What is Tomino's worst work? For me it's between Zeta

1. Zeta
2. Turn A
3. Garzey's Wing

>>14673073
Turn A doesn't belong on that list. It's kinda mediocre, but it's not Dunbine, which mind you, is still better than other Byston Well shit like Wings of Rean.

Garzey's Wing

>>14673065
Garzey's Wing

Everything he has ever made other than kido senshi gundam. Everything post and pre 1979 has been utter shit.

G-Reco

>>14673301
THIS

>>14673065
Rean was good outside the ending

File: Bellri smug.jpg (6KB, 183x183px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 183x183px

>>14673301
>>14673332
>Geco
>Bad
>Let alone compared to some of the other shit Tomino's put out

I mean was it great? Hell no, not really a master work by any means but it's not an instruction book on how not to do anything like >>14673234 was.

>>14673426
Explain what's so bad about Garzey's Wing other than being really simplistic.

>>14673426
>I mean was it great? Hell yes
ftfy MAL

>>14673065
Brave Raideen.

File: Overman King Gainer 17 confession.webm (3MB, 608x334px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 608x334px

I will always forgive Tomino for everything as he made this scene in Gainer.

>>14673530
great scene

File: 1.gif (985KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

985KB, 500x281px

>>14673301
Oh my SU Cord

G-reco's dialogues and character interactions are just vomit tier

>>14673666
t.Okada

>>14673670

I mean, in fairness, the only bit of dialogue originating from that product that anyone seems to remember aside from everything pre-recovery Raraiya says is Mask rambling about Bellri being a dictator.

Oh, and post-recovery Raraiya going "IT'S YOU ADULTS WHO DO THINGS LIKE THIIIIIIIIIIIIS" in a very subtle delivery of one of the show's core messages.

>>14673685
>subtle delivery
Tomino himself said that his primary focus of G-Reco was to deliver his message

>>14673703

And he could have done that in a manner that didn't involve treating the audience like idiots, but hey, beggars can't be choosers.

>>14673685
Well and stuff about squares which people act like it's a confusing piece of dialogue because it isn't a generic "AMAI" or something.

>>14673713
But he didn't, in fact it was the opposite, since the show didn't have characters dumping information like in IBO

I almost feel like he made Garzey's Wing as bad as it was on a dare.

File: 1470339602507.gif (537KB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

537KB, 480x270px

>>14673065
Zeta is a masterpiece.

G-Reco is so slow it bad.

The biggest lie ever told on /m/ is that G-Reco is subtle,

>>14673735

No, it was absolutely true, just in different ways, and having a character scream your show's message is one of the worst things you can do.

>>14673802
People who primarily watch anime are retards and G-Reco's editing and pacing were out of the norm . So Tomino's dialogue in G-Reco was considered subtle rather than completely bold faced like every other fucking anime ever made where characters verbalize almost every action.

>>14673811
Nah, the worst thing you can do is make a whole bunch of worldbuilding only to use it on a subpar series where the animation quality is shit and the story never moves forward

aka IBO

>>14673065
Wings of Rean has the unfortunate problem of being rushed. The pace is too fast, it's a mess. I think if they slow down the pace and polish the writing a bit, it could be good.

I mean Wings of Rean story in SRWUX is just amazing.

>>14674866
Check out the manga

>>14673796
Make up your mind /m/, is it so slow that it's bad, or it's it too fast that you can't understand it?

>>14673065

Either Dubine or Ideon. Those were the only Tomino works I've watched that I couldn't finish, though I have'nt seen Garzey's Wings or Wings of Rean yet. Be Invoked was amazing as well. I'm curious, everyone said Brain Powerd was awful but to me it is within the top 5% of anime out there, I need to watch Garzey's Wings.

File: dunbine.jpg (275KB, 1024x726px) Image search: [Google]

275KB, 1024x726px

>>14675271
>Dropped Dunbine

Your loss.

>>14675300
To be fair, the fantasy bit isn't that great. It's awesome when they went to the surface and made the Cold War worlds their bitch.

>>14673065
honestly all of his works are on the same level of mediocrity. he's definitely one of the most consistently shit directors

File: dunbine6.jpg (129KB, 999x747px) Image search: [Google]

129KB, 999x747px

>>14675509
I was actually sad so little was spent in the fantasy world in Rean.

>>14675300

Not him but Dunbine is like 12 episodes longer than it needs to be. The return to earth section is just the same shit episode after episode.

>>14673484
It's just bland as fuck outside of the surreal introduction. There's nothing that stands out about it in a positive way, but there's nothing legendarily horrible either - it's just utterly mediocre. The idea that it's a constant barrage of so-bad-it's-good insanity is an ANN meme opinion.

>>14675708

What Tomino show isn't 12 episodes longer than it needs to be?

>>14676479
Zambot 3. Granted, that may have been due to the NINGEN BAKUDAN thing.

Also, Daitarn 3 didn't have much plot progression to begin with.

>>14675549

This. Tomino is just not good.

>>14673065
Gay Gundam.

>>14675549
>>14676634
You know "mediocre" would still imply that he's one of the select few that's decent at what he does than a majority of other anime directors (especially TV-related ones). There is rarely any "good" when it comes to anime, there's just "less shit than the other".

>>14676434
The earth arcs were fantastic along with the final few episodes.

File: image.png (439KB, 939x529px) Image search: [Google]

439KB, 939x529px

>>14673749
This.

I also really hate that most of the shitposting fags try to make everything a Zeta vs ZZ shit flinging fest.

I love both for different reasons.

>>14677289
Both are shit tho