http://www.comicbookresources.com/a rticle/cbrs-top-100-comi

>>78559312
>Squirrel Girl will beat Grayson
>Squirrel Girl will beat Multiversity
>Squirrel Girl will beat all of Marvel's actually good books
This can't be happening. Fuck, it's not even an SJW pandering thing, I have no problem with Thor or W+D being on this list, but SG is just bad. BAD!

what's the americans' obsession with making lists and rankings?

>>78559435
They're fun

>>78559312
>The Wicked + The Divine
I'm shocked this isn't in the top ten

File: Super Mutant Magic Academy.jpg (318KB, 550x770px) Image search: [Google]

318KB, 550x770px

> Super Mutant Magic Academy below Archie

>>78559441
they are the contrary of fun.
unless you think getting people to get angry and argue because their tastes have been slighted is fun, in which case this is probably fun for you and you will enjoy shitflinging in this thread.
So, uh, to each their own I guess.

>>78559312
Does shilling pay well? If it does, let me know who to contact, seems like easy money reposting crappy CBR articles on /co/.

>>78559435
>americans
what the fuck kinda assumption is this

everyone makes lists, it's a very normal thing to do

>>78559312
>Batman above Grayson

Into the trash it goes.

>>78559383
>>78559523
CBR is alright

>18. Grayson
>17. Batman

How can one list be this wrong?

>>78560004
Just wait until you see the Top 10.

>>78559312
>24. Thor / Thors / The Mighty Thor

No

>16. Multiversity

Okay, but:

>14. Silver Surfer
>13. Darth Vader
>12. Jem and The Holograms

None of these titles deserve to be above Multiverse.

>>78559574
Ha.

>>78559312
Was Vision ranked already? And are they really going to say Star Wars beats Darth Vader?

>>78560322
Multiversity is highly overrated on /co/

Pax Americana was great. Thunderworld was great. The Just, Mastermen, Ultra Comics, and the Guidebook are fine (I personally like The Just a lot)

but Multiversity was a resounding meh that had no real conclusion.

>>78560407
Yeah Vision was already ranked further up in a previous list

>>78560407
>And are they really going to say Star Wars beats Darth Vader?
Looks like.

>>78560446
It's "overrated" by /co/ because there are a lot of folks on /co/ who aren't ashamed to like comics that aren't ashamed that they're comics.

>no real conclusion
What, and everything else in 25-11 has concluded?

>>78559312
>Thor / Thors / The Mighty Thor
Isn't that like three different fucking comics

>>78560556
Yes and thors has nothing to do with the other two besides having thors in them.

>>78560556
Yup. It was basically, we gotta throw them all in with it as to not make the SJWs mad.

>>78559544
anon wasn't talking about "making lists" in the abstract.

anon is talking about the tendency in western media (short hand: America) to contextualize ideas/events/products within an easily digestible Top 10 or Top 100 format, as if the base-10 numbering system somehow gives us clues as to how we should compartmentalize information.

>>78560598
But the SJWs hated Thors.

>Jem and the Holograms higher than Multiversity
>Silver Surfer higher than Multiversity
>Archie higher than Multiversity

And I thought this list was shit when Jughead scored above Prez.

Also, here's the previous 75:

100. Superman: American Alien
099. Elfquest: The Final Quest
098. Howard The Duck
097. Ant-Man/Ant-Man: Last Days/Astonishing Ant-Man
096. Melody: Story of a Nude Dancer
095. A Silent Voice
094. Dungeon Fun
093. Sex
092. The Dark Knight III: Master Race
091. Batman '66
090. Groot
089. James Bond
088. Berlin
087. DC Comics: Bombshells
086. Shutter
085. Transformers: More Than Meets The Eye
084. Ragnarok
083. The Sandman: Overture
082. Invisible Republic
081. Kaijumax
080. Nimona
079. The Autumnlands
078. The Legend of Wonder Woman
077. Heart in a Box
076. Princess Ugg

075. Batman and Robin Eternal
074. Monstress
073. Hellboy in Hell
072. The Sculptor
071. Fante Bukowski
070. Harley Quinn
069. Island
068. The Goddamned
067. Zodiac Starforce
066. Trashed
065. Weirdworld
064. Danger Club
063. All Star Section 8
062. Plutona
061. Wytches
060. Ruins
059. S.H.I.E.L.D.
058. Amazing Spider-Man
057. MIND MGMT
056. Casanova: Acedia
055. Captain America: Sam Wilson
054. Displacement: A Travelogue
053. Black Magick
052. Copperhead
051. Southern Cross

050. Invisible Ink
049. Giant Days
048. The Walking Dead
047. Prez
046. Jughead
045. Hawkeye
044. Bloom County
043. Sam Zabel and the Magic Pen
042. The Arab of the Future
041. Injection
040. Secret Wars
039. Batgirl
038. Constantine: The Hellblazer
037. Loki: Agent of Asgard
036. Sacred Heart
035. Daredevil
034. Lazarus
033. Stray Bullets: Sunshine and Roses
032. Fight Club 2
031. The Vision
030. Phonogram: The Immaterial Girl
029. The Story of My Tits
028. Southern Bastards
027. Midnighter
026. Descender

File: swag.jpg (75KB, 299x343px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 299x343px

>>78559312
>20. Astro City

Goddamn right.

Thors was also pretty great, I know it's getting in on the strength of Thor but it was still one of my top ten books by itself.

>>78560632
>But the SJWs hated Thors.
Why?

>>78560632
>Thors
Secret Wars Thors?

>>78560708
All the dead Janes.

>>78560720
Yeah.

>le multiveriality was good may may

>>78560792
>"opinions different than mine are a meme" meme

>>78560753
Wondered why would they hate it then I saw >>78560730
Christ.

>>78560792
>le meme meme was a meme may may

>>78560683
why so many comics with like 1 or 2 issues out, unless it's a one shot it's kinda fast to pass judgment

>>78559312
http://www.comicbookresources.com/article/cbrs-top-100-comics-of-2015-10-1

10. The Fade Out
9. Bitch Planet
8. The Omega Men
7. Step Aside, Pops
6. Paper Girls
5. Unbeatable Squirrel Girl
4. Star Wars
3. March: Book Two
2. Ms. Marvel
1. Saga

>>78560792
>>78560807
>>78560860
A microcosm of cultural freudo-marxism

>>78560926
All my keks are stolen.

>>78560926
Kek holy fucking shit. Way to call it /co/. Sites like this should be banned from the Internet.

>>78560926
>Saga
>Saga
>SAGA
>SA MOTHERFUCKING GA

Well, at least Omega Men was in the top ten. Then again,
>Squirrel Girl scoring higher than Omega Men

>>78560926
Wow it's fucking nothing. Glad to see Brubaker and Philips is repped even amongst plebs but fuck me this list is the definition of jewry.

File: 1444073952877.jpg (242KB, 1229x1330px) Image search: [Google]

242KB, 1229x1330px

>>78560926

>>78560926
End it pham.

>>78560926
but darth vader is much better than star wars

>>78560926
Too many errors in this list too even make a comment. All I will say is that I'm glad that they gave Omega Men a top 10 spot, but at the same time, I hope no one takes this list seriously.

>>78561067
If you have any kind of taste, yes.

>>78560556
It's all one run. Everything got relaunched for Secret Wars then again for ANAD. Blame Marvel's love of relaunches.

Would you rather one run get 3 spots?

>>78560926
lel

>>78560926
>Omega Men made the Top 10
>still got beat by USG
On one hand, USG being there invalidates the ENTIRE list. On the other hand, I didn't even expect Omega Men to get on the list, so it getting #8 is awesome.

>>78560938
Read that as fedora-marxism, which is far more appropriate given the context to be quite honest familia-senpai.

>>78560926
Hey. Considering it was almost prematurely cancelled, seeing The Omega Men in the top 10 feels good...

File: 1441420822668.png (448KB, 666x664px) Image search: [Google]

448KB, 666x664px

>>78560926
>1. Saga
>Saga
>At Number (Numero) 1

Ok, there are at least some good comics at the top ten (The Omega Men, Ms Marvel) and there are some obvious stupid choices, like Squirrel Girl at 5 (Although I'm glad that it's not the 1st place), and Star Wars being better than Darth Vader, but seriously, Saga at Numbah 1?

ARE YOU FUCKING SERIOUS, CBRats?

Wait people actually like the Darth Vader comics? They are shit. Same with omega men

>>78561235
It's the normie comic book.

File: hork hork.jpg (346KB, 1280x771px) Image search: [Google]

346KB, 1280x771px

>>78560926
this is the future you chose.

>>78561099
>I hope no one takes this list seriously.
Everyone will take it seriously.

>thinking saga is bad
Why

>>78561283
Because the will ain't the main.

And other people like it.

>>78560683
While DC Bombshells and Legend of Wonder Woman ranked lower than I had hoped, the fact Wonder Finch and SMxWW didn't even place makes my heart soar...

>>78561304
But robot IV is a main and he is best

I just counted, and it looks like there were 18 Marvel books in the list and 17 DC books. I didn't bother counting the Image books or other books.

That's actually closer than I expected the split to be, though I may have missed one or two books from either side. In any case, it almost makes me wonder if they fudged with the results to ensure an even split between the Big Two's presence.

>>78561415
Yeah there should have been way less Marvel books, I agree.

File: jVGyOHYBIbgRwCcM5xB-VCudyVQ3J4BdwgV2KzAJ7FE.jpg (32KB, 600x273px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 600x273px

>#58: Amazing Spider-Man
>#24: Thor/Thors/Mighty Thor
>#5: Squirrel Girl
>#4: Star Wars

No Forever Evil. No Justice League. No Carnage: Axis

What a fucking shit list

>Copra not even on the list
This is surprising considering how much of an indie darling it is. But I guess it wasn't mainstream or SJW enough for these faggots.

File: rareMonster.png (175KB, 653x490px) Image search: [Google]

175KB, 653x490px

>>78560683
>33. Stray Bullets
Top 100 of 2015 rank

>287 - 4,583
November 2015 sales rank

THIS IS THE FUTURE YOU CHOSE

>>78561501
It sells well digitally!

The only solace I can take from this is that Captain Marvel & Spider-Gwen aren't listed

Also, Silk should have been on the list

>>78561452
>should have been
Anon, this is CBR. It's a wonder that 90% of the list isn't Marvel, let alone any DC books besides Batgirl being on there at all. Most comic "journalism" sites hate DC because they don't pander to tumblr enough and hate quality, provocative storytelling that pushes the medium forward. That's why they love all this memeshit that image pumps out and Marvel's SJW comics.

File: wat.png (198KB, 672x520px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 672x520px

>>78561515
I have no idea if you just maymay'd or if it actually sells well digitally.

>>78561473
>Forever Evil
>2015
>AXIS
>2015
Are you ACTUALLY retarded or just pretending to be?

Seriously, are there ANY comic sites that don't cock garble at the altar of Marvel or SJW/feminist bullshit?

>>78560538
Multiversity isn't a comic that isn't ashamed that it's a comic. In fact, i'd call it the complete opposite of that. A TV show that references that its a TV show doesn't mean it's proud of being a TV show. Morrison appeals to literally people who want to call comics an "intellectual medium" that can approach grand topics and concepts.

Something like Dial H or even fucking Deadpool do a better job of feeling comic book-y than Multiversity. Multiversity is exactly for people who feel ashamed that they read comics because they have to go "SEE! Superhero comics can be deep too!!"

>>78561563
Maymay. Everything sells well digitally, according to Marvel.
Except Superior Foes, of course. Fuck that book.

>>78559574
CBR's shit, m8. They're company stooges.

>>78561067
They are Disney shills, they can't admit a side book is better than the main book, hell, they made an entire article dedicated to defending TFA from some random guy on the Internet.

Nice to see the best comic book of the decade at #1.

>>78561584
/co/ but no one gives a shit about this board cause /b/ gave 4chan such a bad name.

/co should do a list

>>78561259
You gotta try harder than that, son.

File: 1422848215425.png (249KB, 421x500px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 421x500px

>>78561564

Idk man...sometimes I feel like i've lost track of time

>>78561270
You can almost smell the asspain.

>>78561473
Forever Evil and Carnage came out last year

>>78561645
And people don't like us because we call Jane Whor.

>>78561646
last time /co/ did comic awards, Superior Memes of Spider-Man won best comic of the year

>>78561689
She's woman Thor. She is Whor.

>>78561646
Right, because it's not just going to be:
>1. Multiversity
>2. Omega Men
>3. Grayson
>4. Vision
>5-100. lol fuck off back to tumblr, comics are literally memes desu senpai

File: 1417632386117.jpg (2MB, 1988x3056px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1988x3056px

>>78561691

Superior Foes is great and I won't hear anything otherwise

>>78561235
This list is made for normies.

>>78561738
Foes> Ant-Man.

>>78561689
I can't blame them, that's something a 13 year old would come up with.

>>78561725
Sounds like a good list tbqhwyf

How could anyone dislike Saga?

>>78561738
>thanks obama

>>78561725
I see nothing at all wrong with that list. Do you disagree?

>>78559312
>Squirrel girl is top 10
>Thor is even in the list at all
>Saga at number 1
These are dark times ideed.

>>78561783
The age of the /co/mrades is over. This is now the age of the /co/ntrarians.

>>78561792
Well, it certainly proves that /co/ doesn't read comics and that you guys love to suck Tom King's cock.

File: independent thought alarm.gif (1MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 640x360px

>>78561802

>>78561821
I'll stop sucking his cock when it starts tasting so good

to be fair he's about due for /co/ to suddenly change their collective opinion of him and decide he was never THAT good

>>78561858
I think Robin War was the first step in that direction.

>>78561821
Cause we don't agree with your pleb ass hipster taste? Sure mate, sure. Come back when you've read comics for more than a year.

>>78561858
No, he has to get on a big book first. Grayson and Vision are both small enough for him to skate by.

Wait for him to get Avengers or Batman.

>>78561879
You can't blame that on Tom King.

>>78561858
It's why people need to start screenshotting all the pro-King posts

>>78561595
Where I differ is that I think the "forced depth" of a Morrison book is AT LEAST working within the idioms and tropes of comic books. Layouts MEAN something. He still treats the superhero as an idealistic image. He's not Millar or Bendis or Miller or Moore. He's not ashamed of being corny or sentimental.

I agree about Deadpool and Dial H.

My "comics that are ashamed to be comics" was directed more at very specific books.
>Unbeatable Squirrel Girl
>Hellcat
>Thor
>elements of recent Batgirl, Starfire
>method of "passing the torch" implemented with Hawkeye, Wolverine, Captain America, Thor
>Saga
These are comics that trade on the value of being "OBVIOUSLY NOT FOR ICKY FAT MAN CHILDREN."

In the cases of "passing the torch," they not only made sure to make the "new occupant" worthy, they made damn sure to de-power, shame, humiliate and otherwise emasculate the "original."

It's not enough to just BE the hero now. The old hero has to be destroyed in such a way as to make you question his worthiness in the first place.

To my eye, "put him in a diaper" is the male equivalent of "being stuffed in the fridge."

>>78561858
STOPS tasting, I mean

>>78561879
I haven't seen that much grumbling about Robin War, wait until he's on a big book like >>78561894 says or when he gets a Marvel exclusive

CBR hates Valiant or something

>>78561283
It's not bad, but it certainly isn't the best comic of the year.

>>78561936
It's the best comic every year, homie. It's got great writing and the best art period.

So I read Squirrel Girl this weekend (got it from the Library).

Why do people like it? And at the same time, why do people hate it so much? The art's bad and the humor and plots are boring, but there's books with worse art and writing that don't get that much hate.

>>78561888
I'm pretty sure I've been reading comics for much longer than you have.

>>78562015
15 years mate. Indie titles are great and all but their world is shallow and eventually you are gonna want deeper lore.

>>78561919
Moore isn't ashamed of comic books at all, come back when you know what you're talking about and stop seeing a nonexisting agenda everywhere.

>>78561924
I saw a lot of grumbling in the storytime of the first issue, and I don't see people talking about it without there being a new issue (unlike other crossovers and other TK comics.)

>>78561919
Wait, when had Miller been ashamed of comics?

>>78562039
I've been reading comics for over 15 years too. So I've got "pleb ass hipster taste" for wanting nice, self-contained stories that won't be overturned by some other hack later on and with character development that actually matters in the long run? Stories where the authors actually have a point to make instead of the "good guy punch bad guy" that has come to plague superhero stories so much lately? And really? "Muh lore"? Are we really going down that rabbit hole?

>>78561879
He's not even writing Robin War predominantly, he's just a rotating fill in.

>>78562090
Maybe you are just reading pleb ass superhero stories. Also lore is a valid point so stop trying to meme your way into being correct.

Maybe try Astro City or Grayson.

>>78562092
He wrote the bookends

>>78562000
for the dislike, part of it is resentment. people having a favorite artist they'd rather the Marvel job went to. Part of it is frustration since the artist/writer is friends with an admin on...comicvine I think, so SG gets regularly plugged as 'If you want girls in comics, buy SG!' at the expense of other female led comic books of higher quality like Prez or Tomboy. Part of it is straight up dislike for her 'always wins' gag, mostly from fans of villains that hate seeing them humiliated.

for the like, no idea, but from glancing at the letters page it seems like the target audience is 4-12 year old girls, and frankly only bad things come from caring about little girls liking the 'wrong' things.

>>78562123
>Maybe you are just reading pleb ass superhero stories
Sure bud, I've been reading cape stuff all the way since the 1930's to present day, I'm sure I've just being missing the really good stuff.

>Also lore is a valid point so stop trying to meme your way into being correct
No, it's fucking not, it's just a cheap and shallow way to try to make a story more deep than it really is. Pacing, character development, pathos, a well crafted structure, dialogue, a fucking point, these are all the things that matter in a story, and superhero stories from the Big Two are certainly missing that last one nowadays, when every event that promises to "change everything forever" is overturned by another one in a matter of months, when the latest change in status quo for a character is just done for shock value and you know it's not going to last because it's happened so many times before.

>Maybe try Astro City or Grayson
Astro City isn't a Big Two superhero story, it's a creator owned story, as such, the characters are allowed to evolve, grow old, develop, and even die and stay dead. The stories actually build up to something and you know they will matter because no one else is going to take the book from Busiek.
Grayson is nice, but it won't last, it's just another interesting experiment by the Big Two waiting to be overturned by some uncreative hack that wants to bring everything back to the previous status quo.

>>78562092
He did write the best parts of Robin War, though. The weaker issues were by Ray Fawkes. And then shit tie-ins were Lobdell, predictably

>>78562044
>>78562073
you're missing my point. Miller and Moore pick characters apart in order to humanize them and bring them "down to earth/into the filth". They're two of my favorite creators, I'm not hatin on their output.

But Morrison, at least comparatively, is happy to let his characters stay "god-like." He's trying to build a pantheon, as opposed to humanizing a modicum of one.

>>78562164
>If you want girls in comics, buy SG!' at the expense of other female led comic books of higher quality like Prez or Tomboy.

It's also presumptuous to think women only want/read titles with female protagonists. I've shown my girlfriend several of these "tumblr approved" comics like Batgirl, Captain Marvel, and Young Avengers, and her response to them was lukewarm. But she loved Gotham By Midnight and Swamp Thing because of all the gruesome stuff that goes down.

>>78562257
Who fucking cares if it's overturned, it happened.

>>78562257
>it won't last, it's just another interesting experiment by the Big Two waiting to be overturned by some uncreative hack that wants to bring everything back to the previous status quo.
Who cares? No ongoing run is going to last forever. As long as it's good right now, then nothing else matters.

>>78560926
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsbYx6hevoQ

>>78562000
This is how I feel about the new Batgirl run.

On one hand, some people are putting way too much effort into hating it as much as possible.

On the other hand, when someone calls it groundbreaking or innovative, they're really discrediting other books with similar direction but with much better writing (Ms. Marvel, Silk, etc).

>>78559312
>East of West top 10 in 2013
>Drops to the 50s in 2014
>Completely falls off list in 2015
kek

>>78562279
But that only seems to be in regards to characters, not the medium itself.

>>78562385
This happens to basically all indie books except Saga and Walking Dead.

See how Sex Criminals isn't on the list at all, etc.

>>78562385
Which is made even fucking worse by the fact that East of West has been getting BETTER while Saga has been getting WORSE. The most recent issue alone was better than any of this year's issues of Saga.

I don't think either of them deserve to be the "best comic of 2015" but seeing EoW drop-off while Saga keeps rising despite their quality being the inverse is baffling.

>>78562443
Sex Criminals will be top 10 I'm sure though.

>>78562485
It's not >>78560926

>>78562485
See:
>>78560926

It didn't.

>>78562481
I mean Saga shouldn't even be in the top 100 period. That shit may have flown in 2012 but there's a million better sci-fi comics now.

>>78562507
>>78562508
Oops, thought the top 10 would wait until tomorrow.

Why doesn't /co/ just make a list of the best 2015 comics then?

File: naoto.png (477KB, 649x643px) Image search: [Google]

477KB, 649x643px

>>78559312
>>78560683
>>78560926
So Catwoman, Gotham Academy, Gotham by Midnight, and Son of Batman didn't even make the list? Is this list some kind of popularity poll or something? Why the hell should I care about this list anyway?

I love Batman but it doesn't deserve to be that high, this year sucked. Squirrel Girl is garbage. American Alien made the list with literally two issues out. Paper Girls has 3. And Saga at number 1? I don't understand..

>>78560926
The Fade Out is top ten material but the rest... jeez. Star Wars? Really? Fuck off.

>>78562519
I disagree. I think it's still good enough to rate on the list. Towards the end of the list, granted, but it's still pretty good and there's something to be said for a creator-owned book with no adaptations of any kind boosting its profile having consistently high sales its getting.

Not that sales = quality, but still, it clearly resonates with enough people that thinking it belongs on a Top 100 of the year list is valid.

You're right that there has been a fucking glut of sci-fi action comics in 2015 though. It's like 3/4ths of Image's output these days.

>>78562579
>Is this list some kind of popularity poll or something?
yeah basically

>>78562565

Right here >>78561725

>>78562579
> Is this list some kind of popularity poll
I'm pretty sure that's exactly what it is.

>>78562587
And Omega Men, and March

>>78562601
Why not an actual list?

>>78562601
Is it just Big Two comics? Add Prez, Midnighter, Gotham by Midnight and Section 8 too and you basically have the only comics the majority of /co/ seems to like.

Maybe if we think hard enough we can get 10 books there.

File: Tiny knives.png (25KB, 375x325px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 375x325px

>Archie at #11
>Archie on the list at all
>Archie being higher than Archie vs Predator

>>78562679
Ragnarok, Kaijumax, Harrow County, Onyx, and Autumnlands would be my picks.

>>78559312
>150 comments about the "wrong" rankings
You fucking autists, you're missing the point. It's a list of notable titles of the year, that's all.

File: 1425772805422.png (578KB, 600x580px) Image search: [Google]

578KB, 600x580px

>>78560926
>5. Unbeatable Squirrel Girl
>1. Saga

>>78563085
Shut the fuck up shill. It's numbered so that's the order they rank them.

>>78562759
Archie vs. Predator didn't even make the list ffs
So much for supporting women writers, right CBR? But no, let's just keep shilling the biggest releases of the year, clearly what matters here is how much coverage these comics got and not how good any of them are.

File: You keep using that word.jpg (45KB, 500x420px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 500x420px

>>78561691
>Memes

>>78561725
good list you forgot sandman overture, ultimates and midnighter though.

>>78561689
You mean she is not?

>>78561283
The quality is nowhere near what it was a while back. It getting placed so high just feels like it is due to past success rather than current quality.

>>78563283
Catwoman didn't make the list either.

File: image.jpg (5KB, 137x105px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 137x105px

>>78563248
Wew, CBR sure knows their audience. Make a list, number the entries and you won't even need a clickbait title or a forced controversy.

File: AND THEN.jpg (235KB, 451x700px) Image search: [Google]

235KB, 451x700px

>>78560446
>no real conculsion
that's the point

>>78563455
In what fucking ass backwards world do you live in where you don't list things based on importance? I think you obsessing over how the list isn't ranked, it's just a list with numbers, is much more autistic.

>>78562679
Godzilla in Hell and Archie vs. Predator

>>78560926
>Omega Men in top 10
Everything went slightly better but still pretty much exactly as expected

>>78562679
that Injustice annual from yesterday

File: image.jpg (60KB, 500x344px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 500x344px

>>78560926
I am past angry. I'm not even upset

>>78561283
Saga is the UnderTale of /co/

Wait, why do we give a shit about some stupid ranking though?

Surely we have better things to discuss.

>>78563085
What was notable about Saga?

>>78564090
It's a competently written non-capeshit series.

>>78564250
Well so was East of West but it's not even on the list

>>78564078
/co/ prefers being angry at things that don't matter

>>78559312
>Grayson didn't list last year
>top 20 this year

lol

>>78561725
>Not including Robin war or Sheriff of Babylon

What was in the top ten last year and the year before?

>>78564543
>2014
1. Ms. Marvel
2. Saga
3. The Multiversity
4. Moon Knight
5. Sex Criminals
6. Lumberjanes
7. Lazarus
8. Afterlife with Archie
9. The Wicked + The Divine
10. She-Hulk

>2013
1. Hawkeye
2. Saga
3. March
4. Lazarus
5. Young Avengers
6. Battling Boy
7. East of West
8. The Wake
9. Daredevil
10. Boxers & Saints

>>78564517
Robin War isn't consistent enough

ctrl f
>deadly class
>0 hits

Shit everything, burn it down.

>>78564543
Was curious, so I did the top 25 of the past five years.

2010
25. S.W.O.R.D.
24. Scarlet
23. X'ed OUt
22. Hark! A Vagrant
21. Scott Pilgrim's Finest Hour
20. Stumptown
19. The Unwritten
18. The Walking Dead
17. Beasts of Burden / Hellboy: Sacrifice
16. Duncan the Wonder Dog
15. Brightest Day
14. Demo 2
13. Chew
12. Return of the Dapper Man
11. Morning Glories
10. Wilson
9. American Vampire
8. Thor: The Mighty Avenger
7. Love & Rockets New Stories
6. King City
5. Scalped
4. Parker: The Outfit
3. Daytripper
2. The Batman Comics of Grant Morrison
1. Acme Novelty Library #20: Lint


2011
25. Petrograd
24. Big Questions
23. Wolverine & the X-Men
22. Super Dinosaur
21. Butcher Baker the Righteous Maker
20. Garden
19. One Soul
18. Batman vol. 2
17. Casanova: Avaritia
16. Green River Killer: A True Detective Story
15. Aquaman vol. 7
14. Action Comics vol. 2
13. Anya's Ghost
12. Swamp Thing vol. 5
11. Wonder Woman vol. 4
10. Batwoman
9. Detective Comics vol. 1
8. Ultimate Comics Spider-Man
7. Scalped
6. Uncanny X-Force
5. Habibi
4. Love & Rockets New Stories 4
3. Hark! A Vagrant
2. Animal Man
1. Daredevil
2012
25. Revival
24. B.P.R.D.
23. Ultimate Spider-Man / Spider-Men
22. Locke & Key
21. Wonder Woman
20. Rachel Rising
19. xkcd
18. League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Century: 2009
17. Punk Rock Jesus
16. The Unwritten
15. Mind the Gap
14. Avatar: The Last Airbender - The Promise
13. 2000 A.D.
12. Animal Man & Swamp Thing: Rotworld
11. Fatale
10. Hellblazer
9. Uncanny X-Force
8. The Underwater Welder
7. The Manhattan Projects
6. Daredevil
5. Prophet
4. Batman
3. Hawkeye
2. Building Stories
1. Saga

>>78564998
2013
25. Pretty Deadly
24. Superior Foes of Spider-Man
23. Locke & Key
22. MIND MGMT
21. Trillium
20. Batman
19. The Fifth Beatle
18. Hellboy in Hell
17. Fatale
16. The Property
15. Astro City
14. Bad Houses
13. Sex Criminals
12. The Private Eye
11. Superior Spider-Man
10. Boxers & Saints
9. Daredevil
8. The Wake
7. East of West
6. Battling Boy
5. Young Avengers
4. Lazarus
3. March
2. Saga
1. Hawkeye


2014
25. Amazing Spider-Man / Superior Spider-Man
24. Wytches
23. Silver Surfer
22. Astro City
21. Stray Bullets: Killers
20. The Wrenchies
19. Chew
18. The Walking Dead
17. Southern Bastards
16. This One Summer
15. Can't We Talk About Something More Pleasant
14. Daredevil
13. Batman
12. Seconds
11. Hawkeye
10. She-Hulk
9. The Wicked + The Divine
8. Afterlife with Archie
7. Lazarus
6. Lumberjanes
5. Sex Criminals
4. Moon Knight
3. The Multiversity
2. Saga
1. Ms. Marvel

>>78564998
>>78565029
So apparently their fucking standards dropped year by year.

Like seriously, Lumberjanes at 6. when The Wrenchies is at 20.?

>>78564998
Wow, that 2010 list has a lot of "art" comics in the top 10

>>78562390
I guess I see certain character archetypes as integral components of what Dave Sim would call "comic book metaphysics."

File: 1451569703334s.jpg (3KB, 115x125px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 115x125px

>>78560926
I'm more angry about Saga being first than SG,I mean the're some good books like Omega Men,Bitch Planet and Ms.Marvel and I just don't get why everyone loses their shit with Saga.

>>78565143
Now that you mention it, not counting Vertigo, there's only four Marvel and DC books in the top 25. And SWORD barely made it.

>>78564998
proof that 2010-2012 were decent years for comics. so much good shit on those lists

Why didn't that Sabrina comic place? I read the first few issues in /co/ storytime threads, and they seemed pretty good.

>>78567939
Fiona Staples

>>78559312

>OP confirmed for not being truly outrageous.

>>78568058
Also, CBR weren't as big sellouts.

>>78568201
I don't mind the comic, I just think it's hilarious that they ranked it so high seeing how it's written by one of their staff members. Like I said, no shame.

>>78568289
true. alas, they need to be sellouts to keep funding their website. still, it's nice to see books like king city in the top ten been thinkin about storytiming it myself

>>78564998
>>78565029
>The red-hot Image book for normies missed the no. 1 spot for two years

So basically the battle for no. 1 in those yearly CBR lists since AvX is whatever Marvel book with muh much praise elsewhere vs. Saga.

>>78560926
>Papergirls in top 10
>only 3 issues out
>ms marvel and saga being in top ten again
>SG in top 5
cbr columnist continue to prove their stupidity

>>78560926
>5. Unbeatable Squirrel Girl
>1. Saga
I think I died a little bit inside.

>>78559312
Top three

3. Captain Marvel
2. Ms Marvel
1. Squirrel Girl

>>78564998
it's honestly ridiculous that saga has been either one or two since 2012

>>78568846
ms marvel was 2, squirrel girl at 5.
cap marvel didnt even rank i think

So what WAS COTY 2015? I can't think of one other Mutliveirsty I guess but I probably just have shit taste

>>78569137
Archie vs Predator

>>78568927
I agree I've thought Saga was pure shit from the start and I just don't understand what people see in it

>>78569137
Dunno, probably something from Fanta.

>>78569215
Its a post-modern space opera, so of course hipsters eat it up.

>>78569137
transformers v gi joe

>>78560926
>unbeatable squirrel girl
>top 10
I just threw up in my mouth

>>78565029
2014 is where it all went wrong

Would any of y'all be interested in a Lady Killer storytime?

>>78571703
In this thread?

>>78571719
Nah, a new thread. so folks can find it in the catalog. But you can link it.

>>78571738
Oh cool, then yeah go ahead KS. Never read it but I heard it's good.