>Perfect: An objectively good show that can stand on it's

>>15192357
Destiny and Wing need to be higher, War in the Pocket needs to be lower, and IBO is bottom tier, disagree and you're not a proper fan

Swap G-Reco and 08th and its a pretty good list.

>>15192357
Turn A needs to be much lower, it almost killed the franchise

>>15192405
You know, I wish 'shit taste' was an available option to report people under, just for plebs like you.

>>15192417
my taste are better than yours because I'm smart enough to know Turn A wasn't great

>>15192357
I feel pretty similar, only things that I would change in my list would be putting Victory lower as its ending left a sour taste in my mouth, but my dislike of the show is mainly due to the actions of one of the main cast I would also move up Greco up one tier as it's a pretty fun watch but it kinda ends up being a bit of a mess. Other than that it looks decent

>>15192357
IBO needs to be bottom tier now, it has nothing redeeming going for it

gundam tier lists are useless for anything but inspiring shitposting

fuck off

>>15192357
What exactly makes Wing BAD and Unicorn GOOD but FLAWED?
Because Unicorn certainly has poor writing

>>15192357
I can agree with perfect tier, but I'd move zeta and 08th down into good but flawed.
Move g-reco up to good but flawed.

File: gundam tier.png (3MB, 1522x1838px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1522x1838px

fixed OP's pic

>>15192443
Well of course it's badly written if you think it's a zeekwank, considering it spends its time thoroughly calling Zeon out on how it did everything wrong and how spacenoids need to stop putting their faith in Super ISIS.

>>15192454
glorious

>>15192357
>0080: War in the Pocket
>perfect
Why are 0080 and chris foggots so retarded?

>>15192454
Bait

>>15192463
>can't spell
>calls other people retards
You're either baiting or actually underage and don't like it because there aren't enough ms battles for your adhd

File: 1426467807764.jpg (3MB, 2800x3402px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2800x3402px

>>15192465
No, he's completely right

>>15192463
Mecha Talk memes, especially since the hivemind likes roaming around /m/ spreading their propaganda

>>15192471
>relying on a guide some nouthbreather made instead of having watched every series
Go finish at least UC in production order before posting again kiddo

>>15192417
He didn't even mention his tastes, just that it was unpopular enough to nearly kill the entire franchise.

>>15192480
I've seen every entry in the franchise, mouthaholic

>>15192471
>Turn A
>'Regarded by many as a low point in the Gundam franchise'
Kek, how did we get from "Considered by many to be the best in the franchise", to no mention of its popularity, to this?

File: 1486747079273.jpg (765KB, 2184x1856px) Image search: [Google]

765KB, 2184x1856px

the "real" list

>>15192357
>F91
>Great

Otherwise solid list.

>>15192490
Around the moment GSD gained "considered by many to be the best in the franchise."

>>15192492
obvious bait
>>15192490
falling for MAHQ memes

Turn A is not liked in Japan, anon.

>>15192391
This and make another lower tier. GBF Try and Destiny are on another level of bad that isn't comparable to something like Wing or the 00 movie

>>15192498
Not my fault, SEED fag.

>>15192497
Destiny > Turn A in every way

File: HD Remaster After 1.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>15192492
G-Reco is too high up on this

>>15192497
Holy shit I didn't even notice, I thought the joke was instead that everything would say that it's a low point.

>>15192498
Didn't say it was, I was one of the ones who used to throw a shitfit over Turn A being called the best in the franchise.

>>15192502
Well, music, design, and fanservice-wise, maybe.

>>15192505
>Well, music, design, and fanservice-wise, maybe.
And writing and setting and characters and action and art and animation and everything else in between

>>15192454
this version is better than OP's and was made by proper fans and not just hiveminds from ANN, Anime Suki, and Mecha Talk.

>>15192505
>G-Reco is too high up on this
>It's on "bad tier"

>>15192518
Yeah, make a tier beneath that and put it there.

>>15192521
There's nothing beyond bad.

File: cap.jpg (317KB, 1608x897px) Image search: [Google]

317KB, 1608x897px

>>15192524
G-Reco.

>>15192489
Sure, go back to suckin on yer mam's tit ya baby.

File: hardcore shitposter.jpg (564KB, 1900x5674px) Image search: [Google]

564KB, 1900x5674px

>>15192470
Why do you keep posting these stupid things? You might not even have realized it, but everyone is able to identify their shitposts.

>>15192536
dude you're so retarded I love it
you didn't even realize that you left my post number exactly the same
I was right to think you were impaired in some way I guess
try again next time once you graduate highschool you underage

>>15192536
I don't get your pic, but you should head back to Anime Suki regardless

>>15192536
>left post date, time, and post number the same
dude even I'm not this shit at editing

>>15192357
Okay list, but the idea that F91 is great and that G is perfect is a bit risible to me. I don't think any series is perfect, but I personally would put Zeta at the top along with the original series. The rest vary, but I think those two are by far the best.

I also think your "stand on its own weight" clause is unjustified. Zeta uses its status as a sequel to more effectively explore the themes and story developments that it does. Accessibility isn't the same thing as quality.

0080 wasn't even that good anyway

>>15192527
Are you saying it's good?

>>15192405
There was only a three-year break between it and SEED, retard.

That's as long a gap as the one between CCA and F91, but I don't see any of you mouthbreathers claiming CCA almost killed the franchise despite CCA actually being terrible.

>>15192592
Actually, my bad; only a two year break between Turn A and SEED; the former started in 1999 but ended in 2000.

So it really didn't kill jack shit now did it?

File: chart.png (3MB, 1628x2223px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1628x2223px

Fixed

>>15192599
>zeta
>perfect
Found the retard.

>>15192599
>Destiny that low and Turn A that high
Bait

>>15192544
>>15192545
>>15192549

nice headcanon weebshit, how go back to your AnimeSuki

>>15192603
t. shitpost-kun

File: 1486747079273.jpg (1MB, 1226x1908px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1226x1908px

Real list

>>15192612
again, you're either just baiting or retarded
I'm gonna stop taking that bait, but it was a good time for me and I hope it was for you
have a nice weekend anon

>>15192659
>The Origin in 'Perfect'
The original overall manga has its merits, but I don't understand the love for the OVAs. The back story arc is easily the stupidest and most pointless thing it does.

>>15192665
are you a two year-old child, right?

>>15192391
I fucking love greco but i don't think it belongs anywhere other than good but flawed

>>15192405
Japs have shit taste.

>/m/ is getting more and more like /a/, reddit, mechatalk, animesuki, ANN and MAL.

all thanks to A/Z, VVV and Macross F

>>15192702
Please get psychiatric help, this has gone from irritating to legitimately concerning.

>>15192702
AZ was fantastic though

>>15192454
I like it

>>15192596
How well did Turn A shit sell, shitposteranonkunsenpai?

>>15192702
I tottaly agree with you

>>15192774
Not well

>>15193070
>MAHQ is still upset

>>15192454
>GBFT
>Any amount of good
No sir, I don't like it.

>>15192357
hi bronard

File: seiwut.jpg (53KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 1280x720px

>all these Great ratings for Thunderbolt
I'll grant that the animation is nice but let's not pretend the show contains anywhere near enough context to stand on its own, or is anything but a glorified 60min commercial for the manga.

>>15193438
Still better than what is currently airing

>>15192357
>Gundam X
>Good
>Pick one.

>>15193438
It also didn't have to padded on time to fuck up.

>>15192454
perfect, not a single flaw

File: hqdefault.jpg (15KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 480x360px

>Giving G Gundam a Perfect.
>Giving Build Fighters a Great
>Only giving 0083 and CCA a Good but Flawed
>Not putting UC in bad

>>15197128
I pick both, you prick.

>>15193070
this desu