What are the criteria that makes a bad /m/ related show/movie/game/book

If it has Gundam on the title.

>>13689524
Anything Mazinger or Getter related is 2/10 by default, unless it's manga Go which gets a 3/10 for trying to be a Gundam/Ideon clone and escape from its shitty past

>>13689524
It doesn't have memes

>>13689524
>according to /m/?
It exists.

No seriously that's all it takes.

>>13689524
Being released.

File: 1437677638101.jpg (59KB, 636x476px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 636x476px

>>13689524

>>13689681
>>13689700
I've heard someone on /m/ say the SEED movie is terrible once

>>13689524
/m/ is not a hivemind and assuming it is will only make you look silly

there are people here that like things
there are people here that hate things
there are people here who will pretend to be either for attention

File: mecha fans.png (221KB, 684x1261px) Image search: [Google]

221KB, 684x1261px

>>13689720

>>13689524
>CG
>It's written by someone notoriously pretentious who isn't Imagawa or Oshi
>It's written by post-90s Tomino

>>13689524

It doesn't pander hard to /m/ and /m/ alone or just refer to >>13689717

It's /m/ if jannies don't delete the thread.

A bad mecha show I'd say comes in two flavors

The ones that have a lot of potential but don't do anything with it like Captain Earth. While not offensive, it doesn't leave an impression besides "This really could of been more interesting"

Then you get the shows that treat you like an idiot. In that they try and sell themselves as mature or well written but who fall apart under scrutiny. They don't follow their own internal logic or do things just for the sake of trying to keep the audience hooked with twists. I won't name any names because they'll cause the fans to sperg out and start shit fling.

A good mecha show doesn't need to be high budget or doesn't have to be original. It just needs to stay consistent with itself, provide decent mech action and deliver with it's ending.

I'd say Majestic Prince is a good example of this. It didn't have the highest budget, it wasn't very innovative either, but it never strayed from the tone it established for itself and never tried to be something it's not.

>>13689524
>What are the criteria that makes a bad /m/ related show/movie/game/book according to /m/?

It gets made.

>>13689524
Zeon is the protagonist.

Meaning only MS IGLOO is good. MS IGLOO a shit.

>>13689524
Anything from the early 70s or earlier AKA the infant days of nip mecha when they either didn't know what the fuck to do or how to use what they thought up even remotely properly