>man with most desired opinion in wrestling >never had

Well I mean, you know... ummmmm... it was alright, it was fine...

File: 479px-Bill_Belichick_2012_Shankbone[1].jpg (33KB, 479x599px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 479x599px

>>2588134
>man widely regarded as one of the best coaches of all time
>never played a single game in his entire life
really makes you think

>>2588149
there is a difference between having actual success in a industry instead of just talking and writing about it
but then again, Meltzer made lots of money from it as well so at the end of the day he had success and worked many people as well

>>2588134
>you have to do something to have an opinion on it
damn guess I can't have an opinion on movies, music, video games, wrestling, books and more

>Russo had even less qualifications when he got signed by WWF

>>2588149
Not comparable.

Its more like a TV pundit being regarded as one of the best coaches of all time when he's neither booked or had a match.

>>2588178
>being this disingenuous
He's not saying Meltzer can't have an opinion, he's asking why people care so much about Meltzer's opinion when he's neither been a wrestler or booker.

>>2588194
Because he's been writing about it for longer than most of his detractors have been alive.

Roger Ebert never directed a movie either, y'know.

Did Roger Ebert ever direct a movie?

>>2588204
>>2588226
If I recall, he didn't direct one but he did write one. It was some 70s cheese

Kek

Just IMAGINE spending over 30 years of your life LARPing as a wrestling 'insider'.

File: image.gif (486KB, 500x214px) Image search: [Google]

486KB, 500x214px

>>2588204
>>2588226
>>2588237
It's called Beyond The Valley Of The Dolls and it's fucking kino, you turbo plebs.

First-come-first-served confirmation bias.
His opinion's about as meaningful as anyone else's, he just arrived to the party at a pertinent time.

>>2588204
>Roger Ebert never directed a movie either, y'know.

He wasn't the smartest man, and, as pointed out, he did WRITE one. So, bad analogy all around.

>>2588283
>writing a movie

That's like saying the writers in WWE have any input on the final product ;^)

>>2588287
lel, Not really, no.

>>2588134
And Vince Russo worked in a fucking video store before booking the attitude era.

>>2588278
That movie was unwatchable garbage. Go back to /tv/.

>>2588189
Except nobody cares about the opinions of TV pundits.

>>2588304
I think you're underestimating how obsequious and willing to latch onto anyone seemingly informed's opinion people are.
It's part-validation part-wanting to be in the discussion in a meaningful sense. But yes, people do highly debate TV pundits' opinions just as they do Dave's.
Not with the singularity, because there's more of them. But they definitely do.

>>2588313
I think you're full of shit and reaching. Sorry you're wrong kid, better luck next time.

>>2588340
Not an argument

File: monkey-holding-cymbals-illustration-white-background-31338635.jpg (119KB, 979x1300px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 979x1300px

>>2588134

>E DRONE seething at the fact that Big Dick Meltz is a wrestling historian who prevents WWE Revisionist History bullshit to pass