Is it true that the Council of Ephesus was rigged against

>>2829266
No, that's fucking retarded and that poster is just an edge lord contrarian

>>2829266
I'm pretty sure councils can't be rigged

>>2829266
The conclusion is proper. Maybe not the way the argument is set up, but Catholicism is fake Christianity, and always has been.

File: IMG_5786.jpg (24KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 200x200px

>>2829506

>>2829506
Retard

>>2829266
That claim can only make sense if one assumes Nestorius was right. On the matter of Christian Doctrine, who can say Nestorius was right, and on whose authority?

>>2829266
I think there was a lot of political trickery at the councils. Assuming the outcome was guided by God rather than a product of politicking and popular opinion is absurd

>>2830401
>Assuming the outcome was guided by God rather than a product of politicking and popular opinion is absurd
"And the gates of hell will not prevail against the Church"

If Nestorianism was true, it wouldn't have gone extinct of phased out of its churches in favor of the orthodox Christology.

>>2830453
That is of course an article of faith, and thus not worth debating

>>2830453
Nestorianism still exists

>>2831335
No it doesnt

File: IMG_0729.png (1MB, 602x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 602x1024px

Nestorius did nothing wrong

He was /ourguy/

>>2832213
I don't know the exact stance right now, but the Nestorian church defended Nestorius in the late 90s

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mar_Dinkhaa#Middle_Eastern_and_Syriac_ecumenism

On the other hand they made an agreement with the Pope right after that

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Christological_Declaration_Between_the_Catholic_Church_and_the_Assyrian_Church_of_the_East

So it's not completely clear. Or maybe they denounced it a while ago and I haven't read it, but probably not.

Keep in mind that plenty of them converted to Chaldean Catholicism in the Ottoman Empire.

>>2832263
Fixed link:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mar_Dinkha#Middle_Eastern_and_Syriac_ecumenism

File: Purged.jpg (59KB, 613x599px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 613x599px

>>2832230

What a silly, archaic discussion.

>>2832291
You're on the wrong board

>>2832318
This is the only board I frequent.

>>2832263
Assyrian Church of The East isn't exactly Nestorian even though they revere Nestorius.

>>2832318
/his/ isn't a safespace for Christians.

>>2832356
Theology is & Humanities, isn't it?

>>2832420
>& Humanities

>>2832356
/his/ is a Byzantine board

>>2829506

t. jew

>>2832428
i though it was a neo-ottomanism forum

File: 144.jpg (43KB, 600x638px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 600x638px

>>2832437
You thought wrong.

>>2830453
>survival of the council-est
dis some christological darwinism or some shit

>>2829266
What does it matter if it was rigged, it was God's plan for the true faith to emerge once more. Like seeds in a field of weeds, Chaledonian Christianity emerged, then when those seeds were infected their side shoots fell off and became orthodoxy, allowing the main shoot to fully grow into the bread used in every mass across the world
>>2832428
No it's anti khergit

>>2832431
>Jews would back the religion that overall helped them the most and did its best to protect them
>>2832356
It's not a safe space as Catholics talk to orthodoxies In a civilised manner, then proddy scum ruin it all

>>2833875
True Christianity started with the Reformation