My first time having sex, I think I came inside her but I didn't

>>18664518
She's either loose, your dick is small or both.

>>18664525
It was pretty tight

>>18664550
Plus I'm 8 inches long and 5 thick.

If your peepee didn't tingle, it's unlikely you came. Possible, but unlikely.

File: 9e2f5f1d338f16eeea6173347cfe79b4.png (1MB, 967x949px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 967x949px

lol you peed in her, good going OP

>>18664518
Don't be worried dude, if you ejaculate normally when fapping it means it's not a physical problem.

When you're a bit stressed during sex (like everyone's first time) and not used to the sensation, and want to last longer, your dick will make some weird shit.

The sensation was a bit too strong and you didn't control your shit, some involuntary spasm triggered some kind of orgasm and you released a bit of cum.

Be way more worried of the std coming with unprotected sex and the mood of a girl on the pill.

>>18664518
Guys can nut without orgasm. Not entirely uncommon, especially if you're nervous or otherwise not mentally 'there'.