The great debate fafner vs evangelion vs rahxephon vs the

Whoever wins, /m/ loses as this thread is likely just going to be wanking and shitflinging with little discussion on what makes any of these shows great or stand apart from each other.

>>14875150
Ideon

Who cares?

Like what you like.

The correct answer is not RXP

>>14875150
Eva and Fafner's quality is subjective (personally I like both) but we can all agree that RahXephon is shit because it's a clone of the former.

File: nigelkenji.jpg (415KB, 735x886px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 735x886px

I like all three

>>14875198
>Fafner
>not an evaclone

>nge
>not a gundamclone

>RXP
>evaclone
Wew

>>14875380
Absolute madman.
You probably like Gasaraki, huh.

File: tumblr_o1gtcdgXPt1ur501zo1_1280.jpg (186KB, 1234x694px) Image search: [Google]

186KB, 1234x694px

>>14875383
I do in fact

>>14875383
>Fafner
>not an evaclone
Only for the first half, and that's when the show was at its worst

>nge
>not a gundamclone
>RXP
>evaclone
Oh look it's a delusional rahxefag
Go back to watching your """""""""""""modern raideen"""""""""""'''

>>14875391
Me too

>>14875394
Status:
>Rused [X]
>not Rused [_]

>>14875410
>I was just pretending to be retarded!
gg no re

>>14875394
>Only for the first half,
not even, Fafner departs pretty early on form its questionable Eva influences.
Like episode 8 or 9, and even before then there's not too much similarity past its setting and premise.

File: Argento.Soma.jpg (1MB, 2197x1500px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2197x1500px

>>14875150
this wins

>>14875394
As someone who just started Fafner and onto episode 17 of the first series, the Eva themes in the first half were pretty subtle and half-hearted at best.

>>14876463
I feel like people say this because of how it looks.
I haven't seen much of it, but it felt more like rahxephon then Eva.

why do people hate Rah so much? at worst it's just "okay".

>>14878988
Bones.

>>14875169
I actually just came here to type that.

>>14875150
Fafner > Evangelion 1.0/2.0 > Rahxephon > Evangelion

>>14879351
Hello gay man. Open as usual.

>>14879351
>Evangelion 1.0/2.0
>ever greater than the original

>>14879550
Watch Evangelion again without nostalgia goggles senpai

>>14875150
>great debate

It's really not though. No one even remembers Fafner and Rahxephon except /m/. Evangelion is iconic and simply better than the other two by literally any standard. This thread is stupid.

>>14877438
the latter half of the show is a goddamned masterpiece. The first half is pretty hit or miss monster of the week where every monster is the same monster, but the build up is absolutely worth it

>>14878988
I hate it because it barely even tries to tell a story and instead basks in LOOK AT HOW DEEP AND MEANINGFUL WE ARE DID YOU CATCH ALL THE SYMBOLISM!!?? when most of the show says absolutely nothing about anything and ultimately it's just a shallow sci-fi love story

It's the anime equivalent of reading an emo teen's poetry on facebook.

>>14880253
>It's the anime equivalent of reading an emo teen's poetry on facebook.
how wrong can one man be

>>14880253
Agreed, and I wanted to like it. It's not even visually interesting outside of the art direction, so you may as well just go rewatch NGE.

Alright; which one of you faggots let Evageeks in?

Fuck y'all niggers RahXephon was a good Eva clone

>>14875150
brain powered

>Evangelion
>mecha
It's kinda mecha, but it's absolutely not mecha at the same time

>>14883028
>It's kinda mecha, but it's absolutely not mecha at the same time
Gigantic piloted cyborgs aren't mecha?

Get outta here, newfag.