>WRITERS WILL NEVER DELVE INTO WHAT SORT OF "EARTH PONY

>>27487732
>le applejack isn't a good character meme

File: full.jpg (126KB, 752x328px) Image search: [Google]

126KB, 752x328px

>>27487732
Background characters aren't usually complex and well written, Anon.

File: 1435143844109.jpg (20KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 480x360px

>>27487732
Applefags can't seem to get a break.

File: 1464142119860.jpg (7KB, 243x181px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 243x181px

>>27487732
She's shit, buddy.

File: 1459861455244.gif (940KB, 350x267px) Image search: [Google]

940KB, 350x267px

>>27487732

>>27487732
>earth pony magic
Stopped there.

>>27487732
>inplying any characters in this show are actually complex in any way
dude, the show is MADE for children and immature adults , if they create a complex character, no one will understand him/her

File: sweet (4012).gif (134KB, 650x569px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 650x569px

>>27489379
I can think of a few episodes with complex, thoughtful characterization, and most people here totally missed the point of those episodes. Misunderstood the character's feelings and just called it boring, because fuck putting any effort into thinking about pony.
Those same people were probably the types to praise Gauntlet of Fire as finally doing Spike justice and making him a good character. I can't blame the writers for normally relying on more simple characterization, when less than 10% of the viewers will be able to appreciate it when it's thoughtful.

>>27487732
>le headcanons

>>27487732
Trying to find depth in Applejack is like diving head first into a shallow pool.

>>27489441
>I can't blame the writers
Kill yourself.

>>27489457
When putting effort into it only gets them shit from whiny retards with ADHD, and making shallow crap like GoF gets them endless praise, why should they put forth the effort? The fans sure aren't willing to think about it.

File: 348619612.jpg (130KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 450x450px

>>27488063
>If it refutes my opinion/taste than it's just a meme

>>27489441
congratulations, you're one of the few people that actually isn't childish and immature. I think you're the first brony i encoutered that actually have a critical thinking set of mind

>>27489379
This.
Plus, if SOME character can have Depths (like Rara, dash, or pinkie in breakdown mode)...

AJ's ENTIRE shtick is being the straight gal. The logical one. The "I'm here to fix shit" pony. She really doesn't have any real character behind that.

So when they have to challenge her, and its not about honesty, they have no other way than to make her a retard, because aside from appul and family her common sense is all she's useful for.