8/10 8.5/10 7.5/10 Let's see how quick this thread

I'm a DCuck, but you should be ashamed of yourself for this bait

>>85491103
3/10
2/10
5.5/10

These are the true scores.

>>85491122
Not bait.

You know, this board has really taken a turn for the worst. Every single non approved opinion is consistently called bait. Moreso than any other board.

8/10
(Ultimate Edition) 7.5/10.
Haven't seen yet.

>>85491103
8/10
5.5/10
Haven't seen it/10

BvS is absolutely not better than MoS

SS is better than BvS but still edited to fuck and back

>>85491103
Didn't know cohesive editing, relatable characters, and a story with an ounce of soul were only worth 1-2 points.

3.5/10
Unwatchable/10
5/10

>>85491103
MoS: the fighting is cool
BvS: raise my expectation but fail it
SS: entertaining

>>85491149
this

4/10
Did not watch as MoS was bad
Did not watch as MoS was bad

@85491103
3/5
2.5/5
3.5/5

>using a 10 point scale

>>85491103
8/10
7/10 (Ultimate cut)
7/10

They could of done alot better though.

>>85491159
I agree

>>85491103
6.5/10
3/10
-/10

>>85491103
7/10 MoS
4/10 BvS
3/10 SS

t. disappointed dcfag

>>85491103
7/10
9/10
haven't seen yet/10

I enjoyed Suicide Squad but it's impossible to deny that movie has serious structural problems that are impossible to overlook.

I mean I'd rather watch it over like Oceans 12 or The Usual Suspects or most Will Smith movies but it frustrates me to no end how they butchered this movie with nonsense editing.

>>85491103
2/5
2/5
4/5

>>85491103
7/10
4/10
5/10

5/10
4/10
5.5/10

>>85491103
3/10
4/10
5/10

They've all been shit, but at least Suicide Squad had elements of a good movie that seemed to be edited down to shit.

>>85491514
OP jere. I agree that it seemed tampered with, but it's still an above average movie.
I'd wonder what the fuck is wronf with criitics, but then I remember that Critics like TFA for christ sake, so I don't think that they actually have critical thinking skills.

MoS: 8/10
BvS (Ultimate):8/10
SS: 5/10

5/10
2/10
.5/10

And I'm being generous

>>85491103
6/10
9/10
5/10
IMO

>>85491621
You liked Suicide Squad the least?

>>85491103
Okay guys, more important:
Fuck, Marry, Kill

>>85491638
Fuck Boomerang
Marry Batfleck
Kill Ultraman

>>85491559
RT scores are ultimately only reflective of technical competency in a movie. Is a movie effectively made with a plot that follows the 4 major literary devices of dramatic structure? Because that's pretty much all it takes to make to get above a 70% on RT since the lions share of critics tend to give judge films on technical matters. That's why utter dross like Lady Ghostbusters, Age of Ultron, or TFA is rated so highly because there's enough "meh it's boring but it flowed correctly" type reviews to push it to the top.

>>85491631
I hated it the most

5
2
4

MoS 8/10
BvS (Ultimate Edition). 7/10
Suicide Squad 7/10

Jesse Eisenberg ruined Lex Luthor for me

>>85491942
He was good though.
>not muh
Is all you have to bash that performance with.

>>85492145
To me he felt really cringy, enjoyed the rest of bvs tho

1/5
3/5
2/5

I actually like man of steel more with every rewatch.

SS is some hot garbage outside of the acting performances, maybe the eventual joker edition will change my mind

>>85491103
8.5/10
Infinity/10
7/10
BvS went beyond "masterpiece"

>>85492422
mite be b8
but I agree

>>85491103
7/10, uneven but still largely enjoyable, each viewing makes it better
8.5/10, doesn't quite manage to balance everything but all in all, great entertainment. Need to see the Ultimate Cut soon.
8/10, fun to watch popcorn flick, even if it has less substance than BvS and MoS.

>>85491659
>RT scores are ultimately only reflective of technical competency in a movie.

But that's not true though. If I had a dollar for every "not fun," "not Marvel," and "problematic" comment in a negative review for a DC movie, I'd have a decent amount of cash.

7
7 (Ultimate Edition 8)
6.5

>>85491103
7/10
5/10 - Ultimate 6/10
6/10

9/10
9.5/10
4.5/10

SS really dropped the ball.

>>85491103

6
5
Have not seen yet

>>85491103
I don't get it. Those are certainly good scores.

8.5 is a B+, 8 a B, and 7.5 is C+

All passing grades and certainly good.

>>85491514
>usual suspects
Nice shit taste

>>85491103
>MoS 7/10
>BvS 8/10
>SS 8/10

Why can't DC into third acts?

>>85492479
Why did you rate SS higher than MoS? Just curious.

>>85492557
Suicide Squad wasn't meant to be as grandiose as the other two, so they didn't try as hard. It was still enjoyable though.

>>85491103
I don't like the decimal 10 system I prefer the 5 star system it's more to the point
3 stars
1 star (2 for the Ultimate Edition)
3 stars

>>85491103
>MoS - 4/10
>BvS - 4/10
>SS - 7/10

I don't understand how Ant Man can score higher than Suicide Squad

>>85492753
Ant Man was good.

I don't understand how the Iron Mans or Thors can, though. Cap, GOTG, and Ant Man are the only truly excellent Marvel movie lines.

>>85492753
Ant Man was decently edited instead if being just a collection of scenes thrown together.

I legitimately think that every MCU movie is better than all three of these DC movies. Even at their shittiest, the MCU movies at least seem like they like the characters on screen

>>85491159
I liked the films, but even if you didn't want this for a reaction, you clearly knew you would get it. I'd just love a day where someone doesn't bring up the DCEU films

>>85492753
Anon Ant-man was a top self film.

>>85492753
Why not? At least its editing isn't a total shitshow.

>>85492810
All movies are a collection of scenes thrown together.

>>85492753
Ant Man is as good as Green Lantern was. It's a forgettable movie that might make you a bit mad when you're finished, but you'll move on after a few minutes. I don't know how it's as well received as it is.

>>85491103
4/10 5/10 4/10

>>85492829
I agree
And it makes me mad because I like DC heroes more

>BvS
3/10

>MoS
6/10

>SS
Haven't seen

>>85491103

Well, you are right that Suicide Squad was the worst one. So you've got that going for you at least.

>>85492836
>I'd just love a day where someone doesn't bring up the DCEU films
t. Disney stockholder

>>85492850
But some have a flow that brings one scene into another, and a movement driving the story forward. Suicide Squad did not.

>>85492829
>>85492863
wew
>muh fun
just 'wew'

>>85492854
this

>>85491103
SS>MoS>BvS

This is just my opinion. You can disagree if you want.

>>85492802
>>85492810
>>85492846

yeah I get that Suicide Squad had strange editing, about 1000 pop rock songs back-to-back and not enough joker.

But ant man was by-far the most boring MCU movie. It had terrible CGI, and it just felt really gloomy through the whole thing.

Whereas Punisher, Iron Man 1 and Incredible Hulk were top-tier contained super hero movies.

>>85492668
MoS has few glaring pacing issues where it runs a bit too long and is disjointed at places, it has too much stuff for the running time that is has, which hinders the viewing experience. SS doesn't have perfect pacing either but it flows considerably better and is far more straight forwarded and thus more easy to enjoy.

>>85492897
Yes it did? Characters did things and the situation was changed because of those actions.
Meme elsewhere.

>>85492927
Ant-Man had characters people like and jokes that hit.

File: batman.jpg (39KB, 482x483px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 482x483px

MOS: 7/10
BvS: 6/10 - ultimate cut 7/10
suicide squad: 7/10

File: 1470257545463.jpg (172KB, 1024x660px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 1024x660px

>>85492829
>>85492863
Most of that comes from the studios wanting to actually make cape films while WB is doing it's broken system of throw big names and money at the production day one and hope it works.

>>85492928
>but it flows considerably better
That's not the narrative, goy.

>>85492912
How did "fun" become relevant to either of those comments?

>>85492951
>haracters people like and jokes that hit.
subjective as shit

>>85492972
you tell me

>>85492934
>Characters did things and the situation was changed because of those actions.
What specific character development was in the movie? What made the team come together by the final act besides the plot saying that they had to?
Fuck, Boomerang just straight up leaves the room at one point, and is back in the next scene with ni explanation as to why he came back.

>>85492972
he's shitposting for (you)'s

>>85492988
>subjective as shit
Well, yeah. And so is calling Ant-Man "the most boring MCU movie."

>>85492988
>you tell me
Because you brought it up, not because that was my opinion.

>>85492951
Yeah, it did. It had really funny moments. But the whole movie felt really drab. Same reason I have a problem with Deadpool. They're funny movies but they're so... gray for lack of a better word.

That's why I held out hope for Suicide Squad. For some reason I thought it would have the same feel as a the promotional material, where it would be bright and colorful and different but also have that murdery side.

I'll wait for the ultimate edition I guess

>>85492997
>What specific character development was in the movie? What made the team come together by the final act besides the plot saying that they had to?
>Fuck, Boomerang just straight up leaves the room at one point, and is back in the next scene with ni explanation as to why he came back.
>summarize the movie for me
All your questions are explained in the film.
Meme eslewhere.

>>85492964
>Marvel makes a bunch of trash films and very few good ones
>gets praised for them

>DC makes three good films
>everyone hates them for it because it ain't Marvel

>>85492997
>Not expecting Boomerang to come right back

>>85493034
>All your questions are explained in the film.
When specifically in the film is this explained? Because I watched it on opening night, and saw no such explanation.
>Meme eslewhere.
Not sharing your opinion is not what meming is.

>>85493019
STOP HAVING OPINIONS THAT DIFFER WITH CONSENSUS

FUCK

Why are contrarians so stupid?

>>85493044
>DC makes three good films
None of them are good films, though. They are all fundamentally badly made movies.
>>85493052
...
Actually if this was the reasoning behind that scene, then I would be totally cool with it.

>>85493063
>Because I watched it on opening night, and saw no such explanation.
I don't believe you.

>>85493044
stop disagreeing with the smart viewing public

>>85493044
>DC makes three good films
lel

File: 1450145553324.jpg (36KB, 446x358px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 446x358px

>>85493091
>They are all fundamentally badly made movies.
this is just too much holy shit

>>85493044
I don't think that comic was about Nolan's movies, anon.

File: 8351365.png (38KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 625x626px

>>85493044

>>85493127
TDKR was shit.
Stop memeing.
DCEU>TDKR

File: Screen Shot 2016-08-15 at 12.png (226KB, 1613x870px) Image search: [Google]

226KB, 1613x870px

>>85493096
>I don't believe you.
Well, sure. Just pretend that everyone who doesn't agree with you didn't see the movie.

>>85493148
TDKR is a masterpiece compared to the DCEU movies.

>>85493117
Did you watch them? They were poorly written, poorly acted, poorly structured, and poorly edited. They failed on every basic level of filmmaking.
>>85493148
Honestly, as much as I disliked The Dark Knight Rises when I saw it, watching Man of Steel has made me look back more fondly on things.

File: 1453681312247.png (7KB, 679x427px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 679x427px

>>85493178
ok bud

>85493157
>invoking the same """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""critics"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" that liked The Force Awakens

My godforsaken sides!

>>85493238
>invoking the same """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""critics"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" that liked The Force Awakens
I didn't bring up critics. Those are my personal reviews on that website.

File: you.png (4KB, 609x230px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 609x230px

So does shitposting just help you feel better?

>>85493127
Of course not. 2/3 Nolan movies were bad. Only Dark Knight barely competes. And that still loses to MoS and BvS.

>>85493184
>They were poorly written
nope
>poorly acted
nope,
>poorly structured
only MoS,
>and poorly edited.
only SS
BvS theatrical was perfectly fine , contrary to what meme hustlers will tell you.

>>85493238
The fact that you don't know how to link to a comment really isn't making you look like an intelligent film critic.

>>85493286
>deleting a meem arrow makes my opion invalid
weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeew
seek help child

>>85493275
But Batman Begins was the good Nolan film.

File: opinion.jpg (64KB, 441x705px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 441x705px

>>85493279
That is some good reasoning right there. You sure showed him by just saying "nope" to his points.

>>85493273
I really wonder what percentage of /co/ is made up of people who genuinely don't like the DCEU and are honest about it, what percentage actually like it, what percentage pretend to like it to get responses, and what percentage are just hipsters and contrarians who can't like anything the public likes because that means it's just not DEEP enough.

>>85493279
This guy gets it. Didn't even mention volume control, good visuals, scene transitions, music, and how great the character development was.

Why doe people pretend to like DCEU movies? Is it because they don't like Marvel and that's the only competition it has?

>>85493306
Calling it a meme arrow doesn't help either, for that matter.

File: 1448826060567.jpg (24KB, 480x516px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 480x516px

>>85493333
Because he claims were so well argued.

>>85493091
>Actually if this was the reasoning behind that scene, then I would be totally cool with it.

Confirmed for not being able to think for yourself

>>85493312
It was poorly edited. Rachel made me want to kill myself. Batman had reverse character development. There were a lot of other problems that I don't remember right now. I could find them later if you want.

>>85493273
But is he shitposting, or does he really think that he's doing a good job defending these movies?

>>85493365
You asked him why he didn't like the movie, he gave his reasons. You then said "nope, LOL."
That's not an argument.

>>85493359
JUST stop son

>>85493342
I love the DCEU. I also like Star Trek Beyond and other ADHD meme generation friendly movies.
The MCU is just the same movie over and over again.
Sitting in the theater for Cap 2 I realized I'd seen this moive five times already.

>>85493377
Dark Knight has way worse editing and pacing than Begins..

>>85493415
meant for
>>85493339

>>85493415
>I love the DCEU. I also like Star Trek Beyond and other ADHD meme generation friendly movies.
That says a lot more about you than it does about anyone else.

>>85493415
Yes, but which one of the above are you? Can we ever truly be certain?

>>85493423
No way. The fight scenes were all over the place and a lot of scene transitions were terrible. Dark Knight actually improved from Batman Begins, which surprised me a lot.

>>85493415
Man Star Trek Beyond was so shit. I have no idea how it scored so high.

>>85493405
>That's not an argument.
/pol/ pls

>>85493446
>everything I like is a negative
>you want me to have theconsensus

>>85493339
This is why I genuinely hate movie threads on /co/. There is no actual discussion about the movie because there is always just one guy saying "The movies are all great, you just hate it because it's not Disney" that stops everything in its tracks.

File: 4573782463.png (9KB, 1081x154px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 1081x154px

>>85493339
I wager most people are not passionate about either side but feel Marvel has a better track record than DC
However you are on to something about it being popular
There are countless shows that are loved here till other communities start to enjoy them as well, then it just gets stupid.

>>85493477
Don't forget the constant
>It's popular so it's good
>It's popular so it sucks

>>85493470
>everything I like is a negative
Probably because you've consistently posted about liking awful films.
I'm guessing your a big Michael Bay and Adam Sandler fan, as well? Just shilling out for lowest common denominator films?

>>85493466
I'm telling that I love the DCEU. If you think i'm lying right off the bat, you would seem to have some sort of complex.

>>85493477
I think everyone knows by now

MCU
>Great movies, for sure. But hardly seem to surprise.

DCEU
>Mediocre movies, with shots and scenes that are usually greater than the sum of its parts
Although that has mostly to do with Snyder

>>85493467
I'll give you that those are terrible in Begins, plus it has that really fucking stupid Bat Sonar thing from Year One. But man it's hard to watch Dark Knight. It's a 2 and a half hour movie that feels like 5 hours. It has two endings before it even gets to Two Face. Loved it on my first watch, but I just can't watch it anymore without getting really bored.

File: implying cat.jpg (36KB, 530x416px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 530x416px

>>85493502
Based on how you're acting, I'm definitely going with "lying"

>>85493499
>I'm guessing your a big Michael Bay and Adam Sandler fan, as well?
nope
Although, Pain and Gain was better than any Marvel film.
MCU>Transformers tho.

My favorite films are the Thin Red Line and Signs.

>>85493496
>There are countless shows that are loved here till other communities start to enjoy them as well, then it just gets stupid.
Well, to be fair, it only has to be popular on Reddit, Tumblr, or sometimes Twitter/Facebook. The problem with that being all it takes to be considered popular on any of those sites is to know a couple of random morons who love it, at which point it becomes Reddit/Tumblr/Facebook: The Show

File: 1461597779573.png (35KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 625x626px

>>85493415
>Sitting in the theater for Cap 2 I realized I'd seen this movie five times already.
Explain. What all 5 of those films have exactly?

>>85493511
Considering Suicide Squad, I'm putting a lot of blame on the producers at Warner Brothers rather than just Snyder. There were traces of a good film in Suicide Squad, but it seems to have been destroyed on the cutting room floor.

>>85493511
>>Great movies, for sure. But hardly seem to surprise.
oxymoron
kill yourself

>>85493520
Why is that?

>>85493517
I agree with you there. Dark Knight has no replay value. Plus I only like it for Harvey Dent, Joker just wasn't good enough for me. Harvey was a real hero. I'm also glad Rachel died since she was a horrible person.

>>85491103
7/10
7/10
3/10

>>85493502
No, I believe you, mostly. Just having a joke. But There are tons of people who go out of their way to defend a thing or attack a thing and anyone who likes something too much or not enough and it's generally impossible to tell who is doing it for what.

>>85493560
>Why is that?
Because you continuously say that anyone who doesn't agree with you is just meming.

File: definitions.jpg (45KB, 500x420px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 500x420px

>>85493560
>oxymoron

>>85493536
I never understood this
I like Invader Zim. I think it was a good cartoon. I think the fans are unstable but that doesn't detract from the show.
Yet somehow we have such a "normie" personality that we have to turn anything to an us vs them rather than talk about the entertainment goods themselves

>>85492927
>Iron Man
>Good
no.

Ant Man was a much better movie.

>>85493609
But Scott Lang never build anything in a cave. With a box of scraps.

>>85493547
Generic hero triumphs over adversity with TV tier cinematography while generic 'epic' orchestral music plays.
At least Cap 2 had the Bucky angle. Needed to be more about that and less and Hydra and Pierce. Redford is an incredibly boring actor. The eye candy hunk of his day, hired for loks not skill.

>>85493560
great
ɡrāt/
adjective
adjective: great; comparative adjective: greater; superlative adjective: greatest

1.of an extent, amount, or intensity considerably above the normal or average.

sur·prise
sə(r)ˈprīz/
noun
noun: surprise; plural noun: surprises

1.an unexpected or astonishing event, fact, or thing.

>>85492854
Incorrect.

>>85493595
>great movies
>no suprises
six fingered man false flag

>>85493570
Oh. Cool then.

>>85492753
Ant man was decent. Suicide squad was shit.

>>85492878
>worst

You mean Best.

>>85493609
horrible taste
you are the death of film

File: 45621162567247.jpg (77KB, 1544x800px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 1544x800px

>>85493623

>Generic hero triumphs over adversity with TV tier cinematography while generic 'epic' orchestral music plays.

That's MoS
That's all Batman films
Hell that's most action films in general

this is the last (you) Im giving you. Wwork on your bait

>>85493597
A lot of people can't separate a work from its fans. Worse, some people can't even separate the typical, casual fan from the raving lunatic obsessed nuts. You can't like Sonic 3 without being some guy making [First Name] the Hedgehog OCs on Deviantart.

I guess for a lot of people, it's not even about the shows or comics or whatever, it's just status. "People like X, but I know it has flaws and I hate it, so I'm better than them." It must seriously kill your ability to enjoy anything.

File: read a book.jpg (65KB, 566x480px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 566x480px

>>85493650
He said that it wasn't surprising that they were great, not that the films had no surprises.

>>85493650
Something can be great without surprise

>>85493623
>Generic hero triumphs over adversity with TV tier cinematography while generic 'epic' orchestral music plays.
How many action movies can you think of that don't fit this description?

>>85493675
How is Iron Man any good at all?

>muh RDJ
He's as much Tony Stark as Jesse Isenberg is Lex Luthor.

Mediocre
Terrible
Bad

>>85493654
>>85493636
nope

>>85493682
MoS
>great looking film
>music FAR from generic
>generic
>first Alien on earth

No, (You).

Also, according to man of murder memesters, he didnt even triumph.

>>85493715
die retard

>>85493623
>Generic hero triumphs over adversity with TV tier cinematography while generic 'epic' orchestral music plays.
Are you literally fucking retarded? Reduce any film down like that and you can make it sound generic enough that you would say you'd seen it already.

Take MoS and BvS for example: Good alien beats up bad alien to save humans from extinction is one of the most generic sci fi plots ever.

>>85493739
>great looking film
Everything looked like it was run through a filter to remove all bright colors from existence. Most of the action scenes looked like a mess
>music FAR from generic
It sounded like every Hans Zimmer score in existence.

File: image.jpg (46KB, 357x312px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 357x312px

>>85491353
>puts decimals in his 5 point scale
>criticizes the use of a 10 point scale
ok buddy

>>85493773
>Good alien beats up bad alien to save humans from extinction
BvS has nothing to do with this. Doomsday is mostly huamn, and Lex does definitely NOT want to extinguish the human race.
Try again.

>>85493636
Anon, it's not a good movie. It's full of cliches and full of bad dialogue thrown in because "Hey, pay attention! This unfitting conversation that has nothing to do with anything right now is going to come back at the end!" Hell, it has two characters who hate each other start to love each other during a training montage.

It's bad.

>>85493739

>music FAR from generic
link your claim take the top 3 best from that film and bring it here

>>85493775
>I must deny reality to keep my worldview intact
oh okay
good day to you sir

>>85493817
A person who has a different opinion than you do is not denying reality. Films are not objectively good or bad, there is always opinion involved.

>>85493817
So the movie was full of bright colors and well choreographed fight scenes then?
And you can listen to a track of the soundtrack and say "that is Man of Steel, no question?"

>>85493809
this

>>85493798
>Doomsday is mostly huamn
That's just completely fucking incorrect.
>Lex does definitely NOT want to extinguish the human race.
Lex is an alien now is he? Doomsday was the one wrecking cities who would've been literally unstoppable and murdered everyone.

>>85493809
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7kzKJL6TfnM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N1A8xZVei-g
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpBnxR2zPWk

>all generic!
I know, buddy. I know.

>>85493817
>>85493739
Please remove yourself from the earth you specimen.

>>85493840
not that anon, but I definitely can. It's probably cuz I've seen the movie so many times and listened to the soundtrack so much, but yeah I can.

>>85493857
>That's just completely fucking incorrect.
everything living came from lex
Zod was a dry corpse.

>>85493840
>And you can listen to a track of the soundtrack and say "that is Man of Steel, no question?"
Most definitely.

>>85492895
You must have missed the part where I said I liked the films, but 3 years of shit posting gets to you after a while

File: 1373115531430.jpg (2MB, 1440x2016px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x2016px

>>85491103
9.5/10
10/10
9/10

Fuck Marvel shills

>>85493879
>to PC to say 'kill yourself'
sup neo-/co/

>>85493875
Those first two are definitely not identifiable and definitely just generic epic action scores, all this delusion just makes you look like a complete moron.

File: 1436431443407.jpg (158KB, 537x667px) Image search: [Google]

158KB, 537x667px

>>85493875
Top three results when searching "man of steel soundtrack best song"
You didn't even try

File: kent.jpg (196KB, 1096x800px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 1096x800px

>>85493929
Unironically this.

>>85493339
These kind of threads almost make me think there are shills here
almost

>>85493933
>Muh boogeyman
Kill yourself, happy now?

>>85493953
Oh but I did.
Here's your (You) though.

5.5/10
6.5/10
7.5/10
The DCEU has been okay so far. It's nothing mindblowing, but it's certainly not the absolute garbage people insist it is.

>>85491103
>Let's see how quick this thread will turn ugly.
It turned ugly as soon as you made the thread.

>>85493990
>but it's certainly not the absolute garbage people insist it is.
contrarian
>>>/pol/

>>85493935
>the first two are definitely not identifiable
anon, those are like two of the songs most closely identified with the film. Anyone who's seen it would know what it's from.

Hell, the second one is the basis of the death of Doomsday in BvS. And you know it the second you heard it in that movie.

>>85493953
>Top three results when searching "man of steel soundtrack best song"
literally LITERALLY not true
nice shitpost
i'm fairly angry

File: WCzpbQZ.gif (2MB, 390x277px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 390x277px

>>85494030
>Anyone who's seen it would know what it's from.
That's just wrong. 99.99% of the people watching the movie don't give a fuck about the score and certainly couldn't identify them, especially the second. They're the same as any big blockbuster score.

>>85491103
No red pants/10
Martha/10, African wall/10 (Ultimate Cut)
Dancing woman with bushy eyebrows/10

>>85494089
nope

>>85494101
You're a fucking idiot, keep living in your own little world buddy.

>>85494089
Whatever you say anon...

>all these 7 and aboves
Does all a film need to do for you guys is bombard you with sound and light for a couple hours to view it favorably? Real talk even the marvel movies shouldn't be ranked this high with the possible exceptions of winter soldier and maybe the first avengers based purely on how well it excecuted it's wide scope.

File: 1466309469929.png (102KB, 480x377px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 480x377px

>>85494123
will do

>>85494142
OP here. I would call Iron Man 1 a great film. All the other MCU movies are middling. That includes WS.
Avengers does get props for being sort of well executed all things considered.

Civil War > BvS

Amirite, lads?

>>85494216
no

>>85494195
Straight up forgot about iron man 1. That movie was amazing when it first came out. But in my opinion it hasn't held up the best. That's probably just due to over-saturation of super hero movies at this point though. It kinda lost what made it special. Still a lot of fun though

>>85494302
Why not, pal?

5
3
7

>>85494326
Civil War looks like a tv show.
Film is a visual medium.

>>85494302
They're both a bit of a mess. But civil war is less of a mess so okay

>>85494378
>Film is a visual medium
I can see Civil War tho.

What if BvS airs on television?

>>85494405
>reduced to meme responses
thanks for playing

>>85494425
What do I win?

>>85494439
this DICC niqqa

>>85494378
Cinematography is secondary to plot and characters. I would watch something that looks like a TV show that has a good plot, action and characters but I'd be far less inclined to watch something that looks nice but has nothing to it. Substance > style.

>>85494455
I win a Nightwing?

>>85494468
>Cinematography is secondary to plot and characters.
REALLY debatable. I can see where people are coming from, but that's very debatable.

Also in avisual medium, style IS substance.

>>85494504
TV is looking a lot better these days. Mr Robot has great cinematography.

>>85494524
Better than shit like the first Avengers that's for sure.

>>85494468
This
If only Snyder could get that through his thick skull

>>85494550
At least you agree that TV is getting better, kind of makes your point redundant.

>>85494572
No, merely said that Mr. Robot looks better than the Avengers.
I made no non relative statement about the visual quality of television.
Good try though.

>>85494504
So you liked Sucker Punch?

>>85494587
>Good try though.
Thank you :)
What do I win?

>>85491638
Fuck Superman
Marry Batman
Kill Joker

>>85491103
4/10: Boring.
6/10: Better but still shitty and overblown, however it is rewatchable.
2/10: I just watched it last night. The only fun I had was laughing at it. It is literally impossible to ever rewatch and a fucking incoherent mess.

>>85491638
Fuck Harley
Marry Batfleck
Kill Joker

>>85494597
Yes actually.
Don't love it though.

>>85491103
8/10
6/10
Haven't seen SS, no interest.

>>85494601
a nice phallus

>>85491638
Listen, considering I've fucked every form of physical video copy known to man, neither. Though, I will fuck a Blu-Ray over a DVD.

File: Harley The Batman.png (593KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

593KB, 1366x768px

The only Harley post the classic version that I liked was pic related and Assault on Arkham Harley.

>>85494667
Um... you're providing me with a phallus? I'm not gay though. I'm bi, you have to provide different options because I prefer women to men.

>>85494715
>I'm bi
meem

>>85494731
Not all memes are zany though.

Do you even MLG

>>85494762
w0t

>>85494780
*w0t?

FTFY

>>85491103
MoS 5/10
BvS 3/10
SS, haven't seen it, will probably never see it.

>>85491103
5/10
3/10
6/10

mostly mediocre, bvs actually bad

>>85491103
8/10
7/10
6.5/10

>>85491103
I didn't watch any of those movies / 10

9.5/10
10/10
9/10
All fantastic movies, destined to be future cult classics

>>85495060
I agree, but are you memeing?

>>85495060
The same with Prometheus and Only God Forgives.

Oh, he'll be raping and pillaging by the time he goes north.

>>85494607
Look at this meme loving fuck

>>85491103
5/10 - man of steel
3/10 - batman vs. superman
3/10 - skwad

>>85495121
I can't. It's an anonymous imageboard.

>>85491103
Agree with everything but SS. A 6 at best. Praying for a directors cut or something

9/10
7/10 (theatrical, haven't seen ultimate yet)
6/10

TFA > BvS

File: 1462753719386.jpg (9KB, 221x228px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 221x228px

>>85495290
god no
got me right rustled tho

>>85492829
>Thor 2
>Iron Man 2 & 3
>Age of Ultron
>All better than MoS
I mean you're entitled to your opinion, but it's absolutely impossible for me to take it seriously.

>>85495273
Ultimate is worse.

>>85495298
TFA > MoS

>>85494607
>BvS
>rewatchable

>>85495313
As a huge fan of the theatrical, i've heard this as well.
I would guess it just spoonfeeds the plot more for plebs.
Am I right?

>>85495318
I agree.

>>85495352
>you
>not an idiot

>>85495392
>>85495318
puking_frog.svg

>>85495392
>>85495318
>>85495290
>>85495419
Forbidden Planet > All Sci-Fi

>>85495313
One of my big complaints for theatrical was that it didn't have enough Superman, so, I doubt I'll agree with that.

>>85495448
good post

>>85495481
Love me some Forbidden Planet.

Robby the Robot is a cutie.

File: ngbbs4b61291e8c404.jpg (20KB, 430x299px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 430x299px

>>85492829
We finally meet, Nega-Me

>>85495312
All those movies are more fun than MoS and BvS, I haven't seen SS so I won't judge it.

>>85494689
harley has been unbearable shit since the arkham games
sucks normies think otherwise

>>85496088
>fun
>measure of the quality of a film
christ on a stick

>>85491103
7/10
8/10
4/10

>>85496088
Yeah, no they weren't. Nothing in any of those movies is even close to as fun as Supes' flight scene in MoS.

Moreover, they're fucking boring. They're the opposite of fun.

>>85496128
>fun
>measure of the quality of a film

Actually it is

A film is a form of entertainment, if some films entertained me more than others, they are better films.

File: 1470375931213.jpg (1MB, 2109x3310px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2109x3310px

6/10, had at least a few somewhat entertaining scenes
3/10 literally one of the worst movies of the year, hilariously bad
2/10 genuinely awful. how anyone likes SS is beyond me. What a trash fucking movie

>>85496222
Film is art. Film being entertainment is something plebs tell themselves to rationalize their shit taste.

>>85496326
Okay /tv/

>>85496420
>implying i'm wrong

>>85496326
>Film is art.
Oh boy. Do we get one of those "this is art, this isn't art, and I know the objective difference" arguments?

>>85491103
they're all shit

MoS - 8/10
BvS Theatrical Cut - 4/10
BvS Director's Cut 7/10
SS - 5/10

8.5/10 6/10 not seen/10

>>85493044
Every movie DC has made is on the same level as Transformers.
Enjoyable to super fans, but overall bad.

File: this isn't my battlefield.png (264KB, 275x421px) Image search: [Google]

264KB, 275x421px

>>85491103
>It had potential
>Ohgodwhydidtheychoosetomakeitlikethis
>i can see bits of the good movie behind this atrocious trainwreck


I will keep watching but that was the last time they get my money.

>>85491103
I'm terrible with scores, but I did really like all 3. I'll openly acknowledge they have flaws. I am not one of those fan boys who's like "DC forevah, fuck Marvel! Fucking paid reviewers, conspiracy!" those people give us a bad name. (Also I actually love Marvel too)

>>85496226
You just have awful taste MoS is the worst movie in the DCEU.

File: I just don't know.gif (260KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

260KB, 500x281px

>>85491103
I will say this, they're fun
>Man of Steel had some pretty awesome fight scenes and Zod was a really good antagonist all things considering
>BvS showed off a fun Batman, I think Affleck pulled it off well, and the movie really showed how POWERFUL Superman is.
>Suicide Squad had some fun scenes

But writing got in the way. Jesus-Man is as subtle as a flaming brick, BvS had a retarded villain/plot, and Suicide Squad was just a colorful disaster.
So yeah

>>85493905
omg this. I love the movies, but goddamn I hate that /co/ has become console wars faggotry

>>85491173
BvS is the best of the bunch you bitch pleb

>>85497193
nah they arent bad

>>85496461
no, he is saying film is a medium of art, like books or comics. Sometimes you can use art to make entertainment, but to say film is JUST entertainment is like saying paintings are JUST there to be pretty.

>>85491103
3/10
Didn't see it, don't regret it given surrounding shitstorm
On the fence about seeing it, every day /co/ turns me off it a little more.

Ghostbusters didn't guilt me into buying a ticket by accusing me of bigotry, and in a similar vein the DCEU isn't going to get me to buy a ticket by constantly calling me an idiot or a casual.

>>85491103
hum?/10
What?/10
THE FUCK?/10

MoS 5/10
BvS 2/10
SS 2/10

File: 1368381030519.png (175KB, 430x398px) Image search: [Google]

175KB, 430x398px

> BvS > MoS > SS

They're all terrible.

>>85491103
8/10
7/10
8/10

Pretty good so far.

>>85493840
>And you can listen to a track of the soundtrack and say "that is Man of Steel, no question?"
You might be able to because the movie uses that same two note leitmotif a LOT. And I think MoS's soundtrack is horrifically overrated.

>>85500931
That's fair enough, though he did come off as saying that being entertaining is somehow degrading to art.

>>85495373
Nothing about the "plot" is spoonfed. BvS has too many different subplots all going on at once and each scene feels disconnected from the last. Comic books don't translate directly into movies, there are sacrifices that have to be made for it to make any semblance of sense. Snyder needs to fucking learn that.

MoS 8/10
BvS:UE 7/10
SS 7/10

IM 9/10
TIH 7/10
IM2 7/10
Thor 7/10
CA:TFA 7/10
Avengers 9/10
IM3 8/10
T:TDW 7/10
CA:TWS 9/10
GotG 10/10
TA:AoU 7/10
Ant-Man 8/10
CA:CW 9/10

>>85491103

6/10
8/10
4/10

>>85491103
> MoS 5/10
>BvS 3/10
>SS 2/10

I highly doubt you people would rate SS so lowly if you weren't aware of the studio meddling.

File: kinoSqwad.jpg (59KB, 613x565px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 613x565px

>>85491103
I think you need to work on your context.

>>85502927
>if you weren't aware of the studio meddling
The editing is fucking abysmal, anon.

Like: dude smashes the controller and says, "you're all free to go" and Boomer takes off like a shot ... then he's back?

And the whole first 30 min or so is a fucking mess! And I say that as someone who actually didn't mind (even liked) the pop-up style intros!

>>85503047
I think you're being hyperbolic. If it was abysmal, you wouldn't be able to follow the plot. It definitely wasn't great but cmon.

>>85491103
8.5/10
7/10
4/10

>>85502927
>if you weren't aware of the studio meddling.
So if you didn't see it?

>>85501743
I disagree. The problem isn't that Snyder is directly adapting a comic book. The problem is that he keeps trying to adapt SIX comic books.

The Batman that we see during The Death of Superman is not the same in terms of characterization as the Batman of The Dark Knight Returns. The Superman of Birthright is very different from the Superman of Earth One.
Snyder thinks that by pulling scenes from a dozen different titles he's distilling the essence of the characters but he doesn't grasp that said scenes work in their individual contexts but are not interchangable.

>>85503197
People are skewering it as if it was Green Lantern for F4nt4str4c 4. It's nowhere near that level of incompetent or boring. Call it a meme if you want but the movie was coherent despite the editing and ultimately just a fun ride.

>>85491149
>>85491314
either samefagging or this earth has too many contrarians

File: 1462421565101.jpg (38KB, 604x311px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 604x311px

>>85491103
>BvS
>Anything above a 5

File: DC.jpg (69KB, 920x310px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 920x310px

>>85503532
>Contrarians

Do you even know what that word means?

>>85503781
>implying critics aren't a vocal minority

File: 1455841620320.png (157KB, 516x440px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 516x440px

>>85491103

7/10
6/10
8/10

>>85503781
There is the average score beneath the tomatometer, not that those are much better.

In 3 films it's made more money than the MCU did in its first 3.

3/10
2/10
4/10
Honestly I can ignore the stupid plots (except Martha) and plot holes, but I can't stand the choppy editing.

3/10
9/10
6/10

MoS - 4/10
BvS - 3/10
BvS: UE - 4/10
SS - 5/10

>>85503047
>Boomer takes off like a shot ... then he's back?
Like a boomerang! Deep symbolism! YOU JUST DON'T UNDERSTAND

>>85504968
>Like a boomerang! Deep symbolism! YOU JUST DON'T UNDERSTAND

>knowing that your complaints are so stupid that you have to preemptively defend them
sad desu

7/10
7/10 (ultimate cut)
7/10

actually i'll save everyone's time : Every Cape Flick in the last ten years "7/10" if you like capes and 5/10 if you're a cape-fan

there that should save everyones time. None of these movies have been good really (compared to an actual film)

5/10
5/10(UE)
3/10

>>85491103
5/10 4/10 x/10

Will never again go to cinema for DCEU shits.

Didn't see MoS.
Didn't see BvS.
Gf dragged me to SS and it's a solid 3/10.

I'm glad I'm not a nerd who gives a fuck about this garbage.

File: 1464560863840.jpg (82KB, 507x338px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 507x338px

>>85510486
>on the comics and cartoons board
>not a nerd
Why don't I believe you?

>>85491103
3/5
2/5
4/5

>>85510486
>I'm glad I'm not a nerd who gives a fuck about this garbage.
Posted to /co/

>>85510529
>>85510575
I am a nerd, just not one that's into superhero movies. Really it's tragic that you guys have to put up with this superhero fashion trend that churns out movies which should have been cancelled in pre-production.

>>85510651
>I am a nerd
nah
don't believe ya
>cavalier attidude about 'this garbage'
>has a gf
might be more at home on /soc/ phamily

>>85510706
k, you got me, I'm from /sp/. Gf does like this stuff though.

bye

>>85510781
kill yourself

>>85491103
8.5/10
2/10
3.5/10

File: urfurry.jpg (517KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

517KB, 900x900px

3/10
3/10
Haven´t seen.

Question for those like me who still haven´t seen Suicide Squad: will you pay to see it? I will just wait for the rips.

>>85491508
located the underage b8

>>85496326
Film WAS art, and capeshit its just soma senpai.

>>85491103

7/10 for all of them.

To be fair this is how I feel about most cape flicks.

File: 1471052116878.gif (2MB, 360x213px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 360x213px

>8/10
It was just good. Better pacing (the Kripton flashbacks are more entertaining than the other versions of Superman's origins i've seen, which are Reeve movie and DCAU), cool costumes. All the destruction doesn't seem to be Superman fault. Supes killing Zod was inevitable. Most of the complaints are just"not muh". I agree in that Jonathan is a bad advisor ("maybe" was a bad answer, and "stop, invincible son" scene was retarded) but it doesn't ruin the movie for me. Supes being a depressed fuck makes sense in the whole movie, he's happy when he needs to be (like at the end).

>8/10
I had fun with sperg Lex, even when his plan was too complicated, i actually loved that his motives weren't too clear (was he really concerned of Superman as a potential menace for humanity?, was he was butthurt because no one saved him as a kid from his father abuse?, did he wanted to prove that God omnipotence vs goodness paradox?). I hate Lois shoehorning into everything, and that she always has Supes to save her ass (how he didn't listened as good when his mom was in danger?), but not enough to ruin the movie, Again, emo Supes makes sense given the circumstances. Batman was awesome except for the killing (i wanted this one to be the first non killer live action Batman since Adam West) and the Flash time travel scene. They could have done a better casting for Wondy, i mean, Gal is like a 8/10, but Wondy should be should be a 10/10. I liked the Justice League cameos, what if Lex wanted to give logos to some freaks he was studying?. The BvS fight was cool, and i can't said i didn't hated MARTHA Deus Ex Machina (Batman has a hardcore PTSD for anything related to his parents, so, is no surprise to me that he reacted the way he did when HE HEARD THAT NAME).

>8/10
I can't remember much, but i got out of the teather happy, same for most of the other attendants, i think.

Sorry if my english (or my opinions) are retarded.

>>85510781

Never come back, Chad. I was also into /sp/ stuff, and let me tell you, it's boring as hell, so you don't deserve to judge entertainment stuff.

>>85493898
>>That's just completely fucking incorrect.
>everything living came from lex

Ah, humans and their ability to shoot red lighting, smash through buildings, and grow bone weapons. Those grey skinned orc people don't know how lucky they have it!

File: 1471288024844.jpg (13KB, 255x216px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 255x216px

>>85512091
>Zod was alive
oh

>>85512119
You claimed Doomsday was mostly human. It inherited a weakness to kryptonite from Zod unless Luthor forgot to take his anti kryptonite pills when making Doomsday.

>>85512187
>Zod was alive

>>85512226
So because Luthor was the only live one, it's completely human? With super powers and a kyptonite weakness? What was Zod for if he was just some useless corpse?

>>85512257
>What was Zod for if he was just some useless corpse?
Symbolism for when Supes is killed the exact same why his father was. (Jor)

>>85512285
>How is Doomsday mostly human?

File: i hope your joking.gif (480KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

480KB, 600x450px

>>85491103
Watched SUICIDE SQUAD yesterday and it feltlike i was watching a fucking B movie compared to BVS.

Movie is literally 35-40 minutes of character introductions and followed by mindless action.

>35 half assed charcater intros
>enchantress escapes like it was obvious she could do as she can telport any FUCKING WHERE
>mindless action against B movie looking grunts
>Everyone comes togethor its over

There are actually plebs in this board that thought it was a good film?

Pathetic!

Made BVS look like an oscar contendor

Anyways heres my ratings:

MOS: 7.5
BVS:9.0
SS: 5.5

At least man of steel and Bats vs supes tried to be a full length film and not some throw \together mes like Suicide squad.

>>85491103
Couldn't agree more, OP
Suicide Squad < Man of Steel < Batman v Superman