[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

How did Spain go from a world power with a vast empire to the

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 3

File: 1485342195568.jpg (86KB, 639x960px) Image search: [Google]
1485342195568.jpg
86KB, 639x960px
How did Spain go from a world power with a vast empire to the poorest and shittiest country in Europe?

What went wrong?
>>
Read a wikipedia article on Spain.
>>
>>2274350
Fascism has nothing to do with your question concerning Spain as a "world power"
>>
>>2274368
Given that Fascism stopped Spain from turning into a USSR puppet state run by bandits and thieves and transitioned peacefully into democracy, I'd say yes, it did have a hand in democracy in Spain.
>>
>>2274380
>le republicans were all hardline marxist communists meme

epic
>>
>>2274380
By world power with a vast empire he's probably referring to Spain in colonial times. Or he's too stupid to know the difference between different eras, putting Charles V and Franco, and Communism side by side.
>>
>>2274393
Not all of them, but the ones that would be running the show if the Fascists hadn't won either were, or were taking money from the USSR.
>>
not enough oceanic climate farmland
>>
They fucking deserve for destroy American's society. Hope they all burn in hell.
>>
>>2274419
>They fucking deserve for destroy American's society. Hope they all burn in hell.
What? Spicland was a lot more prosperous and stable under Spain than after independence.Sudacas are to blame for all the shit that they got as they are chimps and barely human
>>
>>2274368
Franco wasn't a fascist. Nor was his government.
>>
>>2274380
>>2274466
He was authoritarian, and in most people's minds authoritarian = fascist. Both are absolute dogshit though.
>>2274350
Spain is a classic example of extreme political polarization that ultimately ripped the nation apart and left it as a weak country. The effects of the Spanish Civil War are still felt in Spain to this day, with a poor economy, poor land development, and some very strange situations, like a virtually autonomous communist town in Spain.
>>
>>2274350
that pic is so stupid on so many levels

>>2274491
>virtually autonomous communist town in Spain.
which?
>>
>>2274498
I was referring to
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marinaleda
But I wouldn't be surprised if there were more.
>>
>>2274380
More than 500 people were murdered during the "peaceful" transition

Also, for all intents and purporses Franco was a fascist, maybe even more retrograde.
>>
>>2274500
your own link says it's not virtually autonomous, two thirds of its spending comes from the state

sounds like a pretty cool place to live in though
>>
>>2274557
Autonomous may not be the right word, divergent was more what I meant.
>>
>>2274491
>like a virtually autonomous communist town in Spain
It is not weird.It is a major that spends his budget on meme cooperatives and what not.They are no comunist nor autonomous
>>
>>2274491
>and in most people's minds authoritarian = fascist.
Anyone who actually thinks this deserves to be shot.
>>
>>2274350

Spain wasn't relevant long before Fascist Spain and certainly play no significantly positive role in modern times. This is due in part with the collapse of their overseas empire through a combination of really dumbass leaders in an absolute monarchy followed by equally incompetent republics back to an even dumber king.

And before THAT time, Spain participated in many wars that drained its coffers and provided few real long term benefits. Regardless if they won or not.

It didnt help that all that silver being brought from overseas reduced the actual value of it.
>>
>>2274380
I wish the Republicans had won

Free gulags for you
>>
>shittiest country in Europe

Its no world player but its far from "shitty".
>>
File: spain.png (28KB, 220x300px) Image search: [Google]
spain.png
28KB, 220x300px
>>2274755
>Spain wasn't relevant long before Fascist Spain
>relevant long before Fascist Spain
>Fascist Spain
Jesus Christ.
>>
>>2274755
>Fascist Spain
SPAIN WAS NEVER FASCIST. They had a government that allied with Fascist. That is all.
>>
>>2274788
>>2274789
As if being franquist made it less worse
>>
>>2274788

You know exactly what I meant, dont bother making shitty threads when all you're just going to do is nit pick things.
>>
What else would you expect from Latinos?
>>
>>2274350

>I know literally nothing about Spain: the post

The economic boom under Franco only began when he dumped all the fascists out of government and invited in fucking Opus Dei to run the economy
>>
>>2274550
I'd say more retrograde considering his piousness.
>>
>>2274832
At least they weren't pants on head retarded like Hitler or incompetent like Mussolini.
>>2274844
Nationalist Spain wasn't fascist, nor was Republican Spain communist. Nationalist was authoritarian and right-wing, Republican was (probably going to be) left-moderate with socialist bits.
>>
>>2275309
>latinos
>In Iberia
>>
>>2275309
leave you mongoloid
>>
Even during the height of Spain's power during the colonial age, the country was always in massive debt. After they lost a huge source of free income when they lost their colonies, that finally caught up to them.
>>
>>2275383
>Even during the height of Spain's power during the colonial age, the country was always in massive debt. After they lost a huge source of free income when they lost their colonies, that finally caught up to them.
The revenue from America was never the main source of income.And Spain in the XVIII century when it wasnpt rulled by Autistic Germans was more solvent than countries like France
>>
>>2275383
Spain was in massive debt because Charles V paid literally world's worth of gold to get elected then Austria's and Empire's wars was funded by Spain, Spain was paying for 30 years war, wars against Ottomans, the 80 years war and more. After Charles II died off and Sun King's Grandson took the throne, they reformed the country and Spain became quite robust economically and was doing okay, even gaining territory and diversifying their economy.

Their inflation and debt problem was literally perpetuated by Habsburgs refusing to fix the country's economy and instead just selling debts away and let inflation grow because they were happy just pouring silver into any problem that showed up, tax only the poorest and let the aristocracy do whatever while the country slowly collapsed under its own weight.
>>
File: carlos II.jpg (193KB, 990x1533px) Image search: [Google]
carlos II.jpg
193KB, 990x1533px
>>2275407
Charlie the economist fixed Spain's economy in 1 reign. He is underrated af
>>
>Known as "the Bewitched" (Spanish: el Hechizado),[1] he is noted for his extensive physical, intellectual, and emotional disabilities and his consequent ineffectual rule.
>>
>>2275423
He didn't do shit but he was such a non-factor some of the bureaucrats under him managed to stay away from Habsburgs "politics" and do something for the country instead. Bourbons fixed the country after him in the image of Louis XIV's reforms.

If the Spanish let Joseph fix Spain in Republican France's model it would also get much better but they refused to acknowledge him. Rallying behind another French monarch whom after "winning" his reign proceeded the fuck the country over.
>>
>>2275430
>ineffectual rule
>Destroyed inflation
>Increased purchasing power
>Increased the revenue
>Didn't lose any posession
>Ended hunger and under his reign there was a massive population growth
>Started a period of peace after 2 centuries of continous war
Charlie the economist was the greatest Habsburgh monarch in history
>>
>>2275435
>do something for the country
>One of the biggest deflactions in history
>do something for the country
Phillip when he arrived to Spain was surprised as how well the country was running and the revenues that it had
>Joseph fix Spain in Republican France's model
Joseph didn't have the support of the colonies and didn't have any claims on the throne.His reign would have been as shitty as Ferdinand's was.
>>
>>2275447
He had support in colonies actually, but he didn't have any support in mainland Spain but it was because Spanish for some reason decided to rally behind a tyrant. As opposed to Joseph who was a reform minded and quite benign person. Who has been also successful with reforms in Italy prior to coming to Spain.
>>
>>2275438
>His jaw was so badly deformed (an extreme example of the so-called Habsburg jaw) that he could barely speak or chew. Fearing the frail child would be overtaxed, his caretakers did not force Charles to attend school. The indolence of the young Charles was indulged to such an extent that at times he was not expected to be clean. When his half-brother Don Juan José of Austria, an illegitimate son of Philip IV, obtained power by exiling the queen mother from court, he covered his nose and insisted that the king at least brush his hair.[citation needed]
>>
>>2275468
>He had support in colonies actually
Who? Most colonies formed Juntas that claimed that they were rulling in the name of king Ferdinand.His only support maybe in Cuba and the Phillipines but that's it.
>Spanish for some reason decided to rally behind the prince
He never rulled before and was the rightful heir and they were opposing an invader that was occupaying Spain with French .It was not weird by any fucking measure
>>
>>2274350
La cigale ayant chanté tout l'été se trouva for décousue quand la bise fut venue.
>>
>>2275338
>At least they weren't pants on head retarded like Hitler or incompetent like Mussolini
Nope, they were pants on head retarded like Hitler AND incompetent like Mussolini
>>
>>2275579
The Philippines as a colony and Spain didn't actually interact that much. The Philippines cost more to maintain than it brought in, so a lot of autonomy was given to spanish officials and the catholic church in their administration.
That lot didn't have a position on the matters of the continent, because it was way too far away for them to give a shit.
>>
>>2274350
8th highest GDP... What the fuck are you saying, faggot?
I'm Spanish and I know what ACTUALLY happened.

>Let's start from the second republic.

It was formed by two governments. The first one (1931-1935) was a right-winged conservative one which was formed by the CEDA.
As the economical crisis at those years in Spain hadn't changed, there was elected the People's Front, a left-winged coallition of socialists (PSOE), anarchists, communists and separatists. Once they were elected they made some political and social reforms as the agrary reform that helped a lot to journalists, they improved the public sector a lot... But what they've done wasn't right to the retrograde church and the military, so they couped against them. But they failed,, and it was the start of the civil war.

Once it finished, there was 15 years of hungry. There was only possible to eat bread and some vegetabls (if you were lucky). At the end of the 60's Franco started to build some hotels and skycrapers at the Mediterranean coast, and it was the start of the cause of the economic crisis that it's in Spain nowadays, only living for the tourism and with no industry.
>>
>What went wrong?

the eternal Habsburg
>>
>>2276343
>he thinks Bourbons are Habsburgs
>>
>>2276347
habsburg apologist detected

>start the great war
>have autists online defend your breath 100 years later
>>
>>2274463
They were better off in precolumbian times.
>>
>>2276354
>he unironically thinks 20th century Spain has anything to do with Habsburgs
The amount of retardation on this board never ceases to baffle me
>>
>>2274368
you're technically right.

"Behind the scenes, and unnoticed
by the major portion of foreign news
correspondents, the clergy, the informed
laity and the Christian educators
are busy piecing together the
abstract structure of a Christian State
based upon "Quadragesimo Anno"
and the Gospel of Jesus Christ."

https://www.unz.org/Pub/SocialJustice-1939may01-00001

https://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19310515_quadragesimo-anno.html
>>
>>2276316
Barcelona Anarchist detected

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_miracle
>>
>>2274788

And yet, they spent the Napoleonic period getting kicked around between the frogs and bongs.
>>
>>2276347
Borbons were better than Assburgs. Onky Charlie the economist was decent form that bunch
>>
>the poorest and shittiest country in Europe?
Even among BRICKS that they not in the bottom tier.
The true suffering of Spain is that a centralized government only works if it neglects nothing.
So far its neglecting most of the country, and giving its best effort to inspire hate in the Basque.
>>
>>2278477
>So far its neglecting most of the country, and giving its best effort to inspire hate in the Basque.
How so? The Basques have more priviledges than anyone in the fucking country.
>>
>>2277390
>they spent the Napoleonic period
Could you just be more specific? Spain won most wars against Britain than the other way around. When Napoleon raised the king and his heir were borderline retarded and the war was basically carried by militias that did more than an ok job.
>>
>>2278615
Maybe I'm misinterpreting him, but "hate in the basque" in English can be read as "hate towards the basque"...

Anyways, Spain dismissed itself as a second-rate power at the moment at which it refused to do anything with its american gold, rather than re-investing or loaning that sum, apprehending that it might be deemed usury by the Church, while others in Europe will maturing their banking system.

And then it became the Habsburg's bottom bitch and then France's bottom bitch.
>>
>>2278632
>Anyways, Spain dismissed itself as a second-rate power at the moment at which it refused to do anything with its american gold, rather than re-investing or loaning that sum, apprehending that it might be deemed usury by the Church, while others in Europe will maturing their banking system.
Spain wasn't a second rate power in the XVIII century. They defeated Austria and Britain multiple times. It is mostly a meme. The Spanish army was amongst the biggest in Europe (bigger than Prussia's or Britain's) and the Spanish navy was the third biggest. And the gold from America was never a big part of the Spanish economy. The economy crumbled when the Habsburgs just put all the economic weight of a huge empire in Castille alone
>Habsburg's bottom bitch
When. Even under Charles the II Spain was more powerful than Austria.
>>
>>2278653
Well you obviously know more than me, but what scraps I have in my knowledge about the Spanish crumbling of power was that it can most accurately be pinpointed at 1643, with the defeat to the French at Rocroi, so would it be valid that even by the XVIIIth century they hadn't been bullied into the background?

>Charles the II
Regardless, he was a Habsburg.
>>
>>2278692
>so would it be valid that even by the XVIIIth century they hadn't been bullied into the background?
They weren't bullied. In fact they made kind of a comeback with the 3 first Borbon kings. The country wemt to shit after Charles the IV ignored all state matters and put a peasant that was his wife's lover as the de facto ruler of the country and Ferdinand VII being an utter moron. Spain was more solvent than France economically and they influcted some major loses on Austria and Britain that were their main geopolitical rivals.
>>
>>2275469
>these are personal failings, not indications of being a bad ruler
>Citation needed
Thread posts: 64
Thread images: 3


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.