which is better? also who wins ? whats the difference which

>>31157940
Caliber dependent answer, dumbass.

Just between these 2?

1911 for 80% of uses, revolver for 20%.

Actually that's a fairly good metaphor for semi-automatic pistols vs revolvers in general. There's a bit more overlap though.

>>31157940
Semi for just about any situation you actually need to shoot something.

Revolver for collecting and shooting for fun.

>>31157954
ah but is it 20% of uses 80% of the time? that 80:20 rule is a bitch

Anyone able to lend some advise?
>>31157810

File: 1472541669917.gif (3MB, 267x200px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 267x200px

>>31157940

It's a matter of Your Personal Shooting skill in most cases. I Prefer revolvers for reliability, accuracy, and stopping power. I'm a crack shot, so I'd rather fling a 357 then the .45.

>>31157940
7 rounds of 45 slow and fat vs 5-6 rounds of 357 man stopper.

>>31157940
Depends if you care about hunting for your spent shells after you've used your gun or not

>>31158590
>.357
>Stoppin powah

I'd like you to take a quick stop by google and tell me what .357 inches is in millimeters.

>>31158628
I'd rather pierce and end it with 1 shot, than to punch him with 8.

>>31158628
Lol really? 9mm is weak sauce. 330 ft/lbs of energy from a 9mm pistol or 900 ft/lbs from a 357 mag revolver. I take revolver

>>31158842

That's not a wonder 9, it's a 1911, but you do bring another form of topic, which is capacity. 6 vs 15. great for saturation and multiple targets, but not needed if you're a dead eye.

>>31158628

... 357 mag has been a man stopper for 80 years what are you saying m8

File: image.jpg (69KB, 639x359px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 639x359px

>>31157940

44 magnum master race can not be beaten friend.

>>31158628
Id like you to take a quick stop and google the muzzle energy difference between .45 ACP and .357 Magnum

>>31158962
.45 has been a man stopper for 105.
9mm Luger has been doing it for 114.

>>31158962
This semi-fag is just butt hurt that it took half a century for a practical semi-auto round to come out that could equal .357. And they are equally butthurt most semi-fags are too effiminate to even shoot 10mm in the first place.

>>31159538
>.45
>9mm
>Manstopper

Nigger this isnt 1916, .32 acp isnt the standard anymore.

>>31159583
You're right.

9mm is.

Because it does just as good as a job as your lousy .357 Mag.

>>31157940
>he doesn't have a nice 1911 and a nice revolver
What's it like being poor?

1911,hands down.

>>31157940
If the question is auto vs revolver, something like an fnx chambered in .40 super would be almost as powerful as a magnum revolver cartridge with over twice the capacity

>>31157940
.357 and .44 weren't in the ER meta analysis /k/ loves to quote so I don't know.

File: 1413754801759.jpg (86KB, 500x710px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 500x710px

>>31158924
>6 vs 15.
>1911
>15