Thread replies: 82
Thread images: 9
Thread images: 9
Is there a way we can convince Blaire to get involved in politics? Like actually running for office and stuff. She seems to be pretty knowledgeable on political and social issues as it is, and the fact that she's a tranny means more diversity.
>>
File: robbiefaggotron.png (712KB, 842x534px) Image search:
[Google]
712KB, 842x534px
>>8232678
um no she isnt knowledgable at all, all she does is ponder to right wing tards for cash you moron
>>
>>8232678
At least choose a smart tranny like Meyer or Southern.
>>
>>8232678
>She seems to be pretty knowledgeable on political and social issues as it is
Well no. Giving some right wing criticism on certain issues and having a deep understanding why things are that way and why they're wrong is a different matter.
Not that you need these skills to get involved with politics.
>>
>>8232678
She's a complete retard... Why would you want her to have any power?
>>
>>8232678
She seems much better at debating than vlogging. But maybe that's just crude video editting.
>>
>>8232941
Never bothered looking at any of her debates, but I doubt she's capable of debating.
>>8232940
Generally hons are right wing, and those who pass and blend into society are "left wing".
>>
>>8232966
There are practically no passers who are right wing.
>inb4 blair
Passing excludes drag makeup. She draws her lip twice the size they actually are.
>>
>>8232696
Honestly this. I think she's hot and would hatefuck her any day, and I'm happy to see a transgirl be confident and make it in the world & have her own views and not just parrot SJW bullshit. But truthfully she's not very good at what she does and only appeals to people because they're just as ignorant. She isn't even THAT right wing, just kinda anti-SJW-ish. Slightly right-of-centre on some things, slightly left-of-centre on others. Meh.
>>8232699
>Meyer
I would very much like to see my transfu in politics, but honestly she ain't to knowledgeable either. Smart yes, funny yes, but not knowledgeable.
>Southern
You mean Lauren Southern? She really a tranny? Anyway, retard who can't tell the difference between being a conservative and being a libertarian. I mean I'm a socialist but I like actual libertarians because they tend to be smart and care about people's rights.
>>8232940
The only people who oppose her are people with opposing views and the only people who support her are people with similar views
What did xir mean by this?
>>
>>8232966
transbian hon who pathologically defends his /pol/ waifu everywhere he can detected
>>
>>8232678
No way. There are enough flamboyant gay men in the politics already.
Like Mike "I tried the shock, now I don't want the cock" Pence.
>>
>>8232975
>You mean Lauren Southern? He really a tranny?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGpZSefYvwM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x7vHvclMgYI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wncuy16R5gA
>>
>>8232990
>I'm a chaser
So, a repressed tranny.
>>
>>8232678
Maybe if you can convince Blair to stop using makeup to make it look like cleavage. Then she can be taken seriously like Alex Jones and Milo.
>>
>>8232990
t. Fiona
>>
>>8232678
>She seems to be pretty knowledgeable on political and social issues as it is
Not really. She's just open minded, unflappable, and an entertaining combination of reasonable and bitchy.
>>
>>8232678
Isn't she one of those uneducated self-loathing "conservative" LGBT people?
No one with her politics would vote for her. They'd want her lynched, at best deported.
>>
>>8232975
Lauren southern legally changed her gender to male to laugh at the system.
You say you like libertarians but I'm a right wing libertarian (right wing ecenomically), the true political leaning for liberty and freedom. Do I count under the libertarians you potentially like?
>>
>>8233401
>No one with her politics would vote for her. They'd want her lynched, at best deported.
You're projecting again.
>>
>>8233366
Fiona is the OP of this thread and Blaire's only known whiteknight.
>>
>>8232940
I like Blaire as a person. I'm not certain if she's actually fit for office.
>>
>>8233861
No, only /pol/ chasers since she represents the redpilled tranny waifu with a male mind that they gush over because ciswomen reject them.
t. chaser
(I mean I'd fuck her but not date her dumb ass...)
>>8233406
Yeah I like the free-market bros, they tend to be smart and compassionate and I respect them even though we disagree on markets. Sure there's Rothbard-crazy but there's also Penn Jillette-witty among them.
>>
>>8232678
I'm a tranny and I would gladly sacrifice Blaire White to ISIL so they can aloha snackbar right at her face, or sell her into a Russian human trafficking gang just to be rid of self-hating hypocritical scum like xirself.
>>
File: blairebf.png (599KB, 799x557px) Image search:
[Google]
599KB, 799x557px
Is there a way we can convince Blaire to get involved in porn? Like actually getting her dick sucked by her bf on camera and stuff.
>>
>>8234206
Isn't that what Patreon is for?
>>
>>8233406
>Lauren southern legally changed her gender
Oh, she got her birth cert re-issued? Because that's what it actually means to legally change your gender. And in the vast majority of countries in the world that requires psychiatric approval, if it's even possible.
So I'll wait until she releases that video.
>>
>>8234318
I've been transitioning for 7 years and even I haven't done that yet.....
>>
>>8234318
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGpZSefYvwM
>>
>>
File: 1492230528360.jpg (9KB, 399x388px) Image search:
[Google]
9KB, 399x388px
>>8234206
Wtf shes with him?!? a beta?!?!?!
Come on thats....I MEAN HIM
At least go out with someone in your own fucking league.
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>8234398
>At least go out with someone in your own fucking league.
Someone in her own league isn't gonna date a trans girl.
>>
>>8234403
Someone remotely in her league then. I mean theres bound to be chaser in there.
He is so below her all he can see is her fucking cock.
Chad needs to fix this NOW.
>>
>>8234416
Honestly I'm surprised she's with somebody white, I expected her to be with a Carth type, especially since she seems receptive to PUA stuff.
>>
>>8234354
I'm a white cis dude. But it's funny how some people on 4chan think they can dismiss your opinion because of your skincolour, reminds me of them sjws who dismiss me because I'm white. Makes u use the ol noggin, huh?
Politically I just said I lean to the left but also respect smart people on the right. I can enjoy political commentary from right-wing people who are smart or funny, TheRebel.media makes me giggle sometimes. I mean I disagree with him often but he's funny and has OK arguments sometimes. So it's no about Blaire having the wrong opinions, it's about her expressing her opinions badly. She's neither well-informed, eloquent or offers any good arguments. It's run-of-the-mill centre-right anti-sjw politics: the only thing special about her is that she's hot. Meyer is hotter and smarter and funnier so she wins.
>Trannies should date boys, not other trannies.
Hear hear!
>>
>>8234398
whats wrong? he looks bretty good as far as 4chan users who are into shemales go
>>
>>8234439
What is PUA?
>>
>>8234475
Sure he`s not bad but 4chan standards are pretty low desu. To everyday normal standards he`s low as fuck. He looks like a failed normie.
>>
>>8234471
>I'm a white cis dude
No wonder you're such a cuck
>>
>>8234520
Pick up artist
>>
File: butthurt.jpg (49KB, 330x250px) Image search:
[Google]
49KB, 330x250px
>>8234525
lol there's no way to win with /pol/ is there? I mean if I'm not white I'm a shitskin and if I am I'm a cuck?
I think the problem is you don't like my political stance but you're so used to "arguing" through ad hominems that you're forgotten how to attack the belief and not the person. Which is fine, my belief wasn't my point and you can disagree & be as retarded as you want. My point was that Blaire isn't that good and /pol/ is just delusional. There are better, smarter and funnier right-wing commentators, who are also more right wing, and there are better, smarter and funnier trannies. Sorry that gets you butthurt.
>>
>>8234520
pick up artist
do you not have google?
>>
>>8232678
Blaire is looking decent because she knows how to use make-up. That is: a lot make-up.
But she is not half as informed as she thinks she is. Some of her videos are outright ridiculous like the recent one, where she says that "transgenderism" is a "mental disorder" because.... well, because the DSM-5 says so. She explains absolutely nothing. Not even the meaning of the terms she uses.
She's just stating opinions. Great.
In some regards - not all - she is just as stupid as the SJW people she's fighting against.
Also: The youtubers she is making (legitimately) fun of are for the most part not huge youtubers at all and their videos have more down- than upvotes.
She is able to appear "intelligent" in some of her videos because she found the greatest morons of youtube to "argue" against.
But there is nothing sophisticated about that. AT ALL.
Did you see that one video, where she "responds" to her "critics"? She just picked out the most stupid of all comments and not a single good critique.
The hype around her is more about her looks and the fact that she is "not SJW". That's the two reasons, why people are watching her.
Her content is never ever original. She just copies what similar youtubers do.
>>
>>8234597
Intelligent people crave controversy and are looking for intellecutal challenges to refine their own opinions.
What you are describing is the law of the jungle...
>>
Hold up... Blaire goes on 4chan? thats the vibe I`m getting. And she met her bf through it? who does that jesus.
>>
>>8232678
>She seems to be pretty knowledgeable on political and social issues
she just parrots any anti-SJW on the youtube scene
>>
>>8234614
So you're saying she's intelligent enough to know that she isn't that intelligent, and therefore only picks the lowest hanging fruit? I would agree. That's why she's mediocre at best.
>>
>>8232678
Blaire White isn't "knowledgeable on political and social issues", and her YouTube content is the same old shit that you see from every anti-SJW channels. It's basically recycling and copying content on all the other channels. It's not that I disagree with her videos, but this anti-SJW shit is getting old, and all it simply revolves around going after low-hanging fruit.
>>
>>8234663
Of course, but doesn't that prove she's kinda bad? I mean if I win every battle but only because I fight weaker opponents, that makes me a decent strategist but I can hardly claim to have the strongest army in the world - in fact my own strategy is proof that I don't and that I'm aware of it. The question was if Blaire was smart and informed enough to go into politics for real. She is not. She's smart enough to carve out precisely the niche she's carved out. Good for her but she's still just a meme enjoying her 15 min of fame.
>>
>>8232678
She has good opinions, but she's a terrible debater. She let Laci Green walk all over her in that debate- never once called her out for changing the subject, strawmanning, and making disingenuous arguments.
Blaire could have easily trashed Laci if she knew anything about arguing effectively.
>>
>>8234857
>woman can't argue
More at 11!
And before anyway points out he isn't a woman, I'd say the same about Milo.
>>
>>8234894
Milo can actually dominate a conversation with his personality alone. Blaire is just too timid to be any good at argument.
>>
>>8234928
>Milo can actually dominate a conversation with his personality alone.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sI3Cb7YHtR0
>>
i would rather see her playing with her dick on chaturbate desu
>>
>>8232914
This isn't your blog.
>>
>>8234593
>she says that "transgenderism" is a "mental disorder" because.... well, because the DSM-5 says so
Except she's right. What she really means is 'gender dysphoria is a mental disorder,' but while that's a pretty important distinction she sees the difference as unimportant semantics. The spirit of the video is "gender dysphoria is a suffering and transition is the only current medical treatment to alleviate that suffering," to combat people who treat being trans like a fashion statement as well as those who dismiss it as mental illness without actually stopping to consider what an appropriate treatment would be or why they're being shitty toward someone they see as mentally ill. She handles a delicate issue in an abrasive way that appeals to people who'd generally lean on the transphobic side of things, it might not be scientific but it has it's purpose.
> and their videos have more down- than upvotes.
Which is a problem. These people generally speak for trans people and other minorities as authorities and educators, and when the general public sees that and rightfully thinks it's retarded, there's good chance of it colouring their views on the minorities in question when they don't have a lot of personal experience (especially for trans people, who are a minute population and generally stealth IRL, so very few people will ever have knowingly interacted with one personally).
People like Blaire circumvent this by speaking the language of people who are put off by these self-appointed authorities and, whether they agree with HER opinion or not, she proves that the status quo retarded SJWs are peddling isn't accurate, that being trans is not a homogenous political identity, and trans people actually have a wide range of beliefs and attitudes.
>>
>>8237807
>"What she REALLY means is ..."
>"The SPIRIT of the video is ..."
You should stick to what she says and not the "spirit" you feel in her videos or what you think she "really means".
Fans like you tend to interpret their idol in the best way possible. What you are writing has nothing to do with Blaire's actual videos. She thinks that being a tranny is a mental illness. She thinks of herself as a man, who believes to be a woman and needs to become one because there is not other "cure".
>"These people generally speak for trans people and other minorities as authorities and educators, and when the general public sees that and rightfully thinks it's retarded, there's good chance of it colouring their views on the minorities in question when they don't have a lot of personal experience (especially for trans people, who are a minute population and generally stealth IRL, so very few people will ever have knowingly interacted with one personally)."
Blaire got popular with going against Milo Stewart and Riley J. Dennis. Both(!) of them together have approx. 50.000 youtube followers. Blaire has around 300.000 followers right now. Milo or Justin were never popular to begin with. They never really shaped the opinion cis people have of transgender people. Their channels got some views because SJWs watched them. That is the rule of youtube: people watch videos that reflect their own opinion. After youtubers like Blaire "argued" against Milo and Justin the latter gained more popularity - now in a negative sense (it's still very low and their channels are far from being successful!). People like Blaire created the phenomenon that viewers now watch SJWs like Milo to make fun of them. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, but without that negative popularity Blaire and others gave these guys they would have never been noticed by public. At all.
>>
>>8232992
>being able to change a letter on my government ID proves that society no longer values truth
flawless logic
>>
>>8237852
>what you think she "really means".
It's not what I think, it's what she's literally stated. It's the argument she puts forth throughout her whole video, and she's clarified herself multiple times on twitter and in livestreams.
And I completely disagree with her that the difference is unimportant, but that's her actual view.
>Fans like you tend to interpret their idol in the best way possible.
I disagree with shitloads of what she says and don't find her particularly intelligent at all, I just also happen to think you're wrong.
>She thinks of herself as a man
She thinks of herself as a male who's living as a woman and doing what she can to attain a female body to alleviate dysphoria. Which is all true.
>After youtubers like Blaire "argued" against Milo and Justin the latter gained more popularity
And? Blaire's not the cause of that, she's just adding another constructive voice to the fray, considering a lot of the people who popularised channels like Milo and Justin's are idiots like LeafyIsHere who literally just berate people as freaks for 10 minutes for an audience of ignorant 12 year olds.
You can't dismiss Blaire as unoriginal for hopping on a bandwagon, while simultaneously holding her indirectly responsible for creating the bandwagon in the first place. People are going to make popularising response videos to retards with or without her, and doing it like Blaire does in a way that provides an actual counterpoint is a damn site better than when people like Leafy do it with nothing but insults for an audience of 4.4million subscribers.
>>
>>8237884
>"It's not what I think, it's what she's literally stated."
Her video is titled "transgenderism is a mental disorder" and not "gender dysphoria is a mental disorder". That is a great difference.
Her "argumen"t goes like this:
>Transgenderism...
>... goes along with gender dysphoria, ...
>... which is a mental disorder....
>... because the DSM-5 as the "leading source of academic information" says so.
>Conclusion: Transgenderism is a mental
disorder just like claustrophobia etc.
She does not really define, what she means with "transgenderism", but strongly implies that she means by this simply "transsexuality" or "being trans".
She makes some mistakes in her "argumentation":
1. She equals transgenderism, i.e. being transsexual, with having gender dysphoria. That is not true at all since gender dysphoria stems from being trans, but is not identical to it. They are not equal just because they often appear together. The ICD-10 states correctly:
"F 64.0 Transsexualism: A desire to live and be accepted as a member of the opposite sex, USUALLY accompanied by a sense of discomfort with, or inappropriateness of, one's anatomic sex, and a wish to have surgery and hormonal treatment to make one's body as congruent as possible with one's preferred sex."
The truth is that being transsexual is a condition and gender dysphoria is the great discomfort, which more often than not comes along with it. The ICD-11 will reflect that (coming soon in 2018).
The thing with gender dysphoria is that transsexuals are able to fight it and get it under control. There are some young transitioners, who experience very little gender dysphoria since they do not make it through male puberty in the first place. Also there are transsexuals, who transitioned and have no gender dysphoria anymore (but are still transsexual people!).
2.She relies solely on the DSM-5, which is NOT the leading academic source of information. The ICD-10 is.
(continued...)
>>
(continuation)
>>8237884
Her one and only (authoritative) argument is
>the DSM-5 says so.
She's right that there are so called transtrenders (like Milo and Justin Dennis..), who are not really trans. They -should- show signs of gender dysphoria since they are neither young transitioners (obviously) nor have they transitioned (also obviously). Calling them "not really trans" is really not far fetched. But the conclusion that having gender dysphoria equals being trans is still wrong. Milo and Justin Dennis are not trans because they show no gender dysphoria - under their current conditions-. Again, that does not mean that being transsexual is the same as having gender dysphoria.
Because she equals being trans with having gender dysphoria she thinks that she is a man, who fights his gender dysphoria by faking the life of a woman. For her, there is no underlying condition that makes her dysphoric, dysphoria itself is the condition, "trans*" is just another name for it. She said so herself in one of her videos, it was a skype conversation with that feminist girl with big tits, if I remember it correctly.
Well, that is an interesting view, especially when you consider that she's trans herself. But it's NOT a reflection of what the academic world thinks. The clownish thing starts, when Blaire actually thinks that she is on the "scientific" side backed up by the majority of the scientific community. She is just as self-righteous as the SJWs she's fighting against, when it comes to trans-issues. And her views are almost just as crazy.
I'm not particulary against "crazy views" and I want to state again that her main failure is to think that she is in some way rational.
>>
(2nd continuation)
>>8237884
>"You can't dismiss Blaire as unoriginal for hopping on a bandwagon, while simultaneously holding her indirectly responsible for creating the bandwagon in the first place."
Hopping on a bandwagon makes it stronger, doesn't it? I'd be futile to find the originator of the anti-Milo-Justin movement. Blaire's still unoriginal and still responsible like all the others, who do the same. A man, who actively joins a group of people beating up a single person, is still partly responsible for the act, though he does not start the trouble in the first place.
>"People are going to make popularising response videos to retards with or without her"
That like saying that Hitler would have killed the jews without the help of SS officer XY anyway, so XY is not really responsible
>>
File: 1473812219322.jpg (34KB, 573x449px) Image search:
[Google]
34KB, 573x449px
>>8234475
>>
>>8238132
>passable
>tfw even chasers won't have you
>>
>>8238064
>>8238075
>>8238108
>Her video is titled "transgenderism is a mental disorder" and not "gender dysphoria is a mental disorder". That is a great difference.
Not to her. I agree that there’s a big difference between those two phrases, but you have to take into account the context of the person saying it, and Blaire thinks close enough is good enough.
And the title =/= the video =/= everything else she's stated on the subject. Acting like a title trumps everything else she’s ever said is retarded.
>She makes some mistakes in her "argumentation":
I don't disagree with any of this, and like I said, Blaire sees the difference between transexualism and gender dysphoria as unimportant semantics. You don't, and I don't either, but the fact that she means gender dysphoria is the mental disorder is very obvious. It’s pretty much impossible to interpret it otherwise.
Even in the portion you quoted, she states that transgenderism GOES ALONG with gender dysphoria, meaning the latter is the mental disorder.
Blaire herself has also stated she has pretty much no dysphoria any more, aligning with what you say about dysphoria going away with treatment etc, and in her video she clearly presented transition as an often vital treatment for dysphoria.
1/3
>>
>>8238177
>But the conclusion that having gender dysphoria equals being trans is still wrong.
Again, you're getting bogged down in specific words that don't have the same meaning to you as they do to her.
Blaire is living entirely as a woman and has stated she no longer has significant dysphoria, obviously she doesn't think she's suddenly not trans anymore. But having gender dysphoria, in her view, is a prerequisite to transitioning and becoming a transexual, since people without dysphoria don’t actually transition.
Blaire has also stated that not all people who have gender dysphoria should automatically transition, since it’s not the best choice for some people, or the most convenient to rush into at any time. That means these people simultaneously have gender dysphoria without being trans, ie putting the false conclusion “having gender dysphoria equals being trans” in her mouth is a misrepresentation of her views.
Colloquially, people very often use ‘trans’ as a term to mean “person with gender dysphoria” regardless of whether or not they’ve transitioned or plan to transition. When people say Milo and Justin are not really trans, that can mean both that they haven’t legitimately transitioned, and that they don’t have gender dysphoria.
>Because she equals being trans with having gender dysphoria she thinks that she is a man
No, that's you putting words in her mouth based on your view of what these words mean and the importance of the implications they hold. You can say that ‘by her logic’, she should think of herself as a man, thus proving her logic is flawed. But that's not something she has ever actually said, and to act like it’s her actual viewpoint is retarded and/or dishonest.
She has said time and time again that she accepts that she is biologically male rather than female. That doesn't mean she sees herself as a man.
2/3
>>
>>8238182
>For her, there is no underlying condition that makes her dysphoric,
Bit of a sharp turn here, what underlying condition would there even be? I’ve never even heard of that. Outside of people who were mistaken in their transition, and just felt ‘dysphoria’ or symptoms closely mimicking dysphoria as a result of an unrelated disorder or trauma.
>dysphoria itself is the condition, "trans*" is just another name for it.
…Yes. What are you not getting? See above about colloquial usage of the term trans.
>The clownish thing starts, when Blaire actually thinks that she is on the "scientific" side backed up by the majority of the scientific community.
Yeah, won’t argue with you there.
>Hopping on a bandwagon makes it stronger, doesn't it?
Not if you bring in a little more sense into it than "CRINGIEST KID ON THE INTERNET SAVAGE"
>A man, who actively joins a group of people beating up a single person,
Except Blaire isn't beating people up, metaphorically or otherwise. She's arguing counterpoints in a genre that was popularised by pure insult videos that broadcasted people like Justin and Milo to large audiences who don't understand the difference between them and actual trans people.
>That like saying that Hitler would have killed the jews without the help of SS officer XY anyway, so XY is not really responsible
Missing the point. Holding Blaire responsible for the genre's existence is retarded, holding her responsible for her own actions within that genre is fine. And even if everything she's ever said is wrong, her participation in that genre still provides a counterpoint and exists as evidence that not all trans people think the same, in a genre populated by people with much larger audiences than hers who breeze by that fact and broadcast retarded SJWs to audiences of people who have no idea what being trans even means.
>>
>>8238177
>>8238182
>>8238185
Sorry, I will not respond to you in great detail. You strongly implied that I am a retard three times, which I don't like very much.
>"She has said time and time again that she accepts that she is biologically male rather than female. That doesn't mean she sees herself as a man."
She sees herself as a "caricature" of a woman and does not believe that she is a woman socially but rather a man, who is playing a character.
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=blaire+white+laci+green
((39:50-40:30)
>"Except Blaire isn't beating people up, metaphorically or otherwise."
I compared the two scenarios logically and not substantial.
>Blaire is a counterpoint to Leafy
I think that almost every single youtuber is a counterpoint to Leafy, so I do not really get your "at least she's better than Leafy" argument here.
>questions that there is some underlying condition that causes gender dysphoria
Again: My whole point was that being trans and having gender dysphoria are not exactly the same thing. Most scientists would agree that you are born trans and experience gender dysphoria at some point in your life.
Blaire dismisses ANY biological reason for being trans (and thus eventually developing gender dysphoria), which is simply not what the scientific mainstream says. She rather thinks that being trans equals having gender dypshoria, which equals being a mentally ill like a white person, who believes to be black.
>"Blaire is living entirely as a woman and has stated she no longer has significant dysphoria, obviously she doesn't think she's suddenly not trans anymore. But having gender dysphoria, in her view, is a prerequisite to transitioning and becoming a transexual, since people without dysphoria don’t actually transition."
Blaire's thinking is incoherent - surprise!
Also you cannot "become" a transsexual. You either are transsexual or you are not. And as a transsexual you decide to transition or to repress.
>>
>>8234593
how buttmad do you have to be to save images like that, calm down TERFy
>>
yessssss
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-mgaPAJmyM
>>
I agree with the anti-sjw stuff she spouts, but I prefer Theryn Meyer a fair bit more.
they share pretty much the same views outside of trans issues
>>
>>8241615
A live chat to respond to only 2 /lgbt/ threads? Maybe I should go look at the archive.
>>
>>8241638
Theryn bitches about being misgendered by Blaire but misgenders other trans women herself.
>>
>>8241654
why do you think it's just /lgbt/, there was a few tweeting her /b/ threads and stuff
>>
>>8232678
this picture really shows how little she actually passes, what a trip, shes like ya straight up hon wew she just really slathers on the foundation and shades the fuck out of the sides of that giant nose, also hiding the hooded eyes by that weird eyeshadow thingy
>>
>>8241661
I've never seen a /b/ thread about her.
>>
>>8241740
people have been sending her chan archives for awhile, this stream was overdue
>>
>>8238132
Why do you keep sucking his dick Trent. I mean yeah, he looks better than Blaire's numale boyfriend, but still.
>>
>>8241798
He's a fit alpha. The perfect model for an ftm.
>>
>>8239658
>She sees herself as a "caricature" of a woman
Of a FEMALE.
>but rather a man
Again, you are making your own presumptive conclusions about what something she’s said must mean, rather than actually taking in the meaning she actually gave you. I’ll eat my hat if Blaire has ever once said she sees herself as a MAN. She sees herself as a biological MALE who lives as a woman.
>who is playing a character
That’s not what caricature means. And Blaire has also retracted her use of this word and offered up less inflammatory compromises such as ‘mimic’.
You’re conflating the physical with the social. All Blaire has said is that trans people mimic the physical form of the opposite sex as best as science can offer, since they're not born with it, but will never truly be the opposite sex.
It has nothing to do with the social role of being a man or woman. While Blaire has danced around outright calling herself a woman, she clearly says she lives as a woman and holds the cultural position of a woman. She has never once referred to herself as a man, and has also talked about people who’ve called her a man and how it’s not only rude but that it doesn’t make any sense socially to refer to her as anything other that a woman.
I don’t see how you can justify the claim that she sees herself as a man, outside of ignoring everything she’s said and drawing your own wild conclusions from statements taken out of context.
Again, if you want to explore these conclusions to expose how her logic as flawed, that’s fine! Theryn Meyer made a great video response discussing why it’s actually a big deal that Blaire conflated transexualism with gender dysphoria when discussing it in the context of mental illness, and dangerous conclusions that can be drawn, but she never implied Blaire was actually arguing for those conclusions.
>I compared the two scenarios logically and not substantial.
wut
1/3 (oy vey)
>>
>>8243423
>I think that almost every single youtuber is a counterpoint to Leafy, so I do not really get your "at least she's better than Leafy" argument here.
My point is that people like Leafy (and there are others like him) broadcast people like Milo and Justin to very large audiences and feed into the misconception that this is what being trans is. People like Blaire might also give Milo and Justin more exposure (to a way smaller audience), but in a more constructive way that actually debunks their claims instead of simply insulting them as freaks.
Holding Blaire responsible for giving these people exposure is silly. Even if you think this entire response video genre is tacky, people like Blaire are the more constructive side of it. And without them, the only people who’d give Milo and Justin exposure are people who conflate them and their views with real trans people.
>Again: My whole point was that being trans and having gender dysphoria are not exactly the same thing. Most scientists would agree that you are born trans and experience gender dysphoria at some point in your life.
Can you define what you mean by the terms 'trans' and 'gender dysphoria'? Because I honestly have no idea what you mean here.
>Blaire dismisses ANY biological reason for being trans
...What? She talks about evidence of feminisiation in the brains of trans women all the time.
>She rather thinks that being trans equals having gender dypshoria, which equals being a mentally ill like a white person, who believes to be black.
No, this is another complete projection on your part about what 'must' be meant when it's said that trans people are mentally ill. Again, you're hung up on words and ignoring what she's actually saying.
She's even compared Justin Dennis to Rachel Dolezal when explaining why she won't refer to him as a woman and doesn't see him as trans, with actual transexuals like herself being real black people in the analogy.
2/3
>>
>>8243426
>Blaire's thinking is incoherent - surprise!
What's incoherent about that?
>Also you cannot "become" a transsexual. You either are transsexual or you are not.
Your usage of the term transexual here seems to conflict with how I interpreted you to be using it, so again if you could clarify what you mean? The language surrounding trans issues is an everchanging mess, I really don’t want to start an argument over definitions, I just want to understand what you’re actually saying.
From where I'm coming from: a transexual is someone who has medically transitioned. You become a transexual when you transition and live as the opposite sex. But you are born with gender dysphoria, the condition that may cause you to pursue transition (and thus become a transexual).
The same way a gay person is born gay, but not born openly gay or in a gay relationship. Or one might be born depressed, but not born on antidepressants. Or born with a bad limb, but not born an amputee.
A transexual is someone who is actually living as the opposite sex. As I said earlier, the use of trans to mean 'person with gender dysphoria' (as in repressed, pre-transition etc) is simply a colloquialism.
To be clear, you don't have to accept this definition at all. I'm just clarifying what I've meant when I've used the terms, and would appreciate you clarifying your own usage too so we can better understand each other, otherwise I don't see much point going forward since I have no idea what you're even talking about.
>>
>>8241615
FUCKNUGGETS I'LL BE AT WORK
Thread posts: 82
Thread images: 9
Thread images: 9