>Top Tier Batman Wonder Woman >Great Tier Superman (just

>Superman anywhere above Meh Tier
FEELSfag pls go.

>>84951494
nah

>>84951436
I'd bump red hood up a tier

>>84952277
Oh, aquaman and green arrow up a tier as well

I felt I had to get this out, but it didn't facilitate a new thread.

It's one of those things that you don't realize even though all the facts are staring you in the face.
When you acknowledge the facts separately, but it never occurs what they mean together.

Guys, Lois Lane is now a MILF.

>>84952415
pics, anon

>>84952415
She was already a MILF, I'm sorry you're a casual who didn't actually read pre-Flashpoint Superman books though. Chris was their son.

>>84951436
>Great tier
Superman
Red Hood and the Outlaws
Batman

>Good tier
Green Lanterns
Action Comics
Aquaman
New Super-Man

>Meh tier
Hal Jordan and the GLC
Wonder Woman
Green Arrow
Detective Comics
Batgirl and the BOP

>Terrible tier
Justice League

>Didn't bother to read tier
The rest

>>84951436
>>Terrible Tier
>... Has anything been really bad yet? Not even Lobdell, Humphries, or Percy?
Don't kid yourself.
Justice League is just slightly above this tier, but Batgirl and the Birds of Prey totally is in this tier.
Shit art and that incredibly cringey confessional scene can't let it rise above this level

>>84952481
And how long did he last?
One story arc in a single title before he was forgotten?

If he comes back, I'll gladly call him Jon's brother, but that just isn't the case right now.

Justice League and Action Comics are not good.

File: Rebirth_checklist_Week_8[upd2].jpg (3MB, 1200x4773px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1200x4773px

You can place your tiers on pic related.

>>84951436
>Red Hood and the Outlaws
This definitely not a meh tier.

>>84952497
I agree with the list, but I switch Aquaman with WW and GA.

>>84952609
The flashbacks and backstory were nice, but some of the writing for the present day stuff was a bit forced.

>>84952589
No, Busiek had him in a few arcs because Last Son was delayed. And then he came back in New Krypton too for a year or so. He was in a lot, you're just a casual.

>>84952776
I personally thought it was both great (the flashback and the present day).

The present day stuff actually made me really excited for the next issue.

>>84951436
>Top Tier
>Batman
>Wonder Woman
More like top kek tier. Batman is average, WW is decompressed.
>Great Tier
>Superman (just on the border, maybe I'll bump it up)
It's just average, great art being wasted on fucking Tomasi. Story is predictable with off pacing, characterization isn't a standout. People only like it for Shota fetishes.
>Nightwing
>New Super-Man
These are definitely belonging in this tier.
>Titans
Haven't read it yet.
>Batgirl
It's pretty good, not great.
>Detective Comics (just on the border)
Pretty good.
>>Good Tier
>Flash
It's great tier.
>Aquaman
Good tier I'd say.
>Batgirl and the Birds of Prey
Haven't read it yet.
>Green Arrow
Only book deserving of Top tier (barely). There are stakes in this book, pacing is perfect and visually it's breathtaking. Only criticism I have is dialogues sometimes are bit overdramatic and unnatural. But I like those in my books.
>>Meh, but not terrible Tier
>Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps
Didn't read.
>Green Lanterns
I'll bump it to borderline good. Art is uneven but it's fun. Dogfucker is nailing the characterization.
>Justice League
Didn't read.
>Action Comics
Mediocre offensive garbage.
>Red Hood and the Outlaws (surprisingly)
Didn't read.
>>Terrible Tier
Has anything been really bad yet? Not even Lobdell, Humphries, or Percy?
>Hellblazer
Didn't read.

>>84953168
>It's great tier.
Except the art

>>84952965
It just didn't hook me. The direction makes sense for Jason (especially after 5 years of awful stories), but the present day stuff (the parts that will carry forward) just wasn't exciting enough, and the tension between Jason and Bruce felt forced. Haven't they already reconciled?

>>84953168
>Only book deserving of Top tier (barely). There are stakes in this book, pacing is perfect and visually it's breathtaking. Only criticism I have is dialogues sometimes are bit overdramatic and unnatural. But I like those in my books.

I think Percy goes overboard with the dialogue though. I thought he cut back with Rebirth, but the monologues in the last couple of issues were a bit much.

>>84952846
Still doesnt make him any good

>>84953192
>muh poser
>muh house style
It's stylized as fuck and fits the tone.
>>84953242
He definitely scaled back on Snyder esque monologues. There was exposition in last issue where Diggle was talking to that guy with weird face and Percy used that narration over action. It was really well done. I can understand about the dialogues and why people might not like them though.
>>84953261
Fuck off shill. If DC had dumped this new generic kid after Convergence and brought Chris back, your tune would be different. You're literally the most obvious and predictable tripfag on this site. Honestly kill yourself.

>>84953405
Di Giandomenico does not use Poser, he's simply a fast artist who does not care muh house style you're saying.

>>84953446
I dont think they were saying the DiG was doing house style, they were mocking people for not liking his art

>>84951436
Mmmm Etrigan and marvel Family, nice.

>>84953446
I know, it's just those are the retarded criticism someone came up with in issue 2 storytime.

>>84953202
Well, it's a matter of opinion.

The series will officially start on Aug 10th and this rebirth issue has given me what I wanted.

>Haven't they already reconciled?
Yes, Jason is currently working on a mission for him and Bruce actually acting like a dad.

The tension will just always appear between the two of them.

>>84953446
I never said he was doing house style, it's just not muh traditional stylefags that can't get over his art. Some retard did say he uses poser.

>>84953493
>>84953529
That retard is maybe a summerfag or casual.

>Detec
>great

No.

File: TITANS #1 FINAL TEXTLESS.jpg (250KB, 788x1200px) Image search: [Google]

250KB, 788x1200px

Titans #1 textless final cover because it's too late.

File: it_was_me_barry.png (271KB, 680x494px) Image search: [Google]

271KB, 680x494px

>>84951436
Read Flash #3

Was it confirmed that August Heart is gonna be Godspeed or not? His backstory is sort of like Zolomon's, if so...

Could he be a reference to:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/August_Hirt

>>84954759
I hate that artist so much

>>84956303

Unless Godspeed is going a speed-mirage or something they're different people.

>>84951436
drop Red hood into the pit

ITT: Stockholm Syndrome

File: 1467506894888.png (209KB, 500x293px) Image search: [Google]

209KB, 500x293px

>>84951436

>>84956382
August already knows about time travel because of Thawne, could be him from the future.

>>84951436

Superman belongs on Top Tier.

You it everything else right.

>>84951494

Get stomach cancer.

I thought we were ranking actual DC characters and i'm already half way done so fuck, i'll just post it.
>SS tier
Superman in the future where he's all golden and basically God.
>S (AKA personal favorites) tier
Constantine, Tommy Monaghan, Vic Sage, Doom Patrol, Guy Gardner, Animal Man, Aquaman from Batman: The Brave and the Bold
>A tier
Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Wally West, Captain Marvel
>B+ tier
Blue Beetle, Booster Gold, Nightwing,Green Lanterns that aren't Hal, Renee Montoya
>B tier
Martian Manhunter, Barry Allen,
>Everyone else
>Fifty feet of shit
>Apokilops
Hal Jordan, "Badass" Aquaman

>>84959665
>>Everyone else
>>Fifty feet of shit
>>Apokilops
>Hal Jordan, "Badass" Aquaman
Kill yourself, my man

>Top Tier
Green arrow.

>great tier
none.

>Good tier
Nightwing
Detective Comics
Flash

>meh
Green Lanterns
Superman books.
Hal Jordan.

>terrible tier
Everything else.

>didn't read
Aquaman.

>>84951436
>Top Tier
Green Arrow

>Great Tier
Superman
Wonder Woman
Action Comics
Titans (even booth's art is not terrible wtf?)
Nightwing
New Super-Man
Detective Comics

>Good Tier
Green Lanterns
Batman (I'm not sold on this being flawless yet)
Red Hood and the Outlaws (it was solid)
Batgirl (don't care about babs but it was good)
Aquaman
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey

>Meh, but not terrible Tier
Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps (tries too hard to be epic)
Flash (Speed Force was a mistake)

>Terrible Tier
Justice League (i'd rather watch Michael Bay movies)

>>84960216
Badass Aquaman is just a shitty Namor and Jordan is pants on head retarded

>>84960906

Bump Flash up a tier, and Wonder Woman down to "Meh", and that's pretty much my list too.

>>84959665
This tier list reads like babby's first year at /co/ who just read some recommended stuff.

>>84961092
Your mom reads recommend stuff

The only bad one so far is Justice League desu

>>84961417

Even then it's more boring as fuck than "bad".

>>84961417
Nah, Batgirl &BoP was really bad too.
Particularly the art

>>84961478
No JL is pretty bad

>>84962168

Art was really bad, but I didn't hate the writing, I'll wait a bit more, the Rebirth issues can get really stiff.

>>84961417

No, it's bad and rehashed from the rebirth issue.

>Top tier
Superman
Aquaman
Titans
GLs
Green Arrow

>Good tier
Wonder woman
Chinaman
Action comics
Detective comics
Batman
Hal jordan and glc

>Eh... tier
Justice league
Birds of prey
Flash

Rhato rebirth was surprisingly great, but will reserve judgement till the ongoing issues come out.

>>84951436
Is Rebirth a good place to start getting back into DC?

Great:
Batman
New Super-Man
Flash
Green Lanterns
Nightwing

OK:
Green Arrow (Best of these, actually great, but I can never connect with Ollie)
Wonder Woman
Titans (fucking Booth)
Batgirl

>>84951436
>Great Tier
Detective Comics
Wonder Woman
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey

>Good Tier
Nightwing
Batgirl

>Maybe getting better Tier
Batman
Superman

>Have no interest Tier
Green Arrow
Green Lanterns (of any kind)
Action Comics
The Flash
Titans
Teen Titans
Justice League
Hellblazer
Red Hood and the Outlaws
Suicide Squad
Cyborg
Batman Beyond
Blue Beetle

>Waiting to see when they come out Tier
Deathstroke
Supergirl
Superwoman

It's a bit crazy how the ranking of this threads ar different.

And that's great, much better than having one unanimous favorite. It shows that the line is solid enough to have more than just one or two books.

>>84951436

>Top Tier
Green Arrow
Batman

>Great Tier
Wonder Woman
Aquaman
Nightwing
Titans
Batgirl
Hal Jordan

>Meh Tier

>How awful Tier
Birds of Prey

>Didn't Read Tier
Everything else

BoP writing was decent but my god that art

File: q?34.jpg (806KB, 1598x2096px) Image search: [Google]

806KB, 1598x2096px

>>84959665
>Vic Sage
My nigga, wish they'd bring him back

>>84963916
I think it speaks to the overall quality of rebirth that we have such varied opinions, with very few books in the bad tier

File: 1310605113739.jpg (22KB, 493x402px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 493x402px

>>84951436

Rebirth has been complete failure as far as I'm concerned. I wanted real Cassandra Cain and her supporting cast back, and instead I have some fucking X-Men reject called "Orphan".

I'm glad that DC is making an attempt to unfuck itself, but that's all it is from where I'm looking, an attempt.

>God Tier
Superman
Green Arrow
Nightwing
New Super-Man

>Good Tier
The Flash
Titans, even with Booth art
Red Hood and the Outlaws, against all odds
Wonder Woman
Aquaman
Batgirl
Green Lanterns, somehow
Action Comics, but only barely
Detective Comics

>Grodd Tier
Justice League
Hal Jordan and his Amazing Friends
BatBoP
Batman, but it will probably get better in a few months

>Forgot It Exists Tier
The Hellblazer

>>84965153
>Cass is shit
>The whole of Rebirth is shit

I mean, I can understand how Cass fans got the shit end of the stuck but that's retarded.

>>84965336
Did anyone really expect James Tynion to properly balance an ensemble book?

>>84962487
>>84964166
The portion with Huntress in the confession was really, really bad in my opinion, the kind of thing that can ruin an entire chapter as it happened for me

Having her confessing to the priest she has previously killed is something from a C-tier action movie, at best

>>84965336
Cassfags will literally never be happy so it's best not to listen to them

>>84965421
We're 4 issues in, where everything needs to be established. It's way too early to judge things like that.

Yeah, Batwoman got more focus, so what?

>>84965528
The writing was off a bit, but they set up the character dynamics well enough. It feels like one of those books that will smooth itself out over time.

>>84965635
I want to see more Clayface, honestly. Maybe when they kill off Tim, the others will shine more

>>84965571
>Cassfags will literally never be happy

Funny how that only became a problem when their character got shat on in worst ways possible year after year after year.

>>84965989
DC could bring back Puckett to write an Orphan Cass solo and they'd still find shit to complain about

>>84966024
>DC could bring back Puckett to write an Orphan Cass solo and they'd still find shit to complain about
>Orphan Cass
>shit to complain about

Not exactly hard to find, dawg.

Just fucking admit that BRE was a bad idea and erase it from continuity. That's all you need to do. Give Cass her original origin story back. There was nothing wrong with it.

Right now you're asking the fans to accept a character that has:
- different backstory
- different supporting cast
- different abilities
- different costume
- different codename
...And accept her just because her face and name are similar. No. Rebirth is specifically supposed to avoid fuckery like this. Just accept that this is a mistake and correct it, as is the goal of the event.

>>84965571
Same can be said for all characterfags. John Stewart fags will cry racism endlessly whenever Hal Jordan does something, but when it's Cruz or Baz, they'll cry pandering.

And Jasonfags are actually having an argument on CBR over Jason being too hungry in the RHATO flashback

>>84966264
>Jason being too hungry in the RHATO flashback


>Batman doesn't even feed his Robins
>People believe his a hero
When will Supes and co. open their eyes to the dictator of Gotham?

>>84966264
>JasonfagS
It was literally just one person who didn't even like the issue.