So, after the dust has been settled... 1) Dean Ambrose. Gets

>>2195308
>Deanetty
proven anti-draw
boring in the ring
can't talk
won't keep his tongue in his mouth
wacky line

>Seth
can't draw
good in the ring
bad on the mic
botched face turn
accident waiting to happen
tiny dick

>Reigns
good wrestler
can't talk for shit
only one to draw dimes
will forever be booed

>>2195352
>Deanetty
>proven anti-raw
>most over full time face in the company right now who gets cheered the most
...

They all three, especially as the Shield were over as fuck, so over that I used to wonder what was so great about these guys? They were a stripped down version of the nexus, if you remember when Nexus destroyed the Arena

>>2195308
i think the reason why they worked so well was because each a had one great thing about them

>dean/ Mic skills
>Roman/the look
>seth/in ring work

>>2195352
Dean can talk we he's not pretending to be le wacky guy or saying something stupid. Other than that he's shit.

>Ambrose
Great talker and is by far the best at elevating WWE's shitty material. Since the brand split, has by far gotten the best material to work with, which is a huge advantage for him.
He's safe in the ring, but possibly overly so, to the point where it can hurt his matches. Given that he came from deathmatch blood fuck island, and that he apparently wrestles 300 times a year, it's hard to find a lot of fault with him for wanting to work safe as possible.
Gets very good reactions, that bad spot during the Summer being the exception.
>Rollins
Okay talker, has been consistently held down in terms of his character and his material. They kept him heel when he shouldn't have been, turned him face too late and did it in a bad, half-assed way and gave him extremely weak material the entire time. He's been improving a little bit the past couple weeks and this week I think was by far his best as a babyface. It's still a work in progress, but it's getting there.
By far the best in the ring. Not really unsafe, the only time he really fucked up was with Cena, I think. Sting was old and his back was gonna give out eventually, and Balor was a freak accident off a bad spot that shouldn't have been done, there's plenty of blame to go around, there.
Gets great reactions on his entrances and his in-ring work. Actually got people to boo Sami Zayn, probably the most over babyface on Raw.

>>2195613
>Reigns
Not a good talker, but by FAR the most held down in terms of character and material. He doesn't have the charisma to elevate what he's given, but what he's given is week in and week out so unbelievably bad, it's hard to hold it against him. Nobody short of a legendary Cena-tier talker could make the garbage they give to Reigns palatable. If they turned him heel and let him be either a silent badass or a smug douchebag (which he already is as a babyface and it's been dying on the vine for two years now), he'd take to it very well but they just try to keep forcing him into this role that nobody buys him in.
Not the best in the ring, has a lack of stamina that means he can't go for very long, but the dude is coming out in a flak jacket and baggy pants, so that may no be a fair criticism. Extremely limited moveset, but again, you dunno how much they're telling him not to do. Not really unsafe, what happened with Shane was an accident off of a high spot that had a lot of room for error, and both wound up being fine. Shane is the patron saint of spot monkeys, he knows the risks of the shit he does.
Terrible, terrible, terrible reactions, and anybody with ears can tell you that. For like two years straight, now.

Basically, Ambrose is the one who's actually been put into a position to succeed the most, Rollins is the one who's gotten over with his ringwork despite bad booking and Roman is the one who's probably the least talented, but it's hard to say, because he's been so goddamn limited in every aspect by WWE trying to force him into a Cena-esque babyface role.