What percent of soldiers on the Eastern Front actually killed somebody?
What about the Western Front?
I don't think there are accurate statistics for what you are asking. The combined casualties on the eastern front were enormous
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastern_Front_(World_War_II)#Casualties
casualties on the western front were big. But not as big as in the Ost
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Front_(World_War_II)
Do some reading as well. Don't just use the encyclopedic Jew.
Less than combat deaths / total strength. Probably only a tiny fraction of that, actually, since most combat deaths would be from artillery, machine guns, etc.
So maybe... 1%?
Would it be fair to say that artillerymen probably killed someone, in many cases - several people?
>>1988001
After WW2 British and US American soldiers were asked about that topic. About 40 or 50% said that they did never shoot at the enemy, despite fighting at the front. And only 2% said that they shot at the enemy with the intention to kill them.
>>1988658
do you have a source on that? did they mean that 40-50% never shot at all or never shot at the enemy? because that sounds really low, and then to say that only ~4% of those who shot at the enemy intended to kill sounds really low as well
>>1988001
If you piloted an airplane or served a artillery piece you killed above the 3:2 average. Otherwise results varied wildly.
>>1988658
"After WW2" So this doesn't take into consideration anyone that died and had shot at/ killed someone.
>>1988638
Machine guns are manned by a dude who witness his kills
>>1988787
Not him but I assume he's referencing 'Men Against Fire' by S. L. A. Marshall. It's an extremely controversial book, though.
Marshall was chief US Army combat historian during World War II but is known to have opted for dramatic narrative over truth in most of his work, which ruined his credibility. The Army even came out and stated that his "systematic collection of data appears to have been an invention."
>>1989778
http://strategicstudiesinstitute.army.mil/pubs/parameters/articles/03autumn/chambers.pdf
>>1988001
It's a common thread in modern war memoirs that when in combat, with multiple people engaging targets, it's nearly impossible to tell who fired the shot that hits an enemy. The obvious exception being snipers/spotter teams.
>>1988651
Figures from WWI list artillery and mortars as the cause of 75%-90% of all fatalities.
>>1988001
Probably a good number of them, the death toll on the Eastern Front exceeds the number of 38 million.