>Element of Generosity >Completely wierded out by the idea

>>26961341
I don't think you really paid attention to the episode

>>26961341
>Against giving something that is essentially part of Pinkies character, that she has never her seen without.
Yes, Rarity was totally out of character saying she gave to much.

File: truth.jpg (674KB, 1160x1024px) Image search: [Google]

674KB, 1160x1024px

>>26961341

>>26961341
Too bad the element of harmony doesn't exist anymore.

>>26961348
This.

OP you need to stop sucking cocks while watching new episodes, you are bad at multi-tasking.

File: 1459044771607.gif (67KB, 350x350px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 350x350px

>>26961341
I'm a dedicated faustfriend, but even I have to admit that this episode had good characterization.
Realize how wrong you are or ignore it like the rest of us do with actually shit episodes.
>>26963979
cease to be

>>26961341
No, he shouldnt
That never happened

File: 1459613130383.jpg (856KB, 1000x915px) Image search: [Google]

856KB, 1000x915px

>>26961341
Rarity takes Manehatten was about not letting your generosity get you taken advantage of, and not letting those who would take advantage of you lose your generosity.

Rarity was perfectly in line with her developed character.
Being generous doesn't mean giving away everything.

File: 1459569044495.png (352KB, 318x355px) Image search: [Google]

352KB, 318x355px

>>26963979
>Laughter, Honesty, Generosity, Loyalty, Kindness and Magic will never mean anything again in the series

>>26963920
>Pic accurate

>>26961341
I can see where you are coming from but I think something that important allows for an exception

File: 1456214726052.png (196KB, 800x566px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 800x566px

>>26961348
>>26961364

Although i agree with these anons, I'm like 80% sure Harber hasn't watched any of the show before writing episodes, and just rolls with the descriptions of the characters he was given on day 1

>>26967641
I thought so at first but he was so spot on with pinkie i m not so sure any more
Wait haber dident write this episode did he.

>>26967674
He didn't.

Also it's obvious Haber watched it. Spike's mirror showing off is a callback to when he confessed to Pinkie way way back in Party of One.

>>26964909
>>26964789
>>26964242
>>26964169
>>26961364
>Rarityfags everyone

OP is right, Rarity was out of character not only with her lack of generosity but also with her freaking out and acting like Pinkie. Nefags just need to watch first episodes.

File: 1455839144843.png (154KB, 442x441px) Image search: [Google]

154KB, 442x441px

>>26967769
>Rarity freaking out and acting like pinky
Please fucking tell me you are not referencing the one time gag about Rarity addressing that ponks isnt acting like her usually bouncy self.

>>26967769
>not understanding the difference between character development and flanderization
>"How dare she emphathize with her friend's problems instead of just writing them off as beneath her! She's a bitch for not being a stuck-up bitch anymore!"
I refuse to beleive you aren't a Rarity shill who's buttmad your waifu isn't a dick anymore.

>>26967769
You mean like when she freaked out and acted like applejack
For that matter rarity has always consistently represented her element unlike applejack

>>26961341
She doesn't understand why /Pinkie/ would give up her cannon.

>>26967769

you're right, rarity in early seasons is a bitch

>>26961341

If your friend got a shit deal you'd wonder why they took it you autist.

>>26968098
This. What Pinkie did wasn't generosity, it was sacrifice.

>>26968121
inb4 "there's no difference"

>>26968121
That's actually a good point. I hadn't thought about the difference between sacrificing something and being generous. I suppose they are quite different in many areas.

File: 1069386__safe_twilight+sparkle_screencap_princess+twilight_floppy+ears_faic_spoiler-colon-s05e26_the+cutie+remark+-dash-+part+2.png (361KB, 1023x577px) Image search: [Google]

361KB, 1023x577px

>>26967674
Pinkie in the premier was fantastic, pinkie in yesterday's episode was right back to "loud and annoying is easy to write so we'll stick with that".

After the premier I still had some hopes for the season - it wasn't great but wasn't too bad so I'll take it. Episode 3 was basically pretty fucking bad - aside from maud smiling the episode had basically nothing to offer unless you're a maudfag

File: 1459045679671.gif (866KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

866KB, 450x450px

>>26961341
ITT: Rarityfriends want Rarity to regress to being an insufferable upper-class shithead

>>26968783
and Ponkofriends want Punka to be a side character.

>>26968783
At first it seems like pinkie is just being randumb during the sightseeing scenes but when you think about it pinkie lives to make people happy and this is a huge opportunity to do so and it's for her sister it makes perfect sense for her to sperg out.