I'm friends with this girl who is very overweight, we have

No, you stuck by your friend while simultaneously chucking someone that was going to make your preferred situation more difficult. What's the problem here?

>I picked a fatty over a hot girl

To me you fucked up. Doesn't matter what I think or anyone else because it's your life. If your relationship with the fat girl was more valuable then you made the right decision. Only you can know whether you made the right choice is what I'm trying to say

>>18261413
She was really fucking hot.
But my friend and I have been friends a long time and our arrangement is pretty sweet... she's even gotten me laid with friends of hers (granted they're also overweight and pretty sperglordy)

>>18261416
yeah but my fat friend, to be fair, lets me do anal, and has gotten me a couple of threesomes, also shes chill to hang with where the hot girl we really only fucked and I would try to leave asap because she was fucking boring.

You chose friendship over self-respect and a future

>>18261408
Maybe dude. You should have discussed with chubster on how it would affect your relationship. Maybe just put the breaks on for a bit instead of completely cutting off. No one can answer this seriously because who knows what youre into or what your long term plans are with either or neither of them

>>18261443
The hot girl just wanted to be FWB
>>18261449
I dumped the hot girl cold... she gave me the ultimatum and I just told her "Nope later" and bolted right after we had just fucked.

>>18261455
So what. You have the right to think and rethink about things. If you think you made a mistake, call her up and tell her you reconsidered. What do you have to lose?