Does the fact that Ashkenazi Jews come from Khazaria null the concept of a promised Jewish holy land in Israel?
No because the khazaria theory is anti semitic bullshit.
>>2691204
you the antisemetic one, just because theyre mongols they arent less jewish
>>2691204
Is it though? I am not antisemitic btw, I've heard this argument a few times
>>2691204
this
>>2691200
That theory has been repeatedly debunked
>http://anthromadness.blogspot.com/2015/05/the-khazar-theory-give-it-rest.html?m=1
>>2691200
>Does the fact that /his/ has become /pol/ with dates just like everyone thought it would null the concept of a promised history and humanities discussion board on 4chan?
Why does everyone throws the word anti semitic like its supposed to be insulting?
>>2691247
Play Crusader Kings 2 you dipshit. They got jews in Khazaria.
>>2691262
Anti semitic does not have to be loaded or a value judgement. Similar to racism. They are inherently neutral terms but are not used that way often. Though anti Zionist is probably a better descriptor of the khazaria theory than anti semitic.
I hate Jews as much as the next /pol/ack but the Khazar theory has failed every test: genetic, linguistic, cultural, etc.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khazar_hypothesis_of_Ashkenazi_ancestry
so where the fuck are ashknazi's from? /His/ told me the levant isnt white so they couldnt have come from isreal
>>2691824
They have Y-chromosomes from the Middle East and X-chromosomes from Italy.
That's the really short answer.
>>2691834
that makes even less sense
>>2691841
It means Jews migrated during the Roman era.
Interesting to see it's not a valid theory, if that's the case why are/were there so many Jews in Ukraine? My GF family is Jewish and immigrated from Ukraine many years ago.
>>2691871
Yes, the reason for lighter skin is natural selection among Jews. White skin is beneficial in the European climate.
>>2691889
thats fucking retarded, now i dont even know if you were just shitposting
>>2691247
>anthromadness.blogspot
>>2691200
Ashkenazi Jews are partially Khazar, partially Slavic/Germanic and partially South Italian. The entire zionist/Israeli shit is the biggest literal LARP this world has ever seen, they even collectively started learning Hebrew from scratch after speaking a German dialect (Yiddish) for hundreds of years. The fact that they're displacing people who are actual ethnic Semites is even more absurd.
It's as if a group of niggers in the Congo became enamored with Shakespeare and Chaucer, decided they are actually a group of misplaced Anglo-Saxons, collectively learned English and then invaded England and toss the actual English people out claiming they are the frauds.
It's fucking absurd.
>>2691971
>It's as if a group of niggers in the Congo became enamored with Shakespeare and Chaucer, decided they are actually a group of misplaced Anglo-Saxons, collectively learned English and then invaded England and toss the actual English people out claiming they are the frauds.
It's already happening.
I'm not sure if I even understand how the White supremacist strategy (this old, pre alt-right one anyway) is even supposed to work.
Far as I can tell, it's to bring solidarity to the White peoples by exposing them to Jewish tricks, and the way to do that is to delegitimize in White minds any Jewish claim to the land of Palenstine, through conspiracy theories like Holocaust denial and Khazarism?
>hur dur saying european are from a european jewish state is racist
fuck off, jews aren't arabs, semites don't have blond hair and blue eyes
>>2691268
Noice
>>2691310
>I hate Jews as much as the next /pol/ack but the Khazar theory has failed every test: genetic, linguistic, cultural, etc.
not only that, it's only spread by other Jews. It's a theory STRICTLY pushed by Jews (Arthur Koestler and Shlomo Sand)
ITT: idiots that don't realize over 60% of Israeli Jews are middle-eastern
>>2691868
I want to know this too.
>>2691868
>>2692327
While the Jewish presence in what's now the Ukraine dates to at least the 11th century and is possibly older, most of them seem to have come in from a wave of expulsions from further west in Europe (think modern day Germany and the Czech areas, as well as some from France) around the 13th-14th centuries.
I don't get it, if it's wrong why are there Khazarian Jews then? There's a letter sent from a Spanish Jew sent to the Khazars and the Khazar king Joseph responded explaining their conversion to Judaism. So even if not all Ashkenazi Jews are Khazarian, a good chunk of them are.
http://www.celticnz.co.nz/Nazca/Khazar%20Conversion.htm
I still have not had a proper answer yet. Can no one lay this to rest? Is this real or not?
>>2691200
If Jews were from Khazaria, then they would have a much different appearance. Also, what would that mean for actual Jews?
The curliness of Jewish hair, the shape of their noses and the tone of their hair, eyes and skin is enough proof of their Afro-Asiatic origin.
>>2693817
It's simple: khazars are not Jews. Ashkenazi Jews are a lie and not real Jews. They just pretend to be for various reasons. Normal Jews actually had a lot to suffer because of the khazars.
>>2691971
"Jew" is a religious identity. Race has fuck all to do with it unlike Anglo-Saxon.
>>2693875
>Jew isn't an ethnicity
>>2691868
Jews settled Eastern Europe after repeated expulsions from the West.
Khazaria was an ethnically very mixed nation, like all steppe empires.
Its ruling elite choose judaism for practical reasons, to avoid christian and islam influence. It wasn't a state religion, iit was adopted by perhaps a few ten thousand at most.
And there is no record of this judaistic group after Khazaria fell.
>>2691942
>.blogspot
that's what i was thinkin....
though, he does have works cited
>>2691200
They aren't Khazars but their claim to Israel is no more legitimate than the Italians.
>>2691310
>>2691834
>genetic
What did Nasser mean by this?