle network was canon with the main series?

>>29019211
thats not fair. /v/ hates everything.

>>29019217
This, I've never seen a bigger group of contrarians.

>>29019214
Oh yeah it isn't, but it did reimagine the characters to push a school setting.

>>29019217
Really? From what I've seen, /v/ is willing to stomach dogshit if they think it aligns with their interests in the smallest way.

>>29019217
>/v/ hates everything.
including themselves

>>29019183
But thanks to EQG now we know that ponies can get along with humans just fine and wouldn't look down on us or find us disgusting at all, unlike some fanfic writers I know of.

*COUGH*Chatoyance!*COUGH*

>>29019183
I guess that's a consolation prize.

>>29018989
I'm pretty sure Flash Sentry appearing was an animator cameo thing, and it wasn't on the script at all.

>>29019286
next you're going to say the voiced lines were just an animator cameo thing too.

File: 912124__safe_screencap_animated_spike_happy_g1_laughing_moondancer_firefly_medley.gif (1MB, 290x220px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 290x220px

>Long ago, hooves and no hooves used to live together in harmony....

>>29019312
That all changed when the fire nation attacked.

>>29019309
and the voices lines were-
!
he... he stole my favorite trick!

File: 1469430385566.png (806KB, 1440x900px) Image search: [Google]

806KB, 1440x900px

>>29019286
He had a spoken line voiced by his VA
Completely canon
Flash = Canon
Flash = EG
EG = canon

>>29019331
How is that evidence?

>>29019309
his appearance in twilight's kingdom was a hasbro mandated thing, which is why he's never shown up since

>>29019331
That argument only makes people who defend EQG being canon look like idiots, please never stop using it

File: (You).gif (415KB, 480x238px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 480x238px

>>29019331
>Rarity = Canon
>Rarity is in EqG
>EqG = Canon
What a horrid argument.

Is Sunset the biggest reason people even like EQG?

>>29019350
they dropped him from the show because they didn't want people making the "flash is canon, equestria girls might be canon too" association. hasbro and the staff have been adamant in keeping the two franchises separate ever since

>>29019360
Her waifufags are the only reason we have these canon/not canon arguments

>>29019360
Pretty much.

>>29019360
No

>>29019358
Rarity's appearance on the show predates EQG. Flash's appearance doesn't. He has never appeared in any episode that took place before the events of EQG.

>>29019360
Her and the Dazzlings seem to be. There's some prime waifu-bait in the series.

The highschool setting is also ridiculously popular, and has been forever.,

>>29019350
>was a hasbro mandated thing
You could say that about a lot of things in the show

>CARS
>Cadence being an alicorn
>Flurry Heart
>slice of life

Also
>hasn't shown up since
Again you can say that about a lot of characters, no appearing doesn't suddenly make a character canon. Fuck, the opposite happened with Maud as she was retconed into being a part of the pie family and being in Pinkie's first party despite no hint of her existence in the original flashback we got.

>>29019360
Yes

>>29019377
Are you actually retarded?

>>29019358
when the show takes references that are exclusive to the movie and uses them in the show, theyre using movie lore in the show, and thus it is canon.

But Sunset, while being great, only seems like such a well made character because she is the only decently developed character EQG has

>>29019371
As a Shimmerfag, I can confirm this is true. Most of these start because someone says shes not canon even though she is and it turns into this.
Ive never seen it happen from someone calling Scitwi not canon

>>29019437
Would you bother watching EQG if she was added into FIM?

>>29019437
SciTwi's based on a canon character though. Besides, SciTwiFags got cucked super hard in the latest movie.

File: 1481065659618.png (1MB, 2000x1250px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2000x1250px

>>29019439
Tbqh, probably not.
>>29019444
That is the second shittiest argument I have ever heard in any canon fights I've ever fought in and I'm a hardened veteran in these. Please rethink every life decision up to this point.

>>29019439
Sunset is only thing keeping EqG alive. That and nude edit martial.

>>29019496
Why do you think EQD defends it?

File: 555.jpg (16KB, 600x375px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 600x375px

>>29019479
>Argument
It was a statement. There is no argument.

>>29019502
I never actually used EqD honestly. Everything I know about it comes from here.

File: shoo-pirate-carribean-johnny-depp.gif (802KB, 500x600px) Image search: [Google]

802KB, 500x600px

>>29019502
Because the director cares about it and has a chance to be something decent.
>>29019515
>Pic related

>>29019524
That's like only knowing about America by browsing /pol/

>>29019528
Hasbro doesn't care about EQG enough to make it more than a blatant cash grab, sure FIM is designed to sell toys, but it has substance beyond that.

>>29019528
But EQG hasn't explored any of its potential since it's conception.

>>29019528
Ruddel deserves better than EQG.

>>29019554
more like they can't in the span of time the writing team has to work with.

>>29019437
That's because scitwi fags don't have an inferiority complex. Sunshit faggots think the show owes sunshit something and that glim glam store sunshit "rightful place"

>>29019574
That's bullshit and you know it.

>>29019286
Jim Miller confirmed it was on purpose and done by request so everyone should stop hating Meghan.

>>29019496
Kek bullshit
Sunset is pretty much secondary character to scitwi and she is also not prominent in advertisement. Hell she wasn't part of the EqG mini first wave. Sunset could be dropped from mlp and EqG could still be doing fine.

>>29019574
EQG fags and their fucking excuses.

>>29019598
Then it has to be SciTwi, the humane 5 have nearly no character.

>>29019437
because scitwi has no waifufags and if she did, they would probably be into NTR

>>29019574
I can't believe EQG fags actually believe this.

>>29019574
You are an idiot.

>>29019574
They have more than enough time.

>>29019439
To be fair with all the spotlight Sunset hogs maybe they could've spent it on the m5. They were LITERALLY just mana batteries in FG. I'd rather see them develop into independent characters from their pony counterparts.

>>29019634
Most of them come off as more self-absorbed than their Equestrian counterparts.

>>29019646
especially Rarity

couldn't stand her in LoE

>>29018975
I did see a gif of a horse eating a baby chick here recently.

>>29018945
>it's canon but it doesn't impact the events of the show

Which is to say it's like the comics, which is to say it's for all intents and purposes not canon and will never be canon because its lack of impact makes it completely irrelevant to show discussion.

I thought it became uncanon in show with Equestria Games when Twilight denied going to the Crystal Empire when the first EqG took place.

Anyway people here only like it because Sunset and EqG is just slowly going to be another Twilight delivery vehicle with Sunset bland as fuck. Not that it matters to the dedicated fan fic writers and waifufags.

>>29019125
It's what they deserve.

>>29019646
I don't know how anyone can like them.

it'd be funny to watch.

File: 1451444501832.jpg (131KB, 1185x768px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 1185x768px

>>29018922
>open the thread expecting funny stuff like Twilight replicating Dildos or computers or some shit
>it's another is EQG canon shitfest

File: 394594359345.gif (2MB, 242x442px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 242x442px

>>29019312
>King Anon and his harem.gif

File: bait topkek.jpg (49KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 625x626px

>>29022600
Its the new way to bait people who like EqG.
And its pretty effective, I wonder how long it will last.

>>29018922
yes

>>29018922
>>29022600

>"I just don't understand why it won't work!"
>Twilight stares dejectedly at a tablet
>"It worked there, but less than a day after I brought it through the portal, it refuses to function anymore."
>"I could have a whole library at my fingertips! I could take it with me everywhere! But it just. wont. work."

>Unbeknownst to Twilight, the battery is dead.

>>29019183
Hey, the first arc was pretty good.

>>29019634
>They were LITERALLY just mana batteries in FG.
That's true of a lot of the show's big events. Twilight tries to solve the problem while the rest of the Mane Six get maybe one or two "character moments" before activating the Rainbow Friendship Lasers at the end. The show's pretty hit-or-miss for how it handles the Power of Friendship.