My fellow millennials who would you consider the pink flyod of

>>733374913
Magna Carta Cartel

>>733374913

Ulver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AUQpHPPbdCI

>>733374913

Who is pink floyd?

You got a link to her mixtape?

>>733375013
bump

>>733374913

No one. Prog rock is dead. Mars Volta maybe?

>>733374913
None.

>>733374913
Animal collective

Harry styles is a bit like pink floyd &beatles

>>733374913
Drake Bell

>>733375069
69s are truth bedlam in goliath is a master piece.

My Morning Jacket

>>733375228
Have you listened to their new ep?

there is none

tool can be argued for in a way. others can too but none of them come close

Bassnectar

Tame for sure

Basshunter

Dimitri Vegas
&
Like Mike

File: 6600599.jpeg.png (103KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]

103KB, 720x720px

Ween, no question.

Basseater

>>733375281
This

DJ Snake

>>733374913
pink floyd

BassJackers

Frank Oceans Blonde album is a timeless piece and will always be good

Nicki minaj

>>733375281
Bassnectar is fucking garbage. I don't understand how people can listen to a single bass line at nausium for hours on end.

Carl Cox

Bass crown

Tool

Pretty Lights if you're into the EDM scene. Listen to live recordings with the band.
Puscifer comes on top for me though. Live shows are a combination of theatrical performance, visuals, and outstanding music with underlying tones of reality.

Bassmakers

>>733375473
Get with the yolo

Deadmau5 is pretty cool

Basscapades

File: 1phxof.jpg (35KB, 500x437px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 500x437px

>>733375473

>>733375513
This.

Bassterjaxx

Bassmill

>>733374913
Darude

Bassbass

Dream theater

File: Screenshot_.jpg (2MB, 1740x999px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1740x999px

Stop labeling everything, newfag.

Susan boyle

>>733374913
There will never be anything near that level of talent

>>733375683
oh no, a anime retard lover.
How is life in your basement kiddo? How old are you now? 14? Good for you big boy!

Basshell

>>733374913
>>733375677
I love both of those bands, but no.

>>733374913
>>733375351
Tame Impala/ Ween qualify as being Floyd-Like in spirit, rather than shitty edm shit or something.

>>733375281
>>733375319
>>733375360
>>733375394
>>733375486
>>733375538
>>733375580
>>733375640
>>733375657
>>733375676
>>733375749


Tied for these

File: IMG_1802.png (262KB, 500x497px) Image search: [Google]

262KB, 500x497px

>>733375013
Kek

boards of canada

Basspage

Bassdrop

Bassclapper

Bassboomers

>>733374913
Of Montreal

17 years old here

My favorite albums:

Interpol - TOTBL
Daft Punk - Discovery
Radiohead - OK Computer
Pink Floyd - Animals

>>733375940
reported for underage faggot

Flaming Lips

>>733375940
Mods.

Basslayer

>>733375743
I wish I was still 14..
>Sad.gif

>>733375940
>interpol
An hero, you know you want to.

File: jailb8.png (334KB, 287x394px) Image search: [Google]

334KB, 287x394px

>>733375940
b&

Bassclock

>>733375969
>>733375970

Im on my school wifi, even if they ban me I will still continue to post from my home

>>733374913
Just to be clear, OP, you're asking for the worst band whose members are all currently about 30, right?

Ace of Bass

File: 81LqUMYQhmL._SL1500_.jpg (274KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

274KB, 1500x1500px

Tool

>>733375069
mars volta are garbage and have been since 2004

File: 1200x630bb.jpg (25KB, 630x630px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 630x630px

>>733374962
Came here to post this.

FUCK tobias forge.

>>733374993

Oh man Future Sound of Music and Hallways of Always two of my all time favs

mac demarco is lennon
kevin parker is pink floyd

Post Animal, highly recommend them.

>>733376252
Can you stop the micro-agression?
Gawwd I'm offended, community member!

>>733376231
yeah but they're not pink floyd

>>733376400
Huh

Bassflopp

Basstrouble

Basschair

Basstable

Bassnectar

Basshoney

Bassquote

>>733376119
That's not how it works, kiddo.

Bassjam

Basscar

Bassectomy

Basswaiter

Bassplane

Basscook

Basshigh

Bassbutter

Basscreeper

Bassquads

>>733374913
our generation doesn't make music, so no one

Bassdub

Amazing bassera.

Bassphemy

Bassperger

File: 1495300276382.png (492KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

492KB, 800x600px

>>733375743
>be on site originally about japanese culture
>on site based on japanese counterpart
>Anon complains about anime
>mfw

Bassinonyou

>>733375743
>been here since summer break

lurk moar faggot

Bassflailers

>>733376773
It's more of a tool to view summerfags, fine by me

>>733374913
Temples OP Temples are the Floyd of the modern age

>>733376868
you've been reported to the official admins for saying that

File: 1495096030515.jpg (85KB, 1137x1012px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 1137x1012px

>>733376868
Lurking won't help him Anon

Bassfukr

>>733376953
no but it will shut him up

File: 1494467745045.gif (1MB, 800x533px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 800x533px

>>733376931

if by "pink floyd" you mean really good music, then I'd say we're at a point where you either have to choose between mainstream pop (because it's popular, not because it's good) or you'd have to pick your favorite from one of the thousands of niche subgenres that music has evolved into. so basically
-arctic monkeys
-flume
-alt-j
-any other artist that brings something to the table and has their own identity, rather than this lil uzi/migos/drake/lil yachty/xxxtentation/kodakblak bullshit where every song objectively sounds the same

>>733375513
>meme rock
>pink floyd of our generation
pick one

File: randymarsh.jpg (177KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 500x500px

there won't be another pink floyd
there won't be another 'dark side of the moon'
there won't be another insanely popular album that's meant to be played in one sitting
it's all single songs these days
3 minute servings of beats and jingles collected together in some youtube playlist

>>733376931
>my uncle knows 4chan, he'll ban you

>>733376992
>>733376953
>>733376901
>>733376868
>>733376773
You've all been baited :) :P

>>733377067
Bass pro shops

>>733374913
Modest Bass

>>733377038
I can't disagree, though, there \are\ still some albums sharing the beauty.

>>733377067
Not be the emoji dude.
That's certain

Bassmodest

>>733377148
>By*

>>733377167
Bea

>>733377038
this, until a band comes out with a great rock opera, there will never be a pink floyd of our generation

File: 1492398036510.jpg (82KB, 1000x1118px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 1000x1118px

Probably the closest you faggot millenials will get. You are the worst generation ever.

https://youtu.be/ZADckLlzPao

>>733377209
Bay

>>733377228
>'91
Dude, am I a millennial?

>>733377228
Wait for Gen Zyklon. They'll top us.

>>733377299
a generation comprised of failed abortions...

>>733377228
I'm a huge JK fan and a huge dark star fan but they aren't our modern Pink Floyd, they're just the best dead cover band

>>733377282
Yes

there is no pink floyd of our generation cause our parents effectively murdered them by doing a war on drugs

>>733377468
Huh, shitty gen.
Doing nothing and brainwashed to infinity.
Hope the next gen is less shitty.
Oh, more genders.. yeah.. no.

>>733377557
Says the dude who can't find drugs.

>The Contortionist

>>733377038

What about Muse and 'Exogenesis', for example and just to name a pretty popular band

The Mars Volta, no doubt

>>733377578
I should add Justin Bieber and liberalism.

>>733374913
Daft Punk. Yes I'm a fan boy. But I'm a PF fanboy too. Listen to Touch. Or this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JF_QVNfyRY8 everyone called that Pink Punk or Daft Floyd when it dropped. They may not be as psychadelic, but they're definitely on the same level of creativity. I'm happy they've become a household name in recent years.

>>733377789
no they aren't, don't get me wrong daft punk is pretty good but nowhere near the same level as pink floyd

>>733374913
Muse

>>733374913
You wont know until like 30 years from now. In Floyds time a lot of bullshit was released and a lot of great stuff, maybe in better than floyd probably came too that never stuck and faded into irrelevance.

Gotta wait and see what people are still listening to and whats being praised as timeless.

>>733375818
you'll listen to anything containing bass in it's name, won't you?

Boogie Matrix Mechanism. They were a group from my area that played with yonder and rumpke mountain boys a few times.

Already split up but they were the closest of anything ive ever heard.

>>733374913
I need a definition

>>733377915
Their evolution from their acid house beginnings to RAM is untouchable compared to their contemporaries. Their way ahead of everyone else. Just like PF in their prime.

Unrelated: Anyone here seen Roger Waters on tour this year yet?

Can't believe no one's said this yet

Godspeed You! Black Emperor

>>733378149
read this
>>733377220

>>733378149
They're*

File: 1f189-ok252bcomputer252bpng.png (249KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

249KB, 500x500px

sup /b/

>>733378234
Listen to their visual album Discovery. It was never done before. A House Opera? The fuck? The movie accompanying it is extra feelsy too. I'm telling you, they're on that level man. I may not call them the PF of this generation, but they're up there with them imo.

File: south-park-s11e09c05-bonos-broken-record-16x9.jpg (117KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 960x540px

>>733374913

Maybe U2.
It's bad, old and overated.

>>733378424
i did, it wasn't good, but it wasn't as bad as some, like i said they're pretty good but not on the same level
>>733378455
obvious b8

>>733374913
No one, not yet.

Just go find David Gilmour's stuff from post Pink Floyd, there is a good torrent for his concert Remember That Night on tpb

ITT pretentious music snobs with shit tier tastes and no comprehension of true uniqueness.

>>733378649
pls teach me uniqueness, bro

>>733378551
To each their own m8. I respect it.

But did you watch Interstellar 5555?

It really adds layers to each track.

>>733374913
Arctic Monkeys

>>733378893
Nah,, Pink Floyd always pushed the boundaries, The Arctic Monkeys are just regurgitating the same dad-rock tropes that everybody else has been at since the 1980s.

Ok guys, so how about summing it up?
Tell me, what is special and unique about Pink Floyd? I recognize this band to be genius and one of a kind, but have troubles with nailing why so.

>>733379149
As a PF fanboy I can confidently say you're not the only one. They just struck all the right chords, so to speak. And because of that their music is just timeless. Musical perfection that transcends time. Kinda wanna shoe horn DP back into this...but I'll leave it alone ;)

>>733374913
I fucking love Kevin Parker.

File: shortsharpshock.jpg (30KB, 278x278px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 278x278px

>>733374913
Pink Floyd
you faggot

>>733375069
Yesss

limp bizkit

>>733374913
kesha

>>733374913
The Porcupine Tree comes pretty close, too bad the band isn't touring together now, hopefully they'll reunite someday soon

>>733378087
Bassically

>>733377252
Bee

kill yourselves all of you
,,as soon as possible.
this thread gave me autism

>>733380724
nah, you had autism way earlier

>>733377030
>Implying pink floyd isn't meme rock

>>733374913
I like the band but... they're not as popular and iconic as pink floyd.

Arcade fire hands down. Reflektor stands with anything PF released

>>733375393
This

>>733381041
Was that last record any good? I havent checked it out yet

>>733375513
This.
Tool, apc, puscifer. Deep shit

File: 1494264318563.jpg (38KB, 500x617px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 500x617px

>>733381291
Being this gay

>>733375876
Yes.

>>733374913
no one
floyd had their own approach to production.
as a matter of fact, they were responsible for a lot of technical innovations that today's bands take for granted.
bands these days also can't afford to rent studios 24/7, even if the scheduling allows them free access to the studio.

add to the fact that every engineer, sound tech, producer and record mogul wants to change whatever any band records (so that they can claim direct involvement in the project) and you have a playing field that ends up yards deep in crap.

there is no modern floyd, that brand of creative freedom is long dead.

>>733378372
This faggot didnt even pick the bends.

>>733378067
Not the same. Back then there was niche music of course, but this was before the internet, videos, hip hop bullshit that tainted radio play, and there were record shops where people talked about and listened to music together. A Pink Floyd would fail now and vanish into obscurity because they weren't good looking, didn't care about making the songs friendly to singles, and required a level of patience listening to an album and seeing how it all connected together. You can barely get anyone's attention for 3 minutes now, much less 45 minutes to an hour for musical literature. Maybe another time will come when they could exist but it ain't now.

>>733377021
seriously, how old are you? 17?

File: ArcadeFireReflektor.jpg (48KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 300x300px

>>733381817
Have yourself a sit-down.

>>733377675
muse is definitely one of the shittiest bands out there right now. they've so over-welcomed their stay.

>>733374913
Not one fuckin band or dj listed in this thread is millennial. Your generation has contributed absolutely nothing at all. Not even a shitty band, how does it feel to be the last Romans before the fall?

Enter Shikari.

>>733382040
eh?

>>733382092
OP posted a picture of tame impala. kevin paker's definitely a millenial, you stupid motherfucker!

>>733382092
there's also this.

one direction?
>i kid of course.

File: 1494249585344.jpg (495KB, 2048x1152px) Image search: [Google]

495KB, 2048x1152px

https://donovannelson.bandcamp.com/album/donovan-nelson-ii

II is a legitimately amazing record. Just dont pay for it

Pink Floyd was kind of the top of the bell curve for what could be done with rock music when you approached it with a mix of freedom and emerging technology. It was at a time when experimentation was celebrated in music. After that the pop trend of the 80's was the slide back down the curve to the disposable crap we have again.

Not saying there aren't artists trying, just that they were a pinnacle and if there's another Pink Floyd it'll be when music has changed so much that they won't sound anything like them, will just be embodying the spirit of taking a medium to it's creative reaches while still being pleasant to consume.

>>733382245
Never heard of any of those. You might as well just be naming your friends shitty garage bands

>>733374913
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6GYYUVIAQ4

anime memes are the only band i worship

>>733382498
just look at the thread's related pic and look up the band. have been favorites of pop music critics for some time. what kind of music do you mainly listen to? balkan folk music?

>>733382498
>shitty garage bands
that's about the extent of the indie scene
the rest is tired rappers rehashing the same old obscenity filled garbage and media whores sucking up undeserved attention.

floyd caught the last truly creative wave early and rode it right into shore. it's never going to happen again.

>>733382686
>favorites of pop music critics
there you go

floyd was never, by any definition, a pop band. please. do some research.

>>733380492
m8 Steven Wilson still makes albums.
The most Pink Floydy PT albums were before he had a band anyway

>>733382401
Eh, kinda boring with no words

>>733382829
pop, as in popular music, not in the restrictive sense of the genre pop. and yes, pink floyd were definitely a band that made popular music. get your head straight, kiddo.

i cant believe nobody has posted sound tribe yet?
sts9 is amazing PF tier for sure
https://youtu.be/lJRbTfQpgJA

>>733382829
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0jqPvpn3sY

there you go, btw.

>>733382955
Just saw em live

>>733382686
>>733382742
My point was that all the decent bands are not Millennial, not even close. People who listing tool and Radiohead as Millennial bands, are you fucking kidding me. Those bands were coming around when I was growing up and I'm 35. The rest is mostly Electro trash which I do enjoy from time to time but it's hardly music. Millennials are responsible for shit like a little yachty or however you spell that dumbasses name

>>733383084
nice ive seen them 3 times. always great except that fucking new get loud is cancer af

It's definitely king Gizzard and the lizard wizard

Linkin Park

>>733383252
fag

>>733375281
dies

>>733383111
oldfag here, too. i'm 30. you're right about that, but i think you can also read OP's request as "what are the bands that we millenials celebrate". a millenial can be someone born in the early 80s.

>>733382401
Son this shit is amazing. Did you make it to downer?

>>733375013
Top Kek

>>733375677
I used to love Dream Theater, had all songs. Then, first time I stopped to listen to Pink Flyod discography I felt like Dream Theater sucked ass

>>733376122
>>733377021
>>733378649
>>733379149
You know, I never understood why people hated Pink Floyd.

Is it just because it got popular and people like to say "Pink Floyd" to sound cool? Because once upon a time I went out of my way to go listen to a bunch of songs done by Pink Floyd that almost nobody could name at the time, since the years in which they actually came out.

I liked it. I just don't understand.

>>733381917
>hip hop bullshit
There were still record shops where people talked about and listened to music together almost exclusively back when
>hip hop bullshit
got airplay and ran videos on TV. I just think you don't like/didn't like hip hop, which is fine.

>>733377578
Every generation had its shit.

>>733383111
You're a millennial if you're under 37-38, anon. That's the beauty of the shitty ad-hoc label- it lumps in all kinds of people that shouldn't belong together.

Tool is as close as you can get in my opinion. But let's be honest, there will never be another like Pink Floyd, and I'm pretty sure that is why our generation is stuck where it is musically.

Explosions in the Sky to me is one of the best bands if this generation. Pink Floyd is Pink Floyd though.. can't compare any band with them.
Tame Impala is awesome.
This Will Destroy You are also really good.
I'm really into post-rock
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsSIyk026P8

>>733382948
floyd were :
during the syd barrett years, considered a jazz/blues fusion band

and during their gilmour/waters years they were considered a progressive rock band, which is the label they still carry.

what made them popular was that in an ocean of mediocrity they produced intelligent/innovative music. in reality, their following is not that huge, certainly not large enough to classify them as popular.

and outside of a couple of songs off a couple of mid 70's albums and then the wall in the 80's very little of their stuff gets airplay.

SHPONGLE
https://youtu.be/ZYowY7tvBbY

Modest Mouse

>>733383821
and we'll all float on anyway well

File: images (1).jpg (8KB, 275x183px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 275x183px

>>733383490
Sets itself up

>>733383644
i know the different line-ups and their respective sound/genre/whatever, although their early stuff is usually regarded as psychedelic rock. the piper at the gates, and shiat.

suggesting that the late 60s and 70s were decades that produced un-intelligent un-innovative music is probably one of the dumbest things i've ever read.

There isn't one. our culture is far too fractured.

Igorrr

>>733374913
tame impala is more spot on than anything else in here...

I looked it up. I was born in june on 1995, so I'm apart of gen z. so fuck you old people.

File: 412674B5VKL.jpg (18KB, 303x300px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 303x300px

>>733383821
Lonesome crowded west is 10/10. Too bad its 20 years old..

File: 1494344370135.gif (2MB, 245x207px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 245x207px

>>733384167
Shut up kid

>>733374913
In all reality, jokes aside probably jaden smith. Think about it, he is always saying and thinking wise and beyond his year thoughts. Also is EP had a lot of deep powerful lyrics

File: 1493879644240.jpg (123KB, 1003x1024px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 1003x1024px

>>733384436
Pretty sure he wrote wish you were here behinds the scenes for pink floyd. Underrated

Dj yung vamp

>>733374913
skrillex

You will have dealt with it.

>>733376621
Too many bass cooks will spoil the crack

>>733385069
https://youtu.be/Y7CITnYsTeU

yung herp

>>733375351
This.

>>733379803

Came to post this.

Thread can now end.

>>733374913
Nickelback

>>733386575
>>733386575
That is non-electric music, so you're wrong.

We are a generation of electronic music you mong.

>>733376303
My fucking nigga!! I've seen them live a few times and they're fantastic

>>733387189
>not remembering house music
>or synth wave

>>733374913

I don't know if I can think of a band from today which produces that particular kind of suck.

>>733380536
You're my hero.

soulja boy

File: 6c725625622f07a3c0644319be954d0f.jpg (21KB, 470x444px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 470x444px

>>733374913
>>733375013

File: image.jpg (83KB, 498x482px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 498x482px

Itt: people post garbage hipster bands one other person knows about and everyone else complains about post 90's music

>>733375013
kekkest kek

>>733375463
Agreed

>>733374913
>the pink flyod of our generation
ì don't know any new band, that sucks so much

I really can't think of any band that would have had as much musical and cultural influence as Pink Floyd, so... Lady Gaga, I guess?

>>733388627
Metallica, SOAD?

File: 0021516125.png (12KB, 226x345px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 226x345px

>>733383557
>>733388402
Please explain to me why PF sucks.

>>733388402
This is why we are fucked....

>>733388847
>>733388893
it's the most boring, uninspired shit ever recorded. i don't feel anything listening to it. if you tell my grandfather, who has no idea of music or art whatsoever, tell, he should make some music, he would do something like pink floyd. these people must be the most boring musicians of all time.

>>733389144
>it's the most boring
>uninspired
>I don't feel anything listening to it
>he would do something like pink floyd

Boring how? Why does it sound uninspired, what specifically is it lacking? Do you just not like that style/s of music? Why do you hate your grandfather?

>>733389144

hurdur you need to take more drugs, then you'll get it

>>733389421
>what specifically is it lacking
heart and soul. fun. depth. it's kind of conservative in a way, not wanting to surprise the listeners in any way. but it's also not "cozy" or lulling. it's like music for people, who actually hate art in general, because it makes them anxious or whatever. i never thought once, that something significant was happening, when i was listening to one of their songs (excluding first two records)
>Why do you hate your grandfather?
read again and then fuck off

The Mars Volta?

>>733375534
>pretty lights
mah nibba

>>733375351


One for the Boog.

Go do yourselves a favor and listen to the Stallion in its entirety.

>>733390095
>heart and soul
>fun
>depth
Anon, that doesn't explain anything. What the hell is "heart", what's "fun", what's "depth" to you?

>not wanting to surprise the listeners in any way
I feel like Any Colour You Like, as one example, is surprising the first time you hear it, because it's all over the damn place, but that's just me.

>also not "cozy" or lulling
Another "pop" song is Wots... Uh The Deal. Pretty relaxed.

>it's like music for people, who actually hate art in general
Alright. I don't understand, though. What's art?
>because it makes them anxious or whatever
That sounds like a rationalization. I've listened to all kinds of genres and enjoy all kinds of music- music does the exact opposite of instil anxiety in me. I've never been made uncomfortable by music. Even death metal is fine every now and again. The only reason I'd listen to Pink Floyd is to get something out of it I can't find elsewhere for the moment. It might just be that I need/would like to hear a specific arrangement of chords again, because it sounded nice, and I'd rather go to the source than listen to a remix or a clever cop by another artist (yet).

>i never thought once, that something significant was happening
Fair. But what you're saying is that you never thought something significant was happening. Pink Floyd isn't godsend, yep. But why? What makes it particularly, exactly bad, besides just feeling like it was bad? If you can't explain that... I can't really say I know why Pink Floyd is bad, or why you think it is. Is it the progression? Is it the experimentation? Is it the speed of the songs? What is it?
>read again and then fuck off
You said your Grandfather would make Pink Floyd, and you apparently hate Pink Floyd, so by extension you believe your Grandfather is only capable of doing/being what you hate. You essentially said you think he's boring, uninspired, and shit.

>>733375280
>>733375513
>>733376231
This.

File: BD_Wrong.jpg (87KB, 466x409px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 466x409px

>>733387189
>We are a generation of electronic music
You can't just ignore all the music you don't like.

>>733374913
TOOL or Mars Volta. All other answers are wrong

Pink Floyd sucks ball.

>>733391273
>Anon, that doesn't explain anything. What the hell is "heart", what's "fun", what's "depth" to you?
see, you want to argue about art and have absolutely no idea about it obviously. these things are not easy to grasp.
>Any Colour You Like
just listened to it. grandpas trying to be edgy. still boring as hell
>Wots... Uh The Deal
sounds like one of the most boring beatles song ever
>What's art?
yes, you are the typical pink floyd listener, who wants to have the definition of art first, so he can see, if it fits. art is about emotion and new experiences
>That sounds like a rationalization
it is
>music does the exact opposite of instil anxiety in me.
so, what are some other bands you like?
>Even death metal is fine every now and again.
that is in fact a very boring and conservative genre
>I'd rather go to the source than listen to a remix
what is that supposed to mean?
>Is it the progression? Is it the experimentation? Is it the speed of the songs? What is it?
it is the attitude/mindset, that shines through every piece of art. in this case, it makes me feel like these are people who have a nine to five job and a house, yelling at their wifes, about how the food is bad or at the neighbors kids for being too loud. who pay tax and hate everyone who isn't as hard working and boring as them. it's people who hate change and questioning themselves and "the system". like old people.
>so by extension you believe your Grandfather is only capable of doing/being what you hate.
no, what i said was: my grandfather has no idea of art. but he would never decide to make music all of a sudden.
>You essentially said you think he's boring, uninspired, and shit.
but he's not an artist. he doesn't have to be inspired
another thing with pink floyd fans is, they are easily insulted, when it comes to people not liking them.

File: wat.jpg (177KB, 500x746px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 500x746px

>>733392442
>death metal
>boring and conservative

>>733392532
i mean it. doing some crazy technical stuff is not art. it's being in control of the guitar, but not being artistic

>>733374913
Nothing from this generation sounds like pink, if in the pass 5 years though maybe foo fighters or red hot chili peppers

>>733392629
>x is not art
>how to tell if someone is full of shit

>>733392851
so everything is art for you?

ITT 15 year old tier music tastes

>>733392658
>if in the pass 5 years though maybe foo fighters or red hot chili peppers

bwahahahahahahaha!! good one!

>>733392851
you can be the best guitar player in the world and have not wrote any song. are you an artist then? no, you are an interpret then

>>733392442
You know one thing even cringier than fanboys who can't accept people having contrarian opinions about their favorite bands?

Posters like this who seem more obsessed than the fans that like the band.

>>733393035
no, i just like to talk about music and art

>>733375013
Pink Floyed is a songwriter who wrote lots of Biebers hits. He owes his career to J.B.

File: IMG_0342.png (207KB, 750x1334px) Image search: [Google]

207KB, 750x1334px

>>733374913

>>733374913
k with tame impala, but what is pink flyod?

>>733374913
>pic related
>220x220
You sir, are an asshole.

>>733374913
Go back to mu

>>733375534
Mother Fucking Pretty Lights for Sure
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_81x8234OSE

>>733375069
This

>>733375228
Awww yeee

>>733390466
(you) know

>>733392442
>you want to argue about art and have absolutely no idea about it obviously
If these things are not easy to grasp, maybe it is because they are steeped far into the realm of subjectivity, and for you to communicate these things effectively, you need to be able to dictate them in a more objective and tangible manner.

I can't read your mind or feel what you're feeling- you need to describe that to me.

>you are the typical pink floyd listener
>who wants to have the definition of art first
>so he can see, if it fits
I was asking you that question to see where exactly your definition for "art", fit. Because I'm not you, and again, as not being you, I don't understand why you would not like Pink Floyd, or why you would suggest that any form of music is suddenly not art (and then by extension not... music?). I'm not defining art, it isn't my definition for sure. If art for you is about emotion and new experiences, then literally listening to Pink Floyd even once makes it art, because even if you hate it, you feel a strong emotion of dislike and you gain the new experience of having had to have the displeasure of listening to Pink Floyd.

>that is in fact a very boring and conservative genre
This has to be bait now.

>what is that supposed to mean
I would rather listen to the original song (source) of whatever it is I want to listen to, than another remix. A remix. You know, a re-mixing of a song?

>it is the attitude/mindset, that shines through every piece of art
That's fair. All you had to do was say this.
>it makes me feel like these are people who have a nine to five job and a house
Except I absolutely don't understand this. What? I think you're just confabulating some feelings from the pretentious people who like PF because it's "mainstream" and praise it like it's a gift from the heavens. It reads that way.

>>733392442
>my grandfather has no idea of art. but he would never decide to make music all of a sudden
Well, that's not what you said.
>>733389144
>tell, he should make some music, he would do something like pink floyd

>but he's not an artist. he doesn't have to be inspired
Doctors don't have to use surgical tools. But it often makes surgery easier when they do. Artists don't have to be inspired. But then, they're not artists, they're just people who "made" art, usually really basic art, but art nonetheless.

>another thing with pink floyd fans
Good thing I'm not a vapid blank slate, then. I'm not upset that you don't like Pink Floyd, I've just spent a very long time hearing people parrot "PF sucks" without any real explanation than "because". I'm curious, because I've usually never gotten any other kind of answer.

>>733392629
John Petrucci

>>733393655
best example that undeniably having superb chops doesn't automatically mean that it is art.

File: art.jpg (49KB, 545x203px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 545x203px

>>733392629
>doing some crazy technical stuff is not art
>>733394113
>undeniably having superb chops

>art
>the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination
>creative skill
>skill
>a skill at doing a specified thing
>a specified thing

>undeniably having superb chips doesn't automatically mean that it is art

>>733392629
Art:
1 The exercise of skill acquired by experience, study, or observation.

2 The conscious use of the imagination in the production of objects intended to be contemplated or appreciated as beautiful, as in the arrangement of forms, sounds, or words.

>>733393520
>steeped far into the realm of subjectivity
art is exactly that. expression of the subject.
so you want a scientific evidence and formular for these emotions? this statement says so much about you and how you don't get what art is and still want to be part of it for some reasons (like pink floyd)
>and for you to communicate these things effectively, you need to be able to dictate them
yes, to communicate them. but not for making and understanding these pieces of art.
>I can't read your mind or feel what you're feeling- you need to describe that to me.
there is no need to do this. we have art for it.
>why you would suggest that any form of music is suddenly not art
i'm not going that far. it's art. but boring and by people who have the wrong attitude towards it
>because even if you hate it, you feel a strong emotion of dislike
no, that never happened. it just bores me. like absence of emotion. plus PF sure didn't intend to express the emotion of hate
>This has to be bait now.
nope. death metal bands always focus way to much on the technical side of guitarplaying. they lack emotion, so they fill it up with playing the guitar very well and doing things, that are hard to play and think, by that, they have made something of artistic value. they haven't. they just practiced a lot.
>A remix
i don't get, what you want to say in this context? are you trying to say, that todays music is only copying the old stuff?
>I think you're just confabulating some feelings from the pretentious people who like PF because it's "mainstream"
no, it's the music itself, that makes me feel this way. it's just too much playing it "safe" or even wanting it like that and promoting it

>>733375069

Very nice

File: IMG_0349.png (269KB, 750x1334px) Image search: [Google]

269KB, 750x1334px

>>733374913

>>733374913
>>733375716
LOL Pink Floyd were edgy, over the top wannabe existentialists in their time and they are now.