Did Judaism stole monotheistic ideas from Akhenaten or it

>>1453413
They both developed independently.

Yes, through Moses who was once the Prince of Egypt.

>One god greatest among gods and men,
>Resembling mortals neither in body nor in thought.
>… whole [he] sees, whole [he] thinks, and whole [he] hears,
>but completely without toil he agitates all things by the
> thought of his mind.
>… always he remains in the same (state), agitated not at all,
>nor is it fitting that he come and go to different places at different times

Did Xenophanes stole monotheistic ideas from the Jews or was it the other way around?

>>1453443
Could Akhenaten actually be Moses?

>>1453449
I am sure that Jews existed before him. In fact the very first human was a Jew.

>>1453413
That's what Freud said in "Moses and Monotheism."

Moses was an Egyptian priest in the cult of Aten. Gone into exile in Palestine, killed in the wildnerness.

This hypothetical murder that is what Freud attritubtes Judaism' Father complex.

>>1453413
What Akhenaten crated was not a monotheistic religion. It was a polytheistic pagan religion that scrapped all but one God.

>>1453847
Like Judaism then?

File: 800px-GD-EG-Caire-Musée061.jpg (146KB, 800x1067px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 800x1067px

>>1453413
10/10 facial structure

>>1453882
You are so stupid it hurts
The jews most endearing contribution is monotheism

>>1453943
They started as polytheists anon. This is why here there are no Gods before me, for example. Not just there are no other Gods ever.

File: image.jpg (257KB, 1280x706px) Image search: [Google]

257KB, 1280x706px

>>1453963
>the Sumerians created writing
>"but before they knew how to write they were illiterate"

There is no truly "monotheistic" religion. Scholars debate when the Jews began believing Yahweh is the only God, and even afterwards rabbis had to pass dictates against worshiping Angels. Putting aside the trinity and Mary, Christianity has scores of saints and angels that can be petitioned to before God. Even Shia Islam has holy figures that can be petitioned to much like Catholicism.

Also there's virtually no difference between worship and petition when you're asking for a divine favor.

File: image.png (566KB, 1136x640px) Image search: [Google]

566KB, 1136x640px

>>1453983
>there is no truly "monotheistic" religion
What do you think a monothesitic religion is?

>>1454007
A religion that claims worship of one God, but in reality has a pantheon of figures, Saints, or Angels

>>1454019
okay then what do you think "real monotheism" is?

>>1454089
Something like Deism where there only one divine being.

>>1454135
Nope you are wrong