Now that we've hit the lowest of low, it can only get

>>28751539
I don't even get why people think S6 was that bad.

>>28751539
>S1
>Perfect

File: baitpone loves your bait.png (69KB, 405x431px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 405x431px

>>28751539
>that entire chart

>>28751554
>>28748894

>>28751573
>>28748980

File: for-you.png (13KB, 971x576px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 971x576px

>>28751547
>>28751553
>>28751554
made an /neomlp/ version
Enjoy!

>>28751591
>conflicting opinion detected!
>not answering questions
>avoiding having to defend my viewpoint
>deploying memes and buzzwords
>target eliminated, status-quo restored

File: appleugh.png (103KB, 212x226px) Image search: [Google]

103KB, 212x226px

>>28751591
"not perfect" doesn't mean terrible and "not that bad" doesn't mean perfect, you god damn philistine

File: 1477198742561.jpg (175KB, 1280x853px) Image search: [Google]

175KB, 1280x853px

>>28751641
>/neomlp/ pretends to have watch any other season beyond 5 & 6
my sides are leaving this dimension desu

File: NyxBait.png (72KB, 405x431px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 405x431px

>>28751554
FTFY

>>28751539
Either tonight or tomorrow night I'm starting another series of episode ranking threads to see how this one actually fits in with the others. I'm pretty sure it'll at least beat season 3, but I doubt any individual episode from it will crack the top 10.

File: shiggy.png (43KB, 502x284px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 502x284px

>>28751656
^:)

>>28751663
>implying it wont just be a bunch of nostalgiafags voting again
i used to look forward to those polls, but now i really dont care.

>>28751677
I've got a second method to contribute in it now that will hopefully help if there wes a large voice of other Anons that weren't heard. I'm guessing the fact that Anons had to sit for hours to make a list kept opinion to specific sets perhaps. We'll see if this other way to vote makes a difference.

>>28751641
This is a reasonable chart.

I don't agree 100% on the specifics, but in broad strokes I'm with you. I hope you're right about s7.

>>28751641
not perfect, but reasonable

File: fuck you retard.jpg (41KB, 249x225px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 249x225px

>>28751641
>>28751737
>>28751779
>Season 6
>Rehashed locations, forced memes, fan pandering 1000x
>Good

>>28751841
>wah wah fun is bad everything is terrible i hate the show

This site might be more to your liking:
https://www.ponychan.net/pony/

File: fan pandering.jpg (56KB, 1642x187px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 1642x187px

>>28751841
>Rehashed locations
ponyville is 22 of the 26 episodes in season 1.
>forced memes
the only forced memes come from this shithole.
>fan pandering
pic related

>>28751641
I'd move 1 and 2 up a bit and 4 down, I'd say 1, 2, and 5, are the best ones, then 4 then 6 then 3.

File: 42872484.png (174KB, 580x301px) Image search: [Google]

174KB, 580x301px

>>28751907

>>28751907
That's my thoughts to a T, honestly. Completely agreed.

>>28751907
This.

File: 1271734__safe_queen+chrysalis_changeling_facehoof_thorax_to+where+and+back+again_spoiler-colon-s06e26_spoiler-colon-s06e25_king+thorax_it's+a+phase.png (464KB, 957x872px) Image search: [Google]

464KB, 957x872px

>>28751539
Reminder to you non doom sayers that season six ruined an entire fucking species. it deserves to crash into hell as the OP has it.

File: Golden_Oak_Library_destroyed_S4E26.png (636KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

636KB, 1280x720px

>>28751993
And season three ruined the main character. What's your point? Shit gets ruined all the time in this show.

>>28751993
Maybe they retained their shapeshifting powers, and some will decide they like their old forms. Please hasbro.

>>28751547
It's not that it was "bad", it just feels different. It's a radical departure from previous seasons.

Now, if the change makes FiM better or worse, that's up to you.

>>28752046
>it just feels different.
I agree. As a season 6 hater, I'm completely sure that I could've liked some of the episodes I disliked this season if I had watched them in other show. My main problem with this season is, the mood of many episodes just didn't match at all what I expect to find in this show.

>>28752149
>its not the same as before
thats the worst reason to hate something. if it was bad in its own right, thats one thing, but to hate something purely because it wasnt a carbon copy is asinine.

>>28752169
But he didn't say that. He said that as part of MLP, it was inconsistent and lacked cohesion.

File: pink_bitch_eating_popcorn.gif (2MB, 662x600px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 662x600px

>>28752169
If I were to buy hamburgers and they gave me chocolate ice cream, I'd be disappointed, no matter how much I like ice cream.

>>28752187
this show isnt made to your order, anon. thats some more shitty reasoning.

>>28752198
If I were to buy food in a place where they had been selling hamburgers for five years and one day they only had ice cream, I'd be disappointed, no matter how much I like ice cream.

>>28752218
from your own reasoning, you would be an idiot for continuing to visit a place you know changes its menu every year and being surprised by it.

>>28752046
Veterans left and we're full of new writers now

It's a fact

File: i got that fire 4 cheap.png (115KB, 449x425px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 449x425px

>>28752187
>>28752218
Well fuck now I want both

>>28752236
Your fantastic summary would work if I had complained about more than just one season. But I literally said that I've been eating the same food for five years, that's not a change every year, it's just one single change. So it makes sense to be surprised by said first change.

>>28752269
except it has in fact changed every year, you just didnt seem to notice.

im curious what was so drastic in s6 that made you switch entire food groups if you considered s3 on par with every other event.

File: 1465445527800.png (74KB, 480x610px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 480x610px

>>28752277
I liked S3, it had one of my favorite episodes in the entire show, the bad episodes weren't really that bad, and MMC wasn't a problem for me. Why should I dislike it?

Although, wait a minute. Are you implying that you didn't like it? Then why are you here? You should have left! People is supposed to leave when they don't like a season!

>>28752335
sleepless in ponyville remains my all time favorite episode
i didnt say you should dislike it, your argument was the show changed drastically in s6 and not at all from s1-5, which is objectively wrong.
are you going to answer my question? what did s6 do that you hated so much?

File: 1454020661089.png (476KB, 689x643px) Image search: [Google]

476KB, 689x643px

>>28751539
>>28751641
>season 4
>perfect
>even ranking it above mediocre
I'm not taking that bait, desu

>>28752705
it was better than this response. ^:)

>>28751591
I chuckled.

>>28751539
>S1
>Perfect

what the fuck?

>>28751641
this i agree with

>>28752767
correction
S2 is perfect

>>28752705
>Season 4 is sooooooooo bad, even though I've only ever watched season 5 & 6 xD
t. /neomlp/

>>28752916
>season 2+ is soooooo bad
>even though i stopped watching the show after season 2
>"oldfag"

>>28752916
>>28751656
>>28751591
>neo/mlp/
I honestly don't know what this means, sounds like a buzz word.

>>28751851
> wah wah criticism is bad the show is perfect, perfect and if u disagree u are a hater
THIS site might be more to YOUR liking:
http://www.equestriadaily.com/

>>28753462
That's because it is.

>>28751547
It's growing pain. We're seeing less and less of the mane 6 doing fun shit and more of shit characters doing shitty shit.

>>28752033
When the library died I wanted to cry. It was where so many things started and so many things happened. Stupid castles aren't what friends need to have a good time.

>>28753762
>Stupid castles aren't what friends need to have a good time.
sure doesnt hurt your chances, though/

File: 1141081__safe_screencap_trixie_no+second+prances_spoiler-colon-s06e06_no+second+glances.jpg (30KB, 610x560px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 610x560px

>>28752916
>didn't start watching until S2+
>thinking you're not /neomlp/

File: 1477594079401.png (13KB, 971x576px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 971x576px

>>28751539
>>28751591

File: 1477594079401.png (9KB, 971x576px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 971x576px

>Watching the show