Are they well written for children's/YA books? I haven't

>>8426273
Why don't you read them and tell us?

They're not well written at all frankly. Even Roald Dahl and Dr. Seuss is way superior.

>>8426291

>even

What do you mean?

>>8426308
Just disregard that "even" tbqh, don't know why I wrote it now.

>>8426273
>since I was a baby
Jesus, how young are you?

>>8426273
They're okay. Really good by child/YA standards, but terrible when compared to actual literature.

They hold a spot in my heart as they are humble, unassuming narratives and I find they are the epitome of comfy lit. There's something pleasant in reading about the day to day life in hogwarts that is filled with enough wonder but also enough familiarity to make it a very easy book to just blaze through.

Is it good? In the right mindset, and most likely the right age, yes. For any type of serious reading as an adult? No, don't treat it as such.

>>8427887
this tbqh. maybe it's just nostalgia, but Hogwarts is such a genuinely interesting place to read about

File: 1460730163037.jpg (59KB, 306x475px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 306x475px

>>8426273
Pleb-tier YA fantasy. Real kids read Deltora Quest.

>>8426318
Well, the first one came out '97. The last one came out '07. We could theoretically have someone born in '97 or '98 who was read the first few books as a very small child.

As YA/children's books, they're very good. J K Rowling is a good story-teller, and that's something you need for children's books. Good stories.

As adult novels, not so much. Story-telling as a skill will only get you so far in literature.

Hermione is great. She's up there with the other classic kid's lit heroines.

>>8428005
Mein nigger. Deltora Quest a greato.

Shame the not-really-a-sequel Doors series wasn't as good.

Reading Rowan now though and so far I'm pleased with it.

>>8426291
>Roald Dahl
Still inferior to the various famous classic child's lit desu.

*stands up*
*stretches legs*

heh, nothin..personnel... kid

*stretches fingers at 600mph directly into OP's fucking face*

>>8428005

>Deltora Quest has a saturday morning anime series
>Harry Potter doesn't

I think thats pretty conclusive evidence of superiority.

>>8428273
And the anime is great too. It's actually so good it beats the majority of the other fantasy anime Japan has churned out.

Nothing else is quite like it except maybe Lodoss.

>>8428243
>Reading Rowan now though and so far I'm pleased with it.
I got the first book for free somehow but never got into it. I wasn't interested in anything not set in Deltora.

>>8428273
I was pretty spooked by the anime series just now. I didn't know such a thing existed, but I would have loved the hell out of it when I was a kid.

File: The Curse of the Gloamglozer.jpg (53KB, 316x473px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 316x473px

>>8426273
I enjoyed the Edge Chronicles more than I enjoyed Harry Potter honestly. These anons >>8428026 >>8427887 summed it up pretty well.

>>8428005
My dude!! My brother-from-another-colored-mother got me hooked on this series. I did get him to read The Edge Chronicles though they aren't nearly as good.

well, I read them in the probably ideal way thanks to being the right age when they were hot shit / coming out; I was a kid when I read the first ones, I was a teenager when I read the last ones

"growing up" with them was a very good experience and I remember it warmly

yes, they're good YA or even children's books. "well written" would need to be defined to give more of a review. the world is interesting enough for such fantasy, though full of problems if you get into thinking about it. their language isn't that great.

>>8427887
>they are humble, unassuming narratives and I find they are the epitome of comfy lit

...the books about magic nazis and the magic communist revolution are humble and unassuming?

>>8428398
the wizards are shitheads if you really start to think about it, but while reading them, you won't. they're comfy lit while reading them.

I always found the nazi vibes to be a mostly aesthetic thing, you know, being the ultimate evil and so forth

>>8428405
>shitheads
Nah famalam, they are the true shitlords. A lot of shit could be compared to fighting off Nazis, especially in YA novels.