[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IaR 8KO4VFPM This girl is su

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 173
Thread images: 28

File: Untitled.png (1MB, 1440x900px) Image search: [Google]
Untitled.png
1MB, 1440x900px
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IaR8KO4VFPM
This girl is super good if you didn't know her channel already, and this video is also very fucking good if you ever felt like the show wasn't fulfilling your expectations anymore, but couldn't pinpoint why.

For example, I didn't know before this video how much I needed an episode WITHOUT STEVEN IN IT. It is such a missed opportunity.
Discuss.
>>
>>95195813
Surprised Robobuddies has never been mentioned on here really, she's cool.

I'm not long into this video, but she makes me want to study scene composition all of a sudden.
>>
>>95195813
Isn't she also a homestuck fag? I'm kinda liking here more. She could improve on her script reading though.
>>
>>95195937
I've been sharing some of her videos for a while, I honestly want her to become more popular than pan, she just deserves it more.
>>
File: 1504472567970.jpg (65KB, 750x737px) Image search: [Google]
1504472567970.jpg
65KB, 750x737px
>>95195813
>that voice
>>
>>95195813
This is something I've known about for a long time, Making the show strictly from Steven's viewpoint really hampered it. So many episodes are about Steven getting two people to hang out with him so they can unfold their emotional laundry in front of him.

It's one of the reason Greg's flashback episodes are so good, they can revolve around other characters
>>
File: 1504768167894.png (24KB, 378x366px) Image search: [Google]
1504768167894.png
24KB, 378x366px
>>95195813
Wow I wrote that OP like a fucking drunk. Sorry, I went to the bathroom midway through and just didn't re-read before posting. Sorry it doesn't make sense.
If you didn't know her channel beforehand, you should, she is very critic and analytical.
This is one of her best videos yet, but not the funniest. Check out her analysis on WITCH later, if you can spare the time.
>>
File: 1492536823867.jpg (45KB, 639x480px) Image search: [Google]
1492536823867.jpg
45KB, 639x480px
I'm watching the snow episode and I'm already pissed off at Steven
>>
Thank you Anon
OP not a fag this afternoon
>>
File: muttley_what.jpg (1MB, 1814x1029px) Image search: [Google]
muttley_what.jpg
1MB, 1814x1029px
I prefer E;R's take down. Might not agree with all the shit he shovels on it, but I much prefer that to.
>No I swear it's fucking good I swear, don't hate me fan base but it's like almost not quite perfect here and here.
AAAAH YOU WEAK BITCH! HAVE A FUCKING OPINION THAT ISN'T INFLUENCED BY HOW SENSITIVE THE FAN BASE IS.
>>
>>95196089
What do you call it when the end of the sentence slopes down to almost whimper?
Oney uses it a lot with his "pathetic" chararacters
>>
>>95196191
was that video even serious
>>
>>95195813
So this is Mrs Plinkett reviews Stephen Universe right?
>>
>>95196191
She has one, check the ending. You can like something, OR you can like something enough to talk shit about it. Dark Souls is my favorite game ever, but fuck me if that game isn't so full of shit. A third of it I'd say isn't even fun, its just you looking for the fun parts to come back again.
I think E;R aims too much for a cynical look at things, highlighted by the way he sometimes cherrypicks and ignores major points that would diminish his arguments, which is basically pandering but for the side of the spectrum that hates the subject matter.And I dislike that more than I dislike pandering in itself.
Putting a disclaimer for fans is the only way for you to diminish the amount of trash you'd have to look at when trying to interact with your fans and actually talk to someone about your opinions. Your annoyance seems contrived and should be rather focused on the people that make the need for such disclaimers real.
>>
>>95196191
E;R straight up compared it to anime, said the designs were subjective but then went on to say the backgrounds are mediocre and no better than anime. Not to mention he likes fucking shoveling in his politics and gay memes. Fuck that guy.
>>
>>95196191
I thought E;R was just taking the piss with most of what he said, and while he did have valid criticisms, it was mostly a fan of the show goofing around.
>>
>>95195813
This video is pretty good.
>>
>>95195813
Tumblerina voice no thanks
>>
File: 1488575919536.jpg (23KB, 296x270px) Image search: [Google]
1488575919536.jpg
23KB, 296x270px
>>95195813
i love robobbudies too but i fear you sharing this video on /co/ will bring...certain people.
Then again,it was bound to happen.
As a SU fan i liked it,even if i disagreed in some points,and thought comparing SU to other shows wasnt really necessary.
>>
>>95196473
I only watched the first twelve minutes but she never does any even remotely tumblr shit and has got smarter opinions than most of /co/.
>>
>>95196473
Just because she has fry it doesn't mean it's the same as a Tumblrina accent.
>>
>>95196240
>>95196332
>>95196333
E.R allready said he was messing around. Thats what makes the video funny. People actually think it was a real video about actual criticism.
Im pretty sure that he likes SU as a guilty pleasure. He thinks its shit but he still enjoys it.
>>
>>95196533
>he
>>
>>95196473
That's called a female anon.
>>
>>95195813
Based on that post, I'm almost absolutely certain that OP is the creator of this video.
>>
>>95196128
Why?
>>
>>95196776
based on this post, im almost absolutely certain that anon is a retard
>>
>>95196128
really. THATS the episode that pissed you off? Seriously?
>>
>they've SEEN good fight scenes

Oh snap
>>
>>95196991
>From the creators who saw Shrek
>>
I disagree on the fight stuff outside the general shoddy animation. DBZ became hugely popular because of the fights when it nearly never uses the environments, characters are regularly complete morons in the middle of serious moments, not every fight is personal yet manage to be memorable and attacks are regularly forgotten or not used when they could be (instant transmission standing out).
>>
>>95195813
>i love you forever peridot but you dont contribute to anything now
this.
>>
>>95197304
DBZ used the environment all the time. The examples she gave kinda went off the point she made in the composition segment
You need to use "props" to use the environment.

Having a character punched through a cliff wall is a DBZ staple. That's using the environment. It doesn't need to "Take a shopping cart and pretend you're cars". Punching people into things and having that thing explode is the environment.
Steven Universe doesn't even do that.
They fight in a void, most times than not
>>
>>95197413
That was a separate point in the video, destruction of environment and using the environment to fight are different points

>Having a character punched through a cliff wall is a DBZ staple
If that is all you need then SU would pass the test. The video even has examples of that in SU like Jasper being hit into the generator

>They fight in a void, most times than not
DBZ has a literal time void where multiple fights took place, plus environmental variety was really not the series strong point especially by Buu.
>>
>>95195813
How much of a counter-culture dicksucking contrarian do you have to be to preface your video with
>I wanna be the first to rant about this thing people are starting to like

A lot of these shrill complaints fall short due to plenty of it being chalked up to personal taste, failing to understand show goals, and outright ignoring contrary evidence.

The greatest irony is that this video (which seeks to critique a visual series for its shortcomings) is a meandering 40 minutes that misses its mark several times.
>>
>>95195813
Shill b gone
>>
>>95195813
I love robobuddies. She's one of those cartoon critics who actually know what they're talking about. It's sickening how people like Valskibum94 and Mr Enter overshadow her.
>>
>well thought out analysis
>valid criticisms
>calling out the instances of off model characters and the clusterfuck of the Cluster Arc.
>the WECC segment
What more can I say, she laid out everything flat as rain as clear as a mat. Robobuddies knows their shit and it shows. Good find OP. Great stuff.
>>
>>95198238
I wish she had talked about the Malachite arc, because as shitty as the Cluster was Malachite was so much worse.
>>
The editing reminds me a lot of the Mr. Plinkett reviews.
>>
>>95200013
Well that and her constant references to them
>shot, reverse shot
>they must have had the script, oh there it is
>>
>>95198238
Even then, it's really disappointing that SU fell on the same fate of Adventure Time in terms of the storylines.
>>
>>95195937
>Surprised Robobuddies has never been mentioned on here really,

Because despite what you may think, your shitty show are only liked by a loud, cancerous minority.
>>
Here's another very fucking good video about why SU is shit.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j38aX4JxINQ
>>
>>95195813
>I needed an episode WITHOUT STEVEN IN IT. It is such a missed opportunity.
no, you need a show without that faggot in it
>>
>>95200171
>Steven Rapeyverse
>very fucking good

Yeah okay buddy.
>>
>>95200171
>missing the point this badly
>>
>>95200058
"fell" would imply that it was good in the first place
>>
File: 1460040572262.png (241KB, 571x573px) Image search: [Google]
1460040572262.png
241KB, 571x573px
>>95200221
>>
>>95195813
>it's a "/co/ discovers a new content creator with a vagina" episode

I swear to christ if you nigfags /lit/ this one up you will officially become lower than /tv/.
>>
File: 1430038809216.gif (401KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]
1430038809216.gif
401KB, 400x400px
>>95200304
>MUH LAYDAYYYYY
>>
>>95200283
Rapeyverse isn't even a takedown. It's half a Leafy-tier cringe comp of the retarded shit the fanbase has done, half a "checkmate atheists" tier "lol rocks aren't really girls so steven universe isn't gay xd" logical black hole. It's basically E;R making a mandatory shitting on a blatantly Tumblr product without taking a definitive stance as to whether he dislikes the actual product, which considering how much time he spends on the show without actually shitting on it a la Whorra, is likely very little.
>>
>>95200344
Let's not pretend that this hasn't happened before. 4chan is autistic down to its very core, and /co/ has no good content creators.
>>
I thought people got over this show already. Like seriously guys its kinda old and its pretty much a kids cartoon.

I'm pretty sure adventure time never generated this much autism even though that show has much lower points that SU.

Why not watch something more akin to your age range like Rick and Morty or Game of Thrones instead of pastel cartoons mae to teach pretteens lessons about love and acceptance?
>>
>>95200459
Are you from reddit?
>>
>>95200171
She was a thin-skinned crybaby, so good riddance.
>>
>>95200491
>>95200304
>>
>>95200485
No im just saying maybe its not healthy to have so much vitriol over kids cartons.

Why are these videos even popping up NOW when things like shoddy animation and poorly developed plotlines are things that have occured since the shows inception, and i thought the last bomb was well received.
>>
>>95200389
Only a few if you're lucky but it looks like you just proven your point once again.
>>
>>95200558
You were too busy masturbating.
>>
>>95200459
>I'm pretty sure adventure time never generated this much autism
AT had a different form of autism back in like 2012, you wouldn't believe how many people there were who couldn't stop gushing over it and acting like it was the deepest show ever created.
Then all the fags who did that moved onto SU where they're currently being just as faggier, if not faggier.
>>
>>95200558
Why do you think? People just want attention and views through controversial videos of a (popular? is this show even popular anymore?) cartoon
>>
Most of the arguments are hit and miss, but the criticism of Pearl's scene in Mr Greg makes no sense. Everything you need to know is delivered through the lyrics, the movements and Pearl's facial expressions. So what if there's no dramatic overhead shots? The audience knows it's a big moment because everything has been building to this and it's given the right amount of care and attention to detail.

Really a lot of the rant comes across as if it was written during season 4 without any context as to what's happened since. That and it deliberately leaves out examples that counter certain arguments (i.e fights don't make use of scenery when you have Bismuth, Smokey vs Jasper and Malachite vs Axelandrite) which kind of undermines a lot of genuine issues the video brings up (pacing etc.).
>>
>>95200679
It's a cartoon. It doesn't cost anything to add a little effort to the composition
Her argument is that it doesn't everything it needs to and little more.
Yeah, Pearl's expressions and lyrics told the story.
But that's the minimum and minimum is boring
>>
>>95195813
>quality character designs
Seriously?
>>
>>95200836

Can you explain why they are bad?
>>
File: 1391591388865.png (95KB, 449x447px) Image search: [Google]
1391591388865.png
95KB, 449x447px
>>95200366
>>
>>95200715
It had some of the most complex shots in the show in terms of animation, music timing etc. Implying that the Crewniverse put no effort into it is hyperbole at best and disrespectful at worst. This is supposedly a video by a "fan" too.
>>
>>95200946
I AM SILLY
>>
File: what halal edition.jpg (31KB, 397x372px) Image search: [Google]
what halal edition.jpg
31KB, 397x372px
>>95200969
>It had some of the most complex shots in the show in terms of animation
Which one?
A slow rotation around Pearl's head?
Animated her spinning?

Jeez, how do they do it!
>>
>>95200888
Because you have characters like Pearl or Ame which are basically personalities given form, and then... a Disco Niggress.
And that's just one example.
>>
>>95200715
>"Her" argument

We can stop pretending that this isn't you, what with the amount of tumblrinas on /co/
>>
The Seinfeld parts were funny.
>>
>>95200972
Yes we know.
>>
>>95200989
Got some goalposts that need moving if you're interested. Seems like you're already good at it.
>>
honestly, this show just needs to end. its a failed clone of AT and has just generated controversy. CN needs to save face and just cancel it, its for the best
>>
>>95196855
what's your boiling point then?
>>
>>95201094
They're still promoting nuPPG, you're delusional if you think they're gonna cancel SU. If anything, they're gonna milk it until it's dry.
>>
>>95200969
>It had some of the most complex shots in the show in terms of animation, music timing etc
Have you never seen another cartoon in your fucking life?
>>
>>95201092
>this is really good
>which part
>UH STOP GOAL POST MOVING ASKING FOR EXAMPLES IS MOVING GOAL POSTS
Nigger
>>
>>95201114
nuPPG hasnt generated as nearly as much controversy as SU
plus SU actually costs more money to produce than it makes
it would be better for everyone if it either went to a web only series or just got the axe
>>
>>95201127
> What is context?
I said in the show, not compared to other shows.
>>
>>95201111
i dont have a boiling point. i like steven,but i can understand why people can find him annoying.
But he doesnt do shit that episode.
>>
>>95200344
>not knowing what a gamma male is
>>
>>95201137
Woosh.
>>
>>95200998

Thats a very weak point you are making, anon.
>>
>>95201156
Okay, sorry. Let me change my question.
Is this the only fucking scene in SU you've seen? The shots weren't "complex" in any sense of the word. I don't think it could have been more rudimentary if it tried.
>>
>>95201183

>Expecting the whole of the internet to know what bullshit terms a bunch of neckbeards made up so racionalize why they will never get laid
>>
>>95201145
and NuPPG is much better show than SU

and I actively mean this; both subjectively and objectively good. watch as this'll get guaranteed replied heh

>>95201168
to me it was when it literally became crying: the show
>>
>>95201002
How many people are you going to assume are the OP which is also the creator of the video, instead of accepting that sometimes people just want to share something and participate in a discussion?
Probably me too, I'm guessing
>>
>>95201249
Taken on its own, without music or lyrics I'd agree, but the art book goes into detail about how difficult it was to sync everything perfectly. It's much harder than it looks, which is why they often keep things simple in some areas and boost it in others.
>>
>>95201400
Look, anon, the other anon didn't say that scene was BAD, he only disagree, much like I did, that it could have been better and given even MORE weigh. And it would have been easy. It Robo had given a very far out idea, I'd say "well, I can see why the creators didn't think about that, so I don't think that argument is THAT valid", but the concepts Robo gave out are very basic and only a display that she picked to show how much WASTED POTENTIAL this show has. Which is her actual argument by the end of the video and therefore, consistent, instead of hit and miss.
And this is why I disagree with you, but I still see where you are coming from with what you said.
>>
File: 1490422639884.png (196KB, 523x767px) Image search: [Google]
1490422639884.png
196KB, 523x767px
is there anybody who likes this blob?
>>
>>95195813

>open video
>expect something angry
>get a kinder, gentler Plinkett-style takedown of SU instead

Well I'm fucking hooked. Subscribed!
>>
>>95201511
Yes.
>>
>>95201511
She would be the best character if she had better development that stuck desu
>>
>>95200558

It takes a while for a show to establish trends. I doubt you watched the video considering you described it as vitriolic, which it's not, but one of the points specifically is that long standing shows tend to have something new to shake things up in S4, because a formula break keeps things interesting. The video emphasized how nothing really changed in S4, just like nothing really changed up to that point, either. This is a point that could literally only be made years after the show is out.

Like if you're not interested in people talking about composition and plot and characters that's fine but this is a really interesting video to learn from if you are.
>>
>>95201400
>Taken on its own, without music or lyrics I'd agree
So you agree that the shot composition, or lack of it, is mediocre? Because that what I thought we were talking about, not synchronization of the shots with audio.
>>
>boring bitch parrots the SU critical tag for half an hour

That was pretty bad guy.
>>
>>95201576
Season 5 is kind of that point.

>>95201494
Fair enough. Consistency is a problem SU's had since conception.
>>
File: 1478475496433.png (346KB, 865x666px) Image search: [Google]
1478475496433.png
346KB, 865x666px
>>95201511
I do.
>>
File: armrest.jpg (123KB, 457x477px) Image search: [Google]
armrest.jpg
123KB, 457x477px
>>95201511
yup.
Amethyst is end-game tier
>>
>>95201729
Well, to be fair, it does have the word "rant" on the title of the video. I'd have guessed you knew the meaning of the word before wasting your time.
>>
>>95195813
Actually pretty good video, all the critiques are well thought out. I like how she talks about composition and fight scenes, and her point about the show wanting to be super dramatic while also having wacky OOC comedy makes the characters seemed fucked up is good.
>>
File: 1504860189051.png (486KB, 615x458px) Image search: [Google]
1504860189051.png
486KB, 615x458px
>>95200171
>Fandoms are the determining factor for the quality of a work
>>
>>95201953
It's ok for shows to be both comedic and serious. You just get shit like Rocknaldo from time to time which drags down the decent SOL episodes.
>>
>>95201328
the ratings and money agree with you. its time for CN to end it and get sugar on other projects rather than this failed experiment
>>
File: 1475814299370.png (48KB, 195x206px) Image search: [Google]
1475814299370.png
48KB, 195x206px
damn she thicc
>>
>>95200171
Nah, that video is shit
OP's video is good though
>>
File: CM-Punk-Pipe-Bomb.jpg (65KB, 528x297px) Image search: [Google]
CM-Punk-Pipe-Bomb.jpg
65KB, 528x297px
I don't hate you Steven Universe writers. I don't even dislike you. I do like you. I like you a hell of a lot more than most shows on CN.

I just hate this idea that you're the best. Because you're not. There's one thing that you're better at and that's kissing Tumblr's ass.

You're as good as kissing Tumblr's ass as PPG was. I don't know if you're as good as Adventure Time through. They're a pretty good ass kisser. Always was and still is.
>>
Glad it touched points on the inconsistent models and it made me realize the shot reverse shot thing, and how good moments like "Its over isn't it" song could have been done much better.

Wished it talked about the consistent hiatuses, besides some of the worthless episodes that's why it feels surprising why we're 4 seasons in. It feels more like 2.
>>
>>95202071
There's nothing wrong with having a lot of both comedy and drama, hell I usually love dramadies, but SU doesn't do it effectively.
>>
File: IMG_1189.jpg (99KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_1189.jpg
99KB, 1280x720px
Wow, another derivative, long, boring review for faggots to spam in SU threads. I'm so excited for the references to shift from E;R's ridiculous shtick about John Money to Robo's seemingly pointless segue to Ratotouille and Motorcity, in which she proves that those projects have certain concepts, but never really elaborates on how Steven Universe doesn't.

This is great. Can't wait to have the URL burned into my fucking retinas
>>
File: 1497764653125.png (11KB, 393x314px) Image search: [Google]
1497764653125.png
11KB, 393x314px
>>95202753
>getting this butthurt over people criticizing your shitty show
>>
>>95202661
>Wished it talked about the consistent hiatuses, besides some of the worthless episodes that's why it feels surprising why we're 4 seasons in. It feels more like 2.

I think that would have distracted from the point of the video. She's criticizing the creative staff of Steven Universe, not the corporate executives.
>>
>>95202849
Hey, I didn't spend hours on end writing and editing a "Steven Universe rant," full with my own shitty art, OCs, and pseudo animation so at least I have that going for me
>>
File: 1504575721995.jpg (30KB, 600x453px) Image search: [Google]
1504575721995.jpg
30KB, 600x453px
>>95197516
>How much of a counter-culture dicksucking contrarian do you have to be to preface your video with
>I wanna be the first to rant about this thing people are starting to like

Thanks for proving you didn't actually watch the video. What she actually said was
>It's probably going to hit a brick wall at some point and I want to be the one who called it


>A lot of these shrill complaints fall short due to plenty of it being chalked up to personal taste,
Weighty, impactful fight scenes being better than floaty, unconvincing fight scenes is not a matter of personal taste, Anon.

Character writing consistency being better than character writing inconsistency is not a matter of taste, Anon.

Dynamic composition being better than flat, stale composition made up of predictable camera angles is not a matter of taste, Anon

Consistent character attributes such as height and hair style being better than inconsistent versions of the same is not a matter of taste, Anon.

Don't you have a SU episode you should be working on?
>>
>>95202933
Yeah, you instead waste your time writing pathetic, blatantly passive-aggressive posts about people who criticize a show you like.
>>
The real issue with the show is the hiatuses, it's the biggest hype killer.

We'll be entering in our fourth month of hiatus pretty soon. I heard that if it continues much longer, it'll be the longest hiatus in Steven Universe's entire run.
May feels so long ago
>>
File: 1502393799704.png (370KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]
1502393799704.png
370KB, 600x600px
>>95200459
>Why not watch something more akin to your age range like Rick and Morty
>Ricky and Morty
>>
>>95202620
>You're as good as kissing Tumblr's ass as PPG was.
*still is
>>
File: 1481345905631.png (183KB, 483x384px) Image search: [Google]
1481345905631.png
183KB, 483x384px
I'm up to the uncle grandpa episode.
how much did /co/ hated this?
>>
File: kanye-west-shrug.jpg (20KB, 449x232px) Image search: [Google]
kanye-west-shrug.jpg
20KB, 449x232px
What does she look like?
How can I value her opinion if I don't know what she looks like?
>>
>>95203641
>how much did /co/ hated this?
Too much.
It's funny.
>>
File: robobuddies.png (5KB, 320x221px) Image search: [Google]
robobuddies.png
5KB, 320x221px
>>95203661
Like this

>>95203641
I unironically love it, don't know if anons waited months for that one to get so much hate, but I just laughed a lot in it.
>>
>>95203771

That's cute enough for me. I'll listen to her.
>>
File: oh ok neat.png (217KB, 565x539px) Image search: [Google]
oh ok neat.png
217KB, 565x539px
>>95195813
>Thought the video was fucking amazing
>I gotta see more
>There's no other videos like it
>>
>>95195813
Steven Universe is shit thread? Steven Universe is shit thread. More rants:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j38aX4JxINQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hc8Oin4De6s
>>
>>95195813
>Uploaded yesterday
>7,000 views

Nice shilling.
>>
That video was really good and actually brought up some stuff I never thought of before i.e the Steven-only perspective being super repetitive and why Mindful Education worked so well.

Now what I actually want to see is a compare and contrast with that Land of the Lustrous manga that's being turned into an anime, since despite their obvious similarities they go in completely different directions and it'd be interesting to see.
>>
Wow, this is super constructive and in-depth. This is WAY better than the other rant video.
>>
>>95204291
>Land of the Lustrous
Whats that about?
>>
File: 1504820504657.jpg (228KB, 600x699px) Image search: [Google]
1504820504657.jpg
228KB, 600x699px
>>95200171
That video is overated as shit.
This isn't worth it to copy and paste anymore. If I have any reasons to bring up why I don't like Steven as much I'm just going to bring up OP's.
>>
>>95196533
Him liking the show and him being funny doesn't compare to the overall constructive commentary and quality the other vid has desu.
Honestly, I think he's just another memelord.
>>
File: IMG_0143.jpg (53KB, 566x800px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0143.jpg
53KB, 566x800px
>>95204317

It's a manga that started publication a year before SU premieres and gets compared to it a lot but. The core premise of sentient genderless gem-people fighting beings from outer space with a mix of tropes in the magical girl and sci-fi genres are shared between the two, it's a lot of the finer details and setups that make each other different. For example, in SU the Crystal Gems are on Earth constantly interacting with humans, but in Lustrous it's set in a post apocalypse where humanity has died out. Another example is how the Crystal Gems in SU are actually constructs of hard lights from the gems on their "bodies", while as in Lustrous they are 100% the actual minerals themselves, which lets them play with the concept more. There are a lot more but for the sake of spoilers I won't say more.

Here's the most recent trailer for the upcoming anime adaptation that's starting in October https://youtu.be/pwFpAyEuph8
>>
>>95200389
I can't believe you're saying "content creators" here unironically.
>>
>>95196191
>E;R
Faggot. His Korra videos (although not wrong) are chiefly cringeworthy, mostly because he wants to be what Pinklett was to Star Wars, but ends up turning into what MrEnter is to SpongeBob instead. He needs to step out of that basement and stop being a NEET.
>>
File: undersiders_by_shadaan-dahwc9f.jpg (242KB, 1000x650px) Image search: [Google]
undersiders_by_shadaan-dahwc9f.jpg
242KB, 1000x650px
>>95204432
>oh no, its 3D anime
It looks good enough desu (better than Ajin, fuck you too Japan), but I'll have to check that out to see if the trailer isn't cherrypicking, if it isn't, then manga it is. I liked the aesthetics, will put on my list of things to check out.

Gonna drop a quick shill here as well, but if anyone in this thread is interested in just a prime example of characterization and worldbuilding, check out the webnovel Worm, by Wildbow. Great creative use of superpowers where there are a scarce few that are generic, and weak ones get turned on their head because of clever use and situational occurrences that can lead to a not-necessarily strong group of villains to rule over a city out of lack of competition and sheer scariness factor that only occurs when they are a combined threat, or a very clever and seemingly unbeatable cape to be taken down through cleverness and abuse of their maybe one weakness. Its really fucking long, but there's a lot of just delicious tidbits of writing in it.
Anyone interested in creating something could get inspiration from it, be it a book comic or animation. As someone who likes it, I can say that it has a lot of flaws, but the good parts vastly overshadow the bad ones at least IMO
>>
File: 1490229417218.jpg (93KB, 574x582px) Image search: [Google]
1490229417218.jpg
93KB, 574x582px
>>95195813
>someone else watched motorcity
>a grill
>>
>>95195813
If this was transcribed into an essay I'd probably read it, I'm sure there's some interesting takes buried in there but I'm not wading through 40 mins of low rent Plinkett review aping intro to film 1000 shit to find them

>shot reverse shot
>shot reverse shot
>shot reverse shot

shut the fuck up, you read some posts on about composition on tumblr once, this does not make you a cinematographer, no one cares
>>
7 minutes in and I gotta say I'm still invested in her critism. I still like SU but it definitely has its flaws. Also I wanna check out that motorcity show. Never heard of it before but it looks fucking good.

Damn this succesful shill

>>95203161
I would be less bothered by the hiatus if they actually announced return dates for once on time. Makes me feel less anxious. CN seems to do this more often than any other cartoon channel. Hell they still didn't even bother to put the SDCC trailer online. Instead we have to do it with shitty potato quality clips from the audience who were there at SDCC.
>>
>>95205706
Don't you have a SU episode you should be working on, shill?
>>
>>95205706
But she's right, most of the villain characters were first introduced very weakly, like YD didnt look threatening at all in her first full appearance and even less with that design
>>
>>95205957
I'm sorry, maybe if I copy pasted shot reverse shot another twenty times I could have made you laugh at my incredibly funny joke instead

>>95206054
Again, yeah, that sounds like legit criticism - which I'm never going to see because she decided she could wring a Plinkett Star Wars prequel review out of some minor nitpicks regarding a show she kind of likes but not entirely
>>
>>95195813
>an episode WITHOUT STEVEN IN IT
you mean like garnet universe
>>
>>95206218
>nitpicks
but most of her complaints are actually things that fan constantly pointed out over and over, specially fight scenes feeling weightless and floaty
>>
>>95206229
Still involved Steven by letting him make up the story about what Garnet did that day.

Every episode which had focus on other characters still involved Steven somewhat.
>>
>>95197304
Counterpoint
DBZ is garbage
>>
>>95195813
She talks like YMS guy.
>>
>>95206229
Garnet's Universe is literally about Steven's internal world as a tween weeaboo with a magical destiny who's beginning to understand the realities of the adults in his circle
>>
>>95196473
Tumblrinas would have a lot more sentences ended as questions like this? She could work on her speaking but some girls are just born with a mousy sounding voice
>>
>>95202753
This anon sounds bitter
>>
>>95206933
The show's always gonna be from Steven's POV, it's his story. What I think the crew should do more is find ways to bend that rule (which they do already) with more flashbacks etc.

We're probably going to get a fair bit of that what with the Pink Diamond mystery arc going on right now.
>>
She sounds like Sadie.
>>
>>95203053
In short: QUALITY is not a matter of taste, Anon. You can enjoy a piece of shit as much as you want, but you still have to recognize it as one at the end of the day.
>>
>>95205884
Oh, please watch Motorcity. It has fucking Mark Hamill as the main villain.
>>
That was damn good review why does she hate trollhunters tho?
>>
>>95210178
Idk maybe watch the various videos about that
>>
Steven Universe is shit, I thought everyone knew this already?
>>
>>95201511
Me, she's my favorite character
>>
>>95196533
JUST PRETENDING TO BE RETARDED EKSDEE EKSDEE
Fuck that
>>
>>95197304
>characters are regularly complete morons in the middle of serious moments, not every fight is personal yet manage to be memorable and attacks are regularly forgotten or not used when they could be (instant transmission standing out).
Name one moment in DBZ where they are a moron in a serious moment. Her point wasn't that a fights needs to be personal, it just have to fit the character motivation. And the whole instant transmission thing is solved once you know that move takes time to do it. Goku have to gain distance between his enemies to use it or they'll just attack when they see him. Every single time when Goku uses it, it takes a few seconds for him to do it.
>>95197500
>If that is all you need then SU would pass the test.
Yes, but DBZ do it constantly, SU does it for once in the full moon. Along with DBZ doing it throughout their entire fights as well. Steven Universe three most recent "fights" don't do any of that
>>
>>95196240
Luan from The Loud House does it a bit.
>>
>>95195813
>Mindful educ-
Stopped right there
She was right but holy shit the autism
>>
>>95201511

Me. Although she needs a bath.
>>
>>95200171

Keep plugging it, asshole.
>>
>>95215865
>Japan being better at animation/framing and composition than the west? Impossible!
>>
>>95211197
It was clearly a parody and if you actually took something so blatantly tongue in cheek that it had 5 solid minutes of literally pro-Nazi faux propaganda at the end that's your own fault for being such an autist that you take everything at 100% face value.
>>
>>95202753

Then don't watch it.
>>
Wonder what she thinks about OK KO
>>
>>95216489
>Parody
>28 minutes
>decent editing
This guy can't possibly have a job, right?
>>
>>95216482
>LOLOLOL WAS GUD
no it wasn't, the plot was garbage
Animation couldn't save that episode
>>
>>95217250

She was only bringing up the episode for not having the same problems with its inconsistency when she was praising the episode, she never said anything about its plot.
Thread posts: 173
Thread images: 28


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.